oddsare

Episode 8 wrecked me. I’ll admit I’m an easy crier, but this one earned it.

Somewhere in Episodes 7 and 8, the show stops being a clever premise and turns into a quietly devastating family drama. On the surface it still looks like slice of life. What makes it feel distinctly Thai is the way the big turning points keep barging into that ordinary texture. Japanese slice of life tends to stay quiet and let the meaning sit in what goes unsaid. The Thai version here would rather feel everything out loud, letting the sweetness and the grief and the irritation exist all at once.

On the romance side, Save finally realizes that what he feels for Guy is not admiration or confusion but the real thing. The realization is too big to sit on, so he kisses Guy on impulse. The moment is clumsy and completely sincere, exactly what this version of Save would do. Guy is in a harder spot. He has already been burned by betrayal once, and a single kiss does not reset that. His hesitation reads as honest rather than frustrating. He can care about Save and still not be ready to pick up where they left off.

Grandpa’s thread is peaking at the same time. The BL novel he started to chip away at the family’s old debts and keep the orphanage afloat begins to find readers, and his family is openly proud of him. Then, right as the good news lands, the show slips in a new worry. His eyesight is going, probably cataracts, and his vision keeps drifting in and out of focus. It’s handled gently, with no big dramatic scene, which is exactly what makes it sit so uneasily. He is successful again, finally, and his body is starting to quit on him.

My favorite thing in Episode 7 is the rhyme between Save and Grandpa. Save is feeling his way toward being honest about his sexuality. In the same stretch, Grandpa literally hides in a closet because he cannot bring himself to tell his old writer friends that he has switched to BL. The gag is funny and also pointed. He is scared his peers will think less of him, that the genre is beneath a “serious” novelist. Underneath the comedy is plain insecurity, the same fear of not being safe that keeps a lot of queer people from coming out. Two men a couple of generations apart, hiding from the same kind of judgment for different reasons.

Episode 8 adds another layer when we learn that Save’s uncle is gay, and that an old misunderstanding has kept him and Grandpa at a distance for years. The generous read on this family is that they are warm, durable, and people of conviction. The blunter read is that they are all stubborn, Grandpa most of all. Put those traits under one roof and a rift between the uncle and his father feels almost inevitable. The love is there. What gets in the way is pride, fixed beliefs, and a wound nobody wants to reopen, and together those make an honest conversation feel out of reach.

Being a Thai PBS production, the show refuses to stay purely in the feelings. It works in a very current problem: scams. Grandpa gets taken in by a scam operation and hands over the savings the family scraped together over weeks. Watching the money disappear is bad enough. What actually broke me was the aftermath. That night the whole family crowds into Grandpa’s room, not to lecture him but to keep him company while he lies down in his shame. They are worried and upset, and they choose to stay by him anyway. That was where I lost it (thank goodness I had barely any makeup on).

Add it all up, the fragile thing between Save and Guy, Grandpa’s secret career and failing eyes, the estranged uncle, the scam that empties the family account, and on paper it should collapse into soap opera. The show sidesteps that by staying in the small moments. An impulsive kiss. An old man quietly pulling a closet door shut behind him. A whole family packed into one bedroom so Grandpa does not have to sleep alone on the worst night he has had in a long while.

So I recommend it, with one caveat. Do not show up expecting a sugary BL built on fanservice. Watch it instead as a grounded family dramedy that happens to carry a BL thread through it, a show about love and pride and the daily work of staying afloat. That is what Thai PBS does better than almost anyone, and it is why a story this messy keeps landing exactly where it means to.

“The lost one has nothing to lose by always telling the truth” is going to stay with me. That is the cleanest version of the idea I have seen anyone put. And you saying it as someone who grew up in the church gives it a weight I cannot, because I was reading the riddle as metaphor and you lived the actual thing. Being gay and a Christian is not impossible, you are the proof standing right there, no matter what the institution has turned into. Thank you for trusting the thread with something that personal. It means a lot that the writing met you where you are.

