Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 15 hours ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 62 LV2
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: July 16, 2014
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award1 Flower Award2 Dumpster Fire Award1
Replying to Skibbies Oct 23, 2018
I think it's absolutely marvelous, but it's a very different drama from Ashes of Love (or most cdramas you see…
not really. I'm still stuck in this drama hell, trying to finish some previous dramas I started too. I'm generally pretty picky about cdramas and none of the ones I like are romance focused. My recent favourites are My Huckleberry Friends (realistic-ish ensemble high school drama) and Die Now (interesting games like liar games). Tienstin Mystic is interesting too though not a fav (neat crime solving drama with fair bits of chinese mysticism, plot gets messy near the end though).
0 0
Replying to Pau Oct 20, 2018
Can someone advise if this drama worth to watch? I'm contemplating between this and Legend of Dugu. Still can't…
I think it's absolutely marvelous, but it's a very different drama from Ashes of Love (or most cdramas you see tbh).
2 0
Replying to Skibbies Oct 20, 2018
Review The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
I thought she was fine towards Helian Zheng, she's just very blunt about her refusal. She's pretty blunt in general.…
He was a very fun character, though at times he was little jarring because he felt like he belonged in another drama (he was in the middle of court while they were suspecting Ning Yi isn't a prince. or anytimes Ning Yi and Zhiwei are at the same place, he just can't follow along. poor kid)
RIP on the last episode, if it helps, there's some very nice acting scenes in there?
2 0
Replying to Skibbies Oct 19, 2018
Review The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
I thought she was fine towards Helian Zheng, she's just very blunt about her refusal. She's pretty blunt in general.…
She didn't really have a choice. She HAD to be become a Tiansheng princess so that Shaoning wouldn't have to marry to a foreign country, marrying to Jinshi is like the only way she could live. Of course, that might not matter to Helian Zheng, which is why she's blunt about her refusal. She specifically went to battle when they married (the excuse was to help him stablise his position, but they just got married.) He knows about her feelings but he still feels indignant, which is fair but why does she get blamed for acting how she always have been?

I've seen her getting blamed for smiling and being nice to Helian Zheng and Ning Yi saw, she was literally doing her job as an empress and she still got hate, a girl can't win.

I think the ending make sense for her characterisation. Where it fails is she doesn't see through everyone's evil plot and schemes, it feels like she's caught in a whirlwind and couldn't get out. which IS what essentially happened, but for a better audience experience, they could use far less sudden events. I just don't think her character was the only one that suffered. Like christ, what was that Helian Zheng death, excuse me? He died to cause more last minute misunderstanding? What an insult to his character.
1 0
Lively Persimmon Oct 18, 2018
For Yang Mi, only RoCH is wuxia and she had a guest role. TMPoB and Chinese Paladin are both xianxia which is different. Fuyao toned down its wuxia elements significantly that it ends up being less wuxia-ish than Chinese Paladin.
3 0
Replying to The White Truck of Doom Oct 18, 2018
Review The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
so when I first started watching this drama I was puzzled by your review. The drama was not just beautiful, it…
I thought she was fine towards Helian Zheng, she's just very blunt about her refusal. She's pretty blunt in general. I think she was hoping that he wouldn't dwell on her. I'm not sure why you think she's a whiner? snivelling I probably agree with since she end up crying a lot (thanks scriptwriters!), self centered is debatable, she's no more self centered than any other characters in the drama., they are all pretty flawd and that's what I like about the drama. I do think the execution of the last 7 episodes pretty terrible since it needed far more build up and foreshadowing for lot of the characterisations to work.
2 0
Replying to The White Truck of Doom Oct 8, 2018
Title The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
So Ep 49 did the headmaster deliberately cause the "outing" of Zhi We's mother and brother? And if you reply,…
More of a general comment. Our protagonists in this drama tend to screw up more than you expect, in this case, Headmaster Xin was trying to damage control the entire time, and turn the situation to be more favourable towards Ning Yi even when it got out of hand. I really like multiple parties with different priorities here clashing tbh, even on "our side", Xin and Ning Yi and mum and Zhiwei all have their own agendas.
2 0
Replying to Apple Eye Oct 7, 2018
Agreed about NiF, the comparison wasn't mine though, it was made on the internet by TROP fans. I haven't read…
The book is constantly referred as mary sue book on Chinese internet. It pops up a fair bit in drama discussion when people mention the book. I mostly poke around douban and weibo. If you are talking about where you can read the novel, just look up 凰权, there's txt and read online sites floating around.

Zhiwei actually studied for years but yeah she's intelligent and have values that's not really from her time period. She does look like a young boy while crossdressing though so I have little qualms with that, especially when I think her teacher just teach her. She did some dumb stuff in the beginning. Some of it is from the book (she's more overpowered in the book so it's just a thing). She only has two love interest in the drama, Ning Yi and Helian Zheng, the other people all have their own agenda and aren't love interests?

Ahhh it's just a common arcetype because that's what gets past SARFT. especially his characterisations as an emperor near the end. It's not that he's so good at revenge, let's go for the throne. It's more power is a means for revenge (as it was in the book), and he was pushed onto the path for the throne because of people that worked for him. It's also the only way to ensure Zhiwei is safe. (this isn't really clear in the drama but it's his motivation in the book and Ning Yi does want both power and love around ep 50).
1 0
Replying to ToRoom19 Oct 6, 2018
It's sad to know that they shot almost 100 episodes worth of footage but cut it down to 70 because of censorship…
It was slated for 50 then expanded for 70 episodes. They shoot that much content because they don't know what would pass. I honestly think they have to take quite a bit of responsibility on how the drama came out.

