News
Alpha wife & Omega Husband
(rewritten review post finale)Originally, I've written this review around episode 9 because the discourse has gotten so ridiculous. I felt like this drama was treated unfairly and I stand by this point, however - I think it's safe to say this isn't your standard historical romance cdrama and therefore it didn't click with the audience.
I've never watched Blossom. Never seen Meng Ziyi and Li Yunrui together on screen before, and so I have no previous bias towards them. But from what I've seen, they do have amazing chemistry. It's easy to understand why they had been put together again.
This is a role reversal romance vise, first and foremost. You can go to the comment section and just scroll a few comments and to this day, you'll see a) complaints that Yan Shang (Li Yunrui) is too weak, asking if he knows some secret martial arts and if he gets stronger as the drama progresses. The answer to all of that is "no." It's the whole point. Yan Shang is calm, quiet, he is a scholar and he is highly intelligent man, unbendable in his convictions. He is physically weak, he can't ride a horse. He is meant to be this way. Mu Wanyao (Meng Ziyi) is domineering person who has harsh words for everyone, especially for Yan Shang. This is particulary contentious among the audience. Either you are willing to understand her or you don't. Mu Wanyao has been through a lot of trauma, her confidence and cruelty is a self defense mechanism. Push others, especially men, away and you'll never be hurt again. Yan Shang understands that and is more than willing to meet her half way.
I love the characters in this drama. Wanyao and Yan Shang are complete people, independent on each other, with their goals and dreams and agendas. Those don't always overlap. A massive shout out to the villains, who are not just cacking caricatures, but they have backstories, loved ones and sometimes they may end up quite pitiful.
The dramas pacing is just perfect. It's not too slow or too fast. I think people watch too much TikTok's and short dramas, so they expect to be every plot point served on silver platter in first five minutes. That's not the case here, they take their time and the plot is moving forward nicely. Tigers Sniff The Rose feels more as a historical and political drama than romance at certain points. Romance is still big part of the story but it's not at expense of the plot, which I really appreciate.
The score, costumes, cinematography is beautiful and production quality is high. They shot on real locations and you can see that on how beautiful the sets are. There is no freaky editing and weird cuts - I've seen people complaining about abruptly cut endings - which is true, but to me it wasn't an issue. In the end, we can't avoid the mechanical horses, which is a shame but at this point part of the cdrama circuit. No drama is perfect and so I'll agree that sometimes the OST is too loud for the conversation in front of it, and my personal pet peeve - that the characters stare at each other for way too long.
As for the rating: Tigers Sniff the Rose had the unfortunate event to air when other two major dramas were airing and so to prop then up, in the beginning there was massive downvoting going on. Secondly, as this is a third collab between MZY/LYR, especially people who loved Blossom and expected Blossom season 2, they ended updisappointed because, even though I haven't seen it, just by the description, this isn't another Blossom, it's the exact opposite in fact.
Lastly, the director of TSTR is Zoe Qin, who just did Love Beyond the Grave - my, now, second favorite romance of this year, I very much recommend it - LBTG had the same couple dynamic, it's what the director does, and it was also criticized to oblivion
-> I know I am an outlier, and most people prefer "big man, army general, martial artists, cruel but loving towards FL/gentle flower petal FL who is soft but clever and gently guides her ML to success," I don't and this isn't that drama, again, it's role reversal and many people can't stomach it and can't get into it. Which is fine, we all have our preferences.
This is 9.5/10. I was in cdrama slump since June, and finally I found something that pulled me out. I have my minor disagreements such as the loud music, but honestly what bummes out the most is that it's not role reversaly enough. I wish they leaned into it even more, but I am more than pleasantly surprised by this series to forgive a lot.
P.S. I think it's fair to give a warning: there are very dark themes and content in this drama such as SA. I understand this is very upsetting for some and that's fair. To me it was handled very well, it's treated with respect and heaviness something like this deserves. However - I'll admit that the villain wasn't treated as such, which was disappointing, for a monster like this, the consequences should've been much heavier. With that being said, this arc itself is very dark and sad, and the viewers should be mentally prepared. (Of course, this is a cdrama, it is NOT graphic at any point)
Was this review helpful to you?
