This review may contain spoilers
No romantic vibe at all
I felt no romantic vibe throughout the whole show.It seems more like they get together because they've known each other for so long and they know each other so well that it just feels right to be a couple, like sticking to their comfort zone forever.
The only remarkable scene is the one of the breakup, the only episode where I could actually feel something and sense some sympathy for both characters.
Between the two, anyway, ML was the more communicative both towards the FL and the public with his acting.
Was this review helpful to you?
I was about to drop it, but then it changed completely
I was about to drop it becuase I found both acting and story boring, but halfway everything changed and I couldn't stop watching any more.The story became more deep, the acting so natural and sincere, it felt like watching a real story, with real people simply being themselves.
The ending could have been better, but all in all it was right like this.
I didn't enjoy much the second couple storyline, it felt too awkward and a little forced. Not counting the fact that the hearing imparing was completely useless and incredibly solved in a second with a hearing aid. If you wanted to brush it off like this, you had better not put this element in the first place.
Was this review helpful to you?
You will need a huge suspension of disbelief...
...as Coleridge said. Nothing makes sense in this drama, starting from Ever 9.An AI created to treat emotional issues that has more emotional issues than the human he's supposed to help. Please tell me that I missed something or I missunderstood something because this doesn't make any sense.
It's the classical fast-paced BL, so I didn't expect many explanations or a slow-burning story, but the cold-hearted main lead fell in love without much esitation with this robot and it doesn't make any sense to me. May it happened because Ever 9 kissed him straight away without any apparent reason? No sense.
Was this review helpful to you?
Friendly suggestion: start from episode 6
The first half of this drama is just a bunch of random stuff that messes up the main plot..as it often happens in kdrama.If you start from episode 6 you won't miss anything and you'll be plunged straight at the core of the story.
The funny thing is that even plot holes are declared by the characters and the issue is solved with a simple "I don't know this person/objetc has a fate of its own beyond the power of God"..ok, thanks for the sincerity Mr. Writer :-)
Anyway, the soundtrack is wonderful and engaging and I was completely charmed by Kim Hyun Joong gaze.
Was this review helpful to you?
Take it for what it is and you'll enjoy it
I don't understand all the hatred for this drama. It's not a masterpiece, but if you take it for what it is (a light story made to entertain and not to think too much while watching) you'll enjoy it.All the characters are interesting and funny..except for Woori who's unbeareble up to me. I don't know if the actress ever played other roles different from this and the one in My ID is Gangnam beauty, but I find her characters selfish and hateful and the way she acts increases these features.
Despite this I liked the rest of the cast and loved the way things turned out, I never got bored and it made me laugh several times.
Maybe it deserved one or two episodes more to make the ending less rushed.
Was this review helpful to you?
I wish I had watched only the last 5 episodes or so
I read a review under another drama stating that often the issue with kdramas is that they tend to be complicated just for the sake of being complicated, and that's exactly the case. I wish I had watched only the last 5 episodes. Boring and slow at the beginning, just the acting of Lee Jun Ho and Lee Se Young kept me from dropping. I started to enjoy the show as soon as they stopped adding more and more characters and intrigues.In the end I felt like nothing was resolved (but actually it was, it's just me that couldn't thoroughly follow all the scheming and plot twisting) but the story left us with a bittersweet ending which wasn't completely sad in my opinion.
Was this review helpful to you?
Came here for the BL and stayed for the straight couple
Lately Thai BL are really disappointing me, but I wanted to give this a try.Well, I slept throughout most of the episodes (surely missing a lot of important pieces of the story) and endured only for the "straight couple" secondary plot.
No chemistry, no feelings, no credibility.
I felt akward and a little irritaded every time Solo called Gui "Guitar". It should have been a meaningful and sweet way to address him, but to me it felt only annoying.
The classic clichés typically used to trigger the action here feel just boring and seem to be used without sense, just put there to justify 13 episodes.
At least the characters were boring, but not completetly stupid like other Thai BLs.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A drama to be seen without biases or high expectations
This was a nice drama to watch, a plot that merges comedy and more serious parts. I found a lot of food for thought but the funny scenes made the drama enjoyable and not too heavy or boring.By the way, talking about the balance between funny and serious parts, PHS acting reminds me a lot of Jim Carrey and his versatile talent.
What bothered me were the too many drinking scenes (I don't think that drinking so much alchool is suggested when dealing with depression and taking drugs) and the fact that a lot of subjects where brought up without really focusing on one or the other remaining on a shallow level.
Lastly...the sub-plot of the friend betrayal was really unecessary.
Was this review helpful to you?
Deceiving from the start..
