1
This is truly not a drama for everyone. I noticed many negative reviews, both about the production and the cast. I had already added it to my watchlist because of Wang Xing Yue, as I really admire his work and the way he brings his characters to life. However, after seeing so many criticisms, I decided to start watching it sooner.
“Sooner” is just a figure of speech, because with a drama that requires so much attention, that is absolutely impossible. And this one definitely does!
The episodes were long, which I greatly appreciated. I really dislike short episodes like those in many Chinese and Korean BL dramas. They often leave me with a feeling of disconnection, emptiness, and not enough time to properly connect with the characters and the story.
In *Revelation: The Jade Wind*, the connection with the characters was excellent—not only with the main leads, but also with the many supporting characters involved in the different cases presented throughout the story. There were several storylines, many mysteries to unravel, many beautifully choreographed fight scenes, and numerous moments of reflection and wonder.
I really enjoyed seeing Xiao Huai Jin (Wang Xing Yue) as a calm and thoughtful astronomer—intelligent, rational, physically weak, and even quite frail at times—yet a perfect counterpart to the impulsive Li Pei Yi (Bai Lu).
I wouldn’t say they were a couple with overwhelming chemistry like the wonderful pair in *Fated Hearts* (Li Qin and Chen Zheyuan). I hope fans forgive me for making this comparison, but I truly dislike when the male character treats his partner like a fragile porcelain doll—barely touching her, offering only quick pecks, and showing almost no real passion.
In my opinion, if someone chooses acting as a profession, they should fully commit to the character they are portraying. That is not to say the actors here did not give their best. On the contrary, their performances were excellent. But the romantic scenes… unfortunately, they left much to be desired. I kept hoping to see at least one more intense moment. Ah!
That small complaint aside, the plot itself was impeccable. For those who enjoy a good criminal investigation, mysteries, and suspense, this drama delivers very well.
Among all the storylines, the one I liked the most was the case involving the former castle maids. As for the resolution of the main case—the murder of Li Pei Yi’s family—it could have been more engaging. I didn’t particularly like how it was concluded, and once again, as happens in many Chinese historical dramas, the king’s character comes across as obtuse and weak, falling far short of what one would expect from the leader of a nation.
Would I recommend it? Yes, absolutely—but mainly for those who have patience and can appreciate a well-developed story despite its slower pacing.
Was this review helpful to you?
I'm waiting for better development in the plot.
Unfortunately, I still haven't been able to connect positively with the drama. I don't see anything different here from the usual Korean dramas of today. The political aspect is the same old greed, and the idiotic villains only change actors. Even worse, the romantic storyline—aside from the couple's chemistry—doesn't captivate me at all.Eun Nam is far from my favorite type of heroine. She's opportunistic, rich, spoiled, and has a gorgeous, devoted man at her feet, yet she's drawn to more and more money... disappointing! Where is her nobility of character?
Park Hyung Sik is a great actor, incredibly handsome and charming, but his character, Seo Dong Ju, despite being intelligent, is emotionally weak. This makes him less appealing in a role that initially seemed vengeful and determined.
I'm waiting for better development in the plot, but for now, just good fight scenes and action aren’t enough to win me over.
Such a shame—I had high hopes for this story.
So… the wait is over! The drama really wasn’t what I expected.
The first thing I felt when I finished the drama was a raw sense of uselessness. I even called myself stupid for insisting on something that hardly captivated me from the beginning.
Then, after cooling off, I thought I was being unfair to myself for disregarding my own effort — and unfair to a great actor like Park Hyung Sik.
At the very least, I felt obligated to share some thoughts about this absolutely confusing production that was *Buried Hearts*.
From the start, I felt this wasn’t a production that could accommodate a romance between the main characters, Dong Ju and EunNan. In fact, in my opinion, EunNan was one of the worst characters in the entire plot — she didn’t even deserve the title of female lead.
From beginning to end, she was bland, ambiguous, and unappealing in her decisions regarding Dong Ju. At no point did she deserve to be by his side — neither as the protagonist nor as the FL character.
