News This review may contain spoilers
Don’t Let the Bandwagon Decide for You
I like to think I’m fair, so I’ll try my best to be just that while also not boring you to sleep, so I’ll keep this concise. This drama takes on a lot of big topics: cheating, depression and mental health crises, suicide, grief, guilt, dysfunctional families, and corruption and crime. With that much ground to cover, the story naturally tries hard to let you into each character’s inner life. It does, but it can only go so far. I wished the writer had gone deeper so the audience could truly vouch for a character, but I see how that could have been a challenge, and it was still executed rather decently.I know many people complain about the storyline and fixate on certain aspects, such as the cheating. To that I say, if you’re still fixated on that by the end, you’ve missed the point entirely. The writer portrays a plethora of characters, each one flawed but also admirable in other ways, just like you and me. This drama in no way follows the traditional fairytale K-drama formula, and I liked it even more for that. If you’re looking for a drama that goes against the grain, pushes through clichés, and does the things you wished you’d seen in other dramas, this is it.
It draws on beautiful metaphors that may take a second to understand, but once you see it, you see it. It’s about two people and their connection through life, and it shows that a relationship takes many layers of effort. It’s not simply love, but also communication, chemistry, and understanding. Everyone deserves someone who sees them for who they are, flaws and all, and loves them for it. Everyone deserves happiness in a relationship. Sometimes it gets hard, and there are ups and downs in every relationship, but issues can snowball if they aren’t addressed. Time doesn’t heal that. It just creates scars, and some scars are too deep. Sometimes you need to let go, and to do that, you need to learn to love yourself.
Just because a relationship fizzles out and ends doesn’t mean it was all in vain or meant nothing. People change people. Within us, we carry pieces we’ve gathered from every connection we’ve made, each one making us who we are in this moment. Those pieces can be good or bad, but it’s up to us how we move forward with them. We can let certain experiences eat away at us, or we can take them as lessons and gain humility from them. Just because it’s over doesn’t mean it wasn’t real. I think this was a beautiful drama, and it was never boring. Maybe frustrating at times, but life can be frustrating. If you’re open to following the characters as they come to realize this in the end, I’d say give it a shot. Keep an open mind, because sometimes things aren’t all they seem.
Was this review helpful to you?
Felt like punishment
I knew within the first few seconds that this show was going to test my patience.The storyline is annoying, the relationship is irritating, and the characters are somehow even worse. Not a single soul I want to root for. The leads are pathetic, the romance is frustrating, and the entire thing feels like a punishment disguised as a love story.
You know a drama is a disaster when I start thinking the ML deserves better. ME. Thinking the ML deserves better. I never do that. That's how you know things have gone terribly, terribly wrong.
This show is an absolute waste of time, a waste of effort, a waste of potential. This isn't a realistic portrayal of adult relationships; it's a parade of pathetic, ridiculous individuals making one infuriating decision after another, with the audacity to call it a love story. And honestly, the longer I watched, the less I cared whether they ended up together.
Seo Kang-joon is one fine shyt. This man is somehow even finer now than he was in his twenties, and yet his script selection hasn't improved one bit. ‘When the Weather Is Fine’ cannot be the only good thing in this man's filmography.
Ahn Eun-jin, GIRL. GET UP. DO SOMETHING! How did the woman who led the masterpiece that was My Dearest end up here? Dynamite Kiss, Goodbye Earth, and now this?
I'm dropping this. No guilt, no regrets, no looking back. There are better dramas out there, and I refuse to spend another minute watching a romance that makes me root for absolutely nobody. Why waste hours of my life forcing myself through something I clearly hate when I can just drop it and go on living my life in peace?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Honestly, I would give it a shot on a boring, slow afternoon.
I really enjoyed this show. I don’t even fully know how to explain it, but it just got to me. So many people called it a show about cheating, but by that final episode, I realized it was never just about that, it was about two people drifting apart. And it’s not an ordinary relationship where you can just pack up and walk away. They have so much history and their lives are so deeply intertwined that they’re almost family before anything else. That’s what makes it hurt.If I had to sum up the whole gist of the show, it’s really a story about moving on.
