This review may contain spoilers
INSANE CASTING!!!!
I've watched the anime, read the manga, and I have been a fan for over a decade now - THEY DID SUCH A GREAT JOB WITH THE SEASON 2. Though, there were some changes of the plot, like laboon's island, and in this live action, they just changed it instead into luffy recommending the idea. What they did was kinda' understadable though, it would be so hard to do with the whole island inside Laboon's mouth. ALSO!!! I love how they added more conversation between the crewmembers which the anime now is lacking, since the anime now is mostly action packed, we all missed the canons when they are just having fun as a crew and i'm so glad to see it being fulfilled here in the live action.There might be comments saying this season is underwhelming, but I would say that it's just a perfect fit since skypeia and water 7 will be CRAZY to be both in 3rd season.
OVERALL, I LOVE THIS SEASON SO MUCH, and I binged watch it right after it dropped earlier. Luffy kind of cringe still, but that's part of his personality. THOUGH, I wish they could've made my Sanji a little bit simp and there's way too much aura farming with zoro for these first 2 seasons, give him some funny scenes man - they already killed it in the anime, don't do the same for the live action.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Disappointing Adaptation That Misses the Heart of One Piece
In my opinion, the One Piece live-action adaptation falls short in one of the most important aspects: its cast and character portrayal. The only truly successful casting choice was Mackenyu as Zoro. He captures the essence of the character quite well, even if some creative choices—like giving him a slightly “big brother, wise” vibe—feel a bit off at times.The rest of the Straw Hat crew, however, is disappointing. Sanji lacks the charm and charisma that define him in the anime. Usopp… I won’t even get into that. Nami is acceptable, but nothing particularly memorable. The biggest letdown, though, is Luffy. How do you miscast such a central and iconic character? Anime Luffy radiates innocence, simplicity, and a pure-hearted energy. That feeling is completely missing here.
Even worse, the handling of Luffy’s fights is incredibly underwhelming. The 1v1 battles—some of the most exciting moments in the original—feel watered down. Instead of showcasing Luffy’s determination and strength, the fights often rely on him running around or needing the crew’s help to take down a single opponent. It barely feels like proper combat.
One moment that genuinely shocked me was hearing Luffy use curse words. That completely breaks the character. Luffy is supposed to be straightforward and pure, not someone who talks like that.
Zoro’s scenes are mostly accurate, but even then, something feels missing—especially moments like his iconic, driven smile when challenging Mihawk. That emotional intensity just doesn’t hit the same.
On top of that, the lack of memorable music doesn’t help. There’s no impactful new OST, and they didn’t even make use of the original themes that fans love.
Overall, this live-action adaptation fails to capture the spirit, energy, and emotional core of One Piece. It had so much potential, but in the end, it feels like a missed opportunity.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Grandline Here We Come!
Let me start by saying that this live action iteration of the beloved manga created by Oda Eiichiro is not perfect. It's not even as great as many are claiming. And no, it's not as good as the manga or the anime, and it never will be. But it's not meant to surpass the source material or even equal it, its purpose is to introduce the series to those who haven't read the manga or seen the anime and don't plan to. It will never replace the original work and that's alright. It will never ruin the manga or anime, far from it. For those who prefer them, you can still enjoy them and they will be around for as long as people appreciate them. For long-time fans like me, it's a reminder of how much I love One Piece and that it truly is one of the greatest stories ever told, and that's all that matters.This second season is, I dare say, better than the first. The action scenes, for one, are better choreographed, and Zoro's Kill Bill-ish fight against 100 Baroque Works agents is reason enough to watch it imho. The special effects have improved as well, but that's to be expected as Netflix started investing more money into it when it was clear that their One Piece live action will become their new cash cow for many years to come. The casting this season is more spot on. I was on the fence about Charitha Chandran's casting as Vivi at first, but she quickly grew on me. I wanted Jamie Lee Curtis for Kureha, but Katey Sagal is a more than worthy actress for Dr. Kureha, so I have no complaints about that. Mark Harelik as Dr. Hiriluk was an inspired choice, he was the character come to life much like their casting for Mihawk. Same with Joe Manganiello as Crocodile, Clive Russel as Crocus, David Dastmalchian as Mr. 3, and James Hiroyuki Liao as Ipponmatsu. It's like they stepped out of the manga or something. But the most perfect casting was definitely Lera Abova as Nico Robin. She is absolutely wonderful! I am looking forward to seeing more of her in the succeeding seasons.
