Critica sin filtro

All Hype, No Substance

Bon Appétit promised a lot with Yoona in the lead role, but the result turned out to be a major disappointment.

The finale spends almost the entire episode on the rebellion against the king, in scenes that feel almost copied from Mr. Queen. What should have been thrilling quickly dissolves into a predictable climax. Even the long-awaited love confession feels flat, lacking passion or emotional weight.

The ending, where she returns to the present and reunites with him, arrives without logic or convincing explanation. It all happens simply “because it has to,” leaving the audience to fill the gaps on their own.

In the end, Bon Appétit is neither a memorable K-drama nor a strong romance. It’s a recycled, sugary, and directionless story. The only thing sustaining the buzz around it is the fandom, unwilling to admit that their favorite stars ended up leading a trainwreck of a series.

Read More

The Cowardice of Great Ideas

What could have been the story of a single man standing against a corrupt and oppressive system over something as ridiculous as a small sack of rice —and, in that simplicity, define the perfect anti-hero: someone who doesn’t fight for the people, nor for justice, but out of pure exhaustion— turns into a feast of soulless fights, weightless characters, fake intensity, and villains striking caricature poses.

Everything moves with a sleepy rhythm, a scattered plot, and a message that drowns in empty metaphors. The Murky Stream doesn’t lack ideas; it lacks courage.

Read More

A Recycling of Korean Villain Clichés

Mantis is supposed to be a spin-off of Kill Boksoon, but instead of expanding that universe, it reduces it to a parody of itself.

The “recipe” of clichés is complete: villains cast only for their “evil face,” slow-motion walks, heads tilted back, lazy one-liners before killing, and of course, the eternal knife fights. Instead of building tension, they provoke laughter.

The opening airport scene says it all: what should be a tense introduction turns into a catwalk of arrogance. Later, when the protagonist’s company “goes bankrupt,” he’s surrounded by people offering him jobs as if he were a K-pop idol at a fan meeting. It’s impossible to take that seriously.

The pacing is slow, the acting mediocre, and what is meant to be stylish ends up as pure posturing. In the end, Mantis is not a thriller about assassins — it’s a catalog of recycled Korean clichés, where real tension is replaced with scenes so ridiculous they feel like a sketch.

It will only work for teenage fangirls who don’t care about the story as long as their oppa is on screen. For everyone else, this borders on trash.

Read More

Zomvivor (2025) – Review

The series should’ve been called: “How to Destroy Your Survival Group in Three Easy Steps.”

Step one: let your phone alarm go off in the middle of a zombie invasion.
Step two: don’t turn it off or throw it away,
because sentimentality weighs more than instinct.
Step three: run straight toward your friends to share the disaster.

That’s what separates smart tension from self-parody:
here, characters don’t die because of danger,
they die because of the stupidity programmed by the screenwriter.
And the audience, instead of suffering, ends up yelling at the screen:
“Just let her die already, please!”

Then comes the contractual drama:
the virus spreads only when the plot finds it convenient.
When a character is irrelevant, they turn in ten seconds.
But if they’re important, the camera gifts them three minutes
of close-ups, tears, and sad music.

And the flashbacks… oh, the flashbacks.
In a zombie series, how important is it to know the origin?
None.
When the world is falling apart, what defines the story
isn’t why it happened — it’s who survives.

Knowing why zombies exist rarely improves a story.
In fact, it often kills it.
If it’s a virus, it turns into sci-fi.
If it’s an experiment, it becomes a cliché.
If it’s divine punishment, it’s a sermon.
And if it’s “no one knows,” that actually works —
because what matters isn’t the origin,
but how the living react.

Zomvivor brings nothing new
to the already over-saturated zombie catalog.
The story is as shallow as a puddle.
And if you’ve seen too many undead films,
you’ll be bored to death —
because you’ve already seen every one of these scenes before.

Read More

Romantics Anonymous – A Fantasy About Chocolate and Denial

Romantics Anonymous starts with chocolate, but don’t be fooled — this isn’t a sweet story, it’s a clumsy one.
She suffers from scopophobia, the irrational fear of being watched.
He has misophobia, a fear of being touched.
Two people trapped in their own anxieties… that the script turns into romance.

Instead of showing what it means to live with social anxiety or touch disorders, the series uses them as excuses for “cute” moments.
He falls on top of her, both panicking — and the script goes, “Look how adorable!”
There’s no tenderness in a mutual nervous breakdown.

