So in your theory someone else killed Puifai and the serial killer aka Jay is taking revenge on the whole group?…
Yeah, I know my theory has loopholes and might not be right, but there are a few things about Jay that really stand out to me. He always seems to know whatās going on with his friendsālike with Tonkla and Bellāand even after all these murders, heās unusually calm. He doesnāt really show fear the way youād expect. What makes it even more interesting is that Jade and Kamin donāt suspect him at all, mostly because heās Jadeās brother. And honestly, after watching so many thriller K-dramas and C-dramas, Iāve learned that the person closest to the protagonist, the one who seems too innocent or gets overlooked, often turns out to be the real killer. So yeah, my theory might be flawed, but Jay being completely off everyoneās radar is exactly what makes him suspicious to me.
I think that is because Tonkla chose dare and on the dare carte he had to choose btw Belle or Chareen and he chose…
Yeah, and thatās why Kamin suspected Tonklaāhe thought Tonkla was hiding the Dare card. But in reality, Tonkla actually chose that card, and that choice led to Bellās death.
1 
1 
What makes it even more interesting is that Jade and Kamin donāt suspect him at all, mostly because heās Jadeās brother. And honestly, after watching so many thriller K-dramas and C-dramas, Iāve learned that the person closest to the protagonist, the one who seems too innocent or gets overlooked, often turns out to be the real killer.
So yeah, my theory might be flawed, but Jay being completely off everyoneās radar is exactly what makes him suspicious to me.