
Gabster:
What is a series that you LOVE, but others have said that it's overrated or that it's bad?
I have a tendency to overlook a lot of flaws for the sake of what I like (especially cuties), or to enjoy BLs which are admittedly trainwrecks because trainwrecks can be strangely fascinating (and to be honest, usually also because of the cuties) - so this could be a long list.
To narrow things down, I looked at my Completed list and see 181 titles that have average MDL ratings of 6.9 or lower.
Some were truly and inexplicably awful, even by my low standards (e.g. "Love Is Like A Cat").
Some of these were reels, which tend to get harsh ratings, often unfairly (e.g. "Crush On You" with Tutor and Yim, probably the first BL vertical I watched - and I loved it!).
Some were interesting or enjoyable for me but I can understand why others didn't like them or gave brutal punishment ratings - in particular: very very hardcore themes (e.g. "Dangerous Drugs of Sex", "Playboy and the Gang of Cherry" or "Grand Guinol"), or underage actors or characters in BLs that probably cross the line in terms of sexual overtones (e.g. "Hit Bite Love", "Sweet Boy" or "Brothers").
But that leaves quite a few regular (non-vertical) series with average MDL ratings below 6.9 that I really liked, despite whatever flaws. I'll pick just four that jump out at me:
"1000 Years Old" (avg MDL: 6.3): Yeah, it's a goofy vampire spoof with a lot of weaknesses, but it's adorably cute and has a great group-of-friends dynamic, catchy music and a surprisingly touching ending. I loved it!
"Tin Tem Jai" (avg MDL: 6.2): Here also, great group-of-friends dynamic and really cute, sweet watch despite some glaring weaknesses. I loved it!
"Blossom Campus" (avg MDL: 6.7): Yeah, the story's not great, the love rival (triangle) didn't really work and felt forced/cliché, and the university campus was bizarrely devoid of students (@Strongberry: Huh? I know you're on a tight budget, but couldn't you have rounded up some extras?). But it had cute/appealing protagists, and despite its flaws, I really enjoyed it!
"Love By Chance S2" (avg MDL: 6.8). By today's standards I'd undoubtedly rate this a lot tougher, but this was among my earliest BLs, so it's nostalgic for me. Yeah, this was (along with "My Bromance S2") one of the worst BL retcons ever (i.e. the incongruities vs. S1), there were a lot of weaknesses and slop in story and execution, and of course, Pete/Saint was missing, leading to Ai/Perth being annoying moping throughout the sequel. But I loved it, most of all because it fixed the biggest problem with "LBC S1", namely the awful way it ended the Tin/Can storyline. It gave me the HEA that I was craving!