Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 24 minutes ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: October 20, 2021
  • Awards Received: Coin Gift Award1
Ren Yu chinese drama review
Completed
Ren Yu
0 people found this review helpful
by John Hart
4 hours ago
22 of 22 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 7.5
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 9.5
Music 10.0
Rewatch Value 4.0
This review may contain spoilers

REN YU -- On The Turning Away...

I find myself in an odd predicament. This was a really good series that absolutely didn't stick the landing. In fact it profoundly fumbled the ending, leaving loose ends in every scene. Otherwise I could almost highly recommend the show -- providing you skip the two last episodes. See my problem?

I follow actors to find my C-Dramas. Two brought me to REN YU.

Huangyang Tian Tian is a funny story. She was in my very first drama (RUYI'S ROYAL LOVE IN THE PLACE) and my 3rd drama (REBEL PRINCESS), but I wasn't aware of her. She played the female leads of each show briefly as a child actress. It was only in my 6th drama (THE GREAT CRAFTSMAN) playing a young Yang Mi did I realize I've been seeing her all the time -- and she was terrific in that role, which was what inspired me to watch her again. Tian Tian is young adult now and it's been fun to watch her grow up into a young woman and she breathed wonderful life into Su Lin.

The other actor that brought me to this series was Dong Yong, who played a rather entertaining and complex businessman in BLOSSOMS SHANGHAI. Dong Yong didn't disappoint here either.

The premise is about high school girl Su Lin who lives in an unfortunate family of stress and poverty. Her Dad is a bad news alcoholic, her Mom lives in fear of the Dad, and her younger brother is getting preferential treatment. She feels so invisible in her home that a retired cop up the hallway not only befriends her but feeds her food.

SIDEBAR -- I want to stop right here and show appreciation for Chinese Dramas. In the West, the male retired cop would be considered a pedophile until proven otherwise. In the East, it seems kindness is appreciated as kindness instead of suspicion. Considering this series has a serial killer hidden somewhere in the story, it's only all the more remarkable (and refreshing) to see people accept an older kinder man as just that.

So Su Lin is bullied by three girls in her school. A fight breaks out with the main meanie -- Ma Na -- which results in Su Lin being pushed down a sewer drain and abandoned for dead. This is the main twist that gets the story rolling, and what introduces the most interesting element to the story -- Vincent the Mentally Ill Homeless guy.

You have to understand this show is interesting because of a reality most adults are too busy to pick up on. Over my life I've noticed there's an age where some very caring girls in Western culture pour their hearts out to homeless people. They reach an age where they realize adults are pretending homeless people aren't starving and cold by their feet. Latter day Pink Floyd did an amazing song about this called ON THE TURNING AWAY.

So the very best reason to watch REN YU is to behold young Su Lin not turning away from Vincent, but becoming family with him -- since his family is dead hers is useless. So REN YU is a girl of poverty losing everything she had -- but slowly finding so much more.

REN YU is also about a serial killer that -- don't act surprised -- likes to lure in pretty young woman. He rapes them and then dumps them dead into the same sewer system Vincent and Su Lin live in. Since we don't know who the serial killer is -- this story is also a whodunnit, leaving red-herring possibilities everywhere. I cheated and asked AI if the killer is one of the characters in the story (but don't tell me which one) and it said YUP.

As the series progresses, there are moments where you yell at the screen and say, "Just tell the teachers what you saw!" or "Just tell the cops what you know!" over and over and over again. "Don't go into the sewers by yourself!" or "At least tell someone what you're doing!!!"

But all of the normal things normal people would do don't happen here to increase tension. But to me it's artificial tension and takes me out of the story. REN YU didn't have to resort to this.

And at story's end, almost every choice the characters make don't add up.

In the last episodes, Su Lin decides if she went to her cop friend and told him what's been going on, he wouldn't believe her. Of course that's the exact opposite of the situation. He loves her like a daughter and would immediately call his cop friends and help her get justice.

Instead she does these weird things that don't add up. And none of the obligatory scenes demanded by this story ever happen.

1. She has trapped her nemesis Ma Na and could finally give her a piece of her mind. But instead... nothing. She just dumps the girl by a shore, which we're not sure Su Lin had the physical strength to pull off. Ma Na would have a ton of stuff to tell everyone, but instead is conveniently catatonic in hospital being fed food by a nurse. WTF...

2. Su Lin observes the serial killer manipulating Vincent to do terrible things, but never sees his face. The OMG scene when she realizes she knows who he is -- never happens on screen. WTF...

3. When Su Lin has trapped the serial killer she has... nothing to say to him. This is because he wasn't trying to kill her but Ma Na. But since she knows the killer from her life you'd think she'd be FURIOUS at him just the same. But the show cuts the scenes where she and Ma Na would have been yelling at him.

I think this is because the writers couldn't figure out a believable way to make Su Lin and Ma Na allies after all they've been thru. Any writer on the planet would have solved this problem by having the serial killer capture Su Lin instead of Ma Na, but this story had a habit of abandoning the lead for a supporting character. Case in point --

4. -- schoolmate Ting was featured so much in this story you started to wonder why. It was Su Lin's story. And Ting had her own WTF moments by remaining silent way too long. And at the end --

5. -- where her Mom ditches her at the last minute of a custody hearing and Ting is all 'Okay Mommy' just became absurd.

6. When our retired cop Gu offers Su Lin a new home and wonderful life, it made no sense for Su Lin to say "too little, too late" to her friend who clearly loved her. This is the moment the series shattered into a thousand pieces and made zero sense. Including --

7. -- a poetic notion regarding Mermaids that even Dong Yong couldn't pull oft.

So this is the tragedy of a really good show that completely fell apart. SIGH. The actors playing Su Lin, Gu, Vincent, and Ma Na were otherwise riveting -- but it's painful to waste great acting on incoherent scripting.

I believe the writer chickened out. It would have been much harder to deal with Su Lin returning to society with Gu but leaving Vincent behind. I mean how do you exactly do that? Would we believe him living with Gu and Su Lin? Would he want to?

Also, it would have been much harder to show Ma Na and Su Lin bury the hatchet, but that too would have been far more interesting to watch.
Was this review helpful to you?