This review may contain spoilers
Amazing high school romance that goes nowhere
Great performance by Kim Tae Ri, Nam Joo Hyuk was my dream boyfriend, lovely directing, but I'll never forgive the show for being such a huge bait and switch. Maybe I'm wrong but I have a theory, and suspect that two ideas were at war for the script : someone wanted this to be a sublte queer romance paying hommage to yuri stories of the 70's with rival lesbians fencing, and someone else wanted this to be a straight romance spanning decades and crises paying hommage to The Way We Were and the Before Sunset/Sunrise/Midnight trilogy. I think both ideas were good, but obviously doing them at the same time is a huge challenge and 2521 is no Rose of Versailles, so as a result the story ends up somewhere in the middle, cutting both stories short. The ending is also a big middle finger to those of us who were invested in Baek Yi Jin's story arc as he ends up after so many hardships and heartbreaks being reduced to a side-note and memories. You can also make a case of the show trying to be : a "Reply" like romance that kept us guessing about the future (that went nowhere), a social commentary on the 90's crisis and the evolution of sports and journalism, a friendship is magic tale, a family drama...and in the end it all crashed with a tepid conclusion, leaving me wondering what was the point. I still adore the Na Hee Do/Beak Yi Jin high school friendship and romance but I can't ignore how the drama *completely* wasted the potential of their adult relationship (I didn't even need them to end up together, I just needed their adult story to make sense !).
Was this review helpful to you?