And of course, the message is the same as always: love cures everything.
She wins a contest, spots him in the crowd, runs, hugs him… and magically, she’s healed.

In real life, these phobias don’t vanish with hugs or chocolate.
They take years of therapy, relapses, and isolation.
But Romantics Anonymous uses them as decoration, as if trauma were just part of the packaging.

So no, this isn’t a romantic story.
It’s a fantasy about chocolate and denial.

Does it work?
Yes — if what you enjoy are surreal worlds and bedtime stories where you control the ending.

Read More

Dear X (Episodes 1–4): From Genius to Overacting

Dear X starts off brilliantly — a sharp, elegant dissection of ambition, trauma, and emotional manipulation.
Baek Ah Jin, played with surgical precision in the first two episodes, feels like a modern antiheroine shaped by pain rather than redemption.
Her cold, calculated demeanor suggests a story about psychological power, not simple revenge.

But by episode 3, the series stumbles.
The script mistakes complexity for excess, turning what could’ve been a chilling, simple act into an over-engineered mess.
Ah Jin stops being formidable and becomes theatrical — a strategist buried under implausible coincidences.

Episode 4 tries to recover tension through a police investigation, but ends up draining it instead.
Ah Jin, once fascinating, now looks overacted and hollow, her silence replaced by melodrama.

Visually, Dear X remains stylish — the rain, cold tones, and restrained pacing still work — yet the emotional impact evaporates.
It had all the ingredients for a story about moral decay and ambition, but it collapses under its own artifice.

Not terrible, but uneven: it begins with fire and ends with smoke.
For now, Dear X feels more like a promise than a revelation.

Read More

A Hollow Attempt at Dark Comedy

Not Other Choice” is a film that never justifies its own length.
From the very beginning, it becomes clear that Park Chan-wook does not have a grip on dark comedy. The film mistakes boredom for depth and builds a structure that is scattered, heavy, and unfocused. It tries to criticize everything—family, society, ethics, justice, media—but ends up saying nothing.

The so-called humor is completely absent. Every line feels clumsy, improvised, and painfully forced. After the first thirty minutes, the movie becomes almost unbearable. The characters are surprisingly unlikable—rare for Korean cinema—and the protagonist goes from being laid off to committing murder without any believable motivation.

The attempt to adapt Western satire to a Korean context simply doesn’t work. The values, tone, and moral foundations don’t translate, and the story collapses under its own confusion.
Lee Byung-hun tries, but never looks natural.
Son Ye-jin is the only redeeming element: every scene she’s in carries more emotional truth than the entire script.

In the end, the film feels like a mix of Breaking Bad and Ozark—but with none of the intelligence, tension, or moral clarity that made those works great.

Read More

Friendship Over Rivalry: The True Triangle in A Hundred Memories

When we talk about love triangles, we usually picture rivalry, jealousy, or even betrayal between two friends. That’s the cliché. But A Hundred Memories dares to flip the formula. Ko Yeong Rye is in love with Jae Pil, but Jae Pil is drawn to Seo Jong Hee. The twist? Yeong Rye and Jong Hee aren’t rivals—they’re best friends. That choice changes everything.

It’s a premise that echoes Truffaut’s Jules et Jim (1962), where friendship and love collide in a way that feels honest rather than melodramatic. Or think of My Best Friend’s Wedding (1997), where the story doesn’t end with the expected romantic “win,” but with a bittersweet acceptance of friendship over rivalry. That’s the same kind of vibe A Hundred Memories might be leaning toward.

What are the possible outcomes? One: Jong Hee could renounce Jae Pil, leaving nobody with anyone. Two: once Jae Pil shows clear interest in Jong Hee, Yeong Rye would realistically back away—because being the “second choice” is painful, maybe even unbearable. And three: there’s Jong Hee’s brother, the law student, who already seems intrigued by her. He could easily become the unexpected twist in this delicate balance.

And then there’s that closing scene of Episode 4. Jae Pil accidentally runs into Jong Hee, now wearing her work uniform. His silence and stare linger too long—it feels exaggerated, almost as if the uniform itself carries judgment. If it were me, I’d have gone with something natural like, “Oh, what a surprise, I didn’t know you worked here.” But the direction makes his hesitation about status clear. Is he truly shocked… or is the drama emphasizing how much appearances still matter in this world?

We’ll see in Episode 5 if he softens his reaction or doubles down. Either way, it’s a fascinating tension between natural storytelling and heightened drama.