The political setting had its ups and downs, but the excess of convoluted family schemes and deceptions was a total turn-off. So many manipulations, so many unresolved entanglements, so many family misunderstandings — it became exhausting.
In the end, many characters entered and exited the plot in na obsolete, meaningless, or completely underdeveloped way. Among them, the unfortunate Ji Seon-Wu, son of Gang-Cheon. I can only assume the producers lost their minds when they gave him such a stupid ending. The kind, gentle young man introduced to us at the beginning suddenly turned into a senseless monster. Saying ambition got to his head doesn’t convince me... where was the character development that justified such a change?
Other characters who entered the story with some promise but led nowhere: the unpleasant daughter Kuk Hee, the mysterious secretary Kong, Dong Ju’s psychologist and his clown-like father, the charming hacker, the president of nothing… among others.
Of course, these are just a few examples, since there were so many unnecessary characters in the drama that I can only assume they were added to fill space or justify part of the production budget.
Even the main villain, Yeon, played by the good veteran actor Heo Jun-Ho, ended up being more laughable than truly threatening. His ending would’ve been far more interesting if they had just kept him locked up in the Daesan vault for life — since his human conscience is clearly unreachable.
Park Hyung Sik was masterful, commanding in both performance and presence. He brought Dong Ju to life like no one else could. For me, his strong presence was the only thing that made the story worthwhile.
It’s not a drama I’ll carry with me. And if they ever create a second season, I’ll happily skip it with no regrets.
I’m glad it’s over — life is too short and too precious… no one should waste 16 hours and 20 minutes on this.
It’s not a drama I would recommend to anyone I care about.
Was this review helpful to you?
Modern, dynamic, and very well executed.
Excellent entertainment.Congratulations to Taiwan for this outstanding production in collaboration with Netflix. I watched all eight episodes in one sitting — the story is that engaging and compelling.
The casting was an excellent choice, the script consistently strong, and the direction sharp and intelligent. Everything works in harmony to sustain the tension and maintain the viewer’s interest without losing narrative coherence.
If you enjoy investigative dramas filled with action, featuring young protagonists and intriguingly crafted killers, this series is certainly worth your time.
Modern, dynamic, and very well executed.
I truly enjoyed it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Laughable!
Honestly, one of the worst dramas of the year.I’m forcing myself to keep watching it for Cheng Yi and a few other actors in the cast, but it’s really hard to endure such a poorly written and badly produced show.
The CGI is downright nauseating—absolutely terrible.
The only redeeming quality of this drama is the costume design and its stunning use of vibrant colors.
I’m currently on episode 25, but as one fellow MDL user perfectly put it, it feels like I’m watching a story made by a teenager, with zero maturity for a project like this.
Laughable, seriously!
I admit I skipped a few parts. Honestly, I couldn’t endure so much mediocrity. But I did finish this tragic excuse for a drama.
I saw that some viewers felt deceived by the plot and the ending. I didn’t feel that way — halfway through the story, I already knew exactly what awaited me.
My biggest disappointment is Cheng Yi. As one fellow viewer perfectly put it, it felt as though he were merely watching his own character from the sidelines. A caricatured face, an empty expression, and a complete lack of emotion or engagement — as if he were simply finishing a dull, joyless task.
I wouldn’t recommend this to anyone who appreciates quality productions. Unfortunately, not even Cheng Yi makes it worth watching.
Was this review helpful to you?
I loved every ill-fated step, every stumble at the gate, every door slammed in the face.