If you look at it from the writer’s perspective through Lee Mi Do, yes, she’s a deeply flawed character and she got so much backlash, she was actually the very center of everything. She showed us what it truly feels like to struggle with change. And to really get that, you have to look at her family, because that’s where the heart of this theme lives:
Her mother: She lost her husband young and had to raise her kids through that grief. Fast forward to the present, and we see someone who has learned how to live through loss and adapt. Mi Do has been frantically fighting and grappling with everything changing around her, and her mom gives her the exact advice she needs at the right moment: don't fight it, don't fear it, just go with the flow.
Her older brother: He came off a bit disjointed and awkward, but underneath all of that, he was just a good man who was always there for his family. It breaks your heart a bit because a man who puts family first still ends up divorced, and the show doesn't even give him a simple answer as to why. Yet, he is forced into change anyway. He has to keep moving forward, even when life isn't in his favor.
Her younger brother: This one hit the hardest. He’s drowning in grief over his late fiancée, so withdrawn that everyone thinks he's strange. But really, he's just consumed by regret. The most painful, powerful part of his story is that his fiancée actually expected him to move on. She thought he’d sell the karaoke place and find her last gift to him, finding closure years ago. Instead, he stayed frozen in place and suffered for years. It’s a heavy reminder that sometimes the very answers you're searching for are waiting for you on the other side of letting go.
So while everyone was arguing and debating over who was cheating on who, they missed the most beautiful part of the show. It was never about the mistresses or the mister. It was about two people on a painful journey where you have to make the hardest decision of all, to leave something you hold dear behind so you can actually grow.
It was about change and moving on, and the show was a masterpiece in how it showed that. If you're just starting it, I hope you view it from this angle and really feel it. It’s such good material.
Was this review helpful to you?
Do the reviews justify the drama?
Fuck these ratings, honestly, because I’m giving this show a solid 10/10 just for the way it ended. The resolution alone made the entire journey worth it for me. I went into this drama hoping for a satisfying conclusion, but I was still worried that things might take a completely different turn, and I genuinely wasn’t sure whether I would end up being happy with how everything played out. Thankfully, I stuck with it until the very end, and I couldn’t be happier with the outcome.One of the things I really appreciated was the family dynamics. They added so much to the overall story and made the relationships feel more meaningful. I loved seeing the different family interactions and how they contributed to the characters’ development. It wasn’t just about the main storyline; the family relationships also played a significant role in making the drama enjoyable for me.
And can we talk about the second FL? Because I absolutely loved her! She was such a great part of the story, and I found myself appreciating her more and more as the episodes went by. I genuinely enjoyed her presence, and she definitely left an impression on me. Sometimes, a second female lead can make or break the viewing experience, and she was definitely one of the highlights for me.
I’ll admit that I was a little apprehensive about the direction the story might take toward the end. I kept wondering whether the writers would actually give us the resolution I was hoping for or take things in the opposite direction. That uncertainty had me worried, but now I’m so glad I didn’t give up on the show before reaching the finale.
Ultimately, I loved how everything came together. The ending gave me the satisfaction I was looking for, and it made the emotional investment feel worthwhile. Honestly, I couldn’t have asked for a better resolution. Whatever the ratings say, this drama worked for me, and that’s what matters. **A well-deserved 10/10 from me!**
Was this review helpful to you?
Because of money they choose this type of script instead she can act in nude films for good money
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Cruda realidad en el amor
Me gustó la historia, si no lo han vivido, no saben y no entienden que una relación de 10 años no se suelta fácil, que hay idas y venidas por toda la historia y etapas compartidas hasta que por fin puedes cerrar ese capítulo.El final lo más real, sano y bonito. Cerrando su relación con amor y sin rencores. dejando claro que se puede volver amar y conectar con mas personas, siendo el ejemplo de cómo se quedan con los secundarios cada uno, ahora con un amor más maduro y consiente.
Claro ejemplo de que el amor no es lo único, ni basta para sostener una relación, puedes amar muchísimo a alguien pero no ser la persona con la que vas a compartir tu vida.
Was this review helpful to you?
Cry Frustrate Like
Have you ever felt like you never fully express yourself, yet somehow, at the same time, you put so much of yourself out there? Like there are things you want to say, emotions you want to express, and people you want to confront, but you just can't bring yourself to do it? Well, this is exactly the kind of drama that brings all those feelings to the surface.It’s emotional, deeply moving, and the kind of story that makes you feel every emotion right down to your bones. There are times in life when you want to hurt the person you love simply because they’ve hurt you, but when it comes down to it, you just can't bring yourself to do it. So you hold back, swallow your words, and somehow continue loving them despite everything. The entire story revolves around these complicated, unspoken feelings of the leads, and that’s what makes it so powerful.
