I remember watching it in the theater and I remember how strong this movie was. The tension there was. The soundtrack is amazing for that and also the silents. Performances are amazing too cause we know those actors and from their previous works you can tell they pushed beyond what we expected from them.
I personally admire a lot the director cause it is extremely rare to have directors who actually have a âconstructive lineâ into their art content (series or movies). You know where it begins where it ends, everything fits. And everything is well thought.
The only reason I am not giving 10/10 is for a very small detail which you can laugh about but I guess to me perfection is also about it.. It is the fact that it is not that rewatchable. I really didnât enjoyed it that much watching it again while I was so hyped the first time. Anyway great art !
I havenât started it yet but I want to hear your thoughts. I finished the webtoon quite a while ago like a few months ago anyway. I remember they did such an infuriating type of webtoon with happy ending (oops spoiler) but since the carnage of see you in my 19th life adaptation I donât know if I want to see it.
I think the age gap can be got over if you think about how old the ML is supposed to be, which is hundreds of…
huh even godlike are supposed to look young right ? cause they donât age but physically it shows. but in any case it is not the reason I donât find it âperfectâ (if perfection can be achieved) but I cannot pin point where it is wrong as I mentionned in a way. it is a mystery đ
I don't know if you've read that Webtoon but this one gives me Lookism vibes. Seems like kdramas are going in…
same I think I like the animation better than the webtoon âlooksimâ . unfortunatelyâŚ. if we are talking about webtoons, both hero class 1 and looksim did go to a direction I donât enjoy that much. Even if I understand the morals behind it in the end.. About kdrama adaptations⌠I believe when they try not to stick too much with the webtoon it is better in a way that readers might have expectations that arenât met if they do. like see you in my 19th life. Havenât watched marry my husband yet :/
you actually said the word âdecentâ and decent is not âgreatâ. Not saying it is a problem but you have…
I like it a lot too ^_^
But for some people⌠they want unreachable perfect stuff or like to compare a lot with other contents that arenât comparable. or idk I must say bullshit but I get you !
I want to say that this is a very powerful drama. They made a poetic series about serious âproblemsâ a lot of us face or have faced or will face.
âI feel youâ is a sentence we never like when facing hardships and cruel reality situations. And this drama is actually saying it âI feel you tooâ. And it feels that for most of us (from ratings to comment section) that we all felt understood.
I want to say it again, they picture the problems very poetically. And the soundtrack is also gorgeous to the silent moments too. Hands down to this scene of BHS crying. That was the most saddest cry I have ever witnessed. It felt real.
Only drawback I think is Dongseokâa stories because I could have stick myself with only short stories of about everyone. But his story seemed at some point to be the main arc of the whole series but I didnât personally felt the need of it.
I am more of a webtoon fan than a kdrama fan so I read Sound of magic and fhe webtoon was such a thing to me. Webtoons rely a lot on âaesthetic visualâ otherwise we would have wattpad instead with no visuals. And Sound of magic has a particularity is that is black and white and very dark. And at the same time⌠so beautiful, and âmagicalâ will actually be the word.
So it was hard to see how they would develop it into a series.
In the end, it is not as good as the webtoon but not bad. I found myself emotionally engaged in the webtoon and not in the drama. But it is not a bad drama.
But I do wonder the experience of those who donât read cause I can hardly understand how someone who hasnât read it can actually like it. Because it is very âpeculiarâ.
I want to say, as the top review says, it is one of fhe drama that you need to see it for yourself to ârate itâ. And still, it is one of the kdrama that will be hard to judge as it will take a lot of subjective thoughts (more than other dramas) to say it is good or not.
So my opinion isnât necessary. But here is what I can tell you. This is not a revenge drama, this is a healing drama. Weirdly enough, not healing for you but for the characters. And this is where it is hard to understand, because we usually make contents for others (viewers) but it feels like it was made for its creator. Like a self letter.
Romance is not the main arc of the drama.
Characters are not meant to be flawless, on the opposite. And this can be extremely irritating, frustrating, want to throw out your screen off the wall sometimes. They are also meant to be disliked. I believe there is a reason but it is too much out of my own speculation to be taken seriously..
