A Kpop stan's dream come true!
Idol I is a cute watch— its basically a dream come true for every Kpop stan. Se Na, a stan of the Kpop group Gold Boys, but specifically the lead singer, La Ik, gets to be his defense attorney when he gets accused of killing his fellow Gold Boys member and good friend. What follows, is a "mystery" that was pretty easy to see through, and a cutesy love story between Se Na and La Ik, which was strangely vanilla, like they were highschool teenagers instead of adults in their 30s.Still, I thought the acting was amazing by both leads, and the chemistry was there. Since it was just 12 episodes, it did not feel very draggy, and was overall a cute watch. I just wish this show did not follow the classic Kdrama trope that I am now seeing EVERYWHERE. Which is, the leads were somehow connected when they were kids, and that's when their relationship "actually" began.
*sigh*
Was this review helpful to you?
Lovely chemistry ~
I binge watched this one only because of the lovely chemistry between the leads, they were cute.Kim Jae Yeong's perf was good, really liked how he protayed his character's emotions. I don't usually watch Choi SooYoung's drama cause I never enjoyed her acting but here she was quite lovely.
In term of storyline and plot, I wasn't that invested to be honest. The writing was barely decent, the dialogues were poor, the storytelling could've been easily better.
The mystery did get my attention but at some point I lowkey didn't care that much... and it turned out bland af + the last episode was worthless.
The directing was nice and the chemistry lovely. Will I rewatch it? Nah.
Was this review helpful to you?
A textbook case of wasted potential
Idol I started with so much promise. The early episodes did an excellent job building its characters, giving us enough backstory to genuinely connect with their struggles. You understood who these people were and why they mattered, which made the first half of the drama genuinely compelling .Then came the climax. The main murder motive was incredibly anti-climactic. After all that buildup, the reasoning behind the crime—and committing another to cover it up—felt so stale and underwhelming . It's the kind of reveal that makes you feel hollow rather than shocked.
What makes it worse is how underdeveloped the murder's reasoning felt. We needed more time with the antagonist to understand their descent. Instead, the reveal feels like a last-minute decision from a long brainstorming session . The writers rushed to close doors they spent episodes carefully opening .
The frustrating part? This drama had so much potential. It realistically portrayed the pressures idols face, the blurry line between support and obsession, and how the industry treats artists as products . But by sidelining the murder mystery that drove the plot, it wasted its own foundation.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
entertaining romantic drama without being overly cheesy ;)
Idol I is an entertaining romantic drama without being overly cheesy (although I did have to roll my eyes a few times). The character development is believable and authentic.SPOILER!!
For me personally, the murder case could have been a little darker, and I ultimately found the resolution a bit shallow and simplistic. There was no real confrontation in court, and I didn't feel that Do Ra Ik was ever really in danger. The obsession with the fans could have been more intense as well.
The supporting character Park Chung Jae as the “unrequited love of the childhood friend” was unnecessary in my opinion. I would have liked it if he had been given a real backstory and more screen time, maybe even as a second romantic storyline. We didn't really learn anything about him, except that he had a difficult childhood and that his mother and grandmother are dead. His character was only meant to be a rival to Ra Ik and show how fixated Maeng Se Na is on Ra Ik. I found the placement of the character in the case very shallow, quite predictable, and clichéd.
Was this review helpful to you?
Engaging and pertinent.
Feb 2026I really enjoyed this, at times gritty, drama ~ more than I expected to.
Wanting something light to watch, there was actually more to it than I anticipated!
KJY is another actor who plays characters in a more understated way. He doesn't go OTT and can convey a lot purely with his eyes.
The story twists and turns, as Maeng Si-na (CSY) battles to clear her Idol, Do Ra-ik/Laik (sorry, but a very weird stage name, I thought), of murder.
Of course a romance blossoms, but it didn't overshadow the rest of the story, for me.
A mix of characters, nice cast; Kim Won-hae has been in a lot lately, and I liked him in this ~ he's a huge favourite!
Most characters looked like the culprit at some point, which I liked.
Some characters were awful; one redeemed themselves; another kind of did, but was still impossible for me to like.
It got very cheesy at times, and the way Si-na continued to fan over Laik, even though her boyfriend, was too silly for me.