What I love most is how easily you can relate to the emotions in this drama, not just through romantic relationships but also through friendships and family. It captures those complicated bonds where you might not always feel excited about someone or even particularly like them at times, yet you still hold them above everyone else. They become such an important part of your life that, even when you're upset with them, you can't stop caring about them or supporting them when it matters.
This is the kind of drama you watch to *feel, relate, and cry your heart out*. It captures what it means to be in a long-term relationship, where love isn't always about butterflies and happiness. Sometimes, it's about knowing someone so deeply that even their flaws, mistakes, and the things that hurt you don't erase the place they hold in your heart.
I genuinely loved the plot, the direction, and the actors. Everything comes together to make the emotions feel so raw and real. This isn't a drama you watch just to see what happens next; it's one you watch to understand what the characters are feeling and, somewhere along the way, understand yourself a little better, too.
If you're looking for something deep and emotionally layered, this drama is definitely for you. It might even help you make sense of feelings you've carried for a long time but never quite understood or knew how to put into words. ❤️
Was this review helpful to you?
It's a mature drama (French Review).
C'est un drama mature, qui n'est pas fait pour tout le monde et qui a été mal compris par la majorité. Il est poignant, touchant et nous fait nous questionner sur l'amour.Il n'est pas linéaire et c'est ce qui fait sa beauté.
Deux adultes traversant des hauts, des bas, qui s'aiment profondément mais dont l'amour n'est pas fait l'un pour l'autre. Deux adultes qui seraient prêts à faire tout pour l'autre mais qui ne sont pas fait l'un pour l'autre. Un amour pur, profond et blessant.
Je dirais que c'est un drama à regarder d'un point de vue "à la troisième personne".
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
UPDATE with final thoughts - after finale
This update isn't really a review but my "unpacking of what I feel now" after 14 dreadfully put together episodes.All characters (especially the main 4) needed intense therapy and counseling. And the enduring feeling I have is the Writer has worked in Psychotherapy and seen all these issues play out in everyday people's lives. It is NOT pretty. BUT, the Writer has yet to present us with drama worth the time of 14 episodes and then leave the viewer with a trite "pretty ending".
Regardless of that, here is what I found unforgiveable. The dialogue was terrible - who speaks like that? Regardless of culture, the dialogue was "cut and paste" from a database the writer has kept handy. None of it felt real, or relatable in their scenes. I can see this drama had countless personalities (not just characters); the drama itself had no personality...but multiples. Next: Our main female MiDo never developed emotionally beyond the age of 9. (and it is likely true of Namgoong until he finally was true to himself). Characters may study; work, take on adult responsibility and even engage in adult sexual expression. BUT their key trait from childhood is an inability to express needs or desires honestly. They remain stunted until mid to late 30s and finally see their own failing in emotional growth. This handicap seriously damaged another person (Mido & Namgoong). And it isn't because there wasn't a kind of love shared, it just was not a healthy love that could sustain a couple in marriage. THAT was obvious to me FROM the very beginning in episode 1. Ahn Eun Jin is an incredible actress - she brought this creature to life and Mido was NOT a likable person. Even at the end, she's still stunted emotionally. All the tears in the world will not fix what's wrong with her.
The family dynamics were dreadfully manipulative; the brothers were weaklings. Namgoong at last realized he needed to break free and the last episode did not make me feel any sympathy for the brothers or Mido. Even if the mother said the right words in the script, she was a flat excuse of a character. Hence my firm conviction - the Writer had a dialogue database they chose lines from...and they never fit. This is the WORST drama of 2026. It was NEVER Romance genre; this was straight up a Psychological (or Horror) genre. And even so, it missed the mark IMO.
Original review: As of Episode 8 - a drama like none other... it's not a pretty one.
This will be a unique and much discussed drama. Many have already decided it's the worst - from a moral point of view. Citing infidelity as their main issue. There is no doubt this story was meant to wreak havoc in the viewer's mind and upset the status quo of most Kdrama viewers. However...there's more going on here and NONE of us will know until the end what the point or trajectory was until then.
