Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 2 hours ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: Sri Lanka
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Birthday: June 07
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: September 14, 2021
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award3 Flower Award3 Big Brain Award1
Tigers Sniff the Rose chinese drama review
Completed
Tigers Sniff the Rose
19 people found this review helpful
by Mrs Gong
7 days ago
40 of 40 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 7.0
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 7.0
Rewatch Value 4.5

A Beautifully Crafted World, Undone by Political Intrigue and Unfulfilled Promises

As someone who absolutely loved Blossom, I had exceptionally high expectations for the second collaboration between Meng Ziyi and Liu Yunrui. Ever since filming began, this costume drama has been at the top of my most-anticipated list. I expected another well-written historical story with intelligent characters, compelling political manoeuvring, and a mature relationship between two equally capable leads. Unfortunately, meeting those expectations proved much harder than I imagined.

The first three or four episodes were rather boring for me because of the slow pacing. I understand that the writers wanted to establish the world, introduce the political circumstances, and build the foundation for the main storyline. I don't necessarily have a problem with slow beginnings, especially in longer historical dramas. My problem was that even after the background had been established, the actual story never developed a particularly convincing flow. It felt as though the plot was floating from one incident to another rather than progressing through a carefully constructed chain of events.

The political setting initially had potential. We have an emperor who is practically a puppet, while a powerful eunuch controls the imperial court and holds considerable influence over the entire kingdom. More than half of the story revolves around this man's dominance, so I was prepared to follow that political arc. A powerful antagonist controlling the emperor is not inherently a problem. In fact, such a character could have provided an excellent foundation for a complicated political struggle. However, the writing eventually made some questionable decisions regarding his characterisation. Giving a villain a tragic background is perfectly reasonable, and understanding how society contributes to the creation of monsters can add considerable depth to a story. But there is a difference between explaining someone's actions and attempting to justify them. I disliked how the drama seemed to want us to sympathise with this brutal eunuch and reconsider our hatred of him simply because he had suffered in the past. His circumstances might explain parts of his personality, but they do not erase the consequences of his choices. Interestingly, Liu Wenji's tragic transformation into another version of the very man he once opposed was much more effective. His eventual fate carried genuine emotional weight because we could understand the circumstances that gradually destroyed him without pretending that his actions were harmless.

The female lead, Danyang Princess Mu Wanyao, was another character I had mixed feelings about. I appreciated that she was not written as a completely innocent or morally perfect heroine. She had ambition, authority, pride, and a strong desire to control her own destiny. Her experiences as a princess who had suffered through a disastrous political marriage also provided an interesting foundation for her character. However, there was a serious contradiction in how the drama presented her. It wanted us to admire her as a woman who understood injustice and wanted to protect ordinary people, yet it repeatedly showed her exercising her privilege over people of lower status without much consideration. Her arrival at Yan Shang's family home was one of the clearest examples. Her attendants casually threw away the family's belongings and mistreated his disabled father simply to accommodate their princess. The narrative treated much of this behaviour as part of her arrogant, amusing personality, but I found it difficult to overlook the underlying class difference. A character cannot repeatedly speak about justice while remaining unaware of how she herself participates in oppression.

This contradiction becomes particularly important when considering her relationship with Yan Shang. He is an educated scholar carrying the trauma of his family's destruction, while she is a powerful princess with access to political influence. Their initial encounter could have developed into an interesting relationship between two people with very different positions in society. Unfortunately, their romantic development did not convince me. I expected the kind of chess-match attraction where two intelligent people gradually recognise each other's abilities, challenge one another, and develop mutual respect. Instead, too much of their relationship revolved around sweet conversations, emotional declarations, and repeatedly rescuing each other. By around episode 22, I still wasn't particularly invested in their chemistry. It was not that I wanted more physical intimacy. Quite the opposite. I wanted more meaningful tension, intellectual exchanges, and strategic partnership. Two people constantly saying how much they love each other is not automatically a compelling romance.