Even after knowing all these and pounder everything it is not the best drama or the year and wonât be. Neither will it be the best performances of the whole cast. BUT we appreciate a lot their acting because it is actually a sort of acting demonstration here from everyone.
Now watch it and make your own judgement. Do not let comments influence you. You might love it and if you drop out it is fine too. It is not made for everyone.
It makes me think of Deathâs game but this is way better. Sorry I shouldnât compare dramas as I am strongly against it but it made me think of it⌠The concept a bit.
I will say I was bothered so much about the drama trying to be funny and some scenes that were odd. But in the end I understood why they are necessary.
Topics involved are deep and so closed to reality. It is disturbing how well they picture reality. And it is crescendo. The more you go the harder and deeper topics get. You need to âlight up the moodâ even if it doesnât work out.
And that is also a beautiful message to our lives and problems. You need light over the darkness. You need people trying to make you laugh when you donât want to or think you cannot anymore. You need ridiculous stuffs to the seriousness of the situation called life.
Finally can someone give LSH some lead role ? This guy has so much to show us and so much under his sleeves.
As I always say⌠I am more a webtoon fan than a drama fan.
I commented on Hero class 1 saying the drama was better than the webtoon. Extremely good indeed.. But..Here it is notâŚ
Idk about those who didnât read it but as someone who devoured the webtoon and cried with the webtoon the drama falls so far behind. And if I can judge it this way is because they really tried to make it exactly like the webtoon without the sex and without the development of the lead male character and side characters.
I think there is a cast problem in a way with the lead characters⌠The female lead isnât that cute she is more of a strong woman. I mean it literally and in terms of personality. Sin Hye Sun doesnât convey well enough that strong character and will. The lead male is extremely fragile but to a point that you feel his fragility. Ahn Bo Hyun doesnât convey it right. It is subjective maybe but I really am surprised from people who did read the webtoon and think otherwise. And I canât agree with you if you say âthis is the dramaâ well.. maybe you shouldnât make it exactly like the webtoon then and have people not expecting the same thing..
But prolly people who didnât read it liked this one a lot and I can understand them better.
Still considering those who read it.. the grades are objectively too high. I shouldnât be higher than 7 (including people who actually liked it) and obviously under 3 for myself.
Go to "community" and the go to "forums" and ask for reccs there. Why would you come into the comments section…
I wrote my previous comment rashly as I found your way to answer quite rude. And in a way I percieve quite rude again. Even if it is prolly my own perception youâll say.
Weirdly enough you seem to include other people in your statement but so far you are the only rude person I percieved so far. So maybe before trying to point out what is annoying you, first take a look at your own words.
Like I said my knowledge about chinese and japanese contents besides animations is bad and as I dropped out this series, I mixed up japanese and chinese.
Also as I said I like everything (seem you only seen gore and horror) so people could recommend romance. I didnât start this romance thinking âoh I donât like romance letâs give it a goâ
and thank you for your advice but I donât have a community dropdown menu. Of course you wonât believe it thinking I am an idiot from the way you talked to me so far. and well, believe what you want to believe đ¤ˇââď¸
And so hoensty is not the problem. It is how you speak to people. It is my perception but I wonder who would perceive your comment as not condescending.
I personally admire a lot the director cause it is extremely rare to have directors who actually have a âconstructive lineâ into their art content (series or movies). You know where it begins where it ends, everything fits. And everything is well thought.
The only reason I am not giving 10/10 is for a very small detail which you can laugh about but I guess to me perfection is also about it.. It is the fact that it is not that rewatchable. I really didnât enjoyed it that much watching it again while I was so hyped the first time. Anyway great art !
About kdrama adaptations⌠I believe when they try not to stick too much with the webtoon it is better in a way that readers might have expectations that arenât met if they do. like see you in my 19th life. Havenât watched marry my husband yet :/
But for some people⌠they want unreachable perfect stuff or like to compare a lot with other contents that arenât comparable. or idk I must say bullshit but I get you !
âI feel youâ is a sentence we never like when facing hardships and cruel reality situations. And this drama is actually saying it âI feel you tooâ. And it feels that for most of us (from ratings to comment section) that we all felt understood.
