News I smiled, I cried, I smiled again. (And boy am I swimming against the tide here)
So many reviewers hated this. I LOVED it.
Sure, the teenage ML was sometimes childish but he just loved with his heart flung wide. And Xing had zero experience of being in love and loving someone -- Lu Hui was the teacher there. The teacher/student relationship would usually be seen as problematic (except that the teacher wasn't really a teacher just a temporary substitute, university student; only a couple of years older than the students.) The 'forbidden love' thing is just a tease.
The story arc made sense and the WONDERFUL decision by Xing at the end wasn't just a sad BL fantasy that 'love can overcome.' It represented that fact that closed-off Xing had not only learned to love: but by learning to love; had developed agency over his own life decisions. He found his personal artistic bliss in his relationship with Yu Hui. And they became each other's muses.
The second couple were well developed and instead of the "I was straight and now I've met you and I'm gay" trope: Bing Chen, who had lost his beloved wife, as he got to know Lu Xi, fell for the emotional similarities Lu Xi shared with his wife - the warmth, the positivity, the caring. The message that you can love anybody is surely one we, as BL fans, should subscribe to. They were both very supportive of Lu Hui's first love and worked together as a team to guide him. (Tho' I did think calling Lu Hui's heartbreak a 'tantrum' was a bit insensitive.)
Did it all happen ridiculously fast? Yes it did BUT in a thousand love stories, Het, BL, or anything else on the spectrum of human loving, the 'romance in a flash' convention rules. The will he? won't he? decision at the end (I'm an old softy) had me sniffly.
Do you like a BL that actually is a ridiculously romantic love story? Then get your hanky and watch, knowing there will sunshine after rain.
Sure, the teenage ML was sometimes childish but he just loved with his heart flung wide. And Xing had zero experience of being in love and loving someone -- Lu Hui was the teacher there. The teacher/student relationship would usually be seen as problematic (except that the teacher wasn't really a teacher just a temporary substitute, university student; only a couple of years older than the students.) The 'forbidden love' thing is just a tease.
The story arc made sense and the WONDERFUL decision by Xing at the end wasn't just a sad BL fantasy that 'love can overcome.' It represented that fact that closed-off Xing had not only learned to love: but by learning to love; had developed agency over his own life decisions. He found his personal artistic bliss in his relationship with Yu Hui. And they became each other's muses.
The second couple were well developed and instead of the "I was straight and now I've met you and I'm gay" trope: Bing Chen, who had lost his beloved wife, as he got to know Lu Xi, fell for the emotional similarities Lu Xi shared with his wife - the warmth, the positivity, the caring. The message that you can love anybody is surely one we, as BL fans, should subscribe to. They were both very supportive of Lu Hui's first love and worked together as a team to guide him. (Tho' I did think calling Lu Hui's heartbreak a 'tantrum' was a bit insensitive.)
Did it all happen ridiculously fast? Yes it did BUT in a thousand love stories, Het, BL, or anything else on the spectrum of human loving, the 'romance in a flash' convention rules. The will he? won't he? decision at the end (I'm an old softy) had me sniffly.
Do you like a BL that actually is a ridiculously romantic love story? Then get your hanky and watch, knowing there will sunshine after rain.
Was this review helpful to you?
