5
36
2
1
3
1
This review may contain spoilers
Letters of love, regret, and hope
‒Review‒
Twelve Letters is a unique concept that delivered plenty of hard-hitting poignant moments. Depending on whether you were fully immersed in the emotions of the main plot line or occasionally distracted by loose ends, this show will either be a memorable favorite or a promising setup that had a shot at greatness.
The highlight of the show is the humble, touching, but often tortured story of the main couple. As high school youths in a small village in the year 1991, the main leads were two strong, decent, and tragic characters entangled in a mess of circumstances beyond their control, and desperately trying to escape. The ML was trapped by previous run-ins with local gangsters that continue to threaten his family and the FL. The FL was trapped by a vicious, manipulative gambling-addict father despite her quest to free herself from him and the town through college. It's through the desperation of the characters, the injustice of society, and the cruel helplessness of circumstance that we come to appreciate the precious glimpses of beauty and hope. The young leads of Zhou Yirang and Wang Yinglu deliver terrific performances, as does the talented supporting cast, including several younger actors. Yu Nian (Zhenghe Huizi) and Shen Cheng (Ren Youlun) were decent, and the 1991 group of Li Chadong (Jia Hongxiao), Zhang Hao (Zhao Runnan), Tan Xin (Chen Haolan), and Wang Manyu (Lin Xinyi) were standouts who deserve more acting roles to shine. The show wraps up the anguish and tragedy by delivering on a final letter of hope that ultimately provides a happy resolution.
Despite the many positives of the story, this had potential to be much more poignant‒whether as a love story, a mystery, or an indictment of society or the human condition. The main issue is the blemished execution of the letter exchange and use of timeline. The story involved the letter exchange in the plot, but didn't fuse it with the narrative or the emotional core. All of the most important narrative, emotional, and thematic moments occurred in the 1991 timeline, with a few in 2005 when ML was released from prison. 1991 had all the consequential events, the live-and-death stakes, and moments that delved into the characters and cruelty of circumstances. Rather than enhancing the story, the letters often distracted from the 1991 timeline as the audience is left speculating about how to alter the events. Moreover, many of the letters were not of the impactful variety as the first love letter from Tang Yixun, or even essential details for unraveling the mystery and changing the past. The result is the additional set of characters, plot, circumstances, and speculations diluted the poignancy of the 1991 story. In fact, the story would have been much more powerful if it had scrapped the timeline travel altogether‒even by sticking to a more conventional setup of twelve letters to and from prison or twelve letters addressed to the other person, the narrative would have been far more profound and cohesive.
In comparison, a few other titles executed the timeline device much better. Reset was much more polished in handling the logic of the timeline and leaving pieces of clues that built up to the plot and thematic climax. It also assiduously kept the focus on the core of the story and didn't get mired in the hows/whys that wouldn't be explainable. Link Click delved into many philosophical aspects of regret, fate, and confronting or even changing the past. It did so through vignettes that culminated in a powerful finish. And Interlaced Scenes is probably the closest in mood and themes. Even though there were no time-alteration aspects, the story was methodically revealed through interlacing timelines that despite divulging some key plot points in the beginning, kept pulling the readers along by revealing deeper mysteries and resonant themes. The key to delivering such powerful story is the approach of subtraction‒excise all extraneous elements and make all the details count. Had Twelve Letters done that, this would have been a masterpiece. Nonetheless, the team clearly put in a lot of effort, and I appreciate the ambition and originality of the show.
--Category Ratings--
- Overall - 7.8 (--> 8.0 MDL)
- Plot - 7.5
- Theme / Concept / Impact - 8.5
- Acting - 8.3
- Visuals - 8.5
- Audio / Music - 8
- Rewatch - 7
- Cultural/Topical Accessibility - 7.5
- Subtitle quality - 8
Twelve Letters is a unique concept that delivered plenty of hard-hitting poignant moments. Depending on whether you were fully immersed in the emotions of the main plot line or occasionally distracted by loose ends, this show will either be a memorable favorite or a promising setup that had a shot at greatness.
The highlight of the show is the humble, touching, but often tortured story of the main couple. As high school youths in a small village in the year 1991, the main leads were two strong, decent, and tragic characters entangled in a mess of circumstances beyond their control, and desperately trying to escape. The ML was trapped by previous run-ins with local gangsters that continue to threaten his family and the FL. The FL was trapped by a vicious, manipulative gambling-addict father despite her quest to free herself from him and the town through college. It's through the desperation of the characters, the injustice of society, and the cruel helplessness of circumstance that we come to appreciate the precious glimpses of beauty and hope. The young leads of Zhou Yirang and Wang Yinglu deliver terrific performances, as does the talented supporting cast, including several younger actors. Yu Nian (Zhenghe Huizi) and Shen Cheng (Ren Youlun) were decent, and the 1991 group of Li Chadong (Jia Hongxiao), Zhang Hao (Zhao Runnan), Tan Xin (Chen Haolan), and Wang Manyu (Lin Xinyi) were standouts who deserve more acting roles to shine. The show wraps up the anguish and tragedy by delivering on a final letter of hope that ultimately provides a happy resolution.
Despite the many positives of the story, this had potential to be much more poignant‒whether as a love story, a mystery, or an indictment of society or the human condition. The main issue is the blemished execution of the letter exchange and use of timeline. The story involved the letter exchange in the plot, but didn't fuse it with the narrative or the emotional core. All of the most important narrative, emotional, and thematic moments occurred in the 1991 timeline, with a few in 2005 when ML was released from prison. 1991 had all the consequential events, the live-and-death stakes, and moments that delved into the characters and cruelty of circumstances. Rather than enhancing the story, the letters often distracted from the 1991 timeline as the audience is left speculating about how to alter the events. Moreover, many of the letters were not of the impactful variety as the first love letter from Tang Yixun, or even essential details for unraveling the mystery and changing the past. The result is the additional set of characters, plot, circumstances, and speculations diluted the poignancy of the 1991 story. In fact, the story would have been much more powerful if it had scrapped the timeline travel altogether‒even by sticking to a more conventional setup of twelve letters to and from prison or twelve letters addressed to the other person, the narrative would have been far more profound and cohesive.
In comparison, a few other titles executed the timeline device much better. Reset was much more polished in handling the logic of the timeline and leaving pieces of clues that built up to the plot and thematic climax. It also assiduously kept the focus on the core of the story and didn't get mired in the hows/whys that wouldn't be explainable. Link Click delved into many philosophical aspects of regret, fate, and confronting or even changing the past. It did so through vignettes that culminated in a powerful finish. And Interlaced Scenes is probably the closest in mood and themes. Even though there were no time-alteration aspects, the story was methodically revealed through interlacing timelines that despite divulging some key plot points in the beginning, kept pulling the readers along by revealing deeper mysteries and resonant themes. The key to delivering such powerful story is the approach of subtraction‒excise all extraneous elements and make all the details count. Had Twelve Letters done that, this would have been a masterpiece. Nonetheless, the team clearly put in a lot of effort, and I appreciate the ambition and originality of the show.
--Category Ratings--
- Overall - 7.8 (--> 8.0 MDL)
- Plot - 7.5
- Theme / Concept / Impact - 8.5
- Acting - 8.3
- Visuals - 8.5
- Audio / Music - 8
- Rewatch - 7
- Cultural/Topical Accessibility - 7.5
- Subtitle quality - 8
Was this review helpful to you?
