Please bare with me! Just trying to get my thoughts and theory out there. Sorry for the long read! This theory probably has loopholes 😅 but oh well!
Okay so here it goes!
Cha Se Gye is the eclipse and Shin So Ri is the comet traveling across time and space. The show references that the comet stayed in the sky for 2 months. Calling it the "Herald of a villainess who brings disaster". Insinuating
If 2 months have passed in the modern day, then that could be indication that its time for her to go back.
Right as she's executed there's frost/snow in the middle of the summer instead of rain. Which is a bad omen. My guess is that they save her and she's been in a coma the entire time.
The Shamen that she meets in 2026 tells her that she specifically time travelled. And that it wasn't a body possession. Meaning Kang Dan Sim and Shin So Ri are one and the same. Just like Cha Se Gye and the Crown Prince are one and the same.
I guess it might be time for Kang Dan Sim to go back and make all of the wrongs right. And then eventually return back to the modern time. Since when she visits the history museum, records have it that she was still excecuted. BUT HERE IS THE TWIST. The women she meets at the history museum tell her that theres the official history records. But then theres the UNOFFICIAL records. My guess is that beck in Joseon, Kang Dan Sim's execution was just pretense! I'm guessing that the some people in the government - the Shamen included - didn't like the King and so they colluded together to fake giving Kang Dan Sim 'poison' and save her and eventually overthrow the King! And we'll see the same happening in 2026 with Choi Mun Do! People in the company bringing him down!
I'm also inclined to belive that the Crown Prince was in cahoots with the Shamen and other people that save Kang Dan Sim and that both the Crown Prince and Kang Dan Sim bring the King down together. But this all happens in the shadows! Thats why there's no official records of what truly happened with Kang Dan Sim.
We actually don't know their ending in the Joseon era because its as Cha Se Gue's doctors tells him. Rather than the 'past' it might be a parallel timeline? Both timelines happening in papallel, 300 years a part. Both happening while the Eclipse and Comet phenomenon is happening! Maybe JUST MAYBE, the Crown prince and Kang Dan Sim both might die in Joseon era and Kang Dan Sim comes back to 2026 and she and Cha Se Gye live happely ever after - with Cha Se Gye having remembered everything from the Joseon era?
Let me know you thoughts and theories! I love reading them.
WOAH. I have been watching K-Dramas for a long time but I only just found out that they sell the script books…
I have only ever gotten the Lovely Runner and it was ~$100 CAD. I feel like that's way less than what people spend on KPop merch and that makes me feel a little better 😅
Ho Su definitely had/has feelings for Mi Ji and knows its her pretending to be Mi Rae.
The picture that Ho Su's mom puts out is an indication of that. He held on to thst picture cus of Mi Ji.
100% one of them still has that Seoul book that Mi Ji asked Ho Su to fill out. My best guess is that Ho Su still has it.
We still haven't seen how they became friends either. Ho Su went from not talking and wanting to be near Mi Ji to pretending to study so he can keep her company while her entire family is in Seoul for Mi Rae.
We've yet to see Mi Rae's POV. Which I think its probably depressing. Always being at the hospital means she probably has a hard time making friends. She was also probably pressured a lot to do good in school to make up for Mi Ji lacking in that area.
It's was an okay show. Kind of expected better from LDW to be honest. Hes been giving such great performances the past 3-4 years. Felt like this show didn't use any of the actor's potential.
Loving this show this thus far. Especially, the actors playing the younger version of the ML and FL. Their chemistry is great. Hope to see them in more shows 🫶🫶🫶
1 
Okay so here it goes!
Cha Se Gye is the eclipse and Shin So Ri is the comet traveling across time and space. The show references that the comet stayed in the sky for 2 months. Calling it the "Herald of a villainess who brings disaster". Insinuating
If 2 months have passed in the modern day, then that could be indication that its time for her to go back.
Right as she's executed there's frost/snow in the middle of the summer instead of rain. Which is a bad omen. My guess is that they save her and she's been in a coma the entire time.
The Shamen that she meets in 2026 tells her that she specifically time travelled. And that it wasn't a body possession. Meaning Kang Dan Sim and Shin So Ri are one and the same. Just like Cha Se Gye and the Crown Prince are one and the same.
I guess it might be time for Kang Dan Sim to go back and make all of the wrongs right. And then eventually return back to the modern time. Since when she visits the history museum, records have it that she was still excecuted. BUT HERE IS THE TWIST. The women she meets at the history museum tell her that theres the official history records. But then theres the UNOFFICIAL records. My guess is that beck in Joseon, Kang Dan Sim's execution was just pretense! I'm guessing that the some people in the government - the Shamen included - didn't like the King and so they colluded together to fake giving Kang Dan Sim 'poison' and save her and eventually overthrow the King! And we'll see the same happening in 2026 with Choi Mun Do! People in the company bringing him down!
I'm also inclined to belive that the Crown Prince was in cahoots with the Shamen and other people that save Kang Dan Sim and that both the Crown Prince and Kang Dan Sim bring the King down together. But this all happens in the shadows! Thats why there's no official records of what truly happened with Kang Dan Sim.
We actually don't know their ending in the Joseon era because its as Cha Se Gue's doctors tells him. Rather than the 'past' it might be a parallel timeline? Both timelines happening in papallel, 300 years a part. Both happening while the Eclipse and Comet phenomenon is happening! Maybe JUST MAYBE, the Crown prince and Kang Dan Sim both might die in Joseon era and Kang Dan Sim comes back to 2026 and she and Cha Se Gye live happely ever after - with Cha Se Gye having remembered everything from the Joseon era?
Let me know you thoughts and theories! I love reading them.
The picture that Ho Su's mom puts out is an indication of that. He held on to thst picture cus of Mi Ji.
100% one of them still has that Seoul book that Mi Ji asked Ho Su to fill out. My best guess is that Ho Su still has it.
We still haven't seen how they became friends either. Ho Su went from not talking and wanting to be near Mi Ji to pretending to study so he can keep her company while her entire family is in Seoul for Mi Rae.
We've yet to see Mi Rae's POV. Which I think its probably depressing. Always being at the hospital means she probably has a hard time making friends. She was also probably pressured a lot to do good in school to make up for Mi Ji lacking in that area.
Absolutely loved JSM in Alchemy of Souls, great to see her back 🫶🙌