1
This review may contain spoilers
Brilliant acting, brilliant pholisophical ideas, minor weaknesses
So, after I had dropped this at episode 2 some months ago due to the only but major weakness of this drama - the fight/shooting scenes especially when it involves the main police officer - I gave it a second try because Kim Young Kwang is the second lead and I just had to see it to the end anyways because of that.
pro:
-brilliant acting of many actors in this one, Kim Young Kwang, sure, but also many side characters were so so good in this (the student in the goshiwon who finally lost it and snapped (Woo Ju Hyun), the police station chief when he finds out his daughter died (Kim Won Hae) , the very shy and silent bullied nurse (Kang Chae Young), Son Bo Seung as very friendly and gentle high schooler who snaps at some point understandably, and especially Park Hoon as Koo Jeong Man - fantastic acting, he really left an impression actingwise with me)
-the storyline is very intriguing on many levels. It throws many fundamental questions at you. How are humans in general, and why? What happens if you change fundamental parameters in a human society? What are ancient mass mechanisms and how are they triggered? How are they stopped? I really enjoyed this and found it intelligent and something everyone should spend some time thinking about. How do I see this? How do I feel about it? And the series got me, at some point, when the two bullied high-schoolers snap and one starts a shooting spree, I found myself understanding his actions, and I found myself thinking 'shoot the main bully, he deserves it' - the show intrigued you to feel that way and then question this feeling.
- Moon Baek - yes, I understand his view of the world too. Given his extreme childhood story and the view he very early had to have about what and how humans are? It's undertandable he feels the way he does. He has cancer too, another joke of fate, after he had it so tough very early on, so he's got nothing to lose really. And in the end he does ask very good and right questions in the last conversation with Lee Do. He does feel Lee Do is kind of self-rightous telling everyone revenge is not the answer and a deceiving feeling - how can he know for other people? Is it really what he feels or is it what he made himself believe he feels because he couldn't go on otherwise? How is it ok he shot a 100 people before and now he shoots one but not the other enemy? I found myself understanding Moon Baek to a rather great extent, and not agreeing with Lee Do on many things to be honest. That doesn't mean Moon Baek isn't a psycho of course, but not everything he says is wrong, the opposite even.
-one of the best scenes psychologically is the one where police chief Cho Hyeon Sik stand before his foe, gun pointing, tears in his eyes, and when Lee Do tries to convince him that pulling that trigger won't help, he says something I feel very true - he says ' I was wrong when I told you that back then, I didn't know anything' (until now, until I MYSELF am suffering this unbearable pain and loss of someone loved through the doing of some scum criminal, NOW I truly undertand that putting such people in jail over and over again does not bring any justice, law is not sufficient this way to bring justice). Very strong acting by Kim Won Hae, he portrayed this pain and anger very believable for me.
-and as the show progresses, more questions come up. What if you really provide guns for just everyone? How would people react? Would it bring any justice? Or would it end in bloody chaos because humans in masses are not able to deal with it? And they depicted that wonderfully, when pro and anti gun people started fighting and even shooting each other. I believe it would be exactly like that would it happen in reality.
cons:
once again the shooting/fighting scenes, in that case of Lee Do. Absolutely ridiculous what they did there =D I know they wanted to make him this ex special op guy, moving silently like a wolf in the shadows taking everyone down, but they really overdid it here. The scenes are so unrealistic it's hard to watch when you know ANYthing about how real situations like these look like ( And I do for some reason). Totally impossible he walks into a small house unarmed and there are about 30 street thugs with knives ( and not afraid to use them full force) and he takes all of them out - no way in hell.
Even more absurd was the scene when Lee Do wants to take down Koo Jeong-man - he has a sniper riffle, runs up to a rooftop ( in an area he does not know by the way!) and while in reality the car with Koo Jeon-man would have been long gone anyways until Lee Do had reached the rooftop, they seriously show him at the edge of the rooftop, with a sniper gun suuuuper far away and trying to hit a VERY fast and unsteady moving vehicle and Lee Do is standing (a sniper NEVER shoots standing, impossible to hit precisely) and shooting a car tire and of course he hits it - Ri di cu lous! Impossible.
And a third one, quite in the end, Lee Do, once again unarmed, and funnily enough fresh from the hospital after he had been shot in the upper body SEVERAL times (which means the man can NOT move normally, let alone fight) is confronted with about 10 guys with loaded machine guns all pointing at him, and again, he takes all these pro guys with machine guns down and out - Laughable of course, he'd be dead in 5 seconds latest.
Conclusion:
I really enjoyed this because it was an intelligent, thought-provoking storyline with a topic everyone is confronted with in the news ever so often all around the globe. It puts you at the spot, making you think how do I see this? What is my opinion and why? Is there a solution? Is it the one or the other option shown here? Or none of both? So as this is so well done, and many actors in this show were more than brilliant I give this a 9 (and if they hadn't f 00ked up the fighting/shooting scenes once again like in so many such showsOo) it would have been a 10 even.