There were actually some very pertinent messages in this drama, too. Mainly, how Sasaengs can ruin an Idol's life, never mind their mental health. Also, how the family of a celebrity cannot be chosen, and their behaviour / activities are beyond the control of any star. How Idols are pushed, controlled, restricted and basically abused in some cases, is also well highlighted. The effects of any/all these issues, really do lead to tragedy, in too many cases.
I just wish these issues were taken more seriously, and could get through to those with the power to change things. Let's hope one day they will.
I was kept engaged, looked forward to episodes and would happily watch again sometime in the future.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A major disappointment! Even Choi Soo-young couldn't save this drama.
A successful, mature lawyer who is blindly and obsessively in love with an idol? That’s simply not believable. If the main character were a teenage girl, I could understand and accept this behavior. But we’re talking about a serious, responsible, and professionally accomplished adult lawyer who becomes deeply depressed for three days just because her idol dating news is revealed. This level of emotional immaturity makes no sense in context.The main character is full of contradictions and lacks psychological consistency, which ultimately makes her feel unrealistic and poorly written. Her characterization is neither coherent nor convincing.
As for the crime/legal storyline—it completely falls apart. Not only does it fail as a crime plot, but it doesn’t even work as a decent legal drama. The narrative is messy, underdeveloped, and riddled with plot holes.
The only reason I continued watching this series was Choi Soo-young, who—despite not being widely recognized by international audiences—was my favorite childhood member of Girls' Generation (SNSD). Unfortunately, even her presence couldn’t save this drama, and the show ended up being a major disappointment for me.
The male lead, Kim Jae-yeong, delivered a very weak performance as well. I understand that the production likely had a limited budget and couldn’t afford stronger casting choices, but that doesn’t excuse the overall lack of quality.
Ultimately, the story itself is extremely poorly written—disjointed, incoherent, and full of narrative flaws.
I know many viewers enjoyed this drama because of the fan–idol romance fantasy, but personal enjoyment of that trope does not justify high ratings or indicate strong overall quality.
Overall, this drama was genuinely disappointing.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
More than an idol-fan drama
Honestly this was a very very solid drama that actually dealt with very real aspects of celebrity culture in Korea. I have always wanted a good drama that handled the entertainment industry in Korea but everytime a new production rolled out it was disappointment after disappointment.This drama however, really got a lot of things right and therefore gets a pretty great score. It dealt with record labels, obsessive fan culture, sasaeng fans, in group dynamics, paparazzi, how privacy is sadly not a right but a luxury for many people in the industry and just overall the backstage of the overly-glamourized world we see on our screens. I hope many people who watch it can see the real life correlations of some of the storylines, especially the ones regarding obsessive fans and paparazzi.
I also thought the crime/mystery aspect of the show was done pretty well and kept you on your toes.
When it came to the characters; I really loved the chemistry between Sooyoung and Kim Jae Young, they were truly cast perfectly. I could truly see Jae Young as an idol in real life tbh and I loved that he sang all the songs himself. I also believe that Sooyoung being an idol herself who has gone through many of the things that the male character goes through on the show really helped to ground the plot in reality. Overall, both of their acting was very well done.
Now! One thing that I genuinely didn't need in this show was the second male leads romantic feelings towards the FL. I think someone needs to tell these writers that platonic male female relationships do EXIST like why does it scare them so much to portray a healthy M-F friendship? However, I really enjoyed Kim Hyun Jin's acting and really liked his character despite this, I also think he handled the situation very well.
I was also very scared as to how they would handle the fan-idol dynamic and how they would navigate that on a script level but Sooyoung's character was written so well and she was just such a great lawyer and her mindset was amazing that I fully rooted for her. I think it was done in the best way possible.
ALSO, finally a drama where a (SPOILER) childhood connection actually made sense and added a very lovely layer to the story. It was very well done and you could tell the intention behind it rather than a random plot device the writers put to fill up screen time and fake a connection between the leads.
The show started and ended in a very consistent quality which sadly is a rare thing these days. If you like shows/movies set in the entertainment industry then this one is a must watch in my opinion.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A fun watch with a deeper insight into kpop's toxic fan culture
Worth the watch. It was enjoyable. A bit cringe and annoying sometimes but otherwise, it was a good binge.I liked how the drama dives deep into kpop idols' life behind the scenes and the trauma they experience. The drama depicts toxic fan culture very well and how fast fans switch up on their favs.