I'm always in a dilemma about how to start writing when everything I say may seem insufficient to express the greatness of a drama. A drama whose complexity and level involves an approach that is almost impossible to edit... there are so many nuances, so many facets, so many striking points that, sometimes, all I can think of are the countless moments in which I found myself moved by its beauty. Therefore, before focusing a little on the story, I must start by saying why I chose to watch it: I love mystery, I love romance, I love criminal investigation, I love daring and I love a good production. This drama has all of this and much more than my meager review property allows. Stunning photography and immersive cinematography in every detail: from the song of a bird, the nakedness of a fruit tree, the croak of a frog, even a drop of sweat. A color palette that deviates from the traditional, but warms you from within, whether in the vibrancy conveyed by the glow of fireworks, the bright gray of sidewalks wet from the rain, or the darkness of a bath in the lake under the moonlight. An alternation that goes from black and white to multifaceted and vibrant colors silences us, on the other hand, it makes our soul scream in scenes of pain, passion and despair. A drama whose metaphors go beyond the figurative sense, being able to use a song instead of a final scene, a look instead of words, a slap instead of a kiss. A “hurt me” instead of “love me” is indeed impressive. A drama that works extremes with mastery. From faithful and touching friendship to extreme humiliation, from gratuitous companionship to irrational public ridicule. From the calm and the ride on a rudimentary boat to the cold torture of an interrogation chair. Intense script, striking dialogues and unforgettable characters give a tender light to what we see here. Zhou Luo is a unique young man. Imperfect in several layers, but full in his convictions. Mature for the age counted in years, immature in the vicissitudes of unilateral love. But bold, persecutive and insistent on his personal desires. This generates disagreements among the public accustomed to admiring a traditional hero. The boldness is above the expected average, above what is permitted, above what is considered normal... I confess, I loved it! And yes, I was saddened by how many people took it so negatively. I guess bursts of youthful passion aren't for everyone. Few understand that this is how emotional maturity is achieved. How else do you achieve fulfillment or learn to live? I loved every ill-fated step, every stumble at the gate, every door slammed in the face. Each true lie and of course the cruel and painful love achieved. I think that the emotional charge of each viewer can make a difference in the evaluation of this masterpiece... what I see differs from what others see, what I feel is far from what others feel. But, on one point, I believe it's easier to agree: Tender Light goes beyond a drama, it's a work of art! I admired the result, but I would have liked more screen time. Even if loose ends are not part of this drama, I would exchange the beautiful music at the end for a long, beautiful tight hug. I recommend it wholeheartedly! Simply exceptional!Was this review helpful to you?
Intense, Brutal...
Intense!Brutal... absolutely devastating!
But, a great source of entertainment. There’s no denying that.
I liked the casting choices... I loved everyone's performance.
Don’t get caught up in prejudices—the story is heavy, but compelling.
I loved Kang Hoon’s character: intense without losing tenderness.
I loved Park Jun Hyun’s character: brutal without losing hope.
I hated Park Yong Woo’s character: monstrous, yet overflowing with talent.
Don’t miss the chance. It will definitely pull you in from beginning to end.
Really good, seriously!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I am not aiming to write a full review at this point, but rather to make a strong recommendation —
I had planned to wait until the finale to share my thoughts on this series, but it is so exceptional — and at the same time so underrated — that I felt compelled to write something now.With three episodes left before its conclusion, **Silent Truth** continues to surprise me.
I have always been passionate about well-crafted thrillers and stories that truly know how to unfold their narrative. Here, we have one of the finest Japanese suspense dramas currently on air. Thankfully, Netflix secured the streaming rights, allowing us to experience the production in its highest quality.
I am not aiming to write a full review at this point, but rather to make a strong recommendation — a sincere and enthusiastic one.
If you appreciate suspense, psychological tension, high production value, and actors delivering truly remarkable performances, then this is a drama you simply cannot miss.
17/03/26
The End
Unfortunately, the ending did not match the reality that the story had conveyed. Junichi’s ending with Makiko was a cold splash of water on such a well-crafted plot.
It could have been much better if the story had a happy yet realistic ending.
I still recommend the series, but not with the same enthusiasm as at the beginning.
Sorry, folks.
Was this review helpful to you?
I take my hat off. Ten out of ten feels far too little. Brilliant.
Watching *This Thriving Land* feels like stepping out of a warm shower and plunging into the deep, cold waters of a lake.So often we are immersed in the polished, ornamental worlds of most C- or K-dramas. Here, however, we are struck by the raw and unadorned presence of characters—beautiful in the plain fullness of life in an agricultural land of the 1920s and 1930s.
