Details

  • Last Online: 24 days ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: November 12, 2020
Dear X korean drama review
Completed
Dear X
4 people found this review helpful
by Tharr
Dec 6, 2025
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 2.0
Story 1.0
Acting/Cast 3.0
Music 5.0
Rewatch Value 1.0

It was a hoax all along

On theme with its theme (haha, I'm so funny *sigh*), from the start this drama manipulates its viewers. From the official promoters of the drama and the so-called "media influencers", to the vast majority of easily swayed users on websites such as this. Users that think that just because they can, they SHOULD post their thoughts about how they feel, but nothing about a media's quality. And I must address this again and again, because those are NOT the same. You can enjoy bad media, and thats ok (aka "my guilty pleasure"). Just make sure you know it is bad.
For those who don't wanna read it all: this drama is sht. Full of plot devices, plot holes and plot contrivances, to make the story move forward. People might say that some aspects are interesting, but don't bother. EVEN if you like a certain actor/actress, you're better off watching some of their other works. Also no, there was no wasted potential from the start. Even the acting was done wrong.
I'll try to keep it short, and this time I might even succeed, because I won't even bother with my usual format, taking apart every aspect every piece of what goes into making a piece of media.

Here I go. Visuals. This is the part where I talk about colour grading, cinematography and such. Well, even though this drama actually deserves praises in this particular section, I won't go out of my way, and I'll explain later why. Yes, some extremely nice cinematography. I was really impressed with some shots. Moving on.

Next I'd usually talk about audio, the pacing, world-building, acting, character development, fight choreography (when there is one), production value and so on and so forth. This time, I wont, I'll go directly at its core problem. The script is sht. Period. Every aspect of it.
I'll start with its most basic aspects. A psychopath kid is first and foremost exactly that: a kid. You can't write him/her with traits of an adult when they have no life experience. Being cold, calculated and such, has nothing to do with knowing what piece of information is important, and why that is, to use for leverage. And from that "simple" aspect, everything goes downhill. Why? Because the rest of the story follows the same flawed logic, the scenes happening in the only way to make the story happen, dismissing logic or probability.
And this is mostly in regards of the "moving parts". Add to that the sht dialogue, with half sentences, not talking like a normal human being, to incur misunderstandings (so the usual dialogue in a k-drama :)) )...
Also, manipulating people happens all around, not just regarding males. You might say she was alluring them with her body, except, no she wasn't. Most of the times it was emotional manipulation, playing on aspects regarding her or her "victim", what was working best, case by case. "I suffered great wrongdoings. Your parent hates you. You and I are the same". Stuff like that. Anything that would help bewitch the victim. Even changing tactics mid-way if needed. (she hugs him, to stop him from talking because the verbal aspect was not working). So, this aspect was also wrong.
And on top of allllll of that, the acting wasn't great either. The viewers are easily swayed, I know, mostly so when its about these dramas, but thats not good acting. Or maybe its the directing... Well, I'll gladly compromise and say "it might be both". And I will give an example. Anthony Hopkins in "The Silence of the Lambs". When you threaten someone or you let them take a peak behind your mask, what they see must be reflected in their fear, their realisation that they are prey. You know, inner alarms going off, dry mouth, the fly instinct kicking off... Because thats the main hype for a psychopath, isn't it? Showing your full might and make the victim know its "insect value" while they draw their last breath. Or something like that, I don't know, I'm not one *sweats nervously*...
What we got here is the usual portraying of a deranged individual in a k-drama. Over-the-top, of even cringe, acting that consists in extreme smiling with a blank face, void looks, like thats supposed to show a "cold/no emotions" aspect.

So, using fewer words: this drama felt fake from the start because of the script and acting. Simple as that. I never understood the hype and I hope this drama will get buried fast.

And now, to sum it up. Is it good? Hell, no. You might enjoy it? No. Not even to pass time? Nope. The only praise I can address is about some visuals and some acting of the supporting cast. Watching it just for SOME nice scenes, sounds insane, especially because you don't know then there will be one. The same for the acting. If you like someone from the cast, watch them in something else. Or, you might watch this drama in the future, when you'll see the child actor in a different drama and check previous works. "Wait, it played in that drama? Hmm, bad reviews. But I like this person so I'll give it a go". Something like that, I don't know. (Yes, the child was good btw).

When a movie has good writing, people will like it even 50 years later (I won't even bother with an example, there are lots). People enjoy "bad" media because of certain aspects, even if the writing is not that good. You might like it for the visuals (the first Avatar), or the IP (the first Mortal Kombat). Or, it is so sht that you actually start having fun watching the low bar (Madame Web, Gal Gadot acting/singing in Snow White). Well, this drama is not it. It has none of those.
It gets a rating of 2 (I've already mentioned its good parts). Enjoyment factor? Re-watching value? LOL.
Have a lovely day.
Was this review helpful to you?