As a Muslim I really didn't mind the concept of iblees being taken
As a Muslim I really didn't mind the concept of iblees being taken I mean they didn't say he was wronged from the start they even showed him being beaten up by the very creation he loathed and falling for the same creation I don't know why you all didn't like it I laughed soo much everytime he was beaten up and the acting of every character was sooo damn good we could see when the FL lead finally started changing because of genie the change in her expressions was prominent especially when she was scared and sad for the first time....I've seen wayy too many kdramas ever since I was a child and I hardly like many kdramas but this one didn't disappoint I wasn't bored all night I was hooked on every episode
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Breath of Fresh air in monotonous Kdrama land
This review will be in two parts.1st part - the actual drama &
2nd part - my views on the hateful comment section this and many other dramas are getting.
---------------- 1st PART --------------------
I am forced to write this review as this drama is getting buried by the false hateful rating, reviews and comments it is getting.
This drama experiments with many new intresting elements new to Kdramas.
Good parts :-
1) 4th wall breaking scenes (like Deadpool) are new and it is done so that it doesn't feel jarring to usual narrative and continuation.
2) Humour is not rinse and repeat i.e. jokes are new and even made including 4th wall like Song hye kyo guest where she acknowledges her real life character. The jokes are actually funny.
3) Psychopath character are done in so many ways in kdramas that it gets increasingly difficult to portray it with new twist. But Bae Suzy does it so good by being a inherently good psychopath who doesn't feel emotions.
4) All the actors and side characters were good with their acting especially or ML the genie.
5)Side Character stories are good and their three wishes are what holds the whole plot of this drama for 13 episodes and doesn't make it monotonous.
Bad parts:
1) Side Character should have been given more time to flesh out their stories and doesn't make the some plot points repetitive.
2) Too many famous faces especially including Ahn Eun Jin was not justified by not giving her enough time to act out her scenes.
3) OST felt lacking. Some good songs were needed to emphasize plots.
4) Too many plots to cover lead to fast pacing which made it tough to immerse yourself in the drama.
Overall this is a good one time watch for its fantasy genre, Chemistry between both leads and enchanting visuals.
----------------- 2nd Part-------------------------
PEOPLE WITH FRAGILE FEELINGS KEEP AWAY
With my watch history there should have been more reviews but I don't like writing. I was angry enough to write this review after seeing the bad rating and comments this and many other drama is getting.
First off to start,
STOP IMPOSING YOUR IDEA OF BLASPHEMY ON OTHERS.
Blasphemy doesn't always have to be religious it can also be cultural. Someone's cherished views of their culture can be different from other's view of cultures. That doesn't mean one can be racist but everyone is free to hold their views.
People were also hating on Tempest and Bon Appetit, Your Majesty.
WHY IS IT ALWAYS WITH CIVILIZATIONS WHERE THEIR IS LIMITED FREE SPEECH THAT THEY HAVE A PROBLEM WITH CREATIVE WORKS OF FICTIONAL DRAMAS?
Islam has Blasphemy and Chinese have their party controlled walled garden. If you don't like something don't watch. Is it so hard to understand the concept of free speech.
This drama is based on Arab culture which is basically Persian. Genies are supposed to be from Arab mythology. People might have raged if their was korean genie with no arabic backstory.
Every ancient civilization had a dark past of Slavery. Even Historically this drama was not wrong in showing slavery and killings, if anything they were tame in their descriptionsof barbarity. On the scale of barbaric civilizations my rating would be
Genghis Khan > Assyrians > Islam > ...
Islamic history is rife with sending conquering hordes of fundamentalists to either convert and loot others. They left alive those who forcefully converted , looted wealth and took s*x slaves even i.e. harems. They burned libraries and were chief in destroying paganic persian civilizations from which they descended.
All this is historical fact and even now some(they are a minority) are more fundamentalists than others i.e. terrorists. But not everyone in that part of world is like that like Saudi, UAE, etc.
Finally stop downrating based on factors other than the actual drama. Let's not make other's experience bad and give death threats in comments.
Was this review helpful to you?
Watch cleanly and w/o reservations and THEN comment~
Leads killed it in the 1st half but it was a bit slow in the middle and dragged at the end. Still funny!! Suzy's persona was Wednesday Addams plus SYJ's Ko MunYeong in It's Ok To Not Be Ok and I loved it and it's pathetic that this drama is going to remembered for one thing that wasn't there at all.IDK why Muslims are turning this into a religious thing but so be it. 90% of the world has a problem w/ the child raping incestual pedophiling women beating death to all infidels marry 6 yr olds jihad inbred screaming join us or face genocide views that Islam teaches. Netflix, SK, and Suzy will all take massive hits to reputation for no reason but it wasn't smart to do anything with any ties to Arabs in general with the atrocities currently being committed. We watch dramas to escape the real world, not be reminded of it and some scenes hit HARD.