The story begins in 1986 with Madam Xiu Xiu, recalling a past that started in the fifteenth year of the Chinese Republic (1926). On what should have been the happiest day of her life—her marriage to her childhood sweetheart, Fei WenDian—Xiu Xiu, daughter of a wealthy farmer and landowner, is kidnapped by bandits. Her father, Ning Xue Xiang, unwilling to ransom her at the cost of his fields, offers his younger daughter in marriage to Fei WenDian, hoping to buy time.
Deceived by his sister-in-law, another wealthy landowner, and misled by his bride’s father who withholds the truth, Fei WenDian ends up marrying Su Su, for whom he has no affection.
On the verge of disgrace, Xiu Xiu is rescued by DaJiao, a childhood friend who, unknown to her, has long harbored a quiet love. Shattered by her father’s betrayal and abandoned by relatives and her former fiancé’s family, Xiu Xiu consents to a hastily arranged marriage with DaJiao. She cuts all ties with her family and vows never to forgive her father’s lack of love.
So begins her saga of life in the countryside. Coming from wealth, she now faces poverty, hardship, and the harshness of tenant farming. Yet in this unforgiving world of hunger and toil, she also discovers the strength of friendship, the gentleness of a companion, and the profound love for the land itself.
Some viewers may find the story slow at times. But the richness of detail, the careful construction of the characters, and the depth of their intertwined lives deserved to be told fully. To shorten it would have been to diminish its power.
Across more than fifty years of reminiscences, Xiu Xiu carries us through China’s cultural and political transformation—from the Republican era to a Communist society.
Through economic crises, the Japanese invasion, cultural clashes, generational conflicts, personal sacrifices, hunger, grief, and natural disasters, the drama reveals countless changes. Minds shift, forgiveness takes root, lives are born and lost, and the cycle continues.
Among the countless Chinese dramas produced every year, *This Thriving Land* stands out. For me, it is a strong contender for the 2025 awards, meeting every requirement with ease.
A cohesive script, strong direction, brilliant performances, magnificent cinematography, and flawless makeup. The entire cast was excellent, but my special admiration goes to the senior actors—Ni Da Hong as Ning Xue Xiang, Xiu Xiu’s father, and Lin Yong Jian as Feng Er, DaJiao’s father—both of whom were extraordinary.
This is a drama filled with emotion, with a powerful beginning, a compelling middle, and a transformative ending. It moved me deeply at every step.
I discovered it almost by chance, while reading about another show, and learned that *This Thriving Land* was the most-watched drama in China. I found it fascinating that some stories can be so beloved at home and yet remain almost unpublicized abroad. Perhaps some works are so intimately woven into the fabric of a people that they are kept close, like a treasure of the heart.
Still, the world deserves to see this other side of China.
I must admit, my own perspective changed. I carry a new kind of affection after watching it.
It is not a casual drama, nor is it for everyone. But it is necessary for life. It gives new meaning to everything.
I take my hat off. Ten out of ten feels far too little. Brilliant.
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the Most Unjustly Underestimated Dramas I’ve Ever Seen…
I started this drama based on a recommendation from someone I follow on MDL. The theme has always been one of my favorites, but I must admit that I was completely taken by surprise. *Under the Moonlight* goes far beyond any single theme—it is, in every sense, brilliant.It consists of 36 episodes that felt like 100. But not in a bad way—far from it! Each episode was so captivating, so well executed, that I often felt like I was inside the story, experiencing every little detail of this exceptional work.
I wasn’t familiar with any of the actors, yet I found myself completely enchanted by every single character, as if they were old friends or long-lost relatives.
The storytelling is simple, the dialogues easy to follow, yet each character carries an entire universe within them. And we, on this side of the screen, are left to navigate a whirlwind of conflicting emotions. Characters we initially view with suspicion end up winning our hearts, while others who first seem wonderful make us wish we never had to see them again as the story unfolds. But of course, that’s just wishful thinking—the emotional turmoil lasts almost until the very end.
Luo Shu, our main protagonist, is brilliantly portrayed by Hu Bing Qing. She embodies determination and independence from start to finish. I immediately connected with her strong, resilient, and fair personality, even as she was cruelly marginalized. I must confess—I completely fell in love with her sharp gaze, her modest yet stunning and captivating attire. It was fascinating to see how a woman can be incredibly alluring without revealing anything beyond her face. She was, without a doubt, mesmerizing.