Yan Shang himself was an interesting character in concept, but the writing did not always do him justice. His family tragedy, desire for revenge, and eventual involvement in the political struggle gave him a reasonable motivation to enter the capital. His decision to remain in Shengjing after avenging his family also marked an important turning point. Liu Xiang's advice that he should climb high enough to determine the fate of those responsible for the suffering of ordinary people was arguably one of the strongest ideas in the story. It transformed his personal revenge into something larger. However, the drama repeatedly struggled to demonstrate the intelligence and strategic abilities that his character was supposed to possess. He was presented as a brilliant scholar capable of killing an experienced military officer, but some of his later political victories relied far too heavily on convenient circumstances and persuasive speeches. I wanted to see more of his actual strategic thinking rather than simply being told how clever he was.

Another issue was the way the drama handled its female lead's suffering. Her past experiences and her traumatic marriage were important to understanding her desire for independence. Yet the narrative repeatedly placed her in situations where she was forced to compromise, endure humiliation, or suffer another setback. I understand that a political story does not need to provide an effortless victory for its heroine. However, there is a difference between portraying the difficulties of a woman fighting within a patriarchal political system and repeatedly making her suffer without giving her decisions enough meaningful consequences. I sometimes wondered what exactly the story wanted to communicate through her struggles. Was it about gaining power, protecting personal freedom, or learning to survive within an inherently unjust system? These ideas could have worked together, but the writing did not always connect them convincingly.

The political storyline became particularly frustrating during the royal hunting arc. This was supposed to be one of the major strategic confrontations, involving the Crown Prince, the eunuch, regional military powers, and several competing factions. On paper, it sounded exciting. In execution, however, it exposed some of the biggest weaknesses in the writing. The alliances were poorly established, the characters rarely seemed to anticipate their opponents' actions, and almost every important development depended on someone making an unnecessarily foolish decision. A political alliance involving the Crown Prince and a powerful regional military leader should require negotiations, guarantees, contingency plans, and some form of mutual protection. Instead, the arrangements felt surprisingly casual. Even Yu Eunuch, who had been established as an experienced and calculating political mastermind, appeared to have no meaningful backup plan when his carefully arranged situation changed.

The same problem appeared when Danyang used a forged imperial order to mobilise the imperial guards. These were supposed to be the emperor's personal forces, yet the commanding officer accepted the order with practically no verification. And then there was Meng Zaishi, a powerful regional military commander with tens of thousands of soldiers, who was captured through an almost ridiculously simple ambush and subsequently persuaded to change sides through a few speeches from Yan Shang. Seriously? This man was supposed to be a formidable military and political figure. His decisions should have involved calculations about his army, territory, political interests, and personal survival. Instead, the drama treated him as though a sufficiently persuasive conversation could completely change his political allegiance.

What bothered me most was the absence of a convincing intelligence network. In a political environment where several military factions are competing for power, information should be one of the most important weapons. Yet the characters repeatedly seemed unaware of movements and arrangements that should have been extremely difficult to conceal. The hunting ground was presented as a complicated political battlefield, but its participants behaved as though they were playing a game without knowing what the other players were doing. There were plans, counterplans, betrayals, and dramatic reversals, but very little genuine strategic calculation. The story wanted the excitement of a grand political drama without consistently doing the work required to construct one.

I also found some of the emperor's decisions difficult to accept. An emperor can certainly be cruel, irrational, and even inhuman, but those characteristics still need to be consistent with his established personality and political interests. Several decisions felt as though they existed primarily to force the protagonists into another difficult situation. The abortion storyline and some of the medical developments were similarly unconvincing. Later, the addition of the blindness arc, followed by Yan Shang's recovery and his miraculous survival after being stabbed through the chest, pushed the protagonist's plot armour to another level. At some point, I genuinely wondered whether these characters had any chance of dying at all.

The dialogue often aims for wit but lands on exposition. Characters explain their plans to each other in detail, then execute them exactly as stated. There's no room for surprise, no sense that these are people who might improvise or fail. The "you save me, I save you" pattern I mentioned before isn't just romantic; it's structural. The plot moves forward because someone is captured and rescued, then someone else is captured and rescued. The stakes never escalate; they just repeat.

