K-Drama 
Decent Live Adaption of a 2 Volume BL Manga.
I've been with this series from the start from owning the manga, drama cds to even getting merch for it. It's actually not a story that's looking to hit you with anything new but to actually send a message that being gay doesn't make the person any different or inhuman especially in a society like Japan where it's still heavily shunned in this day and age. There's a few differences with things taken out and added from the manga to the live adaption that I wish I could list it all out but that would defeat the purpose that I wanted to get across. If anything it's a decent watch but nothing extravagant that took away from the story and characters.Just remember that this is a Japanese adaption so while the intimacy was pretty much bland compared to it's manga counter part, the actors actually did a decent job with the roles and environment that they were given. Some of the settings from the manga would be hard to almost replicate via camera filming angle and financial reasons. Otherwise, most of the main points are shown in the live drama; being gay, outed, treated like an object to be gawked at while pretending to be okay and continuing on as nothing happened while encountering someone for the first time in your life among your peers who is sincerely into you, treats you as a normal person and cherishes you with all of their being. I don't wanna influence a non-manga reader so I'll leave it at that. It's definitely worth checking out.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Disappointed Manga Reader
I wasn't looking for a one to one adaption since I know sometimes that can be hard to achieve due to multiple reasons when it's a manga. As much as I really wanted to enjoy the live movie adaption and I really did try, it did not deliver. They told us they were aiming to make it "as real as possible" but still fell short. Like so, Shishitoren known for it's "bright orange and white jackets" became yellow...what happened there??? I don't mind that there was changes to the story to fit a movie's time frame limit but sadly, because of that, you're given no time to get to know the characters. Thus, I had zero attachment to any of them from start to finish.Adding on to that, I'm just going to say it first to get it out of the way. If you're an only anime watcher, you will get spoiled. As at the time of this film, they added in something from a different story arc that only manga readers knew which hasn't even been animated yet at the time of this review. It was not needed but it was thrown in there I guess to show a connection between Bofurin's leader Umemiya to our main character Sakura which didn't translate well. That's how I knew this movie was just simply being made to ride on the popularity that Wind Breaker has garnered. The stage play musical adaption, despite it's flaws and on a strict stage limited time frame, did a better portrayal and convincing performance.
Wind Breaker, in it's manga, anime and stage play adaptions, have done a great job at portraying it's fighting scenes and has made waves in it's communities for that. Meanwhile, the live adaption failed in comparison and it was noticeable. The fighting scenes were very lack luster due to the camera angles. The zooming in and zooming out on certain fights almost gave me motion sickness due to the camera being "busy" and panning in a way to off show the actions looking "cool". By comparison, the Tokyo Revengers live action did a better job of it's fighting scenes and that's coming from me who is not a fan nor has ever read the manga but only checked out the live adaption out of curiosity.
It saddens me because I do love all of the Bofurin kids and I, too, do love all the Shishitoren members. I was hoping the live movie adaption would be able to bring out the very first story arc to life that captured manga readers and anime watchers but you get none of it here. I truly do think that instead of a movie, it would've worked as a series instead.
Was this review helpful to you?