Qi Meng Lin, the spoiled rich boy, was brought to life with absolute mastery by Zhai Zi Lu—another actor I wasn’t familiar with, but whom I quickly grew to love. Funny, immature, with a kind of naive arrogance, yet soft-hearted when it comes to protecting women and fulfilling his ten humanitarian deeds. His eccentric nature made me laugh, and more than that, it gave a fresh and unexpected touch to the male lead role. I may not know his other works, but in this one, I adored him.
And of course, there’s Magistrate Han Mu Zhi, whose greatest love has always been his honor. Although he fell for Luo Shu, he never truly chose her above his duty. His devotion to his profession and the people under his care defined him. A noble and charismatic character who wins us over with his integrity.
With a compelling script, outstanding performances, and characters that make us laugh, suffer, and root for them, *Under the Moonlight* has become one of my favorite dramas of the year so far. The simplicity of the production was enriched by breathtaking costumes, stunning accessories, and well-executed action scenes—subtle yet deeply realistic and moving.
The only thing that saddened me was how little recognition this drama has received. It’s heartbreaking that such an outstanding production has gone so unnoticed.
I wholeheartedly recommend it—I loved every second!
Was this review helpful to you?
Self-Sacrifice Left a Bitter Taste
I often say that I enjoy dramas as much as I enjoy reading reviews about them. There’s nothing like different opinions to broaden our perspective.
Unfortunately, this time, I found myself in a painful dilemma. The discrepancies and divergences in opinions about *Moonlight Mystique* among viewers, instead of providing direction, often left me feeling unbalanced.
To put it another way, the drama was either deeply loved or intensely hated. Balanced or middle-ground opinions were rare.
Even though I watched the drama sequentially—pausing others I was following—I place myself in the smaller group, meaning the middle ground.
Starting with the episode openings, I agree that there was poor direction in the editing of the scenes. Impactful moments, accompanied by captions, ended up spoiling the element of surprise in many episodes.
Another major flaw in the editing was the use of the same OST in intense scenes. Although it was a pleasant piece of music, it became tiresome due to its excessive repetition in nearly all the scenes—and worse, in every single episode.
The vibrant color palette that bothered some of my peers was not unpleasant to my eyes. The deep green, the vivid red, and the striking purple and lilac captivated me. Unfortunately, I can't say the same for the three main clans. Both the Ye clan, from Lady Xing Yue, and the Demon Lord, Jing Yuan, as well as Yin, from Lord Mo Li, were dull, extremely tacky, seemingly low-budget, and lacking in quality.
On the other hand, some clans were stunning, such as the fox clan and its love tree.
The male costumes were absolutely impeccable. The imposing garments, in exceptional colors, were always perfectly matched with the hair accessories. Rui Peng, both as Fan Yue and as Jing Yuan, looked brilliant.
The female costumes also seemed very beautiful to me, though the excessively heavy makeup left much to be desired in several aspects. Not even Bai Lu’s beauty could compensate for this oversight by the makeup artists.
The script, though heavily criticized by many, had several arcs that I enjoyed. There were emotional, delicate, and even quite controversial moments.
The deeply rooted self-sacrifice in this drama left a bitter taste for many life philosophies. There were so many deaths that, at times, I wondered whether there would be enough characters left to carry out the story’s conclusion.
Seen from another perspective, this significantly reduced the participation of strong characters whose potential could have been better utilized until the end. If there is one major flaw in this drama that I must highlight, it would be this.
Although the narrative wasn’t the best, the cast’s performance was very good. If there were flaws, repetitive and unnecessary moments—such as the countless times Fan Yue fainted and revived or was an excessively sweet and weak demon in front of Bai Shuo—we should blame the execution, not the actors.
Within the demands placed upon them, each did their part.
In the end, a classic Xianxia—romantic and quite enjoyable to follow. I recommend it to fans of the genre and suggest preparing for the collateral losses.
