This review may contain spoilers
script needed more work.... basically a weaker version of Fated Hearts
I don't even know where to begin w this.... the first 29 episodes were EXCELLENT and Fan Changyu skyrocketed to the top of my fave FL list after just a few episodes....... and then the writing just nosedived off a cliff in the last 10 episodes to the point where I was *B E G G I N G* for the show to be over and quite literally pulling out chunks of my hair bc how frustrated I was with literally every decision being made.
As I've seen quite a few other reviews mention, the first third showing Changyu's life in Lin'an is 100% the best part of the show. I adored watching Changyu and Xie Zheng start to trust each other and protect each other and I totally understood how they would fall in love given everything they went through. I had practically no complaints about the first act, but as soon as the show tries to expand beyond Lin'an, it collapses under the weight of trying to balance too many disjointed storylines — the political machinations of the Wei family vs the Li family and their attempts to manipulate the puppet Emperor; Qi Min's obsession with Qianqian and holding her captive; the slow pace of trying to interweave Changyu and Xie Zheng's storylines after they were separated in ep 17; etc etc. There was just too much that the show was trying to juggle after the jarring (but imo expertly done) tonal shift with the brutal Lin'an massacre in episode 18.
The main reason my brain likened Pursuit of Jade to Fated Hearts was honestly the political aspect. Xie Zheng nearly dies in a battle due to people in his kingdom working with the enemy kingdom against him. There's a bit more going on in this iteration of this story than in Fated Hearts — in Pursuit of Jade, the Emperor is inept and has no idea what he is doing and the Wei family and Li family are constantly fighting each other trying to gain control of him. And honestly I'm not fully sure how Xie Zheng fits into this as a Marquis (but pls no one explain it to me, at this point I do not care), but, y'know, that's an official title so he clearly has quite a bit of power. While the politics in Fated Hearts always had me fascinated and on the edge of my seat, it's so peripheral for the first ~half of Pursuit of Jade that I just found it impossible to care about any of the people involved, but then it starts taking up so much space that you literally can't ignore all these annoying power hungry and traitorous people and it's honestly agonizing how much screentime they suck up.
Also, a lot of people are probably going to disagree with me here, but the romance left a lot to be desired for me. Changyu and Xie Zheng were so sweet and cute at the start and I was convinced they were skyrocketing to the top of my CDrama pairings ranking, but then their argument in episode 17 happened........ I understand that Xie Zheng is trying to *show* Changyu how he feels by kissing her, but she pushed him off of her and then he kissed her again??? That's assault! I didn't abandon ship over this bc I do understand the desperation and where they both were emotionally, but it's certainly a moment that made me wary and then as the show continues there are just more moments where he ignores her boundaries: Changyu learns Xie Zheng's real identity given he had been using a fake name in Lin'an and she's like "our relationship can't continue bc our differences in status" and he repeatedly pushes back against that and won't accept that things are over; when she pulls away after learning The Secret™️about her father, he again pushes for them to resume their relationship; there's even a scene in one of the final episodes where Xie Zheng has been drugged (I guess by an aphrodisiac given his behavior???????) and he keeps repeatedly trying to initiate physical intimacy with Changyu and I just had to fast forward the scene bc it honestly was making me sick to my stomach how she kept trying to push him off and repeatedly asked him to stop and he wouldn't. There's also multiple scenes where Changyu gets drunk and Xie Zheng stops her from drinking more alcohol and I know it's *supposed* to show his care and concern for her but given how abrasive he is about, it honestly comes off more as him being controlling. idk... by the end I was just incredibly uninterested in their dynamic.
Where do I even start with the Qi Min and Qianqian storyline....... it started really menacing with Qi Min being fixated on Qianqian upon "meeting" her in Lin'an and then it is confirmed by one of his subordinates that she is the woman that he thought she was. Qianqian has flashbacks of a scarred man and she very clearly has a trauma response and panics when she thinks about him. A few episodes later a maid meets Qianqian's son and reports back to Qi Min that "he looks like you when you were a child." so......... the implication is (pretty clearly imo) that Qi Min raped her. he then spends multiple episodes trying to get Qianqian back into his clutches and manages to do so when she attempts to flee Lin'an the day before the massacre. Qianqian and her son are then being held hostage and Qianqian tries to be as amicable as possible to protect her son. Once she facilitates her son's escape, she no longer cares to play into Qi Min's fantasy and starts to fight back in small ways, leading to him chaining her up in a shed. He saves her when she nearly drowns, then tries to track down their son and threatens to kill him again before Qianqian finally manages to escape. But no of course this plot can't end there, and after only like 5 episodes of freedom, she gets kidnapped AGAIN and Qi Min AGAIN threatens to kill their son and the only reason he doesn't go through with it is that Qianqian threatens to kill herself if he harms her son. Qianqian is back to fulfilling his fantasy as she looks for an opening to steal Qi Min's tiger tally and send it to Changyu but then it turns out he let her steal it as a trojan horse...... so she's back to fighting him which, of course, makes him clamp down on his control even harder. Then, in the final episode (or penultimate episode maybe? I already forget even tho I just finished the show a handful of hours ago) Qi Min has the audacity to say that he fell for Qianqian bc she was the only person who wasn't scared of him upon seeing his scarred face......... So the show is really saying "you saved my life and didn't view me as a monster bc my facial deformity, so I raped you".............. WHAT ARE WE F*CKING DOING?????????????????? And as an abuse survivor, I know that emotions towards your abuser can be complicated, but the last two episodes give a vibe that Qianqian is sad to see Qi Min die / touched that he was willing to die for her and..... it just does not sit well with me, it feels more like abuse apologia than a thoughtful exploration of Qianqian's trauma. (And don't get me started on the finale post credits AU nonsense with these two.)