But this is a FICTIONAL piece for entertainment purposes ONLY. FICTIONAL ppl. Muslims are turning this into a religious thing for no reason. The Islamists crying and review bombing a FICTIONAL drama is HIGHLY ironic considering what they're doing IRL. Parodies of ALL religions have been used in FICTIONAL dramas and movies for ages and they wouldn't have said anything if it was something other than theirs. But that's Islam. Hypocrisy and intolerance at its finest.
I was highly entertained and had no thoughts over religion until I saw the reviews destroying this over it. I also know not all are as bad as the criminal ones engaging in the acts of violence I listed that the media talks about daily as they're caught engaging in their 'religious' practice. So watch the drama for the drama, not the religious slander many are making this out to be. Slander is what I said up top. But is it slander if it's all true?
Was this review helpful to you?
Why all the hate?
Im not sure why there's so much hate for this show. I'm not saying it was perfect but it was a pretty good show overall.The story/plot was fresh take on the reincarnation trope, and pretty easy to follow. Not everything has to be deep and overly complicated. It was a great light hearted comedy that wasn't too corny or cringe.
It was funny, quirky, and a little dark. I loved the chemistry between Bea Suzy and Kim Woo-Bin (pretty good kissing scenes too). The side characters were fun and made the story more enjoyable. The ending was a little sad but "realistic" and satisfying.
Overall I can see myself rewatching in the future.
Was this review helpful to you?
For me it is 9 out of 10
Hey friends, here I am with my review. I just want to tell everyone to give this drama a try. This drama is very good, it has a different storyline, this drama will get better with each episode. I don't know why everyone has spread so much negativity in the comment section.. Yes, I agree that maybe everyone might not like it because everyone's tastes are different, but it is not right to mislead others like this.. In the end, I would like to share my experience that this drama is really very good to watch once, so please do not pay attention to the comments, please try it once, you will not be disappointed.Was this review helpful to you?
A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE K-DRAMA
Quick VerdictA wildly ambitious fantasy-romance that has strong moments and beautiful visuals, carried by charismatic leads (Kim Woo-bin & Bae Suzy), but marred by tonal whiplash, controversial religious elements, and uneven execution. If you like K-dramas with magic, high stakes, and emotional highs, it’s worth checking out — just go in knowing it isn’t perfect.
What’s Good
Lead Performances & Chemistry
The reunion of Kim Woo-bin and Suzy is one of the biggest draws. Their acting—especially in emotional moments—is very strong. Many viewers feel their scenes together are the high points of the show.
Original & High Concept Premise
A genie (named Iblis) who awakens after a millennium, a woman born without empathy, and the challenge of granting three wishes that test human nature. The idea of exploring human flaws via wishes is intriguing. The mythology, stakes, and fantasy elements set it apart from more typical rom-coms.
Emotional Stakes & Dramatic Moments
There are scenes that hit hard, particularly in the later episodes. The relationship arcs, memories from past lives, loss, and sacrifice give the story emotional weight. Fans report being moved by the ending.
Visually Ambitious and Some Strong Fantasy Elements
The fantasy setting, special effects, and overall visual style have been praised at times. Some settings—especially the more magical or mythic ones—are lush and immersive.
Despite that, many viewers found the ending bittersweet yet satisfying, praising its emotional impact.
⭐ Overall Rating: 9/10
Worth watching for fans of fantasy romance and emotional stories, but expect a few rough edges.
Was this review helpful to you?
Kim Woo Bin is back❤️❤️❤️
Just give this drama a chance. eventhough it seems a roller coaster ride story that you dont know whats its purpose. Still its fun to watch. Bae Suzy acting is sooo giving and Kim Woo Bin is sooo back and so attractive in this drama. The kissing scenes is soo perfect that you will think.. maybe its possible that they develop feelings while shooting the scenes... The other characters like Sade is cute and the dog scene Poppi.Try to finish watching it.. and you will appreciate this drama.