A good, serious drama!
Was this review helpful to you?
Khemjira is an interesting drama, but one with considerable flaws in editing and execution.
Khemjira is a mystical BL drama with a distinctive historical premise, yet quite uneven in its overall execution. To begin with, its story holds great potential for strong development. Culturally engaging and rooted in Thai traditions, it becomes a true gem that is hard not to admire.For fans of the supernatural genre—reincarnation, spiritual possession, past lives, and ancient mystical deities—*Khemjira* offers an appealing dish that certainly deserves to be tasted.
Another important point that cannot go unmentioned is the commitment of the entire team to delivering a quality production. This is especially evident in the behind-the-scenes footage shown after each episode.
Unfortunately, in my view, this is where the best aspects of the drama end. I watched it until the very end mainly because of the story itself and, above all, the second couple, Chan and Jet. They completely stole the spotlight from the main protagonists.
With strong performances and chemistry that clearly extends beyond the screen, FirstOne and Tle Matimun portrayed Jet and Chan with mastery, charisma, and that lingering feeling of “wanting more.” Truly beautiful to watch.
On the other hand, the character who should have been the center of attention—Khemjira himself, portrayed by Namping—was a disappointment. Perhaps due to his young age and lack of experience, perhaps because of the way the director shaped his character, or perhaps due to his effeminate mannerisms, he failed to convey sympathy, emotional connection, charisma, or compelling chemistry.
A weak character, overly dependent on others, with an apathetic face and empty or unconvincing expressions, was undoubtedly the worst possible choice for carrying this drama.
His almost nonexistent chemistry with the handsome actor Keng Harit was a missed opportunity. Although Harit himself did not deliver a particularly strong performance—especially considering his potential—his presence in the mildly intimate scenes was appealing. Unfortunately, it simply did not work alongside Namping.
Given Thailand’s tendency to repeatedly pair the same actors across different dramas, I sincerely hope this does not happen with Harit and Namping. Otherwise, their career growth and long-term success could be compromised.
I understand that many viewers may appreciate this casting choice. I do not. Effeminate actors in BL dramas do not appeal to me. My apologies to the fans. That said, my heart remains open—perhaps one day a character like this will win me over.
In conclusion, Khemjira is an interesting drama, but one with considerable flaws in editing and execution. The episodes are excessively long, with oddly paced and unnatural dialogue. Some scenes even become unintentionally comical, with characters staring at each other, seemingly unsure of what to say or how to continue, simply waiting for the “cut” signal.
Do I recommend it? Yes—especially for the secondary couple.
Was this review helpful to you?
Surprising? Not really. The beginning is actually very good.
A drama that promised a lot... seriously! The first episodes were remarkable.Despite the usual clichés—gender swap, a male lead from another clan, a love triangle, and more—Everlasting Longing promised a touching and interesting story, especially with actors well-loved by the audience.
So, unsurprisingly, I fell for the trap.
Surprising? Not really. The beginning is actually very good.
However, unfortunately, our protagonist, Jun Qi Luo, is the type of woman who was born to live alone.
And look, maybe her femininity was one of nature’s few mistakes. Cold, calculating, determined, with her family and nationality above any feelings of love. Angelababy was perfect for the role. Except for the lack of emotional involvement with the ever-devoted male lead, Xuan Lie. Honestly, I felt sorry for the actor/character. I understand this was a production choice, but making him a doormat for the entire drama was just bad.
Jun Qi Luo did everything she wanted. I accepted almost everything, out of love for the character. But the ending? No. The decision about the family was my breaking point—I hated it, hated it, hated it… absolutely awful!
Do you want to watch this drama? Then go ahead. I did. I don’t regret it. But I hated, with all my might, both kings (they both deserved a very different ending), Angelababy’s character, and the fates of Qi Min and the princess (they were both so cute and important to the story—despite controversial opinions, I loved them).
But if, for some reason, you give up halfway through, I’ll applaud you, because the ending is, without a doubt, the worst part.
Thirty episodes… don’t waste your time. There’s much better stuff out there… sorry!
Was this review helpful to you?