DO NOT WATCH IT FOR THE ROMANCE
Let me start this review with saying that the score is an absolute joke. I'm genuinely upset by how unfair people are about this drama and it's actually very simple, for once: if you don't like it - it's not for you. Yeah, it sounds mean but it's true and that's okay. The reason why people give low rating is that a) they got bored because they couldn't follow the plot and b) the lack of romance. These are *THE ONLY* reasons why the score is so low. If you don't believe me, I encourage you to find me a low (below 7) review for this drama. It doesn't exist because there is nothing wrong with it, it's all matter of personal taste and preferences. If you think this is another Overdo, Lament of Autumn, etc. -> it's not. You have to follow the plot otherwise get lost. Romance is hinted here and there, but they are not dramatically in love and pining. That's just not happening.This is a male centered revenge story set in Republican era. Think of mix of Now You See Me, Peaky Blinders, Unveil: Jadewind and Cases Between Us. Basically, con the conman who is playing a con on you with another side secret con, but they know about the con, and you know that they know that you know.... As you can see, this is plot driven drama with layers and plot twists, and it is very well made blend of thriller, horror and comedy. And the comedy was unexpected for me, because judging by the trailers, I expected much darker story, but looking back the levity was needed because *it is* very dark, but sometimes the man who likes to mutilate children is also a complete idiot.
I don't want to say anything more, it's really difficult to write a review on something where everything works. There is no psychotic editing, we've seen in dramas lately, the script is very good, costumes are wonderful, the acting is amazing - Li Xian and Li Yitong are fantastic and Liu Guanlin, who plays Chengming's sidekick, I have to give massive applause because with a role that seemed unimportant, he managed to make third main character, that's how good he was. The score is wonderful, both opening credits songs are fire, it's hard to decide which one is better, I fell in love with both. (Btw, I've seen people saying that the credits are AI, that is possible but unconfirmed, so take it with a grain of salt.)
While the ending left opening for season 2, I'm not sure if it's necessary but I'd happily take it. If it's gonna happen is a bigger question. Not taking the MDL rating seriously, but the numbers weren't amazing, they weren't bad, but not great.
I 100% recommend this drama if you want something slightly spooky for the autumn, you care about the plot and characters journey and simply want something different than is the current standard idol drama. If you don't, that's okay, but please be a grown up and don't give it 1* because there are no kissy kisses. Thank you :)
Was this review helpful to you?
Here for my two leads
I won't go through the plot because it's obviously the most classic reincarnation plot. We are not inventing the wheel here. On the other hand, right from the start I regretted that this isn't longer drama but a mini because this had potential. If they had budget bigger than a peanut and longer episodes, I really believe this could've been a very good drama. The FL/Ml could've easily carry it. Instead we are flying through plot with breakneck speed. No time to waste, certainly not on the plot and character development.Yes, personally, I watched it for Deng Kai and Zhu Lilan, let's be honest, if they weren't there, I'd pass this immediately. But they are here and once again, they are (I don't know how else to say it) wasting their good looks and acting skills on minis.
Deng Kai is playing the greenest flag, Xiao Yunting is a sweetheart. Zhu Lilan's Qi Yuan is clever and she can easily switch from cute to cunning and back. I have to praise their chemistry too, when they look at each other the feelings are believable.
So, is this good? If you are comparing this to big budget 40-50 minute 40 episodes long dramas then no, of course not. If you are comparing this other minis, I think it's fine. Not brilliant but fine. Perfectly passable for a long train ride or rainy evening. And you will have a much better time if you enjoy the lead actors.
Was this review helpful to you?
Imho not role reversal
I'm mainly writing this because I've seen this drama recommended left and right as a gold standard for role reversal but.......... I'm sorry, is the role reversal in the room with us?Now, don't get wrong. This is very good. Like really really good. Better than some of the long, big budget drama's out there but the reversal is not reversing. It had in the first 30 seconds and then it was dropped like a hot potato. Yes, she is cold and he is chasing her like a puppy - that's not role reversal. In fact, our boy drugs her to keep her from harm and also comes to save her, like a lady in distress she is, when she is in danger.
Actually, Mr. ML is the worst this drama can offer, I dislike this man so much. Not the actor. The character he plays. The seventh prince is as pushy as they come. Manipulative and not in the hot way. He is pretending to be weak to gain sympathy, he hurts himself so she takes care of him. Role reversal? No. Red flag? Absolutely. He is jealous of FL when she talks to gay men and other women (fair, because they had triple the chemistry), like....no wonder Ms. FL isn't into you that much. You are annoying, my guy.
The positive is 100% the FL, the actress nails the role and portrays the character as a complex person, a feat on 2 minutes screentime per episode.
