Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 2 hours ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: Eastern Seaboard
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: May 18, 2024
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award1 Flower Award1
Tigers Sniff the Rose chinese drama review
Completed
Tigers Sniff the Rose
2 people found this review helpful
by ibisfeather
3 days ago
40 of 40 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 10
Story 10.0
Acting/Cast 10.0
Music 9.0
Rewatch Value 10.0

A Hidden Gem Temporarily!

Tigers Sniff the Rose turned out to be an interesting take on corruption and chaos in the early Tang, intellectual, idealistic and as bloodthirsty as a piece by Christopher Marlowe or Seneca. All agree that it should have trigger warnings: SA, murder, castration, abortion and infertility. The Rose ends up being a metaphor for power. Honestly, although the basic romance is wonderful, TSTR is perfect for a viewer who loves characters cleverly adjusting to the demands of a continuously changing strategic situation, where preserving the people is at least as important in the plot as the next sweet kiss.

For the first few episodes I thought, Oh this is one of those Brechtian stagey versions of history, all because the stage settings and decor were DIFFERENT from the several epics I had just watched or was watching concurrently. They seemed flimsy, the lighting seemed overly bright and the scenes a little washed out.

That imperial solidity we are so used to seeing -- massive columns, heavy brocades, enormous amounts of tableware -- the gold tones, the soft darknesses...nope. The difference looks like a choice about how to depict the early Tang. It is not a time where the state is on a very solid footing. And although we think of it as a glittering glorious rich period, the level of material accumulation did not in fact reach that of later eras.

So the textures are those of paint, wood, and fabric. All more temporary materials. The actual imperial court with a full complement of ministers barely appears at all, in the beginning. The lighting begins at the side of a southern river where the Nerd lives, and daylight continues to be metaphorically important as a lighting source. The ray of daylight across the Emperor's face in 38!

Female-centric shows can be very unrealistic, and the ways in which this drama more realistically framed the story of the love of WanYao the DanYang Princess and Yan Shang the straightbacked Village Nerd, made a lot of people nervous or annoyed. However, dear viewers, if you hang in there and keep your good tempers it will all even out.

When I realized that the ML was an extremely old-fashioned person, I realized he is the kind of guy who will just serenely ignore a woman's rantings, tantrums, slaps and general acting-out if he thinks it necessary (at first) or finds her desirable (quite soon thereafter). The two fall in love and remain eternally faithful. It is lovely. I dont need perfection in every screen romance; a few quirks and the edge of believability is even better.

I feel so affectionately towards these two medievally bloodthirsty plotters that I want to rant on about them, but honestly there is too much rant going on these days.

This is a very special very wonderful show.

pps. I just heavily edited this after going tp put another version on my viki page and realizing that thousands of viki watchers are absolutely raving about this show while our dour relationship police dominate MDL. No point in being shy, on MDL nobody is watching at all!
Was this review helpful to you?