More Than an Idol Story — A Drama That Teaches Fans How to Love Right ?
I honestly started IDOLI mainly because of Kim Jae Young 😭 He once mentioned that after entering his 40s, he might not get chances to play idol-type roles again, and that made this drama feel extra emotional and meaningful for me. I wasn’t watching just for the story, but for him too and he absolutely did not disappoint at all ♥️First of all, the OSTs are SO GOOD 🎧✨ The music really carries the emotions of the scenes and makes everything feel deeper. Some moments wouldn’t have hit the same without the soundtrack.
What I truly loved about this drama is the message. It shows how fans should treat idols with respect, trust, and care for their privacy and safety. It reminds us that loving an idol also means supporting them quietly when they’re going through hard times, not making things harder for them. That part felt very real and mature, and I appreciated it so much 🥺
Story wise, it was a bit predictable for me. When I first saw the person called “like” , chatting with Maeng Se Na, I already had a feeling about who she really was 👀 But the actual villain reveal?? That part surprised me, and I loved that twist!
The drama also stays in a comfortable emotional zone. It’s not too heavy, not too stressful just something you can watch and enjoy while still feeling connected to the characters. I had such a good time watching this over the last couple of weeks, and I’ll miss the vibe a lot 💫
Overall, IDOLI is a warm, meaningful, and slightly emotional watch especially for fans who truly care about their idols as people, not just celebrities 💖🌙
Was this review helpful to you?
1
1This review may contain spoilers
Idol & Inconsistency
Good chemistry. Fake premise. A lawyer drama that forgot the law, a murder mystery that ran in circles, and a finale that wasted its last shot. The romance carried this harder than it should have had to.-
I signed up for the ultimate Seong-deok fanfic, saving your bias from a murder charge. The cards were on the table. Se-na is an ace attorney. Ra-ik is an idol in handcuffs. Idol I did not bait and switch me. It promised a lawyer with a murder to solve and then spent eleven episodes refusing to actually show her being a lawyer. Every single beat of potential legal tension evaporates into nothing. Her profession is decorative, it is a typo, it is a fanfic device to justify proximity to her crush. You could have swapped her law background for a barista apron or florist shears or a sushi chef hat or walking dogs and nothing would have changed. Same scenes. Same dialogue. Same total absence of stakes. The script treats her profession like it was a typo that slipped past casting. Watching her do literally anything legal is like staring into an empty room waiting for fireworks. Nothing happens. Court scnes? nah?. Not an investigation she drives. Not a clever legal pivot. Nothing. Nada. Ugh.
The murder mystery is limp. Toxic substances in Ra-ik’s and his friend’s blood appear and then vanish. Who gave it to them? Why? Was it overlooked by sloppy investigators? Did someone cover it up? The show doesn’t care. Eleven episodes of circling the same evidence, pretending it counts as tension. They even run away to a cabin right after Ra-ik is indicted like being officially charged means nothing. Cozy romantic fantasy replaces stakes. I am furious.
Se-na dating her client? Ethics evaporated. Prosecutor Jung Jae-kwang suddenly grows a conscience after one conversation with Se-na. His father Kim Min-sang is cartoonish. Obstruction of justice is a casual hobby. These are not plot choices, they are insults to anyone who knows how justice works. The whole thing is nonsense. The story pretends consequences exist while actively ignoring them.
Romance is infuriatingly effective. Confessions, letter in the morning, Se-na running out late at night to deliver a hat. Cute, impulsive, human. The lawyer-suspect tension should create stakes, danger, stress, legal fireworks. Instead, it is proximity to justify romance. Chemistry doing the emotional labor the story refuses to do. I am charmed and furious at the same time.
The ML and 2FL conversations are pointless. One episode he’s in love, next episode he’s not. Watching it feels like staring into a void while someone waves their hands. Surface-level, invisible, whatever their contribution is, it is nothing. 2ML, the prosecutor, is vapid, and his one personality pivot is laughable. Watching actors try to make sense of this vacuum is maddening.