I want to say it again, they picture the problems very poetically. And the soundtrack is also gorgeous to the silent moments too. Hands down to this scene of BHS crying. That was the most saddest cry I have ever witnessed. It felt real.
Only drawback I think is Dongseokâa stories because I could have stick myself with only short stories of about everyone. But his story seemed at some point to be the main arc of the whole series but I didnât personally felt the need of it.
So it was hard to see how they would develop it into a series.
In the end, it is not as good as the webtoon but not bad. I found myself emotionally engaged in the webtoon and not in the drama. But it is not a bad drama.
But I do wonder the experience of those who donât read cause I can hardly understand how someone who hasnât read it can actually like it. Because it is very âpeculiarâ.
I want to say, as the top review says, it is one of fhe drama that you need to see it for yourself to ârate itâ. And still, it is one of the kdrama that will be hard to judge as it will take a lot of subjective thoughts (more than other dramas) to say it is good or not.
So my opinion isnât necessary. But here is what I can tell you. This is not a revenge drama, this is a healing drama. Weirdly enough, not healing for you but for the characters. And this is where it is hard to understand, because we usually make contents for others (viewers) but it feels like it was made for its creator. Like a self letter.
Romance is not the main arc of the drama.
Characters are not meant to be flawless, on the opposite. And this can be extremely irritating, frustrating, want to throw out your screen off the wall sometimes. They are also meant to be disliked. I believe there is a reason but it is too much out of my own speculation to be taken seriously..
Even after knowing all these and pounder everything it is not the best drama or the year and wonât be. Neither will it be the best performances of the whole cast. BUT we appreciate a lot their acting because it is actually a sort of acting demonstration here from everyone.
Now watch it and make your own judgement. Do not let comments influence you. You might love it and if you drop out it is fine too. It is not made for everyone.
I will say I was bothered so much about the drama trying to be funny and some scenes that were odd. But in the end I understood why they are necessary.
Topics involved are deep and so closed to reality. It is disturbing how well they picture reality. And it is crescendo. The more you go the harder and deeper topics get. You need to âlight up the moodâ even if it doesnât work out.
And that is also a beautiful message to our lives and problems. You need light over the darkness. You need people trying to make you laugh when you donât want to or think you cannot anymore. You need ridiculous stuffs to the seriousness of the situation called life.
Finally can someone give LSH some lead role ? This guy has so much to show us and so much under his sleeves.
I commented on Hero class 1 saying the drama was better than the webtoon. Extremely good indeed.. But..Here it is notâŚ
Idk about those who didnât read it but as someone who devoured the webtoon and cried with the webtoon the drama falls so far behind. And if I can judge it this way is because they really tried to make it exactly like the webtoon without the sex and without the development of the lead male character and side characters.
I think there is a cast problem in a way with the lead characters⌠The female lead isnât that cute she is more of a strong woman. I mean it literally and in terms of personality. Sin Hye Sun doesnât convey well enough that strong character and will. The lead male is extremely fragile but to a point that you feel his fragility. Ahn Bo Hyun doesnât convey it right. It is subjective maybe but I really am surprised from people who did read the webtoon and think otherwise. And I canât agree with you if you say âthis is the dramaâ well.. maybe you shouldnât make it exactly like the webtoon then and have people not expecting the same thing..
But prolly people who didnât read it liked this one a lot and I can understand them better.
Still considering those who read it.. the grades are objectively too high. I shouldnât be higher than 7 (including people who actually liked it) and obviously under 3 for myself.
Honestly my comment is very subjective but I do think it is đ
Weirdly enough you seem to include other people in your statement but so far you are the only rude person I percieved so far. So maybe before trying to point out what is annoying you, first take a look at your own words.
Like I said my knowledge about chinese and japanese contents besides animations is bad and as I dropped out this series, I mixed up japanese and chinese.
Also as I said I like everything (seem you only seen gore and horror) so people could recommend romance. I didnât start this romance thinking âoh I donât like romance letâs give it a goâ
and thank you for your advice but I donât have a community dropdown menu. Of course you wonât believe it thinking I am an idiot from the way you talked to me so far. and well, believe what you want to believe đ¤ˇââď¸
And so hoensty is not the problem. It is how you speak to people. It is my perception but I wonder who would perceive your comment as not condescending.