1
Flawed But Not Without Merits
Long story short, I loved it! This drama has lots of flaws and frustrating moments, and it's admittedly not perfect but it still has its fair share of merits.
Many people pointed out the less-than-optimal editing and storytelling, and honestly, it's a bit difficult not to. The editing team did a phenomenal disservice to an otherwise good drama. Especially in the initial episodes where some scenes seemed to have been clumsily stitched together without any regard for the flow, leaving the viewers to read between the lines. But as the story progresses, it gradually gets better and is no longer a major issue. So, if you are willing to give this drama a try, I’d suggest watching at least 6-8 eps before dropping because once you get hooked, it gets better.
The drama has a classical wuxia setting and gives Blood of Youth/Dashing youth and The Untamed vibes with intertwining friendships, love and hatred transcending generations. If you are new to wuxia, it may be overwhelming to keep track of the seemingly important looking unimportant characters sprawled across the board but in hindsight, they are ones who make the Jianghu feel alive and vibrant and help you appreciate the world-building in the long run.
The plot and the characters make for an interesting watch and personally, the cast really pulled through and saved this drama.
Zhou Yiran did a fabulous job portraying Mu Qingyan. He perfectly captured the nuances of MQY and looked absolutely stunning playing him. MQY is a complicated character; he is jealous, obsessive, manipulative, a bit unhinged and morally grey. But he’s also loyal, determined and is willing to go above and beyond to get what he wants because he has seen the people he loves, live with regrets their whole lives. He is very much flawed and at times, a bit difficult to like or defend but it’s still easy to root for him.
Now, Cai Zhao is the free-willed, strong and independent female lead that most writers fail to write. She is emotionally and physically strong and is extremely secure in her standing. She has a go with the flow attitude but is actually willing to take responsibility for her whims and doesn’t expect others to clean up after her or fight her battles. She knows what she wants and followed her heart. She loved MQY in her own way but also refused to compromise and let go of everything else that mattered to her. Some people might call her indecisive, but I’ll forever love CZ for standing her ground. And Bao Shang En deserves so much praise for successfully bringing CZ to life.
The chemistry between the leads is really good but their relationship dynamic is potentially the most problematic part of this drama: They are toxic and rather frustrating to watch at times, so tread carefully. But personally, I think they save themselves before falling from the edge and take time to grow and is actually okay by the end.
And the award for the best second male lead goes to Song Yuzhi! I don’t care what anyone says, I absolutely love him. Yuzhi starts off as the typical cold, rigid, righteous and slightly pretentious 2ML but we soon get to see how clever and surprisingly flexible he is. He did what he thought was right and had a clean conscience. He was always the first to see through MQY’s schemes and called him out on it but never interfered where it wasn’t his place to interfere. And he admired, respected and liked CZ in the best way possible, supportive but never trying to impose or influence her feelings and decisions. And he's so cute, I loved his interactions with his father, who is also an absolute vibe might I add.
The other supporting characters were also written very well. And I simply cannot not mention You Guanyue. He single-handedly uplifted this drama for me ever since he first appeared. He is such a diva and his interactions with literally anyone is a joy to watch.
The character writing is honestly the best part of this drama for me. They start off as typical and risk falling flat but there are certain nuances which give them depth. And most importantly, the writing is consistent. MQY didn’t suddenly stop scheming and become 'good' to be more likable, CZ didn’t just forget she had a life and responsibilities after falling in love, SYZ didn’t become jealous and obsessive out of nowhere just because CZ didn’t love him. The writers being able to move the story forward and portray growth without uncharacteristically altering their personalities is something I can’t help but appreciate.
Now, the plot itself was good but a little weak at times. As much as I understand Cai Pingshu’s importance and why literally everyone admired and loved her, she was overused as the driving force of the plot and emotional building to the point that no one could even have a conversation without someone mentioning her every other minute.
The storytelling was also somewhat lacking, and I can understand the disappointment of the novel readers, especially if they are mourning the potential of what this drama could’ve been. However, as I’ve never read the novel and just watched it as it came, I quite enjoyed this drama. Like I mentioned before, this drama has its flaws and if you wish to pick on it, there would be reasons not to like it. But personally, I think the cinematography, osts, characters and the acting really came together as the story progressed and made it worth a shot.