I also liked Usopp so much more this season. They finally gave him the chance to shine and I'm glad they did because that was one of the disappointing aspects of the first season for me. But the real achievement of this season is successfully bringing Tony Tony Chopper to life. If they had messed that up, I don't think the fandom would ever forgive them for it. But thankfully, they didn't and of course we know why they got him right. This may be a live action adaptation but the creator of the manga is very much a part of the series and that's the real reason why this show has resonated with so many people, more so with those who weren't even familiar with the manga/anime initially.
I do have some beefs with it, though. Mostly the same complaints I had with the previous season so I won't repeat them here. But they are forgivable for the most part, so I don't want to dwell on them too much. I don't know how to feel about the spoilery stuff they included in this season, though. I mean, I get that they have to move things forward and it would probably have a different ending from the manga. But I'm worried that some key story arcs like Sanji's origins might be skipped because of that scene where he talks about his mother. For some reason, it felt like that scene was a kind of consolation for them skipping Sanji's story. I hope not. I also thought some scenes could've been better executed and should've had more emotional impact. But then I had the same issues with the first season. They just don't hit as hard as the anime or even the manga.
All in all, this was a fun eight hour-long-episode journey with the Straw Hats. I laughed, cried, and fell in love with One Piece all over again. As a fan, I'm just glad this live action version exists. And I am thrilled to know that people who wouldn't have dared touch the anime or manga, are acknowledging and appreciating the greatness that is One Piece because of this adaptation.
Was this review helpful to you?
Who doesn’t love One Piece with all its goofiness, grit and curiosity?
The second season is every bit as exciting as the first one.It’s packed with adventure (with a capital A), friendship, cleverness, and total silliness. The story manages to be both super entertaining and genuinely emotional at the same time. The characters are interesting, they’ve got amazing chemistry, and the world-building pulls you right in. I really loved how they balanced the action with humor, and the cinematography and CGI look fantastic overall.
Okay, fine—I’ll admit it: I’m completely in love with these characters.
They’re all so distinct, each with their own quirks, strengths, and personalities, and they’re dead-set on chasing their dreams no matter what. Along the way they run into ruthless Marines, a shadowy organization, and increasingly bizarre islands. And at its heart, it’s a story about friendship—about finding the people who truly get you and discovering a place (or a crew) that finally feels like home.
My only issue with the show was that the ending came very quickly. I want more.
I really love this story, and this season is a nice addition to it.
See you on the Grand Line.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Continuation Of Story
This is the continuation of the 1st season of One Piece, where they are going to the Grand Line and recruit Chopper. It doesn't look like what I hope, but the effect is quite good. I think the 3rd season gonna be great since it's the Alabasta arc. What I love in this season is where they show how Zoro fights those 100 Baraque Works and the effect of the Chopper and Little Garden scene. They really make a hilarious moment.Was this review helpful to you?
Even better than S1!
I already loved season 1 but this season absolutely blows it out of the water — the world-building gets so much deeper and we're introduced to new characters that are such great protagonists and antagonists. You can feel the showing leaning so much more into the wackiness with the set design, costume design, and character designs, which adds so much more to how big and real the world seems.As someone who's already caught up on the manga/anime, it's so interesting to see the foreshadowing they've been able to include. It's so satisfying to see the show take its time setting up stories and plotlines that aren't going to happen until seasons later, and they're able to be fun easter eggs for existing fans and add intrigue for new fans.
I also just have to give flowers to the casting department and the actors they decided on — I think every single character, even those with only a few minutes of screentime, were chosen perfectly, and I love seeing how into it the actors are. Mr. 9 and Mr. 3 were the standouts for me this season, but I genuinely loved every single portrayal.
Can't wait for S3!
Was this review helpful to you?
It’s exactly what it says it is, anime but with people
Which is cute enough
I just have a little issue with their outfits looking too cosplay and not normalistic enough
Does luffy ever, spider man his way through the jungle or anywhere else? Use his rubber arms to swing around?
Cuz he could’ve used that on the mountains
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Adventure of the straw hats
There was an amazing tale of me riding in the adventures of piartes going through their ups and downs.Adventure of the Straw Hats
***Disclaimer: This is just my opinion. We don't have to agree, and I'm not here to argue with anyone.***
OVERVIEW
One Piece is a story about a group of people who come together to form a team known as the pirates, who call themselves the Straw Hats, as they set out to find the supreme treasure of all treasures, the One Piece.
DETAILED REVIEW (CONTAINS SPOILERS)
Initial Thoughts
Right from episode one i was actually being held hostage by this. The setup of their adventures was slow-paced, but they never really had a single dull moment where my eyes would go dim.