Han Do-hee as the ex-girlfriend does good work. She acts bitter, brittle, dangerous. But the writing refuses to earn it. Accidental harm escalates to premeditated murder mechanically. I believed her rage, her resentment, her self-pity wrapped in cruelty. I wish the writing cared as much as her acting.
Kim Jae-young and Sooyoung are the only reason this drama limps along. They give weight, pulse, emotional grounding. Without them, it is rubble. With them, it drags itself to the finish line. They fight the script with everything they have. Watching them is thrilling and enraging because everything else refuses to exist.
Park Chung Jae, played by Kim Hyun-jin, exists to pine and hand over evidence. It is infuriating watching him fight a script that cannot write him a single proper motivation. Side characters barely have motivations. I have seen cardboard targets with more interior life.
Idol/fandom moments land sometimes. Goldys waving flags, obsessive fans, parasocial ugliness, constant pressure, glimpses of real fandom intelligence, morse code in a song that makes me laugh and groan at the same time. It is absurd, ridiculous, but it works in the narrow context of fan energy. Still, it is another reminder of how lazy the rest of the writing is.
The finale is such a waste. Her father’s case barely matters, shoved into a single episode, literally a five-second footnote. Se-na finally functions as a lawyer and it barely matters. Romantic awkwardness happens after the relationship is established, which creates weird timing. The rest of the finale should have been ten minutes tacked onto episode eleven. Everything else is random fan-survival footage.
Idol I flashes brilliance constantly and then immediately smothers it. Se-na could have been a powerhouse lawyer. Ra-ik’s suspense could have carried fire. The investigation could have delivered tension. But the show chooses fanfic logistics over stakes, romance over logic, chemistry over plot, flashes of fandom insight over coherent procedural. It teases you, riles you, makes you believe something might happen, and then refuses to be anything other than padded, sloppy, frustrating nonsense.
It is maddening. It is infuriating. It is exhausting. It could have been sharp, biting, thrilling. Instead, it is chaos wrapped in cute gestures, fan service, and actors refusing to let the nonsense collapse entirely. I am furious and I cannot stop thinking about it.
Was this review helpful to you?
ULTIMATE BIAS BECOMES ULTIMATE DEFENDANT
The drama successfully blends the high stakes of a murder mystery with the often chaotic world of K-pop fandom. By placing a 'fangirl' in a position of power as a defense attorney, it subverts the typical idol-fan dynamic. The story centers around Maeng Se-na, a cold-blooded 'villain lawyer' who conceals a ten-year obsession with the group Gold Boys. Her world is turned upside down when her 'ultimate bias,' Do Ra-ik, is framed for the murder of a fellow bandmate. The tension arises not only from the trial but also from Se-na's struggle to maintain professional boundaries while her 'fan heart' is in turmoil.Unlike many fan-themed dramas, such as "Her Private Life," "Idol I" handles the fandom aspect with surprising maturity. Se-na is an 'ethical fan' who wants justice for Ra-ik—not just because she likes him, but because she values the truth. Coming off her performance in "The Judge from Hell," Jae-young delivers a standout portrayal, perfectly capturing Ra-ik's duality: the polished, 'visual center' idol on stage versus the isolated, cynical, and vulnerable man facing a life sentence. Additionally, the cohabitation trope—necessary for his protection—feels earned rather than forced. Their chemistry is built on a slow-burning intellectual respect, which makes the romantic payoffs in the final episodes much more satisfying.
However, like many K-dramas, the legal procedures are occasionally 'creative.' If you are a fan of hardboiled legal thrillers, you might find some evidence-gathering scenes a bit too convenient or dramatic. While the finale provides a 'neatly wrapped' happy ending, the transition from Ra-ik's trial to their 'organic' romantic reunion feels slightly rushed in the final hour.
