This review may contain spoilers
Seo Jung Woo for the win!
My Girl is a light, fast paced romcom that mixes fake identity chaos with romance and comedy. The drama itself works best when it leans into comedy and misunderstandings, especially the fake cousin identity setup and the messy situations that follow. The pacing is quick and the tone stays light, so it is easy to watch even when the plot gets a bit exaggerated. That said, some of the conflict feels stretched out and relies a bit too heavily on miscommunication, which can get repetitive after a while.
What really holds the story back for me is Seol Gong Chan. His character was often quite mean to Joo Yoo Rin, and not just in a teasing way, but in a way that felt dismissive and emotionally harsh. Because of that, it was difficult to naturally root for their romance, since a lot of their early dynamic is built on him being cold, suspicious, or even unnecessarily strict towards her. Instead of feeling like a slow burn romance, it sometimes felt like Yoo Rin was constantly trying to earn basic kindness and understanding, which made the emotional side of the story less enjoyable and at times more frustrating than romantic. Even when the story tries to soften him later, it does not fully balance out how he treated her at the beginning.
On the other hand, Seo Jung Woo was a much more enjoyable character to watch, especially in relation to Joo Yoo Rin. He felt warmer, more expressive, and more naturally supportive in a way that made his presence feel comfortable rather than tense. Although he was portrayed as a playboy, his actions around Yoo Rin showed genuine care and emotional sincerity, and he rarely made her feel small or judged. That consistency made his character feel more trustworthy and easier to emotionally invest in, especially compared to Seol Gong Chan, who often shifted between cold control and sudden vulnerability.
The contrast between the two male leads also made the romance feel uneven, because Jung Woo’s affection felt more natural and consistent, while Gong Chan’s relationship with Yoo Rin felt more like it relied on narrative obligation and forced proximity rather than emotional compatibility. Even their interactions highlight this difference, since Jung Woo tends to communicate more openly while Gong Chan often shuts down or reacts harshly, which affects how believable the romantic progression feels overall.
Overall, My Girl is still fun and entertaining, but for me it is carried more by its comedic energy and Seo Jung Woo’s warmth than by Seol Gong Chan’s romantic presence, which never fully worked for me emotionally.
What really holds the story back for me is Seol Gong Chan. His character was often quite mean to Joo Yoo Rin, and not just in a teasing way, but in a way that felt dismissive and emotionally harsh. Because of that, it was difficult to naturally root for their romance, since a lot of their early dynamic is built on him being cold, suspicious, or even unnecessarily strict towards her. Instead of feeling like a slow burn romance, it sometimes felt like Yoo Rin was constantly trying to earn basic kindness and understanding, which made the emotional side of the story less enjoyable and at times more frustrating than romantic. Even when the story tries to soften him later, it does not fully balance out how he treated her at the beginning.
On the other hand, Seo Jung Woo was a much more enjoyable character to watch, especially in relation to Joo Yoo Rin. He felt warmer, more expressive, and more naturally supportive in a way that made his presence feel comfortable rather than tense. Although he was portrayed as a playboy, his actions around Yoo Rin showed genuine care and emotional sincerity, and he rarely made her feel small or judged. That consistency made his character feel more trustworthy and easier to emotionally invest in, especially compared to Seol Gong Chan, who often shifted between cold control and sudden vulnerability.
The contrast between the two male leads also made the romance feel uneven, because Jung Woo’s affection felt more natural and consistent, while Gong Chan’s relationship with Yoo Rin felt more like it relied on narrative obligation and forced proximity rather than emotional compatibility. Even their interactions highlight this difference, since Jung Woo tends to communicate more openly while Gong Chan often shuts down or reacts harshly, which affects how believable the romantic progression feels overall.
Overall, My Girl is still fun and entertaining, but for me it is carried more by its comedic energy and Seo Jung Woo’s warmth than by Seol Gong Chan’s romantic presence, which never fully worked for me emotionally.
Was this review helpful to you?
