Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 6 hours ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: March 15, 2023
The Lament of Autumn chinese drama review
Completed
The Lament of Autumn
1 people found this review helpful
by Nil
1 day ago
40 of 40 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 8.0
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 8.5
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 8.0
This review may contain spoilers

unexpectedly one of the best dramas i’ve watched in recent years

well, this was a surprise. a rather pleasant one, actually. i rarely watch chinese dramas, partly because they’re so long, but mostly because they rarely appeal to my taste. this one, however, was a pleasant exception.

i went into this with relatively low expectations and somehow ended up watching one of the most entertaining dramas i’ve seen in years. was it particularly well written? not always. did the writers lose their minds somewhere along the way? absolutely. but did i enjoy it? very much so.

i’ve been watching asian dramas for years, and i’ve always had a particular weakness for old-school melodramas. obsessive love, jealousy, betrayal, morally questionable characters and people making terrible decisions because they’re hopelessly in love. that’s precisely the kind of television i enjoy, and unfortunately, something i find increasingly difficult to come across these days.

now, onto yu changxuan.

what an absolutely dreadful man. and i mean that in the most complimentary way possible.

he is genuinely one of the most morally reprehensible male leads i’ve encountered in quite some time. arrogant, selfish, hedonistic, manipulative, possessive and cruel. a man so accustomed to getting his way that the mere possibility of rejection seems to offend him personally. calling him a red flag would be rather generous. he’s a BLACK flag, and at certain points he practically becomes the antagonist of his own love story. i wouldn’t even call him an antihero.

he’s that morally fucked up. frankly, i found him fascinating.

i’ve always loved the obsessive male lead trope, particularly when the character is genuinely dangerous rather than simply an arrogant man who occasionally gets jealous. what interested me most about changxuan was watching his initial arrogance gradually turn into desperation. he approaches pingjun with ulterior motives, treating her as another person he can manipulate, only to become increasingly consumed by a woman who has absolutely no intention of loving him.

and the fact that she’s already in love with another man makes everything considerably worse.

he can intimidate people, manipulate situations and control practically everyone around him, but he cannot make this particular woman fall in love with him.

and it drives him insane.

exactly the kind of fictional obsession i enjoy watching.

of course, i understand why the relationship has been so controversial. there are scenes involving coercion, sexual aggression, forced kissing and behavior that is, quite frankly, incredibly rapey. some of it is genuinely disturbing, and i certainly wouldn’t recommend this to anyone expecting a healthy romance.

but i’ve never understood the expectation that fictional relationships must somehow reflect what people would find acceptable in real life. i’m perfectly capable of distinguishing the two. i don’t need my characters to be morally respectable, nor do i need every romantic relationship to serve as an example of appropriate behavior.

sometimes i simply want to watch deeply flawed people become obsessed with one another. apparently that’s too much for certain audiences.

cheng lei was phenomenal.

his portrayal of changxuan was easily one of the strongest aspects of the drama. the arrogance, calculated cruelty, jealousy, desperation and particularly the way he expressed physical desire were remarkably convincing. even his posture and the way he looked at pingjun conveyed so much about the character. he never seemed interested in making changxuan particularly likable, which i appreciated.
the chemistry between the leads was exceptional.

those kissing scenes, especially.

i genuinely wasn’t expecting this level of romantic and sexual tension from a modern chinese drama. the lingering looks, physical proximity, suggestive dialogue and overall sensuality gave the relationship a surprisingly mature quality. it was sexual without being unnecessarily explicit or vulgar, and the attraction felt physical rather than merely something the dialogue kept insisting existed.

as for xu ruohan, i thought her acting was perfectly adequate, although cheng lei certainly delivered the more memorable performance.

however, my god, that woman is BEAUTIFUL.

i genuinely couldn’t stop looking at her face. she’s almost ridiculously pretty, and her beauty suited the period setting exceptionally well.

more importantly, i absolutely loved pingjun as a character.

finally, a female lead with a functioning brain.

she’s intelligent, outspoken, stubborn and entirely capable of standing up for herself. considering the kind of man changxuan is, it would’ve been remarkably easy to turn her into another passive heroine who simply exists to be manipulated and rescued. thankfully, the writers gave her an actual personality, her own principles and the ability to challenge him without immediately abandoning every ounce of common sense.

apparently, that’s still something worth celebrating.

now, the writing.

FORTY EPISODES.

i understand that this is a historical melodrama with extensive political and military storylines, but surely someone could have exercised a little restraint.

and yes, i’m perfectly aware that makjang is a korean term, but this is makjang as FUCK.

i’ve been watching melodramas long enough to appreciate their more ridiculous conventions. however, there’s a difference between an entertainingly excessive storyline and one that seems determined to incorporate every possible tragedy known to television.

the political conflicts were already complicated enough. military conspiracies, power struggles, family secrets, endless betrayals and approximately a thousand people plotting against one another. at times, the romance practically disappeared beneath all the political exposition.

and then, for reasons that remain entirely beyond me, the writers decided to introduce amnesia.
i found that storyline particularly unnecessary. the relationship was already compelling enough without conveniently erasing someone’s memory to manufacture another obstacle. it’s an exhausted narrative device, and its inclusion here did absolutely nothing to improve my opinion of the writing.

unfortunately, things became considerably worse around episode 32.

pregnancies, miscarriage, baby kidnapping, presumed deaths, endless separations and increasingly absurd political developments. the characters could barely enjoy five minutes of peace before another catastrophe arrived.

i enjoy tragedy. i enjoy complicated relationships and emotionally exhausting storytelling. what i don’t particularly enjoy is watching writers confuse excessive suffering with narrative complexity.

by the final stretch, the constant escalation had become genuinely tiresome.

a tighter 30-episode drama would’ve been considerably better. the central relationship was more than interesting enough to carry the story without half of these unnecessary complications.

still, despite my complaints, i enjoyed this far more than i expected.

the jealousy is ugly and irrational rather than some harmless romantic gesture, and changxuan’s obsession never magically transforms him into a respectable human being. he’s deeply flawed, often indefensible and occasionally downright villainous.

which, to me, is far more interesting than another perfectly sanitized romantic hero.

so yes, the writing was inconsistent, the final episodes were unnecessarily exhausting and the amnesia storyline had no business existing. nevertheless, the performances, chemistry and overall atmosphere made this one of the most enjoyable dramas i’ve watched in recent years.

would i recommend it to someone who primarily enjoys fluffy romances and morally admirable characters? certainly not.

but for anyone who appreciates obsessive romance and unapologetically dysfunctional characters, there’s quite a lot to enjoy here.

please bring back adult melodramas like this.

preferably with slightly more competent screenwriters.
Was this review helpful to you?