RazzleDazzle

I’ve seen plenty of comments indicating it was a plot hole as to why no one questioned why YXW wanted to poison Grandma Ye and for others for being dumb for believing so. It was not a plot hole to be honest. The reason why no one is questioning how Grandma Ye was poisoned because as the drama mentioned Grandma Ye outcome was a by product of YXW wanting to poison TTJ. It was an accident that Grandma Ye has eaten the poisoned porridge made by YXW. None of them believed it was to poison Grandma Ye. YBC’s alibi was that she saw YXW cooked the porridge and she didn’t know it was poisoned. The maid can probably support YBC’s claim YXW cooked the porridge if needed. TTJ then provided proof to solidify YBC’s alibi by stating that it was indeed YXW that cook the porridge to poison him. Seem pretty logical to me. That was also why Grandma Ye and Father Ye still sided with YXW after finding out she was the one that poisoned the porridge. Maybe we all should turn on our brain when watching instead of having them off.

It was not a plot hole to be honest. The reason why no one is questioning how Grandma Ye was poisoned because as the drama mentioned Grandma Ye outcome was a by product of YXW wanting to poison TTJ. It was an accident that Grandma Ye has eaten the porridge made by YXW. YBC alibi was that she saw YXW cooked the porridge and she didn’t know it was poisoned. TTJ then provided further proof that indeed YXW did cook the porridge to poison him. Seem pretty logical to me. That was also why Grandma Ye and father Ye still sided with YXW after finding out she was the one that poisoned the porridge.

Sure. Probably LSS can change TTJ to be become a better person but then how long? Cause once he died the Devil God will take over if the evil bone is not removed. Baby-Hitler doesn’t have a ticking bomb installed in him. This is like since Hilter was born, someone already set a ticking bomb in him that if he reached 35y.o, an atomic bomb would ignite unless he died before then. So this isn’t actually about the person at all. This is no longer a nature vs. nurture.

In my point of view, it was logical for LSS so act that way though, with the way TTJ reacted afterwards and how he made her stab XL. It was believable to jump to that conclusion.

Actually at that part no one has told her that she poisoned the Grandma. She only hears part of it (the scolding) and her trying to cut ties with the Ye because she believes that the Grandma did die because of her. The main reason on why she was avoiding the Ye family because she plans kill TTJ. She doesn’t want the Ye family to get in trouble due to association with her.

Edit: at this point she is done playing house and just want to complete her mission.

Well Xiao Lin also hinted that it was because of him that tragedy had befallen on Ye mansion, the death of Grandma Ye. So it is safe for LSS to assumed that the culprit is TTJ. Because she tried to save Xiao Lin which enrage TTJ plus TTJ did try to make LSS stab XL. Technically Xiao Lin informant did relay the correct info. Grandma did die after TTJ visit. They just chose to forgo that Grandma was poisoned before the visit. If I were LSS I would assume the same. Lmao

It’s was mentioned pretty early on in the novel. Don’t remember exactly what chapters as it has been a couple of years back since I read the novel.

Definitely. But the drama also never show that Li Su Su doesn’t know about Xiao Lin trial. So there is still hope. Lmao 🤣

No in the drama it has been hinted that Li SuSu does know Xiao Lin is Gongye, with Xiao Lin looking just like Gongye and being a disciple of Xiaodao sect that Gongye was a disciple of. She even want to hug him when she saw him in episode 1. There was never a full acknowledgment but it was hinted. And yes we were never given an explanation regarding Xiao Lin’s trial in the drama so that is also why I indicated/hope that the drama should connected it in the later episodes. But who knows 🤷🏻‍♀️, the ball is in the editor/director’s court.

It’s on top of the comment under recent discussion topics of this page

https://kisskh.at/discussions/hei-yue-guang-wen-na-be-ju-ben/94445-spoiler-why-li-su-su-is-hell-bent-on-saving-xiao-lin-from-a-novel-perspective

Yes I created a topic explaining it. If you don’t mind being spoiled, it gives more reasoning behind LSS action toward Xiao Lin.

There are reasons as to why Li SuSu did what she did regarding to Xiao Lin which hasn’t been touched yet in the drama however to the novel reader we were given an explanation since the beginning. I’m not sure whether the drama planning to touch on that going forward.

Yes, a lot of what LSS action are cause/effect from novel TTJ that are being shown in the drama. Thats why it seem more rough while it wasn’t so much as betrayal in novel as both were doing so to each other. However, they got to get to the tower scene so someone got to character sacrifice to get the plot moving.

I don’t think people have problem with him not as black as in the novel. Lots actually like it in fact. The problem lies with how Li SuSu is being portrayed. She remains the same as the novel while Tan Tai Jin is different from the novel. But then if they change Li Su Su from the novel, then their plot will have to changes as well. Such dilemmas.

Yes definitely. Would have given lots of reasoning regarding Li Susu’s action toward Xiao Lin (her running to XL camp when she saw TTJ mobilize the army in the middle of night and etc). Maybe the scriptwriter want us to see it from TTJ’s perspective and question whether YXW has other feelings regarding XL. You know to justify TTJ’s jealousy.

Who knows what they can come up with. 🤷🏻‍♀️As long as it make sense or at least tied a nice bow around it for us in the later episode.

Oops. 😂 must be tough to keep it a secret as everyone keep on questioning/stating why Li SuSu has no business in helping Xiao Lin. I myself couldn’t and was so tempted that I have to give spoilers . Lmao

Yes they have yet to explain about the importance of this life for Xiao Lin in the drama. Hopefully they can connect it or give us an explanation later in the immortal arc.

Yes, hopefully they will connected it or give us an explanation in the immortal arc.

Actually in the novel it was explained to Li Su Su before she traveled back to the past by her Master that this life of Xiao Lin is the final test on whether he can be immortalized to become Gongye or not. The Gongye we saw in episode 1 was a human that cultivated to become immortal. If he failed to passed his test to become immortal, he can never come back again as the Gongye we saw in episode 1. Li Susu doesn’t know how or what those tests are. She doesn’t want to risk it and just want Xiao Lin to live so that he can complete his task to become immortal. It was never explained in the drama yet about the importance of this life for Xiao Lin.