WhiteLilly

Just rolling my eyes. Why do you even bother to write such long comments?... Back to the drama (as the show, not your attitude): It is good, but has many flaws, and that's it. Please, please, do not reply, I won't read it anyway.

Gosh. You really did not get what I meant, did you? All the overlong stuff you wrote I know, and still, it is sprankled with flaws. Its funny, how me saying that it has flaws is some sort of "agenda" and it makes me laugh how anyone can get so offended by sth like that. You're gonna have one tough life if you are as sensitive as this. It is a SHOW, that anyone can love or critisize as they like, not a discussion abour your hairstyle or family, so keep cool. Jeez.

I am at episode 4 and I just keep rolling my eyes. It is so cliché about bad police-work and bad police-staff and the dialogues...omg, they are so unprofessional. And lacking - like every important dialogue its like "Oh come on, just spit it out, yeah, the most important sentence right now. NOW." (like when the main guy is about to tell the old guy who the killer is and just waits and waits and waits until the emotional old guy, for no logical reason, decides to drop the walkie talkie instead of finding out who the killer is. Yeah, right. I keep watching, but seriously, it is flawed in many ways.

OK. Who's ready for another insanely awesome Reply-drama? I am!

It was a good drama, but not brilliant. However, a believable portrayal of human suffering and the struggle of two star-crossed lovers.

Thanks. I watched 1988 - and totally loved it - and tried to watch 1997 and 1994, but naaah... they fall flat after seeing 1988. Reply 1988 was the best rounded one for sure :)

So I am at ep. 11 now and it is a nice drama, but way more boring and slow-paced than 1988. And - what bugs me moste - is the lack of character from Na Joang. I mean, seriously, besides being straightforward in the first two episodes, what does she do? NOTHING. She just IS and waits for things to happen to her. (I don't mean like she decides to wait, just that her character was written very into a very passive one. Does she have a hobby, a flaw, friends besides the boarding school, is she overly helpful somewhere or funny? No. The only thing outstanding about her is that she doesn't care about farting and pooping and starts doing this one thing when she is drunkt. And that's it.) Besides that - I find her totally UGLY here. I mean, I know the actress from another drama where she looked nice, but here?? What is with this koala-bear-hairstyle? Don't tell me this was in fashion in 1994, because this ain't true. And then, she mostly pouts and makes this AWFUL double-chin. Seriously, most of the time she doesn't have a chin. Especially from profile takes, it looks SO BAD that I cannot get over it. I do not know, why this is such a problem for me, but I feel like she was made into an undeserving person of all the boys' attention - both in behaviour (because she is just bla and exists, nothing more) and looks (because she really does her best to make her face unattractive). And people, I am not a person who is about the looks! I don't care much for looks at ALL, but here it just makes no sense for the plot. At least Chil Dong, the baseball guy, would NEVER fall for this. Best thing might be the unconventional "handling" of matters like farting and pooping. But seriously?.... Not saying a bad drama, just that this portrayal is unrealistic in many ways.

out on the streets the directing and cut is way better than in the school, I wonder why...

I really think the actor does a great job here. Unlike Chi Ang...

Okay, seeing all the hate I was prepared for the worst. But seriously - this was an entertaining, average, very heavy on the romance drama.I found the female lead to be the most annoying with her lukewarm behaviour but besides the ongoing push-and-pull I found this to be quite decent.

Yeah, "dude", and what I say - she should have guessed it by now, meaning she should KNOW it by now. It is totally obvious.

I agree on both "You who came from the stars" and Reply 1997. I just really don't get the hype. (I like Master's Sun, though, even it its just for its weirdness). But "You who came from the stars" had a bitch as the main characters - no likeable traits till the last few episodes - and had no plot at all. I almost hated it. Reply 1997... again, I cannot empathize with the heroine, she is just not my type of girl. Sigh

so far, yes

I really like this. There are just two flaws: 1) The so called "experiment" is on any research level just laughable. But okay. 2) If I'd be put in an experiment about "my type of guy" which I don't get to know more about, then 3 guys start hitting on me out of the blue, and one behaves suspiciously to add, then I'd have to add just 1 plus 1 and figure out that they toy with me because of this experiment. I don't see how she can't see that, she was very clever the first two episodes, but now she is just a "regular" naive woman, kinda

Only those romance-focused people, who's shipping wasn't fullfilled, are dissatisfied. Seriously, you would be insane to miss this drama. It might be the best well-rounded drama about family and friendship that has ever been made. But it is NOT mainly about finding the husband. There is NO main lead like in the other serieses. It is about a little social universe with so much fun and feelings.

Me, too, I dropped the other, too, but this was amazing.

You know, I never ever cry in dramas. I always shake my head when I see comments like "I cried so many times" in dramas where I even cannot thing about a single minute to make you cry... So: I never cried... until this drama came along. I BAWLED EVERY EPISODE AT LEAST THREE TIMES. I mean, seriously, the feels this gives you about family and bonds... it is just insanely TOUCHING without ever being melodramatic or tragic. Awesome. Just awesome. If they make anouther Reply-series (and I found the other not as good by a wide shot), they will have to work hard to make them as good as this one. This is pure gold.

I can't understand the hype, because I cannot get beyond the first episode. All this "fan-girl-behviour" just annoys me to no end, I just cannot watch stuff like that... I never understood how anybody can be a fan of another human being to an extent like this girl here (not critisizing, just saying its not my thing) - it makes it impossible for me to bond with the main character, seriously. I tried already 3 times watching, but I switch off as soon as she starts being a fangirl again... Gosh. Hate it. Can anyone please tell me that this goes away like in the second or third epiisode???

Gosh, this is such a shame. The story is gold, but the directing and some acting is almost amateur... It really comes across like a cheap production. But I really love Duk Seon and Shin Woo, their acting is good. So, okay, it is a bit on the "teenagery" side but I can live with that. They get full marks for romance, though :D And yeah... I guess everyone know where the story is heading, who the siblings are, who the villain is and so on... Still: Wanna watch it! Just Duk Seon by herself is a ray of sunshine

Starting as an insanely good drama with a - literally - ingenious character, it becomes SO BORING from 16th episode onwards... Oh my Gosh, like someone changed the writers and directors. It draaaaaaged forever, was totally predictable and the awesome main character lost all his outlandish charme, he became just normal, duh! Only the last episode was endurable again, but I really had to struggle to continue watching from 16th onwards...