Episode 10 Update
With just one weekend left before it ends, the series chooses stability over catharsis.
After Hee and Rye finally face each other and admit they love the same man, the show instantly cools everything down. Hee realizes—without anyone having to tell her—that she has no real chance against Rye. From that point on, she practically disappears from the episode when it comes to Pil: no contact, no exchange, just her own tension with her mother and the brief encounter with Rye’s brother. It’s a deliberate narrative choice: the script removes her from the love triangle and reframes her as a social mirror rather than a romantic rival. The result is an emotional void—the triangle doesn’t resolve, it simply fades away. A Hundred Memories shifts from the inner fire of feelings to the outer order of hierarchy. Visually stunning, yes, but clearly a choice for stability instead of catharsis.
The preview for episode 11 confirms it: love is no longer the battlefield—Miss Korea is. Where they once competed for affection, they now compete for validation. “Let’s play fair this time,” Hee tells Rye, barely touching her hand. It’s the echo of everything before: two women who once hurt each other trying to win the same man, now standing as equals in a symbolic arena. It’s not reconciliation; it’s acceptance.
Meanwhile, Hyun drifts into narrative limbo. His arc promised maturity and balance, but the script reduces him to a bystander. Unless the finale gives him purpose again, the ending risks feeling uneven. Because if this episode proved anything, it’s that A Hundred Memories knows how to close chapters with visual grace—but not always with emotional justice.

Read More

From Seoul to Hollywood in Three Glances and a Flower

Final Review Typhoon Family: A Storm With No Wind”
Typhoon Family ends with a happy ending, but the drama never truly worked.
It suffered from narrative hamster syndrome: constant suffering, constant chaos, no real progression.
The writers confused accumulated misery with emotion, and movement with storytelling.
The performances are good —especially Kim Ni-ha— but the script wasted them, giving her nothing but crying scenes with no emotional range.
And yes, happy ending, villains in jail, romance finally consummated… but as bland as the rest of the show.
A happy ending can’t fix 16 episodes that never connected. 2025 is full of dramas where the actors are better than the script:
Moon River, Dear X, Would You Marry Me?, No Other Choice. Typhoon Family just joined the list.

Episode 1
The first encounter tries to be tender, but it’s the most overused cliché in K-drama: he falls on her. The only new thing is the melancholic wrapping — the “prestigious” version of the same old stumble.

But then comes the subway scene. The dual visual language.
She (Kim Min-ha) is filmed in tight shots, soft light, and desaturated tones. Her gaze dominates the frame; the focus stays on her eyes, not the background. It conveys introspection, timidity, and vulnerability.
He (Jun-ho), on the other hand, is treated oppositely: wide framing, glass reflections, warm tones, even the pink bouquet as a symbol of vanity and artifice. He knows he’s being watched.
Together, the montage creates a mirror play: she looks, he poses; she feels, he performs.

The separation sequence is built with classic Hollywood grammar. The slight lip bite marks the exact instant when inner emotion becomes conscious. Then, the shot of the falling flower works as a universal symbol of lost contact or missed opportunity — a motif used over and over in Western romantic cinema (from Brief Encounter to Before Sunrise). The camera leaves her alone, the frame widens, and the background fades: solitude in motion.

The falling flower perfectly closes the emotional arc of their encounter — a silent yet unmistakable symbol of attachment and memory.
She doesn’t say “I liked him,” she doesn’t say “I miss him,” but the simple act of keeping something so ephemeral says it all.

The warm light, the curtains, and the static framing turn that moment into a visual sigh, almost a poetic epilogue to what just happened. It’s a device straight out of European romantic cinema (think Amélie or In the Mood for Love), yet used here with Korean subtlety.

It feels Hollywood not because it imitates, but because it adopts the language of classic romantic cinema: the visual construction of destiny, the orchestral music that accompanies without interrupting, the flower as a tangible symbol of remembrance, and above all, the restrained emotion that becomes universal.
That fragment alone is enough to justify the entire episode.

Update episode 2
If episode one was saved by a cinematic moment —that subway scene, poetic and restrained—
episode two collapses into mediocrity.
Nothing stands out.
It’s empty, slow, emotionless, filled with shouting and recycled melodrama.

With two leads of this caliber, such a weak script is unforgivable.
The problem isn’t talent — it’s direction.
Episode two doesn’t stumble… it crashes.

