This review may contain spoilers
I read the entire novel
Well first of all, the timeline and many plots got scrambled and sometimes they merged 2 storylines which make absolutely no sense to me (I speculate they just want to just keep some key details without dragging the plot), however if you read the novel, there just reasons to why the author make it that way.The character is there and quite good and subtlety different from the novel which honestly a good feature in my opinion. Although it is very different from the novel, for instant it feels like MC only love interest seems to be Lian princess and if you read the novel, it basically a harem, despite he did end up living the rest of his life only with her.
Also, I saw many criticisms on the MC accent, and since he is a person from the future, the novel did state that he sounds very different from everyone else since that what he used to (which is the only details I enjoyed but make y'all hate it lol).
I also have to confess I haven't finished the series since I can't cause the film pissed me off sometimes. I know it's unfair, but the characters' appearances aren't portrayed very well, for instance, Wei Yuan and his lover (the Empress), despite their age, they are highly regarded for their beauty, manners and attitude which I just can't see it through the screens.
Overall, I would recommend it cause the fighting scene just an absolute treat to watch and generally it is pretty funny.
Also, this is a COMEDY DRAMA; I love the comic and the novel mostly for the detective scene and Xu Quian supposes to be a police/detective in his previous life (in the novel), IN THE MOVIE HE FELL THE POLICE ASSESSMENT EXAM!!!! And become a real estate agent or something (don't quote me on this) so he would sometimes show good communication and persuasiveness, but I can't see why they changed that detail one bit. Therefore, if you expecting a crime solving masterpiece, there aren't, just some good logical thinking and attentive to details.
PS: I said this already, but I HAVEN'T finished watching the film since my mental health right now just cannot handle it, although I might comeback. Just some small details triggered me since one more thing I really like about the novel is that some small details and decisions made most of the times are influenced by an event or some other small details WHICH YOU CAN'T JUST CHOOSE TO EXCLUDE THEM COMPLETELY FROM THE MOVIE.
Was this review helpful to you?
First Costume Drama I was able to finish in a week.
I've been a C-drama watcher since around 2019 to 2020, but even then, I rarely watched costume dramas—and never actually finished one until now.Guardians of the Dafeng was the first costume drama I enjoyed from start to finish.
One thing I’ve always disliked about costume dramas is the guaranteed pain and angst. I don’t think there’s ever been one without it. That’s why I rarely watched them, and if I did, I usually didn’t finish because I’m very averse to emotional pain and angst.
With Guardians of the Dafeng, even though I knew some angst would come eventually, each episode kept me engaged. I didn’t even realize I was already halfway through the series by the time I started feeling a bit tired.
I think this drama is one of the best beginner-friendly costume dramas you could recommend to someone looking to get into the genre.
Probably the only disappointment for me was the lack of romantic scenes between Tian Xiwei and Wang Hedi. There were a few, but it just wasn’t enough for me.
Also, the ending was a bit rushed, and we weren't able to see any proper ending which is probably intended if they will make a season 2
Hopefully, there will be a season 2.
Was this review helpful to you?
Must see
Show of the year! I am hoping for a second season with the same cast. Dylan wang and the rest of the cast were perfect. The characters were given just enough depth without over doing it. They kept the mystery alive to the very end and the plot wasn’t the repetitive junk that many are. I haven’t enjoyed a show like this since the snow eagle lord. I was shocked at the end and was not expecting it whatsoever.Was this review helpful to you?
Best drama ever!!!
To be honest I’ve never really been a fan of historical dramas but after this I think that may change. I first discovered this drama when I found out Dylan Wang (who I’ve seen in other dramas) was in it. So waited in expectancy for its release and was definitely not disappointed.There were many laughs even from the first episode and the action and suspense progressed throughout the whole season in such a way that left me anxiously waiting for the next episode to be put out. Dylan Wang is the perfect lead for this role by far. How he expresses his emotions and portrays the character while still allowing some comical relief is just incredible.
Although I am late to write this review I wanted to make sure I watched it twice before giving my opinion. I’d say if you’ve been considering watching this drama definitely give it a try because you’ll surely be surprised.