In conclusion, "Idol I" succeeds because it portrays idols as human beings and fans as capable professionals. It's less of a fairytale and more of a reckoning with how we perceive celebrities.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Refreshing Watch That Leaves You Feeling Whole
It was a really good watch! I appreciated how the storyline unfolded — starting with the crime scene, then gradually painting the full picture of the events surrounding it, until everything was brought to light and justice was finally served. I LOVED the cuteness between the leads rather than heavy romance (must've screamed 'Kiyowo' at least 100 times throughout the drama), and honestly, this drama made the male lead Kim Jae-yeong shine so much more in my eyes. I’m genuinely looking forward to his future main roles now.Also, LOL — they tied this drama up so neatly that it honestly could’ve ended an episode earlier and I’d still have been fully satisfied. By the end of Episode 11, I was genuinely confused when the next episode started playing like, “What’s left?? They’ve already sorted everything.” 😭 (Bad K-trauma has truly scarred me with unresolved plots and loopholes.) So it was incredibly refreshing to see everything wrapped up properly, with no loose ends left hanging.
What I really appreciated about this drama:
- A refreshing female lead who saves the male lead, fights for justice, and carries no bitterness — not even toward her bullies.
- No cartoonishly evil characters; everyone had depth, pain, and understandable motivations, making the story feel humane and real.
- The drama didn’t torture the “good guys” excessively — there were turbulent moments, but it always allowed space to breathe. Even during investigations and public cancellations, life continued normally: she could still work, he could still move around — no unnecessary chaos or mob outrage.
- A consistently easygoing, comforting watch — never too heavy, traumatising, or exhausting. Smart pacing - whenever things got emotionally intense, the story softened the moment and restored balance.
- Exceptional casting: the leads carried every scene so naturally that there was zero cringe, even in awkward or quiet moments. Every glance up from the subtitles brought a smile — whether they were smiling, crying, thinking, or just existing, it all felt warm and sincere.
Never once felt the urge to drop the drama — no dragging, no irritation, no emotional burnout.
Overall, the drama felt genuinely refreshing from start to finish.
Was this review helpful to you?
Fame is when ordinary becomes luxury. It comes with consequences...
This is a story of a fan and her idol proving his innocence. Sounds simple, but not easy to prove as the murder happened in the idol's house. There starts the push and pull game of faith, fate and resilience.As a kpop fan myself, it was hard to watch. Idols and fans are inseparable items. Both of them exist for and because of each other. But if one of them crosses the line, everything falls down. It made me wonder how my favourite idols go through their lives. Do they face these types of problems, backlash, humiliation, and negative thoughts every day? I bet they do. In spite of that, they put on a happy mask in front of us. Idol life isn't easy.
Call me weird, strange or crazy, but I liked Laik's vulnerable side, especially when he cried.
Unlike everyone, Laik expressed his deepest emotions and feelings very clearly. Maybe because he was portrayed as a psychologically struggling person, he was aware of his mental struggles and never shied away from articulating them in words. His crying face is painful for me as I found myself moved by them. He looked pretty and pitiful and at the same time.
He was thinking that he'd be protecting others, but he was the one who needed to be saved. Initially, we saw him behaving rudely to staff and band members, but we didn't know why he was acting that way. Idol's life isn't easy, his every move is constantly scrutinised and judged by people without any explanation, even if it wasn't their fault. How unfair is that?
This drama isn't perfect, it has its flaws, but one thing I know, I loved it for what it is. It wasn't a romcom, murder mystery or a full-fledged law drama, but the mix of everything that held its essence till the end. It keeps you guessing and suspecting possible murderers before the police. I loved how it wasn't romance focused because it wasn't. It was a journey of Laik proving his innocence, finding and loving himself once again. Without Maeng Sena it wasn't possible. She was the trust he needed to peddle himself back to his own identity as a person, Laik. Also, I loved how the romance wasn't forced, it was naturally flowy and slow but powerful. If you think it isn't romance-focused, the mystery ends in Ep. 11, and you get a whole episode of them being lovey-dovey. They made up the audience's hope for every single missed opportunity for romance. It was more than enough for me.