Many people pointed out the less-than-optimal editing and storytelling, and honestly, it's a bit difficult not to. The editing team did a phenomenal disservice to an otherwise good drama. Especially in the initial episodes where some scenes seemed to have been clumsily stitched together without any regard for the flow, leaving the viewers to read between the lines. But as the story progresses, it gradually gets better and is no longer a major issue. So, if you are willing to give this drama a try, I’d suggest watching at least 6-8 eps before dropping because once you get hooked, it gets better.
The drama has a classical wuxia setting and gives Blood of Youth/Dashing youth and The Untamed vibes with intertwining friendships, love and hatred transcending generations. If you are new to wuxia, it may be overwhelming to keep track of the seemingly important looking unimportant characters sprawled across the board but in hindsight, they are ones who make the Jianghu feel alive and vibrant and help you appreciate the world-building in the long run.
The plot and the characters make for an interesting watch and personally, the cast really pulled through and saved this drama.
Zhou Yiran did a fabulous job portraying Mu Qingyan. He perfectly captured the nuances of MQY and looked absolutely stunning playing him. MQY is a complicated character; he is jealous, obsessive, manipulative, a bit unhinged and morally grey. But he’s also loyal, determined and is willing to go above and beyond to get what he wants because he has seen the people he loves, live with regrets their whole lives. He is very much flawed and at times, a bit difficult to like or defend but it’s still easy to root for him.
Now, Cai Zhao is the free-willed, strong and independent female lead that most writers fail to write. She is emotionally and physically strong and is extremely secure in her standing. She has a go with the flow attitude but is actually willing to take responsibility for her whims and doesn’t expect others to clean up after her or fight her battles. She knows what she wants and followed her heart. She loved MQY in her own way but also refused to compromise and let go of everything else that mattered to her. Some people might call her indecisive, but I’ll forever love CZ for standing her ground. And Bao Shang En deserves so much praise for successfully bringing CZ to life.
The chemistry between the leads is really good but their relationship dynamic is potentially the most problematic part of this drama: They are toxic and rather frustrating to watch at times, so tread carefully. But personally, I think they save themselves before falling from the edge and take time to grow and is actually okay by the end.
And the award for the best second male lead goes to Song Yuzhi! I don’t care what anyone says, I absolutely love him. Yuzhi starts off as the typical cold, rigid, righteous and slightly pretentious 2ML but we soon get to see how clever and surprisingly flexible he is. He did what he thought was right and had a clean conscience. He was always the first to see through MQY’s schemes and called him out on it but never interfered where it wasn’t his place to interfere. And he admired, respected and liked CZ in the best way possible, supportive but never trying to impose or influence her feelings and decisions. And he's so cute, I loved his interactions with his father, who is also an absolute vibe might I add.
The other supporting characters were also written very well. And I simply cannot not mention You Guanyue. He single-handedly uplifted this drama for me ever since he first appeared. He is such a diva and his interactions with literally anyone is a joy to watch.
The character writing is honestly the best part of this drama for me. They start off as typical and risk falling flat but there are certain nuances which give them depth. And most importantly, the writing is consistent. MQY didn’t suddenly stop scheming and become 'good' to be more likable, CZ didn’t just forget she had a life and responsibilities after falling in love, SYZ didn’t become jealous and obsessive out of nowhere just because CZ didn’t love him. The writers being able to move the story forward and portray growth without uncharacteristically altering their personalities is something I can’t help but appreciate.
Now, the plot itself was good but a little weak at times. As much as I understand Cai Pingshu’s importance and why literally everyone admired and loved her, she was overused as the driving force of the plot and emotional building to the point that no one could even have a conversation without someone mentioning her every other minute.
The storytelling was also somewhat lacking, and I can understand the disappointment of the novel readers, especially if they are mourning the potential of what this drama could’ve been. However, as I’ve never read the novel and just watched it as it came, I quite enjoyed this drama. Like I mentioned before, this drama has its flaws and if you wish to pick on it, there would be reasons not to like it. But personally, I think the cinematography, osts, characters and the acting really came together as the story progressed and made it worth a shot.
Was this review helpful to you?