Was this review helpful to you?
Season 2 please! Same cast!
This was a blast. I enjoyed watching something so different from the usual dramas I watched in 2024 - I loved all the characters, the underlying messages of being sincere and incorruptible, and the ridiculous family. I enjoyed the bit of romance because I thought they were cute when they were together. I thought the acting was great by everyone, and will never understand the Dylan Wang hate. He tries all sorts of things, which I admire in a performer, and I enjoy watching him on screen.I like silly humor, case solving, fantasy world building types of stories. If you start and it seems too silly, you should try watching longer. It keeps having funny scenes, but the story itself isn’t silly.
My only complaint: I want a season 2 as the story lost focus for a bit and there are way too many unfinished storylines. Because the source material is looooooonnnnnnnngggggggg, they obviously needed to cut the story down to drama size. I think just focusing on the Guardians, the case solving, the family and world building would have easily filled 40 episodes. The wizard cult stuff could be explored in a season 2.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Light, refreshing, witty, with intrigue and action
If there’s one thing The Guardians of the Dafeng proves, it’s that Dylan Wang is on a roll. Ever since I first saw him in Love Between Fairy and Devil, I’ve followed his work religiously, and he has yet to disappoint me. This show? Another masterpiece. It’s gripping, intelligent, and refreshingly light when it needs to be — an absolute joy to watch from start to finish.What surprised me most was how much I adored the fact that romance is secondary at best in the plot. Coming from someone mostly into romance, I wasn’t sure what to expect, but Dylan’s versatility made sure I didn’t miss it.
Xu Qi’an is the kind of character that pulls you in — witty, self-assured without being insufferable, and always aware of the absurdity of his own circumstances. He’s got the confidence of a protagonist who knows he’s the smartest guy in the room but the humility to never take himself too seriously. It’s that balance that makes him so endearing, and the way he seemingly easily gathers allies — from the Bureau of Astronomy to the Guardians, officials, and even the imperial family — just proves how much of a magnetic force he is.
Speaking of allies, the chemistry between the cast is incredible. The Xu family dynamic? Chef’s kiss. They bicker like there’s no tomorrow, but when it comes down to it, they will stand by each other, even in the face of death.
I can’t talk that long without appreciating the supporting characters. Beyond the emotional bonds, the show also delivers on the action front, with each character bringing their own strengths to the battlefield. And when it comes to sheer presence, few can match Yang Yan. His fight scenes are pure cinema. The aura, the might, the majesty — every time he’s on screen, it’s impossible to look away. And let’s not forget Nangong Qian Rou, the only female Gold Gong. A total badass and the perfect blend between power and elegance.
Then there’s Mr. Wei, the leader of the Guardians, whose father-son relationship with Xu Qi’an adds so much depth to the story. Watching their bond evolve, the way Mr. Wei both guides and challenges him, is one of the many emotional anchors of the series.
One of my favorite things about this show is its ability to transition seamlessly from deeply philosophical discussions to the most absurdly trivial matters. One moment, we’re questioning justice, morality, and the law; the next, we’re dealing with some completely ridiculous, almost comedic situation. It’s this ability to strike a balance between depth and humor that makes the show so engaging.
My most emotional twist was Xi Qi’an’s trial, where he was charged for killing a Silver Gong — an act of justice that clashed with the very law he served. Mr. Wei, his mentor, was the one forced to hand down the sentence, torn between duty and the knowledge that Xu Qi’an had done the right thing. The weight of that moment, the tension in their gazes, the silent war between justice and the law — it was cinematic gold.
Xu Qi’an’s brilliance in solving the unsolvable cases made him a highly sought-after asset, with Gold Gongs even competing to have him on their team. The respect he earned throughout the series is palpable. Even characters like Li Yuchun, who started off distrusting him, by the time Silver Gong’s death trial comes around, were already standing up for him wholeheartedly.