The lie detail is such a good catch, and I think it actually fits the reading instead of breaking it. Tanrak covering for Barth, telling the teacher it was choir, is exactly the moment he stops being the “always tells the truth” believer the church wants. He picks loyalty over the rule. So maybe the riddle is less about who lies and more about who Tanrak decides to be honest toward, and it is not the institution. I love your point that Barth already knows what he wants while Tanrak has not even let himself ask the question yet. That gap is the whole tension. As for how openly any of this was discussed in a Thai school of that era, I would guess barely at all, which is sort of the point: the silence is the setting.

This might be my favorite reply I have ever gotten. “Comfort and chaos at the same time” is the whole show in five words, and honestly it is probably what Tanrak feels too, so you put your finger on something the episode never says out loud. Thank you for breaking your own rule to come say this. It does not seem trivial to me at all. I am really glad we are both here watching this thing at the same moment, picking up the same small sounds.

Not Tee blaming his split lip on chili instead of admitting he got in a fight. The audacity. The tough-guy act. The little fool actually thinks we bought it, and honestly that stubborn pride is kind of precious.

Just finished ep 2 of Payback and the tension still hasn’t let up. Sun’s stares do so much of the work, there’s this anger sitting right underneath the whole time, like it could go off any second.

Also, is it just me, or does Min kind of look like Takizawa Hideaki from Majo no Jouken at certain angles? Something about the way he shifts from soft and boyish to a little dark in the same shot. I couldn’t look away during the close-ups.

In episode 7, the horror of the scene is in the not-knowing. Gaysorn drives the shovel into the ground with no idea it’s his mother down there, and every push of the blade carries him closer to something he can’t take back. That alone sits in your chest. So when the hand bones become visible, it feels like too much. Instead of deepening the dread, it pulls me out of it and answers the question before he, or I, are ready to ask it.

The scene was already there in the dirt sliding away and the moment something shifts in his face before he even understands why. That awful half-second your mind fills in is always worse, always truer, than anything the camera can show you. I get wanting the horror to be undeniable, but the scenes that haunt me for days are never the ones that show me everything. They’re the ones that trust me to arrive at the terrible truth at the same pace he does, and that gap is where it actually hurts.

The cruelest thing about this show is that it almost never says THIS IS SIN out loud. It just lines things up, one detail at a time, and waits for you to land on it yourself: oh. So this is what people mean when they talk about straying from the right path.

Four moments in this episode would not let me go.

The first is the close-ups of Tanrak’s eyes. Not the confessions or the breakdowns; those I was braced for. It is the small shots, him sitting right next to Barth with what feels like an entire church wedged into the space between them. He barely looks up, and when he does it is sideways, out of the corner of his eye, like holding the look a second too long would trip some invisible wire. Shyness does not really cover it. It reads more like: if I actually look at you, I will have to admit something I am not allowed to admit.

He is a C major chord straining to stay in tune. Clean, stable, exactly what the textbook says a good chord should be. People look at him and see a good student, a good believer, a good son. Then Barth gets close and you can almost hear the chord start to shake. The vibration is tiny. He is convinced everyone can hear it. Nobody can.

Then there is the music question, which is where the episode really got me. I love that the show refuses to write Barth as some clueless outsider. He asks Tanrak his favorite chord, and on the surface it is nothing, just something to say. But Tanrak answers “C.” Of every chord he could have named, he picks the simplest, most defensible one: the home chord, the major triad, the place songs start and end. That is the answer of someone who badly wants to live inside a key he can justify to anyone who asks.

Barth’s reply is sharper than the small talk deserves. He does not nod along. He reaches over, counts up the keyboard, and presses the first of the two black keys, that little sliver between C and D. C-sharp, he says. His favorite. Then he mentions, almost in passing, that he has always felt a bit out of place in groups.

