P Non Portraitist

What’s the title of the song played in EP 5, when the water ghost and ms Qi’s past was being shown?

Will be going this route too! :) I just finished Tales of Tang D., and will dive into the EP1 of Sleuth.

I can't make up my mind... i'm into this but I don't to end up crying. -_-

And so is yours. :) You need to walk your talk :)

Is it just me or the series seems to be dragging its storyline.

I agree with you on that. This series is laughable. :) What a well written comedic series. :)

And oh, I have no high expectations with BL series set in schools. Bye, Felicia!

Are you for real? The Eclipse is enough to over shadow the dull light of this series. Which was made more dull by a whiny character. :)

Reading your weekly review for this series is an antidote for Eiw's whiny-ness. :)

Reading your weekly review for this series is an antidote for Eiw's whiny-ness. :)

Went into this series thinking it won't be this deep... the current story is setting the bar high.

The whiny-ness(?) is getting at my enjoyment. :)

And all the possible ships o.O

I am getting confuse with Phayu's Arc :)

That was one hilarious description of Earth's character here. :)

Not to throw shades on characters he played, but I just got to agree with this observation. There was that "whiny-ness" in them. :)

Why is it going the Oxygen way... soo bland. T_T

If it was 10 or 12 episodes, they could have explored the characters and probably ended great. But yeah, it was mediocre.

And that choice ( if ever their choice had significant weight in the director/writers' decisions in the process of creating this series) made the series what it was after it ended. Gee, so sad.

One unwritten rule of an artist (of different kinds) is to create something as if it was your last. Every artists aims to create something epic. That way, there will be no regrets because you've given it your all. If you were saying that they (the team and artists of this show) choose to make a comedy bl that borders into mediocrity because it was a "goofy story with bonus love story," it just means just that. This series is mediocre.

But then again, I don't believe that was the case. As stated in my review, this could have been a great one. However, it did not deliver in the end. I don't know the reason why it did that way. BUT as for my viewing experience I felt that the series had:
1. Too may sub-plots due to to many pairings.
2. Limited screen time, again due to #1.
3. No character development as if the writer was confused which storyline is the main storyline.
4. Comedic scene should have been used sparingly or at least should have been a plot device and not the driving force to make the storyline progress.
5. Directing was jarring, specially transitions from setting to settings.

These are just my beefs with the show. :) And if what you've said was true, then that'll be #6. A movie/film/series have BTS team and Actors, each has their place. If one wants to be a direct a film, he can't be an actor for that. If one acts, he can't be a decision maker for the one he is acting on... unless they were the producers :)

The actors made that choice? -_- So, it was not the director's choice then.

Loved EP 7 sooo much. It was hilarious and moronic.