Read More

From Chanbara Promise to Death-Game Recycling

Everyone online is calling this the ‘next great samurai series,’ but let’s be honest: it starts like real chanbara and ends as another recycled death game.
The opening is excellent — clean framing, silence, iaijutsu-style movement, a duel over in seconds. Pure Kurosawa influence.
But as soon as the rules, numbers, VIP spectators and the ‘last-one-standing’ structure appear, the mysticism collapses.
It’s Squid Game in a kimono.
Not a bad show — just not new.
And for viewers who actually know classic samurai cinema (Inagaki, Mizoguchi, Kobayashi, Uchida, Kurosawa), this feels more like spectacle than substance.

Read More

A Thriller Built on Clichés and Convenience

Manipulated” tries to sell itself as a dark, complex thriller, but ends up collapsing under the weight of every cliché it borrows. The series builds its entire premise on an innocent man wrongly accused, a flamboyant rich psychopath, a corrupt politician, an incompetent police force, and even a survival car race straight out of Death Race (2008). Instead of suspense, it delivers absurdity packaged as drama.

The investigation never feels real. The prosecution presents circumstantial “evidence” that would be dismissed instantly in any believable legal system. Procedures vanish, logic disappears, and the script constantly removes the presence of the State just to make its villain work. By episode five, the show abandons any sense of grounded storytelling and leans fully into cartoonish spectacle.

Ji Chang-wook once again gives his all, but he’s trapped in a script that confuses intensity with incoherence. The series tries to evoke emotion through exaggerated performances, recycled tropes, and overdramatic set pieces, but never earns the tension it demands.

In the end, Manipulated doesn’t manipulate the story — it manipulates the audience, expecting them to overlook every narrative gap just because the packaging looks thrilling.
It’s not suspense. It’s noise.

Read More

Mobius: A Waiting Line Disguised as a Thriller

Mobius has a huge problem: its time loops kill the tension. The show makes it clear that everything only gets solved on the 5th loop. So what about the other four? Just rehearsals. Pure filler.

Even the main character admits there’s no fear of dying. And if the hero himself doesn’t care, why should the audience? When he dies in the 2nd loop, it doesn’t matter, because you know he’ll be back anyway.

On top of that, the plot is overcrowded with suspects, but that’s not real intrigue — it’s just confusion disguised as mystery. What could have been suspenseful ends up feeling like waiting in line.

Mobius turns what should be tension into simple waiting, and that kills its own suspense. Because if everything is decided on the 5th loop, it’s nothing more than an hourglass that only cares about the last grain. Not a thriller, but a waiting line disguised as mystery

Read More

From Hitchcock-Level Tension to a Fearful, Safe Ending

“As You Stood By” could’ve reached Hitchcock territory.
It begins with razor-sharp tension, a minimalist score that keeps you on edge, and a cathartic, brutal confrontation reminiscent of Memories of Murder, Bluebeard, and The Invisible Man.
But the real test of a thriller is what happens after the catharsis — and here is where the series collapses.
The impostor’s sudden transformation into a gangster feels artificial, created only to prolong the plot.
Worst of all, the most compelling character — the sister, a sharp and methodical detective — is minimized, sabotaged, and ultimately punished while everyone else gets a convenient, almost cheerful ending.
A story that began with genuine courage ends as a safe moral fable

Read More

The Show That Sabotaged Itself

12 Letters can be split into two halves: episodes 1 to 5 are a brilliant romantic sci-fi; episodes 6 to 12 are a disaster.

It starts with a mysterious mailbox connecting 1991 and 2026, a fresh premise that immediately recalls Frequency (2000). In Frequency, a father and son spoke across time with a clear, consistent dilemma. 12 Letters had the same potential, but it quickly lost its way.

From episode 6 onward, everything falls apart: the mailbox is forgotten, cartoonish gangsters show up, school melodrama takes over, and Shen Cheng—once a key character—is reduced to an idiot by bad writing. Episodes 8 and 9 are pure filler, endless flashbacks explaining what we already knew.

The ending is even worse: a last-minute warning letter that magically fixes everything, Shen erased from existence, Yu Nian waking up in a luxurious bed with a different life, and a sad soundtrack to force emotions. What began as a tense sci-fi puzzle ends with a rushed “happily ever after.”

12 Letters could have been the Chinese Frequency. Instead, it’s a collage of clichés and cheap melodrama—a show that sabotaged itself.

Read More