Acting was great! Personally I'm a fan of Choi Soo Young, also the reason I started this drama. But oh boy, got bamboozled by Kim Jae Young's superb acting and his handsome face. I could stare at his face for HOURS!!! Side characters, especially the ex-gf, bandmate's emotional acting was notable. The OSTs were nice, did created a whole idol vibe but nothing really stand out for me.
Overall, a worthy, entertaining drama if you are interested in watching something not very romance-focused.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Interesting, But Not Quite There
I’ll be honest, I started this drama because the synopsis sounded interesting. The mix of idols and a thriller element definitely made me curious enough to keep watching.I really liked the male lead actor, and let’s be real, he’s very hot. Charismatic, interesting to watch, and easy on the eyes, which definitely helped. I wasn’t familiar with the female lead actress, but I didn’t think she was bad either. On their own, both characters were okay.
The thriller plot started strong. It was fun to create theories and guess who the killer might be. At some point, though, it became easier to figure it out, and the reveal didn’t hit as hard as I expected. Some very serious events (especially involving his ex-girlfriend) were resolved a bit too lightly, which reduced their emotional impact.
Now… the romance. This is where the drama lost me a little. I never really felt romantic tension or chemistry between the leads. The story leaned a bit into a fan/idol vibe rather than a balanced romantic connection, especially towards the end. I personally would have preferred a “quiet pride and support” kind of love instead of devotion bordering on fangirling.
Overall, this drama has a good premise, a strong start, and some enjoyable elements, but it didn’t fully deliver where it mattered most. Still, it’s not bad, just a bit underwhelming in key areas.
Rating: 6/10
Was this review helpful to you?
idol I the kdrama YOU should watch
Idol I is a fresh and engaging K-Drama that offers a compelling look into the world of idols while balancing drama, emotion, and entertainment. Unlike many idol-centered dramas that focus purely on romance or fan service, this series takes a broader approach, exploring the pressures, challenges, and personal growth that come with fame. From the very first episode, it is clear that the show aims to give viewers more than just glitz and glamour—it presents characters who feel real, with believable struggles and aspirations.The leads deliver performances that are both convincing and relatable. The actors bring depth to their roles, portraying the joys and anxieties of idol life with authenticity. The main characters’ interactions are layered, reflecting not only friendship and teamwork but also the subtle tensions and challenges that arise in high-pressure environments. Supporting characters are also well-written, contributing to the story without feeling like filler, which keeps the plot engaging throughout the series.
One of the standout qualities of Idol I is how it balances different tones. While the show has plenty of lighthearted and fun moments—highlighting the charm and charisma of the idol world—it also delves into more serious themes. Issues such as personal identity, ambition, and the expectations placed on public figures are explored thoughtfully. The show never becomes overly heavy, but it manages to provide emotional depth that adds weight to the story. This balance of entertainment and meaningful storytelling makes Idol I appealing to a wide audience, from casual viewers to devoted K-Drama fans.
Another strength is the pacing and structure. Each episode flows naturally, with a mix of character development, engaging plotlines, and moments that showcase the idols’ talents and personalities. The drama’s narrative keeps viewers invested without relying on predictable tropes, and it rewards attention with subtle character growth and interpersonal dynamics. The production quality is also notable, with visually appealing cinematography, stylish sets, and music that complements the story without overpowering it.
Overall, Idol I is an entertaining, thoughtful, and emotionally satisfying K-Drama. It offers a glimpse into the idol industry while maintaining a strong focus on character and story. The series succeeds in being both fun and meaningful, making it highly enjoyable from start to finish. Personally, I found myself completely invested in the characters and their journeys, and I would confidently give Idol I a perfect score. It is a series that both idol fans and general viewers can appreciate, providing laughter, heartfelt moments, and a satisfying exploration of life behind the spotlight.
Was this review helpful to you?
chef’s kiss..
