neon_tae

Genie: Make a Wish had all the ingredients for success: a talented cast, fantasy elements, and a romantic premise that could have been engaging. Yet somehow, it managed to fail on almost every level. The drama’s biggest problem isn’t the acting — the cast did their best — it’s the concept itself. It trivializes sacred Islamic beliefs, turning jinn and Iblis into playful, romanticized characters. These are serious theological entities, not props for love stories or whimsical plots, and the carelessness of the writing makes the story feel disrespectful rather than imaginative.

Even with strong performances, the narrative feels hollow. Romantic arcs clash awkwardly with supernatural elements, creating a tone that is confusing, insensitive, and ultimately frustrating. What makes it worse is seeing people rate this drama 10s and 9s, praising it as if everything is fine. The problem isn’t just the drama — it’s that standards and taste have sunk so low that careless, disrespectful storytelling is being celebrated. Talent can’t save a story that is built on a foundation of ignorance and insensitivity.

Conclusion:
Genie: Make a Wish proves that even a skilled cast cannot save a story that disregards its subject matter. A good cast can perform, but writing and concept define whether a drama resonates or offends — and here, it missed the mark entirely, despite what inflated ratings might suggest.