Um refresco nas mesmices
Tirando alguns buracos na conclusão de cada personagem e o vilão um tanto quanto fraco, adorei acompanhar este drama.Ando tão saturada das mesmices nos dramas coreanos que senti um verdadeiro refresco com esta história.
Amei o elenco. Os protas foram divinos. Não conhecia Wei Zhe Ming, mas me apaixonei logo de cara. Além de lindo, um ótimo ator. Vou adorar revê-lo em outro drama, aliás já estou com dois na lista para assistir. Sol Qian também foi maravilhosa. Ótima performance e ótima química com Wei.
Além dos protas o elenco de apoio também foi legal. Em especial meu lindo Bai Shu. Muito fofo em tudo que faz.
Vi inúmeras reclamações sobre enrolação e queda no interesse nos últimos episódios. Confesso que curti cada momento e vou sentir saudades. Se tivesse mais jogos seria ainda melhor, mas a parte humana da história foi muito relevante e muito me encantou.
Parabéns China! Muito boa produção!
Was this review helpful to you?
I have a feeling my Wednesdays will take a while to feel as captivating again
It has been quite some time since a Korean drama truly captured my attention, except for a few rare exceptions. The Manipulated was one of those rare moments.Ji Chang Wook is a fully accomplished actor—this is an undeniable fact. With a strong supporting cast, a renowned screenwriter like Oh Sang Ho, and a high-budget production, there was little room for failure.
This is an intense drama, emotionally stirring at various points, with a brilliant beginning, a tense middle, and a very satisfying ending. I have a feeling my Wednesdays will take a while to feel as captivating again.
The fight scenes were so stunning that I often found myself covering my eyes out of sheer immersion. The visual effects were so impeccable that, at times, I even wondered if they could teach Chinese productions what real blood is supposed to look like—though I acknowledge the comparison may sound humorous. Of course, this does not apply to many Chinese dramas, nor does it justify praising one production by belittling another.
The Manipulated has more than enough merit to stand firmly on its own.
My only reservation regarding many of the comments I read after the finale is that I disagree with the interpretation of the ending as something definitive.
Everything suggests that the story will continue. And if that is the case, I will certainly look forward to the opportunity to appreciate this outstanding production once again.
An excellent and engaging watch.
Note: I only refrained from giving it the highest rating because a few aspects left me slightly unsatisfied. The elderly blind housekeeper, the ailing mother of the main psychopath, deserved a more conclusive ending, and the insecure, doubtful fiancée—who chose not to believe in or wait for Park Tae Jung—should have at least made an appearance in the finale, even if only to die of frustration.
Was this review helpful to you?
Reflection on the eyes that oversee human justice.
I considered Ripe Town one of the most difficult and complex dramas I have ever watched.Unlike the usual revenge dramas, this one presents us with a tangled story of controversial characters, leading us to experience countless different emotions.
I was surprised throughout the development of the plot and, I confess, there were many moments when I found myself confused, with recurring doubts—even about which characters the scene was focusing on.
The historical period in which the story takes place transports us to a dark world full of nuances, whether in customs, the unscrupulous application of justice, or the ambiguous nature of most characters.
This is not a story about heroes, much less a drama that makes us sympathize with the wronged and, in turn, rally behind their vengeful cause. It is, above all, a story with raw characters—human in their essence, prone to mistakes, missteps, weaknesses, good feelings, or, in some cases, absolute cruelty.
In a story without heroes, at the very least, we must appreciate the expertise and creativity of the criminals. Every crime was meticulously crafted, and even though they occur in different time periods, they were seamlessly tied to the present moment of the avenger.
Ripe Town is a drama that captivated me with its persistence and the desire to unravel so many mysteries. The translation in the version I watched left much to be desired, perhaps due to the complexity of the period's dialogues, which, in fact, made it harder for me to fully appreciate the overall context.
Despite my difficulty in fully grasping the work as it deserves, I really enjoyed the production.
It is not a drama for everyone, but it will appeal to viewers who appreciate a good mystery and a deep reflection on the eyes that oversee human justice.
I loved it!
Was this review helpful to you?