@appleeye: Novels go through different authorities from dramas. Movies are subjected to different restrictions too. Prime time and historical dramas are the strictest, and they gotten stricter this year, it's a miracle this drama even aired. Both Yanxi and Ruyi were shooting for tv slot, but neither could get past the restrictions so they aired online. Also it was originally a web novel, from 2010, less restrictions then, less restrictions online.
1 0
Apple Eye Oct 6, 2018
Your description of Ning Yi fits novel Ning Yi to a tee. He is more defined as the drama goes, he didn't actually want the the throne in the beginning, he just wanted revenge. He's pretty consistent throughout the drama, he probably kept the most out of everyone from the book, but a more toned down version with added weakness.

As for Zhiwei, she is an entirely different person from the book one. I actually think it was interesting they decided she could see past revenge, and it fits her more, she's not ruthless like in the book and she never felt like she was part of Dacheng. More importantly, this OTP had trust for the most of the drama, the book OTP only had trust in Minhai and it was promptly broken via unfortunate circumstances. I have gazillion gripes about the last 10 episodes so I'll leave it. She's basically powerless though (because they couldn't let her revive her kingdom. ugh), and even then she's not passive. she saved herself in Dayue. She's less consistently written than Ning Yi, for sure but I think her characterisation holds till uhh idk ep 65? The effects of all those people dying just gradually take their hold on her instead of immediate which is how that ending happened. She take deaths lot harder than book Zhiwei and blame herself more.

idk why you call this Zhiwei Mary Sue tbh. Is it because she's smart but naive? splunky and daring doesn't really go against that, it's part of being young. I mean, it's a common archetype but it's not...sue-ish. It's just little funny because I've had to consistently defend the novel for being mary sue (lots of love interest, OP, too pretty she has to cover her face, lots of descriptions about apperances and flowery language)

The comparison to NiF is largely because the initial arc had similarities. It's also a rare political drama that semi appeal to younger audience, thus the comparison. That and because NiF have become the recent year historical drama standards. Its themes are pretty different though.
2 0
Replying to Skibbies Oct 6, 2018
Title The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
Nope. The novel have a happy ending though so people have been using that to smooth over things.
Apologies. the nope is meant to mean it's a sad ending. Some people think it's ambiguous but I think that's wishful thinking. The drama uses the about half the novel as framework with sprinkles of the 3rd arc, the characterisations are also pretty different.
0 0
Replying to RhopalocerA Oct 3, 2018
Title The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
Is this has happy ending?
Nope. The novel have a happy ending though so people have been using that to smooth over things.
0 0
Replying to namopanik Oct 3, 2018
I'm around ep 12 and feel spoiled by the synopsis. Is the gender bending arc in the academy coming anytime soon,…
The synopsis is actually kind of misleading because it's novel synopsis, and the drama focus is on Ning Yi. You are definitely going to get that arc in next 3 episode though.
3 0
Replying to Sophia Ca Sep 24, 2018
i am at ep 7 and there has not been a lot of development yet, but i don't find it slow , maybe because the acting…
Ni Ni (female lead) debuted in Zhang YiMou's 2011 film, which is probably why you find she has similar aura as Zhang ZiYi. The director is good at picking his actresses. It's first time Ni Ni starring in a drama, and Chen Kun (male lead) had been focusing on movies in recent years too. He has acted in number of dramas before but they were pre-2010 and probably not subbed.
0 0
Replying to amrita828 Sep 21, 2018
Matsujun may not be the prettiest fish in the pond, but he has a passion I always find compelling and enabled…
He has gotten hotter over the years, must be a better stylist lol. iirc he had pimples while playing as Doumyoji and he wasn't tall enough so he always had to walk first when they did group entrance. I think I went on to watch quite a number of Matsujun dramas just because how much I loved him in HYD though.
2 0
Replying to Skibbies Sep 19, 2018
Kseries is DVD/netflix version at the moment. The easiest way to tell is they are usually consistently 45mins…
No. I'm indicating which version the videos are, I can't get the subs to show up lol so I don't know what subs they are. If they are completely different then someone have been subbing the tv version, but I think it's more likely one version is mistimed or something?
0 0
Replying to yshtola Sep 19, 2018
Kseries.net and newasiantv.ch now has English subbed up to episode 7 and 15 respectively. Both of their subtitles…
Kseries is DVD/netflix version at the moment. The easiest way to tell is they are usually consistently 45mins per episode, whereas the TV version will vary from 16, 2x, 3x, 4x, 5xmins with about half the episodes settling around 50mins episodes. The initial few episodes cut aren't too noticeable but sometimes they swap around order of the scenes.
0 0
Replying to Marchesa Sep 19, 2018
Title The Rise of Phoenixes Spoiler
Yep the end is such disappointment....nothing like the book
I don't remember too well tbh because the situation is different in the book. I think he did wish at some point she'd just give up her plans but knew she wouldn't. She was Queen of her own country for awhile before they hit stalemate and she surrendered on condition that he'd treat her friends well. She made him think she poisoned him and "died".
1 0