Best watched without seeing the original
The is a decent, enjoyable BL from GMMTV - not a stand out but far from the worst.The years that Tay and New have been working together and their friendship shows in the natural chemistry and New gets plenty chances to use his trademark confused/shocked expression!
Where it falls down is when comared to the Japanese original with the comdey seeming more forced than natural. . Ok this is an extended version with more of the story covered but much in the same way that happens when there are american remakes of european series/movies it's ended up being more polished and slick (I'm deseprately trying to avoid saying bland which would be a little too harsh) which causes it t lose character.
Was this review helpful to you?
1,000 out of 10--the best BL ever.
Where do I even start? This show blew every other BL out of the water and that's saying a lot as I'm a huuuuge BL fan.The acting and cast were amazing. Every single actor but especially the leads.
It managed to be really captivating and suspenseful, yet there was no painfully drawn-out conflict. Everything was dealt with in such a healthy and wholesome way.
Funny and fluffy but also really touching and deep in parts.
The kisses. !!!!!!!
It's hard to even put into words. This was the most magical show I've ever seen. 1,000 out of 10!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Sweet and cute, but has strong message about equality
Since it is an adaptation, people will definitely compare it to the original (which is the manga, not the JDrama). However, for me, the adaptation is well-formed, well-produced, and well-be delivered. The Thai context is so strong without eliminating the Japan characteristic. The story it self has the proximity aspect of majority middle office worker, especially for the job with no career path. Achi characteristic is well portraited by New Thitipoom, with the way he talks, walks, movements, his expression. Karan's role is also fit to Tay Tawan including his anxiety regardless his perfectness that always be seen by others. Cherry Magic Thailand (CMTH) also the momentum of the coming back dynamic duo TayNew so that many fans were so excited to watch it. Moreover, P'X also is not a newbie in this industry.The equality in this series is shown in several scenes, one of the strongest is the proposal scene in the last episode. Even in gay romance, society often see there must be someone who acts as "man" and the other as "woman". So, usually "the man" will do the propose. But in CMTH, after Karan proposed to Achi, Achi get on his knee and also propose to Karan, with the dialogue, 'let's take care of each other'.
Was this review helpful to you?
Quick and Honest Review
Im just going to be quick and honest, as the title suggests.Cherry Magic was a big hit when it came out, so obviously the expectations were set high when they announced a Thai version. Despite what some people might say, in my personal view, Thailand did a good job in remaking a show in a way that makes it feel new and refreshing. I felt like this version was lighter and less serious. On the other hand, the lack of real "depth" is probably what made some people not really enjoy it.
The pros:
- I liked that Karan was a type of "revamped" and improved Kurosawa. To be honest,in the japanese version, when people commented about Kurosawas beautiful face and looks, i really couldnt see it. But with Tay playing his character, i could DEFINETLY understand the fangirling. I mean, he IS stunning. He also plays the "hardworking,beloved,hot,charismatic,caring,mature" role very well. It was like it was made for him.
- Jinta was a blessed addition to this show. I actually really disliked his Japanese counterpart, and had to skip most of his scenes. For me,he always came off as this creepy old guy, but in the Thai version he is absolutly hilarious. His comedic timing is on point, has great delivery and his chemistry with Min is spot on. I love you Jinta.
- Compared to other GMMTV works,the director did a great job. The scenes actually came out fluid and less "choppy".
The cons:
- Achi. Not completely. Starting off, New did manage to share that "im in love with you" chemistry with Tay, and their shared glances were ITTTT. That being said, i dont think he actually understood Adachis character. Maybe it was a problem with the script or....something, but in this version Achi is just way less...funny. And honestly,not that relatable. You see, Adachi is supposed to be this insecure overthinker but in the japanese version we get these funny moments where he is stuttering, shaking, nearly falling down....he has nervous breakdowns and goes kind of insane, and thats because the actor just gives him a variety of emotions that make him more human, and takes him out of that restricted "im just an insecure guy" box. We kind of get to see him with Kurosawas eyes : a cute, caring, hard working man. But in the Thai version, all we get is that insecurity. The moments where he is actually having a good time are limited and it gets a bit tiring. What im trying to say is that Achi is too one dimentional.
- Limited skinship. Im far from being a NSFW BL fan but COME ON. When you realise that the japanese version has more touching than this, you realise theres a problem. I mean, how do you get an established bl couple like NewTay and only get them to hold hands two times in 9 episodes? Okay, that kiss was actually slay, but i just was expecting more cute moments. Cuddling maybe??? Please, i beg of you....Karan deserves more appreciation.
Overall it was a good and fun show to watch, and doesnt deserve some of the low marks presented here. I think that if you remake a show that big and are capable of making many people still enjoy it,you did what you had to do. Also,forgive my spelling mistakes as im not a native! Objectively i give it an 8.5, but emotionally i think its a 9. Hoping to see more of NewTay in the future!
Was this review helpful to you?
Fell off after few eps
It was funny when Achi was confused with wtf was going on in the beginning. But it got very boring after that. The supporting story with mark and junior didn't really cross-over enough with the main story enough I feel and they felt like 2 completely different shows. Also they're fully grown 30 year old men lol. I felt like the it could have been a bit more mature themed but kept it's romcom vibe.Was this review helpful to you?