The character's dynamics were great, showing the growing layers of their friendship as they learned more about their antics and put their trust in their teammates, and I would learn, too, what trust is all about.
A tale of adventure, with an unbreakable friendship that makes you laugh, giggle, smile, and feel sober, where you could actually learn what having true friends means, and where you could know what adventures are like
Themes & Character
The drama involved a pirate team of five (one added later on), going through the perilous dangers to find the one piece, adding the villain arc was given to an organization called Baroque Works, whose names are known by numbers, days, events, who also want the one piece. Their journey in finding the one piece made them grow stronger in their friendships, trust, emotions, and skills. It equally made some to be actually brave, seeing themselves for who they really are.
Luffy exhibits a captain who have an absolute trust in his teammates, who would never leave anyone of his teammates behind, a character who isn't driven by his emotions to act, instead he goes on his instinct, a character who loves wearing on a smile and laughs which is actually real never shrinks back at his responsibility, never shrinks back from a fight, never feels threatened even when he is faced with a much powerful opponent, he carries on the show as he depicts a character that will die just to protects his crew, this captain is very well deserved.
Roronao Zoro embodies a quiet and aloof character who is the sword of the team, his sword speaks in place of his mouth, He subtly wants to depicts someone aloof but he got lots of words as we got the see in more of the episodes less of the caring type that actually care more without showing it, He is one on the team where you actually see him training not doubting his progressions when beating his enemy in an actual fight.
Nami throws in as the cartographer of the team leading the way to the one-piece, Her character embodies a reserving nature than all talking one were we could see that when she got her worries she just keep it to herself rather than spelling it out to her teammates, a character who doesn't want to be a burden unto her teammates, so she keep some secrets.
Usopp embodies the storyteller of the team, which gives off all-talking vibes, not being reserved or secretive in nature. He is one character where I could see development (weak to strong, fear to strength), where I actually got to see him move on from needing external help to save his friends to becoming one needing to die just to save his friend, his encounter and discussions with Brogy. Were naratively well written
Sanji embodies the chef of the team, and also one who doesn't fight with his swords or with a catapult or with devil's fruit powers. Getting to see him fight with his legs and hands was one of my favorite layouts of this character, where you can see him bleeding some blood like a normal human. Sanji is described as a funny, talkative, caring, and emotionally attached character.
Miss Wednesday/Nefatari Vivi embodies a princess whose kingdom is getting lost to Baroque, went undercover to uncover their Mr. 0 identity, joins our pirate crew on their adventures, and also goes to save her Kingdom from THE hands of the Baroque works with the help of the straw hats.
Likes
As the story seems to delve deeper into some of into some of the fight scenes where they didn't just make the fight scenes a fast paced one e.g when no 9 said they were an 100 men waiting to be fought by Roronao Zoro, really loved as they delved in him killing the 100 while counting their, not him killing the 100 with the screen shut down on us.
The cinematography, visuals, and aesthetics are worthy of a handclap, giving in all well-executed shots, the visuals at the small island (can't remember the name well) kept me on my toes wanting to see more, like the shots of Luffy at the head of the dinosaur above the ground, which were a really well-perfected one.
The cinematography at the sea with the movement of their boats was really spectacular.
Love, as they never created any unnecessary misunderstanding between the straw hats, was the journey they had to fill in any shortcomings with their time together.
One of my favorite loves was for Luffy, who doesn't have to fear anyone; even when they were stronger than him, they were no threats unto him. He was really commendable for that.
Their friendships is very well commendable, as we can see how they just draw closer and bringing in the new friend (princess of Alabasta) in their great dynamics.
The settings that our straw hats didn't have to win every fight were great; sometimes, they just had to get beaten to learn more.
DisLikes
No matter how good some certain flaws take place. While they get beaten by the villains, meeting with the villains again, they get to beat the villains LIKE WHY, when I don't get to see any of them training (except Roronao Zoro could actually see him train with his swords) or performing any strategies to beat the villains, a plot hole.
Getting annoyed at why they don't get to kill their enemies/get to see them alive, you could actually see some of them are just there to complete the plot script, then they are killed by their fellow partner.
Why do I feel they are really making the plot slow, for the making of S3 and S4 equally with how slow-paced it is, S3 will be all about Alabasta, won't be surprised, if they even say S5, that is Netflix behavior.
Final Thoughts
This drama was a thrilling tale of adventure, friendship, loyalty, villain arcs, and battles, a good experience that cannot be missed. The drama started with A good and ended with this is a lot better.
