I may be in the minority here but this dramas was not what I was expecting, it really gets thumbs up for the suspense part of the drama but the romance wasn't well portrayed. The problem for this drama for me is that it didn't defined what kind of drama it wanted to be, a suspense drama or a romance drama or a comedy drama? It was not a good combination in my opinion. But I would love to see a suspense drama written by this author because the plot twist and the villain were written extraordinarily!!
This was an entertaining drama it was not the best drama ever, but it did accomplish to entertain it's a good drama just don't watch it with great expectations and you'll be fine.
Wow most of the ones you picked would not be my top pick for these guys except for maybe My Girl. Ok so my Arashi…
I did like Kagi no Kakatta Heya and actually was considering to write about it, but since I had Maou I didn't want to put 2 dramas kind of the same genre, so that's why I choose Sekai ichi muzukashii koi.
I haven't watched Yoiko no Mikata nor Smile, I'll give them a try.
And as you I was Jun baited to the fandom due to HYD.
I'm very disappointed in this drama, it probably just me because all the other reviews are good reviews.…
I did watch it till the end. When I talk about how it was incomprehensible the way she got involved in the cases, I wasn't referring to the reason she choose to get involved, but that all the coincidences that lead to her getting involve in the cases were pretty unbelievable and the possibilities of that happening were pretty scarce (though I understand this is a drama and not real life, but still is not that credible). I think they scolded her once for getting involved but still they didn’t stop her.
The issue with the closed rooms is that I don’t think it was necessary that every episode had to have one, in Kagi no Kakatta Heya that was the main theme “closed rooms” but here they could have more variety in their cases.
But everyone has their own opinion and I think we can have a friendly discussion. Don’t worry I also get heated when I want to defend something I like, but also when I’m disappointed and I had big expectations for this drama which weren’t fulfilled.
This a lighthearted drama, the main couple is very cute and have good chemistry, is not the best romance drama out there but is pretty entertaining. I was thinking not to watch it because it has so many negative comments here, but I'm glad I decided to watch it. So give it a chance!
I agree with most of them but Healer wasn't objectively awful. It was one of the most logical and satisfying…
I also don't understand why Healer is here? The rating on MDL is 8.9 which is higher than the rating of cityhunter83, so doesn't that mean at least the average like it more than cityhunter83?
I also think Healer wasn't objectively awful and it wasn't makjang at all.
- Fangirl mode activated - Thanks for this article. i've watched them all but I think it's a good start…
Sakurai is still my favorite member!! Thanks for your comment I really like reading your point of view as an Arashi fan. And I was torn between Sekaimuzu and Kagi no Kakkata Heya but since I wanted to put 2 total different genres I choose Sekamuzu. But still Face down is one of my favorite songs as well!!
1 
I haven't watched Yoiko no Mikata nor Smile, I'll give them a try.
And as you I was Jun baited to the fandom due to HYD.
The issue with the closed rooms is that I don’t think it was necessary that every episode had to have one, in Kagi no Kakatta Heya that was the main theme “closed rooms” but here they could have more variety in their cases.
But everyone has their own opinion and I think we can have a friendly discussion. Don’t worry I also get heated when I want to defend something I like, but also when I’m disappointed and I had big expectations for this drama which weren’t fulfilled.
I also think Healer wasn't objectively awful and it wasn't makjang at all.