The last 10 episodes literally made me feel like I was being pranked — the sudden slapstick-y and downright cartoonish humor becomes really prominent (and the majority of said humor does not land), characters are making decisions that make no sense with the way they'd been written until this point, a reveal out of nowhere that one of my fave characters was working with Qi Min...... It was MADDENING. Like okay for inconsistent characterization: Changyu is asked to join the military after killing a formidable enemy general and Changyu is insistent that she wants nothing to do with war after the horrors of the Lin'an massacre and that she can't bear to lose anyone else, but then 5 minutes later she's thinking about something that her mentor figure told her and she's donning the armor she was given. In the battle that she joins immediately after this decision, one of Changyu's close friends dies and she feels like it's her fault bc she wasn't fast enough to stop the enemy, but FOR 10 EPISODES the show completely ignores the gravity of that loss and the fact that he's no longer present is never acknowledged until like the final 20 minutes of the finale?????????? Like so many ridiculous things happen I can't even recall all of the batshit insane developments. One character who had spent half the show fixating on his desire to kill Changyu is fatally stabbed by another enemy of his — someone he didn't even view as an enemy until the prior episode, at that! — and one of his allies finds him before he succumbs to his wound and he holds out an item and tells his ally to give it to Changyu bc it will "help her" and then she's like "why would Changyu trust anything I say" and then he's like "you'll also give her this to show your sincerity" AND THEN F*CKING DECAPITATES HIMSELF. What are we doing??????????????? WHAT ARE WE F*CKING DOING??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
anyway I'm losing my train of thought and I have rambled enough. Changyu I love you I wish your show was better bc you are iconic 💗
As I've seen quite a few other reviews mention, the first third showing Changyu's life in Lin'an is 100% the best part of the show. I adored watching Changyu and Xie Zheng start to trust each other and protect each other and I totally understood how they would fall in love given everything they went through. I had practically no complaints about the first act, but as soon as the show tries to expand beyond Lin'an, it collapses under the weight of trying to balance too many disjointed storylines — the political machinations of the Wei family vs the Li family and their attempts to manipulate the puppet Emperor; Qi Min's obsession with Qianqian and holding her captive; the slow pace of trying to interweave Changyu and Xie Zheng's storylines after they were separated in ep 17; etc etc. There was just too much that the show was trying to juggle after the jarring (but imo expertly done) tonal shift with the brutal Lin'an massacre in episode 18.
The main reason my brain likened Pursuit of Jade to Fated Hearts was honestly the political aspect. Xie Zheng nearly dies in a battle due to people in his kingdom working with the enemy kingdom against him. There's a bit more going on in this iteration of this story than in Fated Hearts — in Pursuit of Jade, the Emperor is inept and has no idea what he is doing and the Wei family and Li family are constantly fighting each other trying to gain control of him. And honestly I'm not fully sure how Xie Zheng fits into this as a Marquis (but pls no one explain it to me, at this point I do not care), but, y'know, that's an official title so he clearly has quite a bit of power. While the politics in Fated Hearts always had me fascinated and on the edge of my seat, it's so peripheral for the first ~half of Pursuit of Jade that I just found it impossible to care about any of the people involved, but then it starts taking up so much space that you literally can't ignore all these annoying power hungry and traitorous people and it's honestly agonizing how much screentime they suck up.
