Yvette

I understand if they thought no one lived there, but when the guy appeared suddenly and GH didn't flinch one bit so it's just wtf 😂

Side note but I found it funny that they kept getting in a property and basement, not caring if someone lived there and GH not being scared one bit when the owner found him inside lmao

Honestly I don't understand how just bc the grey hair guy bought the house in 2005 means he's innocent bc the kidnapping happened in 2004... especially when he said that apparently there wasn't an owner before... so he could've basically just used the house without owning it but anyway, I know as an outside viewer it's easier to say lol (and there's probably another explanation too)

However I'm really curious about the link between the drunk guy and the grey hair guy...
And if he really is the real official culprit, the fact that he also tried to bring back home another little girl is so disgusting.... like he was there all along and tried to kidnap again ? idk

Also I sensed the breakup such a long time ago so I couldn't care less now that it happened.
I find it frustrating but at the same time I find it more understandable than in some other dramas...
Tbh the main thing I want is to finally know about all the secrets 🙄

Istg in this drama every time there's a mystery unsolved, another one appears 😂

For a moment I really thought it was obviously Dahyun's father that kidnapped Gyeyoung, so the red gate house was actually her house at the time, but when she entered and it wasn't actually her house, it got more complicated to me

Right now my two theories are either Gyeyoung or Dahyun's dad as the culprit,
which is probably not it, but I'm really convinced it's someone within their circle...
If it's just a random psycho guy I feel like it has less sense (not that it wouldn't be possible, but for the the mystery to be that big I think it's too "basic" as a plot idk

This is too nerve wracking, every time we think we're getting answers it gets even more mysterious 😂

Tbh I was only trying to understand how their family works, first because at the very beginning I was afraid there was some weird sister/brother thing going on, and then I just got curious… but if their family story isn’t a plot in the story I’ll just stop caring about it lol it got way too complicated for me

But if the daughters paired with the sons don't share the same blood, the men had an "official" wife ? (even though they never mentioned this either), and the Fortune teller woman is supposed to be the mistress or something ? Because they all act like they have feelings for them... it's so confusing

Also for the actress playing the woman with the soldier, it's actually not the same as Seulbi's mom, BUT Minjoon also played the Joseon emperor and his "fiancee" played their daughter running away haha

Actually I understood the ancestry very differently and I never thought the soldier guy was the CEO's father 😂
But it could be, so that would mean seulbi's mom isn't the soldier man's daughter ?
Tbh I stopped following the story in details, because just like you have many questions, I have too many interrogations so I just decided to watch and see what happens lmao

YeahI haven't read the webtoon but have you ? Because unless someone who have read it explains it to us I will always be confused 😂

Okay so I just watched the "story" and it's not helping 😂 they say that the women had daughters and were always hidden, but they never really mention if the daughter goes to a man of another family or anything 😅 or maybe it was explained later on but I don't remember it at all

Oh I don't recall them saying they suddenly got pregnant with no man needed, maybe I forgot ! but I thought that either the woman and the man had a girl and they married her to another "outside" man to pass on the fortune thing...
but then Seulbi and Minjoon's case doesn't make sense ?
I'm genuinely confused bc I don't remind them talking about the "sons" mothers too... So I thought for a sec that there was some incest going on but I truly hope not 😭
I'm going to listen to the first episode again lmao

Wait I didn't really think much about it until now, but how is the genealogy tree working ? 🤔
I first thought the fortune women had to stay by the man's side from father to son for centuries, but does that mean that she always has to get pregnant by another man ?
It's maybe only that, but seriously I'm so confused and I started to imagine weird storylines lmao

I thought he was killed by the mom and the grandma too, but the grandma apparently killed the grandpa too? so maybe the mom helped her back then so that's why it's familiar ?
If DH's dad isn't the real culprit, I wonder what she could have done that would stop her from being with GH
I know LJG is playing a psycho game so he is probably distorting the truth, but imo DH was definitely a witness and/or a victim when Gyeyoung disappeared, and I really don't see what she could have done that is so wrong...
We're definitely missing a lot of elements, but weirdly all the dads in this story seem to be implicated in a way

He said he felt guilty about it and thought it was because of him that she was taken by someone else, so he never tried to deny the accusations. People shaming him is not from his own will, but he decided to stay anyway.
Not blaming him or anything, but I didn’t see him try to fight for his innocence, and he let everyone think that he was guilty. So to me that sounds like he agreed to be the culprit “officially”.
But at the same time I feel like they all know he’s innocent but somehow they are are all hiding smth.

I don't think the context of time or family would change the fact that he was still young, and in his mind he thought his dad was guilty so he thought that denouncing him was a good idea.
I agree that it was a bad thing and it was really not playing on his father's side, but through a child's mind I can understand that he thought it was helping.
And tbh we don't have much context of their family story back then, so who knows what happened between them ?

Again I agree that the letter didn't help, but the cops tried to find a culprit quickly at the time and I don't think they really tried to search for more, since Mr. Han never really fought for his innocence either.
He said he felt guilty so in his mind he was at fault for Gyeyoung's disappearance, and so he agreed to be the official culprit.
So basically he agreed to be shamed and targeted as a payback maybe. That's how I see it, because he could've moved away, but idk why he decided to stay.

Wootak is definitely wrong for beating up people so much (although he's targetting men who are not that innocent), but to me that's another story. I feel like it's coming from smth else, or because he felt so angry for so long, but now that things are changing I'm sure he will change too.

I love how they make the cheesy moments funny in a cute way haha

I just glanced over some comments, and now I'm wondering if Dahyun's father could be the real culprit ?
I first thought it would be Gyehoon's father, but seeing what happened to him, it's still possible but I wonder if there's a reason why we never heard about DH's father

I don't think I've seen the actor anywhere else, but I'm really curious now ! I rarely feel like this about characters, unless they are really good

I think it’s a bit harsh to judge a 10 yo boy who didn’t know about the consequences of his acts like any child. At that time he really thought his dad did smth and maybe thought it was a good idea to tell his friend about it. But Gyehoon was also 10 and felt like it was also the right thing to do too.

The cop literally explained that the witness testimony saying that Gyeyoung went into Mr Han's car was the reason why they thought he was guilty, because he knew Mr Han worked secretely in a Karaoke and the blood was probably from someone else. Even though they believed the dad was innocent, just because one cop told everyone he was guilty everyone in the village thought so too, and seeing how those villagers are they surely didn't make it easier.

Wootak lived in guilt about what he did to his father, but I think he also resented his dad for not fighting back. Technically they both ignored each other for valid reasons, in my opinion. This is why I think it's very touching. The dad cares so much about his son that he didn't want to "bother" him, and the son felt too guilty towards his dad to go to him.
Personally I can tell Wootak is angry at the cops, but at himself too.

And for Dahyun I never said she killed Gyeyoung, but that UNLESS she did, I don't see a valid reason for her not to be with Gyehoon, like Jingeun is trying to say.