I rewound that part twice and I am still not sure I caught everything Barth’s face was doing. But the metaphor is doing the heavy lifting on its own. One boy claims the home chord; the other claims the half step. C is where everyone is comfortable. C-sharp never fully belongs to any clean major key. There is nothing wrong with C. It is literally what the exercises are built on. But the second C-sharp shows up, the music stops being pure in the way the system wants it to be. The note does not break the system, it just will not lie flat inside it.

Then the riddle: a believer, a lover, and a lost one. One always tells the truth, one always lies, one does both depending on the day. The believer says the lover always tells the truth. The lover says the lost one always lies. The lost one says the believer does not always tell the truth.

It looks like a tidy contest problem, the kind with one clean answer waiting at the bottom. The harder you push on it, though, the more it slips. Each line is trying to fix the others’ nature in place, permanently, and that reaches past whatever rules the puzzle set for itself. Sit with it long enough and you stop finding the single correct solution, because it is not really there.

Which is exactly the moment Barth chooses. He thinks, and then he says the lost one is the one telling the truth.

Strictly speaking, that is not forced. The structure is too loose; you can hand out “truth-teller” and “liar” and “sometimes” a few different ways without the whole thing falling apart. But if you stop treating it as math and treat it as a question about who you trust, his answer snaps into place. He gives the truth to the one the system has labeled LOST, not to the believer, not to the lover. In a world where the church gets to decide who is righteous and who has wandered off, Barth quietly says no. The one you call lost is the one being honest about your believer.

For Tanrak that is a soft blow that somehow draws blood. His whole identity rests on the believer being the one who holds the truth. Hearing “actually, it is the lost one who is honest about you” does not just nick the doctrine, it goes after his place inside it. If the lost person is the truthful one, then what is he guarding by being the good believer?

By daylight he still has his C-chord answer. The careful glances, the routine prayers, the model-student face. But that night, when he steadies Barth over the wall and his hand lands on Barth’s thigh, the half step finally gets played out loud. His body knows something his theology has no words for.

So when he cannot sleep afterward, when he ends up in the bathroom, it does not read as a stock hormones scene. It is the first time the forbidden thing becomes an actual act: secret, ashamed, and also more honest than anything he says in the daylight. For a few minutes he stops being the chord everyone expects and lets himself sound like C-sharp in the dark.

A lot of shows would crank that moment up. Heavy breathing, swelling music, maybe a voiceover groaning “I am a sinner” in case we were not paying attention. Ticket to Heaven just gives us a boy at a keyboard, a boy at a wall, a boy in a bathroom, and trusts us to feel it without a line of dialogue spelling it out.

I keep coming back to that one line, the lost one is telling the truth. Maybe it is because a lot of us were trained to trust whoever stood at the front of the room, the pastor or the teacher or the parent, and to doubt anyone who stepped outside the lines. LOST was the word for people who loved the wrong way or wanted the wrong things or asked the wrong questions. Here the truth does not come from the pulpit at all. It comes from the margins, and the only person who recognizes it is another boy who does not quite fit either.

Tanrak’s whole night plays like one long unanswered question: if he really is the believer they say he is, why does he only feel awake listening to the note they call wrong? The episode does not tell us. It does not save anyone or damn anyone. It just sits with a carefully tuned life and lets us hear the first place it slips out of key.

exactly!! they ATE and left no crumbs 🔥 toro and kanit could never exist this hard without tay new energy behind them fr

right?? the chemistry is just too effortless to be only acting lol. whatever they’re doing offscreen, keep doing it 😂🥰

We’ve had our share of time-travel BLs, but this one stands out: thoughtful, well-built, and complete in a way a lot of them aren’t. And the reincarnation angle? Even from a Western lens, the idea that love finds you again across lifetimes is honestly pretty easy to fall for.

