5
1
If It Walks Like a Duck
The series opens with a poorly executed in medias res: within minutes, we are shown an apparent death, only for the story to retreat into flashbacks layered inside other flashbacks. The result is not complexity, but confusion. Eventually, you find yourself looking at a character without knowing which timeline you are in, whether he is still alive, whether you are watching a memory, or when any of this is actually happening.
The tonal incompatibility makes things worse. You cannot open with an apparent murder and, fifteen minutes later, expect everyday problems at a music school to carry the same dramatic weight. The tension the opening worked so hard to create simply evaporates.
What initially looks like a story about talent, competition, privilege, and the world of classical music quickly becomes the usual blender of family hierarchies, an authoritarian grandfather, parental debt, loan sharks, humiliation, romance, trauma, and melodrama. The piano, meanwhile, is almost incidental.
And that is particularly frustrating because there is a much better story hiding underneath all of this: two exceptionally talented young men, one with every resource available to develop his potential, and another who cannot afford the luxury of pursuing his talent because he actually has to make a living. That conflict alone could have carried the series.
Instead of exploring it, the drama keeps adding complications.
If I need a flowchart and a notebook just to figure out which timeline I'm watching, the writer has failed at one of the most fundamental rules of storytelling: clarity.
The tonal incompatibility makes things worse. You cannot open with an apparent murder and, fifteen minutes later, expect everyday problems at a music school to carry the same dramatic weight. The tension the opening worked so hard to create simply evaporates.
What initially looks like a story about talent, competition, privilege, and the world of classical music quickly becomes the usual blender of family hierarchies, an authoritarian grandfather, parental debt, loan sharks, humiliation, romance, trauma, and melodrama. The piano, meanwhile, is almost incidental.
And that is particularly frustrating because there is a much better story hiding underneath all of this: two exceptionally talented young men, one with every resource available to develop his potential, and another who cannot afford the luxury of pursuing his talent because he actually has to make a living. That conflict alone could have carried the series.
Instead of exploring it, the drama keeps adding complications.
If I need a flowchart and a notebook just to figure out which timeline I'm watching, the writer has failed at one of the most fundamental rules of storytelling: clarity.
Was this review helpful to you?