So, if you like action-loaded and tense shows but WITH brain, this one could be for you.
pro:
-brilliant acting of many actors in this one, Kim Young Kwang, sure, but also many side characters were so so good in this (the student in the goshiwon who finally lost it and snapped (Woo Ju Hyun), the police station chief when he finds out his daughter died (Kim Won Hae) , the very shy and silent bullied nurse (Kang Chae Young), Son Bo Seung as very friendly and gentle high schooler who snaps at some point understandably, and especially Park Hoon as Koo Jeong Man - fantastic acting, he really left an impression actingwise with me)
-the storyline is very intriguing on many levels. It throws many fundamental questions at you. How are humans in general, and why? What happens if you change fundamental parameters in a human society? What are ancient mass mechanisms and how are they triggered? How are they stopped? I really enjoyed this and found it intelligent and something everyone should spend some time thinking about. How do I see this? How do I feel about it? And the series got me, at some point, when the two bullied high-schoolers snap and one starts a shooting spree, I found myself understanding his actions, and I found myself thinking 'shoot the main bully, he deserves it' - the show intrigued you to feel that way and then question this feeling.
- Moon Baek - yes, I understand his view of the world too. Given his extreme childhood story and the view he very early had to have about what and how humans are? It's undertandable he feels the way he does. He has cancer too, another joke of fate, after he had it so tough very early on, so he's got nothing to lose really. And in the end he does ask very good and right questions in the last conversation with Lee Do. He does feel Lee Do is kind of self-rightous telling everyone revenge is not the answer and a deceiving feeling - how can he know for other people? Is it really what he feels or is it what he made himself believe he feels because he couldn't go on otherwise? How is it ok he shot a 100 people before and now he shoots one but not the other enemy? I found myself understanding Moon Baek to a rather great extent, and not agreeing with Lee Do on many things to be honest. That doesn't mean Moon Baek isn't a psycho of course, but not everything he says is wrong, the opposite even.
-one of the best scenes psychologically is the one where police chief Cho Hyeon Sik stand before his foe, gun pointing, tears in his eyes, and when Lee Do tries to convince him that pulling that trigger won't help, he says something I feel very true - he says ' I was wrong when I told you that back then, I didn't know anything' (until now, until I MYSELF am suffering this unbearable pain and loss of someone loved through the doing of some scum criminal, NOW I truly undertand that putting such people in jail over and over again does not bring any justice, law is not sufficient this way to bring justice). Very strong acting by Kim Won Hae, he portrayed this pain and anger very believable for me.
-and as the show progresses, more questions come up. What if you really provide guns for just everyone? How would people react? Would it bring any justice? Or would it end in bloody chaos because humans in masses are not able to deal with it? And they depicted that wonderfully, when pro and anti gun people started fighting and even shooting each other. I believe it would be exactly like that would it happen in reality.
cons:
once again the shooting/fighting scenes, in that case of Lee Do. Absolutely ridiculous what they did there =D I know they wanted to make him this ex special op guy, moving silently like a wolf in the shadows taking everyone down, but they really overdid it here. The scenes are so unrealistic it's hard to watch when you know ANYthing about how real situations like these look like ( And I do for some reason). Totally impossible he walks into a small house unarmed and there are about 30 street thugs with knives ( and not afraid to use them full force) and he takes all of them out - no way in hell.
Even more absurd was the scene when Lee Do wants to take down Koo Jeong-man - he has a sniper riffle, runs up to a rooftop ( in an area he does not know by the way!) and while in reality the car with Koo Jeon-man would have been long gone anyways until Lee Do had reached the rooftop, they seriously show him at the edge of the rooftop, with a sniper gun suuuuper far away and trying to hit a VERY fast and unsteady moving vehicle and Lee Do is standing (a sniper NEVER shoots standing, impossible to hit precisely) and shooting a car tire and of course he hits it - Ri di cu lous! Impossible.
And a third one, quite in the end, Lee Do, once again unarmed, and funnily enough fresh from the hospital after he had been shot in the upper body SEVERAL times (which means the man can NOT move normally, let alone fight) is confronted with about 10 guys with loaded machine guns all pointing at him, and again, he takes all these pro guys with machine guns down and out - Laughable of course, he'd be dead in 5 seconds latest.
Conclusion:
I really enjoyed this because it was an intelligent, thought-provoking storyline with a topic everyone is confronted with in the news ever so often all around the globe. It puts you at the spot, making you think how do I see this? What is my opinion and why? Is there a solution? Is it the one or the other option shown here? Or none of both? So as this is so well done, and many actors in this show were more than brilliant I give this a 9 (and if they hadn't f 00ked up the fighting/shooting scenes once again like in so many such showsOo) it would have been a 10 even.
So, if you like action-loaded and tense shows but WITH brain, this one could be for you.
Was this review helpful to you?
