And the casting/visuals of Changge’s mum is so far off from the manhua depiction. Really sad... But I’m happy…
In the manhua, the ML is at first completely unhinged, rather wild. He is a brilliant commander and inspires great fear into everybody. He’s got a feral look and can be rather cruel towards his enemies.
However, as he starts opening up to ChangGe, we see a different Ashina Sun. He’s somebody deeply loyal, devoted, and protective of his people. The Ashina we first meet in the manhua would’ve never gone to Changan, but he does go there later on for the sake of our FL, that’s when he kind of “confesses” to her as well.
The relationship between these two isn’t as clear cut, but it’s deeply moving. He does talk about marrying her later into the manga. I literally squealed while reading that. I truly recommend reading the manhua. You won’t regret it!
OMG, what is this plot... why have they changed it so much?/sobs. Ashina in a Tang city is as unlikely as a bull…
And the casting/visuals of Changge’s mum is so far off from the manhua depiction. Really sad... But I’m happy with Reba’s portrayal of CG, I was worried she’d come off as a much stronger woman than the FL actually is, but it’s actually pretty on point. As expected of such a good actress! Still feel the ML needed to be a bit more raw and crazy-like person. But since they changed the plot, obviously they also had to change the ML character to a certain extent to fit the narrative.
OMG, what is this plot... why have they changed it so much?/sobs. Ashina in a Tang city is as unlikely as a bull dancing ballet in a tutu. He went there later on in the manhua only because of our heroine, and it showed the depth of affection and respect he held for her. Ah... T_T
Absolutely loved it. I liked the playfulness intermingled with great sadness from Wei Ying, but also the intense and serious attitude of Lan Zhan. Both have got loyalty in spades, and are very dedicated. Truly inspiring. I was impressed with YiBo, in most scenes his intensity feels real as opposed to just acted out, I really enjoyed it. The Jin bad guy was well casted, he was so creepy and annoying.
Their relationship is beautiful and the stuff literary works write of...Two damaged and conflicted souls.... one…
I think having been raised in a family which saw a parental divorce pretty early, I was able to see things a tad different as a teen (which is when I discovered NANA). My top favourites (bar Hachi) Takumi and Ren are two people on the same spectre just opposite from each other: Takumi wants love but thinks himself unworthy and so pushes it away; Ren desperately wants to be loved but has no confidence in himself and is able to sacrifice anything in his search for love even his own life. Both experienced a really messed up childhood and the journey they travel from that point onwards is just a rollercoaster, and I just can’t help going on it with them.
Nana-chan, my other fave, had the most amazing transformation from a very naive girl to an independent woman, wife, and mother. I am still desperately waiting for a continuation of the manga where she finally meets NanaO and reunites with her husband and little Ren. The torture...
I completely agree, the drama needs to have actors with mature mindsets and a lot of skill in portraying very fine character features because the smallest mistake can make whomever they’re portraying as a cliche, and we all know NANA is way deeper than just cliche rock and punk stars.
NANA, one of my favourite mangas ever. Ah I hope they find somebody to properly portray Takumi & Nana-chan’s relationship.
Loads of kids see it as them not loving each other, whereas the reality is entirely different, he truly believes that he’s not worthy of love and she is always unsure of her own feelings and wants. I hope that the actors portraying them will be able to showcase these very fine lines Takumi and Nana cross everyday in their life as a couple.
bruh..... dont bring toxi politics in to destroy the mood. Everyone's fave idol in one is, it's like heaven....…
Hmmmm, I think you took it the wrong way. Perhaps not all artists felt obligated to be in this film, but I’m sure some did. I come from a similar country so I know how things work, you don’t need to feel so offended. There’s a good and a bad side to everything. And I’m not hating on China, I actually really like the Chinese culture. Just because I’m not in awe of the government, doesn’t mean I don’t like China. These are very different concepts. Don’t take it so personal, it’s anything but.
Did it occur to you that she perhaps wanted to keep her private life private? Loads of stars never show their…
I’m afraid your expectations of a celebrity are much too out of the realm of reality. And speaking of reality, Zhao LiYing is not Kim Kardashian, whose life I agree others can discuss since she invited cameras into her own home, family, marriage, and even bed. ZLY is an actor, who gives your a piece of art you’re meant to admire or enjoy, but she never invited you into her own life. I think you have watched way too many reality shows and because of that are expectant of others to provide as much insight into their lives. Additionally, I don’t appreciate the personal attack. Please behave like a mature person. We are not savages after all.