~ ITS GOOD U CAN START✶- I love that the romcom vibe doesn’t take over the mystery here.. also it has this melancholic, emotional depth that’s really pulling me in.
✶- What I love most is how we’re first introduced to Ra-Ik and Sena’s separate lives and the issues of the entertainment industry, letting their connection develop naturally..
✶-FL didn’t let her fangirl side get in the way of her lawyer duties.. She did her job well, even while slowly realizing that she doesn’t actually know everything about her idol.
✶- I like how this show is trying to push the narrative that idols are people too and should be able to date. As an international fan I have never understood this mentality that idols can only love the fans..
✶- the childhood connection was executed so WELL
✶-this show is an example of Romantic mystery done correct
✶- But I would say, the murder plot was kinda weak,, or basically u can say there were some loopholes.. but overall enjoyed it
Was this review helpful to you?
Lack of Everything
Premise: I’m not into heavy, highly realistic, plot-driven dramas, so I chose this one because I knew it would be cozy (or at least I thought so).However, I think it’s much lighter than it’s supposed to be.
How can a murder suspect have time to flirt with his lawyer?
Why, at the very beginning, does the autopsy doctor say that the wounds were too perfect not to have been planned in advance, while at the end of the drama it turns out to be an accidental murder?
I usually hate angst, but this time it was actually needed.
Despite the very good acting, the plot is weak and pointless.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Strong Start, Weak Finish
I genuinely enjoyed the beginning of Drama Idol I. The setup was engaging and kept my attention, although the search for the real killer felt unnecessarily stretched out. Unfortunately, the reveal itself didn’t impress me much — the idea that the ML’s best friend was accidentally killed by his obsessive ex-girlfriend felt rather underwhelming and predictable.The last two episodes were especially disappointing. They felt slow and somewhat boring, and instead of being emotionally gripping, they lacked the intensity I was hoping for. While it was clear that the writers wanted to neatly tie everything together, I felt that the storyline involving the FL’s father was left unresolved. I really wished to see some form of justice — particularly for the prosecutor who wrongly accused her father — even if the drama wasn’t primarily focused on that theme.
Another downside for me was the romance between the ML and FL. It felt underdeveloped, and I wanted more emotional depth and connection between them to truly believe in their relationship.
Overall, despite a strong start and some good ideas, the drama didn’t fully deliver on its emotional potential.
Final rating: 6,5/10
Was this review helpful to you?
One time watch
I had big hopes for this drama. But the execution failed and in some places so did the acting.For an idol who has a murder charge on him and is facing jail time, I found him more like a prince throwing a tantrum left right and center.
The first couple of episodes where you feel any sympathy for him soon turns into frustration and annoyance.
The romance felt forced and more like a noona romance which should not be the case going by the childhood memory they share.
It a strange one, I could bring myself to watch this one back to back, but rather one episode a couple of days. Still can recommend for a binge watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
Couldn't carry the weight of its own storyline
This drama was very promising at the beginning. It had an interesting premise, strong actors in place for the leads, and intriguing circumstances bringing them together. Most of all, I really enjoyed the Idol perspective on fans and how they view idols. There was so much potential there.Unfortunately, neither the murder mystery nor the romance paid off for me. I'm a fan of both the actors playing the leads, but this drama was a huge miss. Even their chemistry couldn't keep me engaged. I wish I could say the romance scenes were good, but they weren't. The whole time I was wondering how he could even think of romance when he was a murder suspect! And the kiss...I felt like it was staged to look pretty, not reasonable. That took me out of it completely. I just wish more thought had been put into both the story and the romance to make it believable. This drama would have benefited from leaning into the serious, Idol-life and murder aspect, with romance being toned down a LOT. So, so disappointed with how this turned out.
Would I recommend it? Only if you're a die-hard fan of the leads and don't mind a popcorn (aka empty, hollow) show. P.S. If you're watching it on Netflix, the maximum play speed is 1.5x...
Was this review helpful to you?