As a kpop stan myself, the one thing I would nitpick about this drama is how the MC was lowkey in a parasocial relationship with the ML lol. Its not bad or anything like I get it she was literally his first fan and all but the one turn off was when she was mad/sad when she found out about him having an ex. That scene was crazy. Also the fact that she got over Wooseong's death so fast... like um that's ur ult group?! Anyways, this is a drama so I mean take it at face value lol.
But anyways, the drama was very enjoyable to watch. The romance scenes were kinda cringe and stretched out too much but its fine... not the worst lol.
Oh yea forgot to mention this but the MCs were lowkey dumb and annoying LOL. Considering the fact that he's a literal grown man and she's supposed to be a bigshot lawyer lol.... erm.... And the police team pmo too lol I'm no detective but I feel like I would be able to spot a CCTV within the first two eps... took them like 11 eps to find it.
I just felt like there was so much potential for this to be a 9 or 10. But yea... a 7 at most.
Was this review helpful to you?
Because alongside the tension of a rather well-executed “who done it” mystery, the drama also offers critique about the idol industry, that unhealthy one-sided intimacy and connection that often forms between kpop fans and their favorite idols that make products out of these people and the companies that use that for their own benefit. And unlike some other dramas that have attempted such an approach or similar social commentary goes Idol I deep enough within the topic for it to be satisfactory within the story.
It is this social criticism that is the driving force of the story; drives the plot forward and sets key events in motion until the end where it hesitates a bit too suddenly. But at its core, the center of the story is these two lonely individuals who manage to find trust and hope in each other, in different ways and under different circumstances, when all else fails.
These characters seem very real and tangible, interpreted with a real emotional maturity and heart that makes their struggles recognizable and heartbreaking. Despite the great tension and stakes that the mystery highlights, the characters stay firmly grounded and never get too clichéd.
The narrative is effective and sharp but seems to also knows when to slow down for good, important character moments. The pace serves the emotional depth of the drama rather well and therefore manages to tackle both the theme of the story as well as the twists within the story with good sincerity and without relying too much on predictable tropes.
The romance is there, but it mostly simmers quietly in the background and never rises to a general rolling-boil, which fits very well with the story that this drama is trying to tell. The tone is rather melancholy but manages to strike a light chord from time to time, giving the audience enough time to reflect on the characters’ loss of identity, the pressure, and the emotional cost of being an idol without it feeling too depressing.
Raik’s feelings for Sena are perhaps a little too quickly revealed, making their romantic relationship a bit hasty within an otherwise rather coherent story – but that’s probably because of how few numbers of episodes kdramas get these days.
In general, Idol I strikes a strong balance between dramatic events, the emotional weight of the characters and even the light humor without having too much tonal change within the story. The story therefore has a lot of heart, keeping relatively good pace with a clean, concise narrative and a well-structured plot despite the limited number of episodes it gets to tell its story. Each episode offers an exciting storyline that makes the viewer excited for more and despite the interesting mystery, the story never forgets to focus on the inner conflicts of the characters and the heart of the story even if it does falter on the theme during the second half.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A great production of an unhinged fanfic
First, I'll star with what I loved.Since you read the premise, you know what you'll get. Yes it is unrealistic, but I don´t think anyone expected that. I loved it was sort of a love letter for fan culture. It was great to see all sides of fandom, from the good to the ugly, and also, the representation of a grown, succesful woman who enjoyed beign a part of a fandom as a hobby. People tend to think it's a "teenage" or "childish" thing but never bat an eye when men ar die-hard fans of sports too, but I digress.
The cinematography was great, this has so many beautiful scenes, very well shot. Soundtrack was great too.
The casting, superb. Everyone had chemistry with one another, from the Gold Boys members, to the prosecutor and the detective. You could actually bought they all knew each other from a long time before the start. Same with Hye-Joo and La-Ik, you could feel the history and the broken bond between them whenever they interacted.
Main couple, excellent. Their banter and flirting and of course their kisses 10/10.
Yes you do have to suspend your disbelief a little, in real life something like this probably would never happened, but it is like a fanfic adaptation, and a great one at that.
Now for the one thing I didn´t like, I believe the murder mistery could´ve been handled better and tbh at some point I actually lost interest on who the culprit was. Anything they could've done would've been meh to me cause I don't think it was handled well and I did not like at all mental health issued being the reason for the murder.