Was this review helpful to you?
laughing out loud
I loved this drama. I thought is was funny and exciting. I was laughing out loud multiple times. the actors were great. great cameo’s. I loved all the hidden references to other drama’s.it was fun, i liked the story, i liked the romancen for me it is a 10/10!
this is my kind of humour bit it won’t be for everyone. non the les I don’t understand the low ratings.
I say give it a chance.
it shows us human nature and it gives hope.
I ONLY would have liked a little baby djinn at the end.
Was this review helpful to you?
“Genie, Make a Wish” is such an enjoyable and bingeable drama. Kim Woo-bin and Bae Suzy were absolutely hilarious together — especially Kim Woo-bin! I don’t think I’ve ever seen him play such a funny and mischievous character before, and he had me in literal tears of laughter 🤣🤣🤣.
This drama truly healed all the emotional wounds I had from Uncontrollably Fond. I’m so glad it turned out to be lighthearted and simple, without any tragic or heartbreaking ending this time. A drama always feels perfect when the ending leaves you smiling, and this one definitely did.
I just wish we got a little more of Genie and Ga-yeong’s sweet moments ❤️ They were so adorable together — pure magic on screen!
Was this review helpful to you?
Loved it! Absolutely funny!
I absolutely loved this drama. It is thoroughly entertaining with an incredible cast featuring Kim Woo Bin and Bae Suzy. Fans who have been waiting for these two to reunite since Uncontrollably Fond finally get their closure here in an alternate universe that feels both nostalgic and refreshing.Although there has been some backlash from certain religious groups, I believe viewers should set aside rigid beliefs and simply enjoy the story for what it is: entertainment. The drama begins lighthearted and funny, keeps its humor consistent throughout, and ends on a satisfying, happy note.
Episode 11 stood out to me. The moment when the characters discover their past lives was especially emotional and beautifully executed. I have seen similar concepts in other dramas such as My Demon and The Judge from Hell, yet those series did not face the same criticism and were widely appreciated.
One of the show’s greatest strengths is its stunning cinematography, especially the breathtaking views of the UAE. As someone who loves Dubai and Abu Dhabi, seeing those landscapes again felt like pure eye candy. The visuals brought back beautiful memories and added depth to the story.
The acting is strong, the production quality is high, and the chemistry between the leads shines through every scene. Even the romantic and kiss scenes are tastefully done, enhancing the emotional connection without being excessive.
Overall, “Genie, Make a Wish” is a visually stunning and emotionally satisfying series that deserves appreciation. It is a must-watch for fans of fantasy romance and for anyone who believes in second chances across lifetimes.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Have been waiting for this. Like a wish came true.
They promised us comedy, and they did not disappoint. Loved every episode. Just like my kind of humour. I laughed, smiled and got surprised - that most comedy series can't make me do.I have watched series relating to Lucifer, Angels, and Spiritual creatures. Those were all biblical representations. And I have always wondered what it would be like if they did the same, but from an Islamic perspective. Guess I know now.
They not only used some of the actual stories and facts from Islam, but also added a bit of a story of their own. Iblis, the Leader of Jinns, was expelled from heaven because he defied Allah. They should have added the backstory of Azazil for a bit more character development.
Azrael's purpose was perfectly interpreted, and I like that they didn't make him the actual villain. They didn't include Jibrael, which is fine. Also, the essence of the story of Bilkis and Khalid is similar but not entirely.
I also liked that they paired Iblis with a psychopath because obviously, normal humans would not impress Iblis, and only a deranged mind can fall for Iblis. Like minds fall for each other. The key was that neither characters saw the other as what they actually were. For instance, Iblis was a jinn but was not taken seriously by KaYoung, and on the other hand, Iblis was likely convinced KaYoung was already corrupt and nothing like a human. She also kept the outfit she wore in hell very carefully, like an art piece or an achievement, you can say. She thinks heaven is boring and hell is fun. Totally made for each other's characters.
And for the people who were concerned that this drama is a false representation of Islam, relax you guys, they just borrowed the names and stories of Islam. I'm guessing you guys watch series that represent Lucifer, Satan, Angels and other biblical representations. The Bible is one of the main holy books of Islam too. When those series twist the essence of the characters, you guys stay silent. And it's just a drama. Hope you won't take it seriously. And please don't come at me 🥺🥺. No hard feelings.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Great series
Great series it met my expectations love the effects the characters the story was nice too. That little boy pissed me of he did a great job acting. I love the fact that more people got wishes it was nice to see him acting like a jinnie .It was fun to watch its a light and funny drama the acting was good not everything needs to be that deep i hope you enjoy watching it.Was this review helpful to you?