Ah, and next week is the finale. Not ready. 🥹

At this point I literally cannot tell where Toto and Kanit end and Tay and New begin, and you know what? That’s the magic. My favorite walking argument of a couple. I blink and the episode’s over. DROP the next one already!! 🔥

YESSS Wayu!! Oh my GOD, finally! Look at you, hot stuff, glowing already! We are SO back. Single, hot, and thriving… that’s the vibe! Boys, watch OUT, ’kay? 🎉✨

Oh my GOD, Wayu, stop crying, you’re too pretty for this. Like, what do you even want — tall? hot? Tell me and I’ll handle it, ’kay? We do not cry over boys, that is so not the vibe. NEXT!

Nao is so attentive, so quietly thoughtful in every little thing he does, that Tiger falling for him feels less like a choice and more like something that was always going to happen. Six years of carrying that feeling, and you completely get why.

Tiger leads with his heart just as much. His family has ties to the Thai underworld, but this episode plays a lot more like a romantic comedy than a crime drama. His two friends decide to play matchmaker, which is very funny, and his older brother’s obvious soft spot for him is a real delight. Even Nao’s whole family getting kidnapped never turns into anything too heavy, since you already know how it’ll end: Tiger will find a way to bring them home.

Can’t wait for the next episode.

The scene where Shito and Futami argue while Yotsuya is passed out drunk was so well done. Hirai Amon gives Futami real depth. He even slips into a Kansai accent when he talks, which fits the backstory that Futami had previously been transferred to the Osaka branch. It wasn’t until I looked him up that I found out Hirai was born in Mie Prefecture. Turns out he’s actually a Kansai native himself.

This episode picks up the jealousy theme from before. There’s this whole dynamic of two men sizing each other up, and the headspace behind it is complicated. In real life, rivalry isn’t always rooted in pure hostility. Sometimes there’s genuine respect and admiration mixed in. And in the world of BL, well, there could be other feelings in play too.

Can’t wait for the next episode.

Those memorable Thursdays will haunt us both forever and I wouldn’t change a thing 😌 And babe please, the way you just went off cursing out every single department like a one woman standing ovation? I ADORE it. Fk their acting, fk the drone team, fk the CGI, fk them ALL, you’re so right and you should say it louder.

You never have to know what to comment, just keep yelling into the void with me and I’ll always yell back. Love you to bits 💕

NOT you almost throwing your whole career into the fire pit for these two 😭 babe that’s not unhinged, that’s DEVOTION. Qi Rong heard you and respected the hustle. And honestly chewing on Pete’s chains is exactly where I’d be too, no notes, flawless instinct.

Okay but the cone hats?? I get the hint. I get it SO hard. We are not okay, we are never going to be okay, and that’s kind of the whole point lol 🤭

Anyway listen, about the shirt 😩 you are the most generous angel for even offering, but the delivery fee alone would cost more than my soul (which, let’s be real, Niran already bound to Pete’s, so it’s not even on the market). Please don’t spend that on me. I’ll find a way to get my grubby little hands on one myself, I swear.

You’re seriously the best thing in this whole fandom and I love you to bits. Now go say sorry to your manager for checking out mid meeting 💕

Okay WHO gave this show the right?? 45 minutes flew by like five minutes and now I have to white-knuckle it through SEVEN. WHOLE. DAYS. The disrespect.

So Qi Rong pulls out the mist and splits all nine of them up, and the fog basically forces each of them to stare down their own worst fear / inner demon / personal villain origin story. Cinema. Genuinely the laziest-genius way to do nine character studies at once and I’m OBSESSED.

Side note — Tong’s mist-monster reads super androgynous, and I cannot stop side-eyeing it. Is the show low-key teasing some gender stuff for him, or is it just externalizing his fear of not measuring up to Big Manly Expectations™? Could go either way and I need the next few eps to TELL ME which.

Also I screamed “WE ARE THE WU!” out loud like a deranged person. Where is the merch. I need the exact tee Niran and Pete were wearing, in my hands, framed, in a museum.