A lot of people compare TGOTD to Joy of Life, but to me, the former stands on its own. It keeps things playful even when the stakes are high, whereas JOL— despite Fan Xian’s humor — carries a heavier sense of danger with its plot twists. TGOTD thrives on its witty exchanges, fast-paced storytelling, and engaging character dynamics, making it feel more like a thrilling yet fun ride. While danger is always present, the story never lingers too long in despair. Each twist feels exhilarating rather than angsty. The tension is real, but it never tips into the same level of dread that JOL sometimes reaches, keeping the ride fun and fast-paced.
Was this review helpful to you?
my only let down
the only let down for me is the cliffhanger ending. with no hint from the production that there will be a season 2!😭 it's like my journey to you. 😭🥹 this show is so good how could they not make a sequel???another one of those dramas that made me cry hard. I also loved the OSTs. it's up my genre.
Wang Hedi is such a great actor!! really!! he can really carry any role. Knows how to portray characters really well. comedic, angry, romantic, depressed, happy. I've seen so many facets of him and never been disappointed.
Was this review helpful to you?
It’s not as slapstick as the trailers lead you to believe
I think this piece showcases yet another aspect of Wang’s acting ability. This show is funny, but it’s not stupid. It’s full of triumph, awe, brotherhood, excitement, adventure and leaves wanting more. I have watched several 50 ep period pieces from China. Although I do love them they tend to drag my heart all over the side of the road. Not this show! It’s fun! It’s easy on the nervous system. Don’t expect this to be what it’s not and you’ll enjoy it.Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Couldn’t Make It Past Episode One
Despite the negative reviews, I gave Guardians of the Dafeng a try out of sheer drama drought—but ended up dropping it within minutes of episode one. The opening feels forced and unnatural, lacking the charm or coherence needed to hook viewers in.Having seen Dylan Wang in three previous dramas, I find his acting consistently underwhelming. He tends to bring the same cocky, off-screen energy into every role, which makes his characters feel one-dimensional. This drama is no exception. His performance here continues the trend—flat, unconvincing, and difficult to watch.
Sometimes a show just doesn’t work from the very start. This was one of those times.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
"Dafeng's not worth it " Lol. After so long, here comes a very good Wu xia
This Series ended with a major Cliff hanger and it's damn interesting and makes me to wait for season 2. I really really love this series, I'm actually contended that finally there is one good Wuxia. Dylan Wang's acting was the cream on top. He just killed it. Lors wei was also one of my faourite characters of this series.Other than him the chemistry between the other actors truly deserves applause, Lord Wei's character was so well written and well executed. The comedy was on point that made me laugh wholeheartedly. I loved the fact that the series is well balanced in everything except for romance which was actually not necessary given the story line. Though at the first Lin An role wasn't matched with the phase of the story, as the story moves on her role was much satisfied. Though there was not much romance, the screenwriter gave us what was actually needed.
The relationship between the family members, superior and his colleagues was lovable and heart touching and funny as well.
The emperor was creepy for the whole time and was really ambiguous till the end.
I didn't find this series rushed at all but I felt that they gave us a lot of content in 40 eps which was the limit and that made them to miss many details and major fights wasn't shown, like the one in chuzou was too short, I expected a big fight at that time but too bad it didn't happen. Things were going really fast towards the end.
Mysteries to be unveiled:
There were so many mysteries which has to be unveiled in the next season:
The other 2 members of that jade mirror realm
The kui's story
The witcher sects story
The man whose name was erased from the history and the reason
Su su's father
Lord Wei and Empress relationship
The emperor's goal
The supreme sword
The supervisor's game
The end***( A spoiler):
I couldn't accept the fact that everyone forgets Xu qian at the end of the story after all the thick and thin he has gone through. I wasn't ready to accept Lord wei's death. season 2 without lord wei is unimaginable Plus the ending was really intriguing and making me to wait badly for season 2. I hope season 2 comes soon and reveal the truth.
Was this review helpful to you?
Xu Qian is not a clown; Xu Qian is powerful, upright, just, determined, filial, fearless.
Dylan is amazing, emotionally disarming, his acting so true is disconcerting.
It captured me from the first episode, and it was a crescendo
Nothing else to add.
Was this review helpful to you?