Also the production is very high. This could've been easily longer drama put on TV and no one could tell the difference. On one hand, I'd love to see it because the story was quite catchy, like I said, it looked very nice and FL definitely deserves the screentime. On the other hand, I'm shocked some of the stuff (m/m brothel with very obvious gay character) passed censorship and I'm pretty sure it wouldn't fly if this was bigger production. On and ML would annoy me to death.
Overall very solid - mini drama level - 7.5/10. Definitely one of the best minis out there. Definitely not a role reversal.
Was this review helpful to you?
Tolerable.... to a point.
Writing a review for mini drama of style is like- I know it's bad. You know it's bad BUT is it entertaining? And the answer is.... sorta? For a bit and if you know why you are here. This mini has 3 redeeming qualities to not become trash:1) the main actors are likable
2) Su Yan's wardrobe - I love her painsuits and I need them
3) the younger man/older woman dynamic (yes, he is 19 and she is 30)
And that is why you are probably here. That's the hook. And it's surpringly catchy and quite well done. I can imagine this is how this kind of relationship would look like. He really is that puppy like energy of a 19yo boy in his first relationship. She is mature, lawyer and post break up, so she is having none of it and it's believable.
What's not believable is the plot. I don't even know what to say. I've seen Turkish telenovelas being more realistic, but okay. Last 5 episodes, pissed me off though. Originally I gave it 6.5, then 6.0, now it lands on 5.5. I wish I could bleach those last episodes from my memory. That was offensively bad.
Was this review helpful to you?
Murder Mystery Club
I'm not going to beat around the bush: it's fine.This is a republican mini so the standard is somewhere below the floor though. They have school production budget and a dream - where I completely demolished Overdo with star power, money and gigantic production, this has none of those things and so I have to say this is okay.
As someone who is not oriented to romance, I went into this specifically for the bromance and main trio dynamic and on that level I was left a bit disappointed. They could've done more with it. The three of them come together towards the end, but there is no time for development of any kind, story wise or relationships wise. Then again in 10 minutes, what can you do.
Honestly, I don't even know what to say. Would I recommend it?... No? Unless you are actively looking for a bad melodrama that won't take much of your time.
I love the ending though, there is so much self awareness in there, it's actually impressive. Talk about school production value lmao...
Was this review helpful to you?
Mortal enemy aka the Editing
I was so excited about this drama. The promo materials were exceptional. Even now if you look at the poster you get stunning visuals, they are unique, no other drama materials look like this.Visually, Ashes to Crown, is the same. Some might hate it because it's very different. Very red, yes. But colors have their meanings, they tell the story of to which faction the character belongs, where story is set, and how the characters feel. Flashbacks are not just black/white but very originally main characters are in muted colors. But sometimes, the color storytelling is pushed to the point of ridiculous, like when secret assassin army appears dressed - so discreetly - in yellow, with bright yellow headbands. Part of visual storytelling? Yes. Stupid? Very much so.
Story wise, I like this drama very much. I am not one for romance and this is a political drama with side romance. Zhou Yiran and Chen Duling have chemistry but... let me get back to that in a second. Ashes to Crown is a game of chess more than a simple revenge story. The moment FL is reborn and makes her first move, everything goes. She has her memories from the first life but this is a whole new game. A game full of scheming, plots, court drama and backstabbing.
Strong points are the characters and actors themselves. Chen Duling's Chu Zhao is clever, but not too much, she has her lapses of judgement and I find that refreshing. She isn't perfect. Absolute shout out to the court trio of Xiao Xun (Wang Ruichang), Deng Yi (Gao Maotong) and especially Xie Yanfang (Tang Xiaotian) who were joy to look at. These three were scene stealers, perhaps to the detriment of the main duo, or worse, to our main female lead. It's true, often, what they had going on was more interesting than anything else. Unfortunately, Zhou Yiran's Xie Yenlai comes out the weakest from the five "main" players, mostly because his only ambition is to protect Chu Zhao, that is the whole point his existence and that's not enough to make the character interesting.
Writing is, well, good and bad. The characters make sense, their actions too, however the over exposition is less then desired. Especially in the beginning, it's more tell and tell and not show/don't tell. But it's true the drama is only 24 episodes and to pack in the story, shortcuts and fasten introductions are needed.
Music is wonderful. Chen Duling and Zhou Yiran sang their song and the main theme is one of my favorite this year. The sound editing belongs to the category of editing and... yeah.
The editing.