Episode title pitch: “Tied The Knot!” Because to leash the six-eared macaque, Niran goes “cool cool cool I’ll just BIND MY SOUL TO PETE’S.” Sir. SIR. The shippers are deceased. I am writing this from the afterlife.

And THEN — pre-ritual, Pete’s terrified, so Niran takes off his own necklace, slips it over Pete’s head, cradles the back of his skull, and murmurs the most tender pep talk known to man. I shrieked so hard my cat full-on glared at me. She thinks I’ve lost it. She’s correct.

Tiny nitpick for my Chinese-literate besties: the white robes on the three helper kids have 祭 (“sacrifice”) written WRONG. Props department, I love you, but we got caught. 🙏 (Praying nobody’s offended.)

Why I can’t see Save and Guy as “just friends who fell out”

Maybe this is less about what the show explicitly says and more about what I want from it, but I can’t bring myself to read Save and Guy as just two friends who drift apart. Part of it is simple: I want a happy ending for them. But the bigger reason is that the story itself feels like it’s building toward something deeper, especially when it comes to Save.

Because Save doesn’t read like a secretly-gay-all-along character. He starts off as your typical straight high school boy. Nothing in the early episodes suggests he’s been quietly struggling with his sexuality this whole time, and that’s exactly why his arc matters. Guy, on the other hand, is much clearer from the beginning. His anxiety about losing Save isn’t just about friendship. It feels like he’s already a little in love with him. They’re not starting from the same place at all. Guy already knows where he stands, while Save doesn’t even realize there’s something to question yet.

So when the confession happens, Save’s reaction is everything. He doesn’t magically realize he feels the same, and he doesn’t neatly reject it either. He just shuts down. He avoids Guy, can’t meet his eyes, and doesn’t know how to act. A lot of people read that as him trying to protect the friendship, which is part of it, sure. But it also feels like something deeper. He genuinely doesn’t know how to fit this into the version of himself he’s always believed in. That’s what questioning looks like. It’s messy and uncomfortable, and it doesn’t come with instant clarity.

Then the show throws in the fake dating setup, which is ridiculous on paper, I’ll admit. But that’s also where the story really shifts, because fake dating only works if something starts to become real. The question stops being “is he doing this for a reason?” and becomes “when did this stop being an act?”

And by the second half, it’s clearly not an act anymore. The tension between them, the misunderstandings, the way they hurt each other, none of that reads like casual friendship drama. Save completely falls apart when Guy pulls away. He goes out of his way, almost desperately, to fix things. And the overpass scene alone makes it hard to argue this is just about friendship. You don’t chase someone like that, with that much urgency and emotion, if they’re only a friend. At that point, Guy has become the center of his world.

That’s why the “he was straight the whole time and just went along with it” interpretation doesn’t work for me. It reduces everything he goes through into a phase, something temporary or superficial. But what we actually see is a shift. Save starts from a place where being straight is just an assumption, something he’s never had to question. Then Guy disrupts that, and over time Save is forced to confront feelings he doesn’t have language for yet.

To me, it makes much more sense to read him as somewhere on the bi or pan spectrum by the end. Not because the show explicitly labels it, but because that’s where his journey leads. He doesn’t “turn gay.” He expands his understanding of himself. Whether you call that bi or pan doesn’t really matter. What matters is that he gets there through experience, confusion, and emotional growth.

And that’s what makes his choice meaningful. If he ends up choosing Guy, it isn’t because he was secretly waiting for him all along, and it isn’t because he’s experimenting. It’s because he’s figured something out about himself, and from that place, he chooses the person he loves.

So even if part of this is me wanting a happier ending than the show might fully give, it doesn’t feel like a stretch. The emotional arc is already there. Read that way, this isn’t just a story about friendship falling apart. It’s about someone stumbling into self-understanding and, in the process, realizing who actually matters to him. And honestly, that version is the one that stays with me.