At the beginning of the show Yoon Jae Gook says something like "let's love while we are breaking up"...the phrase should have been "let's struggle and suffer by ourselves while breaking up". They had more chemestry in the first episodes while they were not together rather then when they're a couple. They never really face their problems as a team, but they seem to leave one another out of their struggles, like they need to face everything on their own.And the plot is so frustrating! All the world is against them and their love in a way that is unreasonably fierce. Maybe the cultural gap between Western and Eastern culture makes it hard for me to understand completely why they act like this, but only in Itaewon Class I found a similar harshness. I mean, ok, ok being mean at the beginning, but at a certain point it all becomes unbearable and unjustifiable.
Thank God we had the secondary couple lightening up the scene.
Anyway, despite many reviews stating the contrary, I found the acting of Song Hye Kyo very good and credible most of the time, above all when portraying both the happy and the sad moments of the relationship with her friends and family.
Was this review helpful to you?
Why r u so short?
The biggest flaw of Korean BLs is their lenght. They put a lot of stuff on the table but don't take the right time to develop anything.The scenes pass from one to the other without a real connection just to speed up the plot and that's a real shame. I hope to see a 16-episode K-BL soon with episodes lasting at least 45 minutes like classic kdramas.
If you have already watched the thai version you can't help making comparaisons and, even though the basic story is the same, there are a lot of differences in managing the plot that almost make of them two completely different series. The lack of sexual tension in the Korean version is balanced by the astonishing acting when it comes to showing the feelings.
While I watched the thai version only for Tutor/Fighter storyline, in this Korean version I enjoyed Jung Lee Won story the most because it felt like the K versions of Zon and Saifah did justice to their relationship and somehow filled the gaps of the thai plot.
Was this review helpful to you?
Hypnotic in a positve way
I would have never thought this drama would be so enaging.I started watchin it with in mind the reviews calling it slow, at times boring, to centered on school issues rather than love despite of the title.
In a way all these reviews were right except for considering it boring.
Every single dialogue is so interisting no matter what the topic is. I found myself completely absorbed in every single scene.
And the love story permeates the whole drama.
It's a love story between adults, so don't expect lovey dovey scenes, rainbows and butterlies, but love and warmth is still there and it made my heart beat a little faster.
The other positive thing is that the characters are quite realistic. You won't find prince charming solving all the problems or the perfect FL that succedes in everything she does. Here we have "real" people with all their flaws and weaknesses.
Was this review helpful to you?
I've got you under my skin...
There are dramas that make you laugh out loud, other that make you cry your eyes out, other again than make you scream at the top of your lungs..but this one is none of them.Each episode flew smoothly, never boring, never obvious or banal. I kept watching unaware of how it was silently touching all the strings of my soul. Only at the last episode I felt like I've been living with my heart and soul the journey portrayed by the character and I found a lot of similarities with my own life.
Just like you realise the value of something when it's gone, this drama quietly brought me to the last episode with apparently mild feelings and no strong reactions just to find out that it got under my skin without noticing.
I'm absolutely unable to describe how I feel at the end of this. I just think I won't be able to watch it again knowing how true it is and how hard it can hit.
From story, to acting and setting..I think this can be called a masterpiece.
Was this review helpful to you?
I wish I could give it a 10 but...
...but there are two many scenes without any sense or connection among each other. I mean, a moment they're fighting (with harsh words and gratuitous violence) and a second later they are lovey dovey in love.Moreover, many times the relationships are portrayed with a lot of stereotypes, maybe because China is still against same-sex relationships.
In the end, if you look more closely and more critically this drama, many flaws arise and the score would be even lower, but...Chi Cheng with his fragile yet strong side is irresistible and WeiWei is adorable. How can you rate badly a couple like this?
Was this review helpful to you?
The sooner you finish it, the sooner you'll want to start it over again
I had high expectations for this drama and thank God I wasn't disappointed!I won't talk about He Yu and his Jin Zhao because his acting is great and the character is the perfect modern version of Prince Charming without being excessively cheesy. Caring, madly in love, sexy, stubborn, troubled...the perfect mix!
I want to focus more on Mu Mu. Either you love her or you hate her, but even with her flaws she seems to always perfectly fit in the moment. After a few episodes you can predict her every reaction, but this doesn't turn her into a boring character. This because I think that in Chinese dramas' girls are much more than Korean FL for exemple.
In kdrama girls are either crazy bitches or shy and defenseless damsel. In the cdramas I watched, instead, you find iron ladies pretending to be weak, acting like innocent little girls, when in reality they are ironical, mischievous, funny, brave and strong, focused on their goals and faithful to their feelings and selfs.
Was this review helpful to you?
Fluffy fairy tale with a lesson to teach
A simple, even though a little unlikely, story that will entertain you without much effort. But if you go beyond the surface, there's an important lesson to learn, something that is often lacking in tv series (doesn't matter the country): problems and obstacles can be overcome with honesty and by speaking one's mind. To keep your feelings, thoughts and fears to yourselves can only lead go missunderstandigs and ruin a possible good relationship.Talking about the characters, FL was a little exasperated, over the top. I found her sweet, but bothersome at times.
Was this review helpful to you?
