mayshine123

When I say "betray her," I'm referring to him stabbing her earlier and her being scared of him and him chasing after her. I know he didn't actually betray her. I do not like the Nine Stars plot at all.

I guess you can see it as consistency of character but it just feels like another added trope on top of him "betraying her" and having to ask for forgiveness. It's just hard for me to let go of the novel. BXS didn't exist so it just never would have happened this way.

I saw a comment somewhere on bilibili. He’s being used as a tool. "He appears when you need him to make a match, he appears when you need conflicts between the hero and heroine, and he appears again when you need to face life and death... In the original book, they don't need external factors. It's just that the two hearts that go from suspicion to trust to life and death"

I guess agree to disagree. To me that just makes him a noble idiot.

I'm confused, is that not what I wrote? It would have been logical for him to give YH HPS after he cuts the black flower, but they decided to make it emotional instead and him a noble idiot. If he didn't do it just for her to be free and "happy", than he is too self-sacrificing and thick.

I get what you're saying. But to me, they decided to not do the logical route, which is TY giving HPS to YH, just to get an emotional scene. I understand it shows he is willing to sacrifice himself, but he clearly doesn't need to because of HPS. Maybe if it was a scenario where there wasn't such a clear answer. Which is partly why I said the plot line feels messy. And if TY didn't want to give the HPS to YH because he wants her to be free, he is too self-sacrificing.

Perhaps, but even so, judging from the spoilers she looks like she at least thinks he dies at first. Just like in ep. 27 she thinks he dies when he didn't.

I dislike the whole life-exchange spell thing and seeing how he is going to actually die in just a few episodes it seems to me a little redundant. I feel like the plot line is more convoluted and messy with all this added stuff. I wish I never read the novel because its really making it hard for me to like this with all the changes.

Thanks for letting me know. It seems they are adding a lot that didn't happen in the novel. I just hope they put these two parts from the novel in the show.

Does anyone know if these two parts from the book happened in the show? From what I remember, one is right after Tian Yao got his dragon heart, Yan Hui is buried in rubble. And the other is when Su Ying lied to Tian Yao and said Yan Hui is dead

I wish they just kept the storyline from the novel

What was 2nd CP ending? Did one of them die in the end?

Why not the summer?

I think they followed the novel a little with that as she was injured after falling off the cliff

ML getting stabbed/hurt way too many times it's getting redundant and FL was a bit too useless.

Honestly would have preferred her to be dead to have something different.

Kind of wish the female lead was the grim reaper and the male lead was the human with mysterious powers. That would be more interesting to me.

If I get paid every time the male lead gets injured saving the female lead in Korean dramas I'd be rich. I wish they would come up with something more original. Even if Hae Yi got stabbed it would have been more shocking.

Who dies first in each lifetime? And how do they die in each one?

That was a pretty bad ending. Last three episodes of pure stabbing, shooting, crying helplessness. Just really not good. And the villain waking up after being shot is just ridiculous.