I won’t reply anymore, as I believe what was needed to be said has been said and if you can’t understand such plain truths, I’m afraid nothing can make you see the light. Cheers.
Did it occur to you that she perhaps wanted to keep her private life private? Loads of stars never show their…
I absolutely disagree. People absolutely pestered them about it and she most certainly has the right to privacy. Just because she’s an actress doesn’t mean that she needs to tell everybody everything. Most importantly, you don’t own her to demand things from her, nobody does. You should really reflect upon your entitled opinions.
Wang YiBo has impressed me so much. I’m absolutely amazed by his ethics as a dancer and captain. I’m an ex-pro dancer myself (in ballroom and Latino though), and the way he started off with a warm up and ice breaking activity, continued to be very fair and just in his decision making, was very supportive and respectful to all of the participants, all of this just amazed me because he couldn’t have shown himself from a better light. He put so much effort into ensuring his dancers got those much coveted towels. I was really touched that he got the married couple together after the dance battle (which he won). He was also very keen to learn new things, which shows that he seeks to improve himself and his craft. If I were to dance again, I’d definitely want YiBo as a captain. His understating of dancing and music is deep and multi-layered.
The other captains also did very well, and certainly added to my positive opinion of them.
Did it occur to you that she perhaps wanted to keep her private life private? Loads of stars never show their…
I hid my fiancé from others until he proposed and even then I released as little information to other people except for those invited to the wedding ceremony. I most certainly won’t tell others I’m pregnant until I’ve given birth, since I’ve already lost my first. I don’t like sharing such news until it’s happened not to jinx it. Why wouldn’t she be the same especially when millions of people check everything she does. I fully understand her and support her decision.
So if it’s state funded, does that mean that everybody in this film had to participate or get the cut from industry? Shivers...
Edit: for the avoidance of doubt, through my comment I meant that even if some actors wanted to say no to the project for whatever reason (schedule issues, the character didn’t suit their personal taste etc), most likely they wouldn’t have been able to say no. I’m not implying that the actors can’t feel patriotic about their country or whatever.
P.S. Stop implying I’m spreading western propaganda, I’m not. I’m originally from an Ex-Soviet country, so I’m very aware of what communist regimes are like, since I lived with it for a very long time. Cheers.
However, as he starts opening up to ChangGe, we see a different Ashina Sun. He’s somebody deeply loyal, devoted, and protective of his people. The Ashina we first meet in the manhua would’ve never gone to Changan, but he does go there later on for the sake of our FL, that’s when he kind of “confesses” to her as well.
The relationship between these two isn’t as clear cut, but it’s deeply moving. He does talk about marrying her later into the manga. I literally squealed while reading that. I truly recommend reading the manhua. You won’t regret it!
But I’m happy with Reba’s portrayal of CG, I was worried she’d come off as a much stronger woman than the FL actually is, but it’s actually pretty on point. As expected of such a good actress! Still feel the ML needed to be a bit more raw and crazy-like person. But since they changed the plot, obviously they also had to change the ML character to a certain extent to fit the narrative.
Nana-chan, my other fave, had the most amazing transformation from a very naive girl to an independent woman, wife, and mother. I am still desperately waiting for a continuation of the manga where she finally meets NanaO and reunites with her husband and little Ren. The torture...
I completely agree, the drama needs to have actors with mature mindsets and a lot of skill in portraying very fine character features because the smallest mistake can make whomever they’re portraying as a cliche, and we all know NANA is way deeper than just cliche rock and punk stars.
Loads of kids see it as them not loving each other, whereas the reality is entirely different, he truly believes that he’s not worthy of love and she is always unsure of her own feelings and wants. I hope that the actors portraying them will be able to showcase these very fine lines Takumi and Nana cross everyday in their life as a couple.
Additionally, I don’t appreciate the personal attack. Please behave like a mature person. We are not savages after all.
I won’t reply anymore, as I believe what was needed to be said has been said and if you can’t understand such plain truths, I’m afraid nothing can make you see the light. Cheers.
The other captains also did very well, and certainly added to my positive opinion of them.
Edit: for the avoidance of doubt, through my comment I meant that even if some actors wanted to say no to the project for whatever reason (schedule issues, the character didn’t suit their personal taste etc), most likely they wouldn’t have been able to say no. I’m not implying that the actors can’t feel patriotic about their country or whatever.
P.S. Stop implying I’m spreading western propaganda, I’m not. I’m originally from an Ex-Soviet country, so I’m very aware of what communist regimes are like, since I lived with it for a very long time. Cheers.