Visually, the drama is caught between wanting to be a serious historical drama and wanting to be an idol romance. The costumes are rich, but the lighting is flat, washing out faces and erasing texture. The action sequences are brief, poorly choreographed, and clearly choreographed for maximum slow-motion hair-flipping rather than realism. The music tries to sell emotions the writing hasn't earned. There's a scene where the princess is pursued through the forest, and the score swells with dramatic strings, but all I could think was, "Why are there only five guards chasing her, and why do they keep letting her escape?" The production values promise a Tang Dynasty epic; the execution delivers a costume drama that's not sure if it's about politics or love and doesn't commit to either.

However, I cannot say that the entire drama was without memorable moments. In fact, some of the supporting relationships were considerably more interesting than the main couple. Chun Hua and Liu Wenji gradually became one of my favourite emotional storylines. Their relationship was tragic because neither of them possessed enough power to control their own circumstances. Liu Wenji's transformation, particularly after he lost himself, reflected the destructive nature of the political environment around him. He eventually became someone who could exercise the same kind of cruelty that had once ruined his life. His love for Chun Hua did not magically make him a good person, but it gave his downfall an additional emotional dimension. Their final separation and reunion, with their social positions completely reversed, were particularly heartbreaking. His decision to sacrifice himself after killing the useless and cruel emperor was tragic, but it also felt like the culmination of a character who had gradually lost every other way of protecting the person he loved.

And then there was the relationship between the Grand Princess and Yu Eunuch. Honestly, these two ppl's backstory was almost written to make watchers cry by the scriptwriters. I really hate to invest in a story emotionally; what abt someone who did every brutal and inhuman thing. And it didn't make any sense to me abt their complicated relationship. However, their story was interesting. They were both trapped within the political system, although they occupied very different positions within it. Their relationship carried an unusual combination of power, restraint, affection, and impossibility. Unlike the main couple, their emotional tension did not depend on constant declarations of love. There was something deeply tragic about two people who understood each other yet could never completely escape the positions they occupied.

Meng Zaishi was another character whose appearances frequently caught my attention. Perhaps it was the music, perhaps it was the way his character entered a scene, but whenever he appeared, I found myself becoming more interested. He represented a different kind of political power from the eunuch and the imperial family. His ambitions and military position could have provided a fascinating exploration of the complicated relationship between the central government and regional commanders. Unfortunately, even his character eventually became another victim of the inconsistent political writing.

The ending—the princess as regent, the male lead as prime minister, the young emperor being taught agriculture in Lingnan, the snowy capital—works on paper. It's the "power couple rules wisely" conclusion that these dramas love. But it's rushed. After forty episodes of dysfunction, the show suddenly becomes a governance procedural. The final battle is resolved with miraculous timing, a convenient heal, and the sudden appearance of a loyal army. The antagonists are dispatched quickly and without much difficulty. The emotional resolution—the princess and scholar getting married, the loser prince's son becoming emperor—is tidy in a way the rest of the drama never was. It's as if the writers realised they were out of time and needed to wrap everything up in the last hour.

Ultimately, this was a drama that looked considerably more ambitious than its actual storytelling. I came in expecting something close to the satisfaction I experienced with Blossom, but the two collaborations are not on the same level for me. The lavish production and some genuinely touching supporting relationships deserve appreciation, but the inconsistent characterisation, underdeveloped romance, convenient plot developments, and poorly constructed political manoeuvring made it difficult to remain invested throughout. I can appreciate the emotional intentions behind certain storylines without pretending that the execution was equally successful.

If there is one thing I will remember most, it will probably not be the central romance or the supposedly brilliant political schemes. It will be Chun Hua and Liu Wenji, and the tragic people who were crushed by the very system that the protagonists were trying to control. There were moments when this drama showed glimpses of a much more compelling story. I just wish the writing had been as ambitious as its production budget.
Was this review helpful to you?