Also, a lot of people are probably going to disagree with me here, but the romance left a lot to be desired for me. Changyu and Xie Zheng were so sweet and cute at the start and I was convinced they were skyrocketing to the top of my CDrama pairings ranking, but then their argument in episode 17 happened........ I understand that Xie Zheng is trying to *show* Changyu how he feels by kissing her, but she pushed him off of her and then he kissed her again??? That's assault! I didn't abandon ship over this bc I do understand the desperation and where they both were emotionally, but it's certainly a moment that made me wary and then as the show continues there are just more moments where he ignores her boundaries: Changyu learns Xie Zheng's real identity given he had been using a fake name in Lin'an and she's like "our relationship can't continue bc our differences in status" and he repeatedly pushes back against that and won't accept that things are over; when she pulls away after learning The Secret™️about her father, he again pushes for them to resume their relationship; there's even a scene in one of the final episodes where Xie Zheng has been drugged (I guess by an aphrodisiac given his behavior???????) and he keeps repeatedly trying to initiate physical intimacy with Changyu and I just had to fast forward the scene bc it honestly was making me sick to my stomach how she kept trying to push him off and repeatedly asked him to stop and he wouldn't. There's also multiple scenes where Changyu gets drunk and Xie Zheng stops her from drinking more alcohol and I know it's *supposed* to show his care and concern for her but given how abrasive he is about, it honestly comes off more as him being controlling. idk... by the end I was just incredibly uninterested in their dynamic.
Where do I even start with the Qi Min and Qianqian storyline....... it started really menacing with Qi Min being fixated on Qianqian upon "meeting" her in Lin'an and then it is confirmed by one of his subordinates that she is the woman that he thought she was. Qianqian has flashbacks of a scarred man and she very clearly has a trauma response and panics when she thinks about him. A few episodes later a maid meets Qianqian's son and reports back to Qi Min that "he looks like you when you were a child." so......... the implication is (pretty clearly imo) that Qi Min raped her. he then spends multiple episodes trying to get Qianqian back into his clutches and manages to do so when she attempts to flee Lin'an the day before the massacre. Qianqian and her son are then being held hostage and Qianqian tries to be as amicable as possible to protect her son. Once she facilitates her son's escape, she no longer cares to play into Qi Min's fantasy and starts to fight back in small ways, leading to him chaining her up in a shed. He saves her when she nearly drowns, then tries to track down their son and threatens to kill him again before Qianqian finally manages to escape. But no of course this plot can't end there, and after only like 5 episodes of freedom, she gets kidnapped AGAIN and Qi Min AGAIN threatens to kill their son and the only reason he doesn't go through with it is that Qianqian threatens to kill herself if he harms her son. Qianqian is back to fulfilling his fantasy as she looks for an opening to steal Qi Min's tiger tally and send it to Changyu but then it turns out he let her steal it as a trojan horse...... so she's back to fighting him which, of course, makes him clamp down on his control even harder. Then, in the final episode (or penultimate episode maybe? I already forget even tho I just finished the show a handful of hours ago) Qi Min has the audacity to say that he fell for Qianqian bc she was the only person who wasn't scared of him upon seeing his scarred face......... So the show is really saying "you saved my life and didn't view me as a monster bc my facial deformity, so I raped you".............. WHAT ARE WE F*CKING DOING?????????????????? And as an abuse survivor, I know that emotions towards your abuser can be complicated, but the last two episodes give a vibe that Qianqian is sad to see Qi Min die / touched that he was willing to die for her and..... it just does not sit well with me, it feels more like abuse apologia than a thoughtful exploration of Qianqian's trauma. (And don't get me started on the finale post credits AU nonsense with these two.)
The last 10 episodes literally made me feel like I was being pranked — the sudden slapstick-y and downright cartoonish humor becomes really prominent (and the majority of said humor does not land), characters are making decisions that make no sense with the way they'd been written until this point, a reveal out of nowhere that one of my fave characters was working with Qi Min...... It was MADDENING. Like okay for inconsistent characterization: Changyu is asked to join the military after killing a formidable enemy general and Changyu is insistent that she wants nothing to do with war after the horrors of the Lin'an massacre and that she can't bear to lose anyone else, but then 5 minutes later she's thinking about something that her mentor figure told her and she's donning the armor she was given. In the battle that she joins immediately after this decision, one of Changyu's close friends dies and she feels like it's her fault bc she wasn't fast enough to stop the enemy, but FOR 10 EPISODES the show completely ignores the gravity of that loss and the fact that he's no longer present is never acknowledged until like the final 20 minutes of the finale?????????? Like so many ridiculous things happen I can't even recall all of the batshit insane developments. One character who had spent half the show fixating on his desire to kill Changyu is fatally stabbed by another enemy of his — someone he didn't even view as an enemy until the prior episode, at that! — and one of his allies finds him before he succumbs to his wound and he holds out an item and tells his ally to give it to Changyu bc it will "help her" and then she's like "why would Changyu trust anything I say" and then he's like "you'll also give her this to show your sincerity" AND THEN F*CKING DECAPITATES HIMSELF. What are we doing??????????????? WHAT ARE WE F*CKING DOING??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
anyway I'm losing my train of thought and I have rambled enough. Changyu I love you I wish your show was better bc you are iconic 💗
Was this review helpful to you?
