So in your theory someone else killed Puifai and the serial killer aka Jay is taking revenge on the whole group?…
Yeah, I know my theory has loopholes and might not be right, but there are a few things about Jay that really stand out to me. He always seems to know what’s going on with his friends—like with Tonkla and Bell—and even after all these murders, he’s unusually calm. He doesn’t really show fear the way you’d expect. What makes it even more interesting is that Jade and Kamin don’t suspect him at all, mostly because he’s Jade’s brother. And honestly, after watching so many thriller K-dramas and C-dramas, I’ve learned that the person closest to the protagonist, the one who seems too innocent or gets overlooked, often turns out to be the real killer. So yeah, my theory might be flawed, but Jay being completely off everyone’s radar is exactly what makes him suspicious to me.
I think that is because Tonkla chose dare and on the dare carte he had to choose btw Belle or Chareen and he chose…
Yeah, and that’s why Kamin suspected Tonkla—he thought Tonkla was hiding the Dare card. But in reality, Tonkla actually chose that card, and that choice led to Bell’s death.
So in your theory someone else killed Puifai and the serial killer aka Jay is taking revenge on the whole group?…
Yeah, that’s why I’m leaning toward the idea that there might be two killers — one who killed Puifai, and another who’s taking revenge for Puifai. I know Kamin and Jade believe Puifai also received the Truth/Dare letter, but so far we don’t actually know if that’s true. If it turns out she did get the letter, then this theory obviously falls apart. But if she didn’t, then I really think two murderers is possible. Especially since the masked killer always asks questions related to Puifai before killing their victims — like with Bell and Tar. For now, I’m sticking with this theory until we get more evidence in the upcoming episodes.
What if Jay is the serial killer and he used to like Puifai but never got to confess his feelings to her. He knew what ever happened to her, all the injustices and is taking revenge .
1 
1 
What makes it even more interesting is that Jade and Kamin don’t suspect him at all, mostly because he’s Jade’s brother. And honestly, after watching so many thriller K-dramas and C-dramas, I’ve learned that the person closest to the protagonist, the one who seems too innocent or gets overlooked, often turns out to be the real killer.
So yeah, my theory might be flawed, but Jay being completely off everyone’s radar is exactly what makes him suspicious to me.
If it turns out she did get the letter, then this theory obviously falls apart. But if she didn’t, then I really think two murderers is possible. Especially since the masked killer always asks questions related to Puifai before killing their victims — like with Bell and Tar.
For now, I’m sticking with this theory until we get more evidence in the upcoming episodes.