In my opinion, Ahn Eun Jin is slaying her role as the most unhinged, self-destructively impulsive woman who realizes in her 30s, she's no longer the sure sighted person she thought she was after being "so incredible" in high school. This is a HUGE issue. The other issue is of course the "so called romance" between her and the ML (Seo Kang Joon) that from my own personal viewing...never existed. This drama looks like a friendship that fell into the trap of "youthful sexual attraction and physical needs" because no one else was there. All the flashbacks show a very FLAT romance. There is sexual expression, but no equality of persons - friends who know each other well, and have regular sexual intimacy but...THERE was never any real lifegoals of it leading to marriage. Here is is where I feel the drama wants to drag the viewers on a journey of..."it's time to question what you want to watch in a K-drama romance." Do you want to watch a RomCom, do you want to follow all the usual tropes? In particular, do you want the childhood friends equal fated lovers for life to be your status quo. Or do you want to explore the reality that, being friends from childhood DOES NOT MEAN, there is a romance in your future.
Those are my thoughts after watching the available 8 episodes of 14.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I read a lot of other rivews and comments and many of them were saying things like "this is what happens in reality" and "that's what the title says" and that may be true in some cases but that's no excuse. There are many dramas that do also show cheating but it is not romanticized like they are doing in this one. The main leads have been togeather for 10 years but they've known eachother and have been friends for almost all their lives and I don't think not feeling a spark or stress about life is really an excuse for cheating or anything the writers really messed up with this one cause as a partner or a friend i dont understand how you could bring yourself to betray someone you've known all your life.And as for the title 'a love other than yours' doesn't necessarily mean there has to be betrayal they could have just kept the breakup in the 1st ep and make it about self growth and finding a new love while trying to grow out of the old one.
Overall i love the casting, the acting was good but couldn't save the story. Episode 1 was the best episode till now.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A complacent relationship
This is actually not a bad series.ML and FL have been together 10 years.
The role of the FL.
The FL is open, honest and shares her ups and downs with the ML.
She is transparent. She takes the criticism of her brothers. She is emotionally intelligent. She loves the ML wholeheartedly.
She showed him every side of her (good and bad)
Her mother wants the ML and FL to get married, but FL feels that the ML has not fully contributed to their relationship emotionally, honestly, and openly. She is also seen as someone her brother's including the ML (although ML doesn't show it) as an indecisive and going nowhere very quickly and depending on the ML.
She does everything to provoke him, to learn another side of the ML. She wants him to get angry, have an argument with her, be jealous,, etc.
Her proposal to date other people had nothing to do about cheating, but to make him understand that he should not see her as a confortable armchair, but a companion who would support him during the good and bad time. Viewers get to learn her true intention in episode 8
She advise him to date the woman who has feelings for him - she doesnt want to feel as if she had wronged him.
Also, she wants him to experience a new world without her in it.
The role of the ML
He is a closed book.
He hides his troubles and emotions from the FL because he only wants to see her happy. (Donating a kidney, giving his aunt money, doung extra work, etc)
He is basically a pushover.
He still sees her as a childhood friend, family, and not really a companion.
She has been around him all these years.
He is already a son to her mother, and a brother to her brother's. They go on family outing together and so on. Why would he noy be part of her world?
She is his safe zone.
He gives in to her every whim because he is afraid of losing her completely (physically and as a friend)
They live opposite each other, and he is not deterred by her proposal to date other people because even if he is not her boyfriend, he would still see her around.
He would be the first one there if she breaks off a relationship with whoever she decides to date. Thats how sure he is.
He would still be a part of her family.
Furthermore, he knows she is trying to provoke, therefore he agrees to whatever she says and without getting upset.
He sees her, as Ive mentioned above, an indecisive person who would get bored if she is not happy with something or said person.
Complacency is what brought them together.
It is a good watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
Not for romcom lovers
I always thought I would write my very first review for a crime thriller drama. Instead, here I am.First 6 eps have so much potential. The drama has the opportunity to only focus on our main leads and their conversations rather than keeping all the secrets and twists until the very end. Communication is the only thing our couple needs but the writer decided to focus on second leads and pile up all important details at the end. And for what?
However, I think the drama wrapped up nicely and how I feel about the ending summed up everything I need to say about this drama: it feels so painful and so wrong, but it also feels right...
If you're ready and eager to watch a complicated relationship between two people, you're in for the treat.
But if you want romcom, this is not for you.
Was this review helpful to you?