The thing that killed this drama and why it currently sits on 7.8 and not higher. In one word: abysmal. Characters stare at each other five business days. It's the "when I look you, and you look at him, and when I look at you, you look at him..." it gets old very VERY quickly. Yeah, long glances are part of the cdrama game, but there is a long glance and there is 5 hours long stare. The other thing is that this is cut like Indian day time soap opera. Quick zoom-ins to get reaction, loud sound effects following it, fade in black over and over in one scene like it's a tiktok video, character running suddenly speeds up like the Flash... It's so stupid. It's really really REALLY stupid. Unforgivably so. (Other drama this year already proved that you can have amazing cast and budget, but if the editing is bad, you tank like Titanic.)
If this drama was edited well it could've been easy 8.5-9.0. But it wasn't. Originally, I gave it 7.0 but now that I finally finished it I'm going with 7.5. For the entertainment value. I had fun watching. It flew by. I think this is a great drama to get you out of the slump.
Was this review helpful to you?
Jealousy, oh jealousy
Let me start with this: I knew this isn't for me since the trailer. I genuinely don't know why am I keep doing this to myself, but I'm a firm believer that sometimes things surprise you, and it's good trying out different stuff.Ehm, yeah... I was surprised how unserious the drama is. Which, in a way is a good thing. There is a moment where side character turns a scene into a vertical melodrama and narrates it, I think it's suppose to show that the drama is self aware of it's own cringe factor, which you know - kudos, because it is, but that's not really the issue.
There are two things that I can't over and why I'm dropping this, almost half-way through. The jealousy factor and the fact the main leads are acting like teenagers.
1) the jealousy is my personal ick, I admit it, I think there is nothing more unsexy and unattractive than jealous ML - no matter how sexy and attractive Fang Yilun is. I can forgive it when it's done when needed and for the plot, but here is a constant, it's on going, even when he is in a scene alone he is banging on the window, what if my rival is anywhere in 5km radius? It's honestly, unbearable, overcooked and overdone.
2) both FL and ML are 3000 years old. This is a problem because they both behave like they are 15. The immaturity is honestly staggering, yeah, it's suppose to add to the comedy but come on. The constant jealousy fits, the deer like stares from the FL as if she was newborn fawn, girl you are 3 centuries old, get it together.
Btw, 7 episodes in (no spoilers because I don't know) and I can tell you 2ML is going to be the villain. Here is how it's gonna go: 3000 years ago he loved FL, but he couldn't have her, so he attached himself to their curse/magic, but it backfired and now he is reborn without his memories. FL doesn't know he was evil, so she feels for him, but ML does hence the totally justified jealousy fits. 2ML dies and ML/FL live the rest of their lives to the old age happily ever after.
Anyway, I am out of here, if you like love triangles, the jealous CEO type character and can forgive stupidity as a cute trait, I think you will love it. I am not that person.
Was this review helpful to you?
Oh, I'm dropping this!
Yeah, I'm fairly new to cdramas, I admit it but this is awful. Like horrible. Disaster. Titanic sinking.I'm not the target audience, I'm neither hater or lover of ML/FL and I'm not into yandere ML's. With that being said, I have eyes and ears and I can objectively say that the editing of this is a joke, the camera work I can't even describe, over the shoulder blurry shots, fast close ups that's giving hindi soap opera. Overall cinematography is meh. Sound editing? Never heard of her. The writing and dialogues are cringe and not like in the "I kinda like it" way but it's "I have second hand embarrassment". VFX? 90's and beyond. (Of course, the opening credits are made with AI, that itself is a disappointment.)
The biggest let down is the acting, the leads have no chemistry whatsover, and the performances themselves are below their usual standard. Most of the time they just smirk and scoff, but like.... make it sexy smirk or disappointed scoff or confident smirk and tired-to-pretend scoff. ZLH is unbelievable as Alpha male and Wang Churan tries and fails to act, and just seems blank (unless she scoffs or smirks, of course.) You can blame it on poor writing, I think it's combination of everything going wrong here.
I'm happy I never waited for this drama, genuinely watched it because I had time today and there was a lot of buzz around it.I'm feeling for everyone who went into this with high expectations. I don't understand that this is high profile S+ tier drama and I'd like to ask where the money went because it surely wasn't production.
TLDR: This is a vertical mini drama with very famous actors. And that's not a diss to vertical minis because at least they don't waste your time. They are on budget and they entertain you for couple of minutes. This eats your time, 4+ hours of my life I'm never getting back, and entertainment value is well.... you can hate watch it, probably, if that's your thing. Or if you are massive fan of the leads, I guess.... good luck. I don't know what to tell you.
I'm giving it 2* because I guess everyone showed up to work and Wang Churan and Zhang Linghe are both very pretty.
Was this review helpful to you?

2