Me encantó♡
La comencé a ver por una recomendación y la verdad se terminó convirtiendo en mi nuevo BL favorito💕.Es super fácil/rápido de ver porque es muy entretenido y por momentos super cómico!
La pareja principal es re linda desde los primeros momentos y tienen mucha química entre sí, no se ven besos "pobres" o como "si se tuvieran asco" lo cual me parece super importante 😅
Tal vez lo que no me gustó mucho fueron las parejas/historias secundarias pero como no tienen tanta relevancia en la historia no le quitan "valor" a la serie😊
Tiene un final hermoso, así que YO la super recomiendo💕
Was this review helpful to you?
Magic with good casting
I really enjoyed it.i Just finished this drama.thy make me so emotional. Story of course its a japanese mango.so famous.tay new was so into in it.i really like it .the casting is amazing. Well scripted.and TH version was so good.somtime feel emotional. Something very lovable.relationship between main leads is so cute .Gmmtv 2023 feel good series. Have nice casting,story,
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A very cute watch.
To be honest when I first watch this drama I was a little bored so I dropped it for a while. A couple months later I came back and tried to rewatch it, and I ended up loving it, though the original cherry magic was definitely better. In my opinion Thailand’s version of it is still very good I really liked the casting of Tay and New And I also loved seeing some new faces. Those some parts are cheesy and hard to watch that just made it all the better. There was one plot at the end that did make me rule down my review just a little bit, The no office romance plot. It didn’t really serve any purpose or really do anything to the story so I found it kind of meaningless but nonetheless it out a little bit of drama into the end if you’re looking for something cute and easy to watch this would definitely be it, but if you’re looking for something with a long plot This probably wouldn’t be it. To be completely honest if Tay and New weren’t in the cast. I probably wouldn’t have went back to rewatch it. but still, I give this drama an 8 (To compare I gave the original cherry magic a 9.5)Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Not as magical as it’s Japanese predecessor
GOOD:- Chemistry between the main leads.
- Included the Cherry Magic The Movie story in the series, richer storyline.
- Scenes are more built up.
- Laslty there are a couple of kissing scenes which were lacking in the Japanese version.
BAD:
- Karan, is more serious compared to the Japanese version, so I found his thoughts kinda creepy.
- Jinta who’s supposed to be older looks younger than Min, felt forced.
- It lacked the Charm which Japan version had
OVERALL:
- A decent BL Series.
Was this review helpful to you?
Loved it!
This is my first TayNew drama and i loved it! I really like the dynamics and chemistry between these two actors. It's not fireworks, but a very comforting chemistry.The other 2 couples were very good too, JuniorMark is one of my favorite BL couples.
The whole cast did a great job.
I liked the story, it's not a very new concept, but that doesn't matter, it was very well executed.
The visuals were beautiful and the music good.
I will definatly watch this one again in the future.
Was this review helpful to you?
Sweet and soft like a cherry
It was my first TayNew series. I couldn't wait to experience their dynamic. Before that, I only watched series where one of them played a role, but not both together. TayNew did not disappoint me. I enjoyed their couple and Cherry Magic TH in general very much.I have to say that I neither know the manga nor have I seen the Japanese series adaptation, so I can't make a comparison as to which version I like better. Overall the plot is veeeery sweet. It's stress-free, happy, without angst and with many wholesome moments.
Karan and Achi are very cute together. At first they were colleagues and then slowly became more than that. While Karan had a crush on Achi for a long time, Achi was surprised and overwhelmed by it. But Karan's smile and charm quickly became irresistible. The kisses were so soft, I'm still spellbound.
Besides I like Jinta a lot. He is loud, overdramatic and can be annoying, but that's exactly what I find charming and very entertaining. Such a sweet and chaotic dork. I want a bookstore date like JinMin. It looks like so much fun.
And I really like Tanaka! Sometimes I thought he was going to have some kind of nasty surprise for his employees, but in reality he is just funny, nice and understanding. Best boss!
I'm looking forward to more TayNew content in the future!
[finished watching on 3 May 2024]
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the best BLs I've watched
THIS SHOW IS GREAT!!!! AMAZING!!! GOT ME HOOKED FROM START TO FINISH!!!!Honestly, I'm writing this just because I saw I lot of "I'm disappointed" and "this is bad", and I completely disagree. I think the only thing I didn't like is how awkward and almost emotionless Achi is, even in the last episode. But, that's probably because the original source is Japanese. I've not watched the Japanese one, but let's be honest, most Japanese BL have the overly pushy and the 0 range of expression characters. I actually saw a lot of things and scenes and characteristics that remind me of Japanese BL.
But, talking about the series: it's amazing!!!! Every character is interesting, the whole mind reading thing it's well explored, and the couples are all incredibly adorable. I really don't regret watching this, it was worth all of my time. It's cute, funny, don't have much sad scenes, and all the relationships in it are very healthy. I loved it!!! 💗
Was this review helpful to you?