The final episode, I loved. It was cute, sweet, everything resolved, lots of cute scenes, everyone happy.
I do recommend to watch, always keeping in mind it is a fanfic, don't expect the logic of the real world here.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
not thrilling but a solid drama!
Plot: a stoic lawyer has a reputation of being a workaholic but nobody knows that she has a secret: in her free time she is a super Fan of the boy band "gold Boyz".When her bias gets framed for murder. Will she be able to put aside her inner fan to defend her idol?
Plot:🗯️
It is simple and I liked it.
I feel though They portrait the main conflict ambiguously. The FL is supposed to be a huge fan, but to me she didn't seem to struggle that much to put aside her more "emotional" fan side. She was very professional in her job.
The drama was quite good with putting together the pieces of the murder investigation. I am not a super smart person which means I was fooled be the direction of the drama into pointing at different suspects. I never doubted the "real culprit" to be honest 😅. I changed my mind many times. Calm me gullible i guess.
Characters:🗯️
FL: the actress is good but I found her character quite bland and to be frank I never bite into her "love" with the ml. I didn't feel the sparks. To me they seemed more like a teacher and a student.
ML: good actor, probably my favourite in the drama. He was a complex character and the actor was able to showcase his emotions in a believable way. When it comes to romance I think he has better chemistry with the FL than she has with him.
The other actors were all solid.
Romance:🗯️
Romance wise this drama is not the best to be honest. Sure the characters get close in a natural way but the flame wasn't there for me.
The scenes with them bonding were cute i m Not gonna lie but I feel they could have added more.
Best part:🗯️
This may sound weird but I feel like the best part of the drama were the characters "trauma dumping".
The drama did a good job at portraying broken people with past and present trauma. It felt healing in some way. Lack of trust and secrets are a heavy burden that the characters are able to unload and get past. Some moments were really touching.
they did a good job of showing hit parasocial relationship affect the fans and especially the idol involved.
Worst part:🗯️
The last 2 episode were for a lack of better words disappointing.
When the real culprit gets arrested I expected to see all the drama unrevealing but they never show us the trail or the after math. Immediately after the arrest the drama fast forward a whole year. Even the romance was a bit meh in these episodes. It's been a whole year and the lawyer still uses HONORIFICS to address her now boyfriend.
The FL in the drama puts aside her fan "love" to accept the singer as a real human and not just an idol but in the last episode she is back to her "fan" self. I didn't feel this was necessary maybe even a regression.
also the prosecutor guy. at first I thought he would be the love interest. going from former bully to lovers but I abandoned that idea quite quickly 😅. they could have done more with him, a real bickering , lawyer to lawyer relationship
Conclusions: is it worth it? Definitely yes. This drama is not trembles inducing but it's a solid story with interesting characters and backstories. Romance is there (even though it's not the main focuse).
Watch and enjoy.
Was this review helpful to you?
Good plot, executed badly
I was really excited for this drama to air as it had a really good cast, and an interesting premise. Unfortunately, it didn't live up to my expectations. Overall, it was enjoyable but nothing special.My first problem is the FL. Don't get me wrong, Sooyoung is a great actress, but I felt like her character was written in an unrealisitic way. I feel like this is because as soon as she became the ML's lawyer, she immediately stopped fangirling. As a fangirl myself, I found this to be unbelievable even if the character is supposed to be extremely professional. Also, the fact that she was supposedly professional contradicts with the fact that she was living with her client.
Another issue I had is the ML's ex. For the first few episodes, I found her to be a good character, and quite enjoyed the scenes she was in. But towards the end, I just found her annoying. Not only that but I feel like the group treated her really badly considering that although she wasn't the nicest of people, she had no bad intent towards any of them. I also wasn't happy that there wasn't really a closure between her and the ML.
There were also a couple of other things that got on my nerves a bit, but I won't go into that now.
In terms of things I enjoyed, I thought the chemistry between the ML and FL was really believable and they were also very likeable characters. Another thing I enjoyed was the addition of the ML's mother, as I found her to be an interesting character, although I really wish that there had been more scenes with the ML and her together.
Would I recommend this drama? Probably not. However, if your bored and there is nothing else to watch, go for it!
Was this review helpful to you?