The plot not being able to delve more into the arc of the straw hats & the navy (Smoker) i mean, their dynamics were seen in episode one that was really we just find him chasing them not reaching them, and we actually see smoker in the seventh role don't think it is well deserved, i mean others down that cast definitely had more screen-time than smoker.
The past relationship between chopper and the Dr hilurk was really my most unexpected settling scene of the drama where i could feel what it felt to have the love of a real doctor, what it meant to save lives at the risks of your life what it felt to be loved deeply by your closed one where they could go through fire for you (was really an endearing one) and hide some secrets that will cost you pen.
Chopper joining the crew was a delight to me, as we now actually have a doctor in our crew. The dynamics between Chopper and the witch doctor were perfectly executed; they gave me a real tsundre relationship, which really gave me smiles.
A nice watch in starting my 2026 drama journey, giving this 9.0, the flaws couldn't have made up for these 9, but the moments enjoyed just got to override these flaws
Thanks for reading & happy watching
Was this review helpful to you?
Stupendo, datemene altre 10 di queste
Anche questa volte One Piece si rivela la svolta. Come la volta scorsa (che per sicurezza mi sono rivista nelle settimane precedenti a questa) ho aprezzato tantissimo la ricercatezza nei particolari, nelle idee che sembrano essere diventate esattamente quello che tanti anni fa ho visto nei fumetti e nel manga. Oltre a quello ho amato le sfaccettature che hanno dato ai personaggi, le piccole modifiche che nonostante tutto sono servite a rendere solo più coesa la storia e a facilitarne la trasposizione. Insomma, ho amato alla follia.Devo dire che mi è piaciuto come abbiano ampliati i personaggi, non in maniera differente rispetto alla storia, ma sempre in maniera coesa e ampliandoli, permettendo ad alcune storie di predere già piede e di seminare quello che nel futuro diventeranno le storie di Batolomew, di Sanji e di tanti altri, insomma, la storia di One Piece non peggiora con la serie, si amplia solo.
Passando poi ai personaggi, devo dire che ho amato ritrovare i volti vecchi, ma sopratutto ho adorato conoscere volti nuovi. Ho AMATO ALLA FOLLIA Nico Robin, il mio personaggio preferito del manga, che ho letteramente visto prendere vita. Ho adorato la presentazione ante litteram di Brook e della storia dei pirati di Rumbar. Mi è piaciuta la storia dei ciliegi di Drum e come hanno mostrato il primo incontro fra Whapol e Bibi, una scena che sembra insignificante, ma che diveterà parte integrante di quello che è Vivi. E poi ho amato il cambiamento in Sanji. Insomma, questa serie non smette di stupirmi.
E ora, dopo aver lasciato le fredde montagne di Drum, è ora di salpare alla rotta della calda e sabbiosa, Alabasta.
Was this review helpful to you?
As solid as Season 1, hopefully they keep adapting the manga with the same quality
Disclaimer (same as for S1) : I have not read the entirety of One Piece (-yet) but I have loved what I have read so far and I have even dabbled into watching some of the anime. I have most certainly read much more of the story than what the series is covering and therefore it is very difficult for me to review it without comparing it with the original material.Overall, my feelings about this S2 is quite similar to S1. I think it is a solid adaptation of the manga. Casting did an excellent job with the new characters featured in that part of the story. The costumes / the make up / the visual effects are truly working well at successfully recreating in live action the various protagonists as well as the set in which they evolve. Production is as impressive (if not better) than in S1, with maybe the exception of the OST, which is still very good but I would have appreciated some more reference to the anime songs.
Pacing is pretty fast but not to the point of not allowing some room for emotional moments. However, given the fast-pacing, I'm wondering if the emotional connection that I felt with the various beats of the story might not be the same for people that are discovering the story through the live action media solely, without having read the manga before.
I would definitely recommend this to people that have enjoyed Season 1. In my opinion this adaptation is both satisfying for fans of the manga but also well made enough to onboard people that know nothing about the story (aside from watching season 1). Season 3 is already planned for a release in 2027 and I truly hope we have many more seasons in front of us. Please don't cancel it Netflix !
Was this review helpful to you?
Very fun season
i really liked this season more than the last one.The witty dialogue the funny characters,the set and costume designs were all incredible.
I love that even tho it has a serious goal they keep the childish spirit abd humor from the anime.
Howere i felt like it could have been better, as someone who hasn't read the manga or watched the anime it felt so slow paced i thought they were gonna takd down the organization this season but it was just a set uo for the next season which is fine.
But personally i don't enjoy slow paced things hence the 8.
But i can see a number of people liking this show regardless of the pacing.
Was this review helpful to you?



