News This review may contain spoilers
Missed opportunity to bank on Nanwu trilogy magic.
This Nanwu #3 drama is quite flawed, although watchable for the leads fans and perhaps for patient audience willing to overlook excruciating "slow burn" with inconsistencies, some unwelcome tropes (anxiety pill popping, controlling dad, controlling brother...) and fillers (Feifei episodes + secondary romances). WIMTM is not touted as "healing romance" unlike many others, but I also frown on author's leaning into "mentally flawed" characters who somehow would be "cured by love" only. It is indeed dangerous - one reason why I too did not like fully The First Frost (Nanwu #2).
When I Meet The Moon is so strewn with tropes and references to the first stories that it cannot totally be disentangled from the other two dramas : the story -again- uses as plot devices folded paper (stars, origami moon or half moon, strips of paper with messages) ; strawberries ; "shy" girl suddenly rising to "defend" her man from perceived stalker (although in the original story Sang Zhi was not shy and the stalker was a real weirdo), drunk girl piggyback carrying. There are explicit mentions of the "Overtime" bar and Sang Yan + Sang Zhi in dialogues....
Both Nanwu#1 and Nanwu#3 were shot in Xiamen with local buildings posing as "Nanwu" and "Yihe" in first one, and "Nanwu" and "Xifu" in the present dramatization. Nanwu#1 (Hidden Love - the only drama I really liked in the trilogy)) got credited for starting the drama pilgrimage trend, becoming tied to tourism industry! Production of WIMTM also banked on this : location fans started compiling the spots shown. where audience could discover some views of Xiamen, such as the spectacular one used for EAW exteriors and atrium,in early episodes and finale, or Waldorf Astoria Xiamen (厦门华尔道夫酒店), with its signature doors in final episode .
While some B-Roll Transition Shots were collected from elsewhere for "atmosphere", such as , in ep.27 :
* the Shanghai Film Academy beginning (which has no connection with the shoot), and
* the sweeping glass and steel "skirts" of Shanghai's flagship artificial intelligence and tech hub Shanghai West Bund International AI Tower & Plaza (上海西岸国际人工智能中心), located in Shanghai's Xuhui District along the Huangpu River, on the redeveloped site of the former Shanghai Longhua Airport.
* the Xinhee Design Center (欣贺研发设计中心), designed by by the renowned firm MAD Architects): a striking building which is the headquarters and R&D center for the fashion group Xinhee Co., Ltd. left and center canopies display "追光号3.0" (Light Chaser 3.0)—the flagship VR/tech product developed by Fu Shize's team—while the right canopy shows the "EAW" corporate logo. In the story, this building serves as the headquarters for EAW, the tech company where Yun Li goes for a work trip and product launch in Episode 27. The production crew filmed on location at the Xinhee Design Center in Xiamen and used visual effects (CGI) to project glowing blue holographic graphics onto the building's translucent white canopies.
But I eye-rolled too much in many of the too slow paced and last episodes to give that Nanwu final drama a good rating - this although I am lenient, and always considerate of actors work. The story/script was too expected, not well sewn together. The FL character Yun Li (played by Lu Yiuxiao) with her too often wide eyes stares at ML (even when driving : not focusing on road ahead!!! what was director doing!) became, in my mind, a terribly selfish and cold character. So many inconsistencies : after at last moving in with her boyfriend, she looked outraged that Yu Shize (played by Lin Yi) emerged from the shower in a bathrobe and she demanded he get "properly dressed" (shortly after having been almost crawling over body and face of guy when he was asleep on a couch). The latte-art and sugar-laden rolls as breakfast brought in for a guy who lived on Americanos and whiskey... When Yun Li rushed to fly away back to Nanwu (to watch her brother being operated on), she did not even try to get news from the company,to find out why Fu Shize did not answer her calls and messages, only assumed he was deserting and dumping her! She could not care less if her so-called lover was perhaps -as he was- almost dying alone in hospital (she even demanded a breakup and went to collect her things at their Xifu apartment while he was still in hospital) ! Big inconsistencies....
Also: the very annoying side "love stories" of "fiery" Tang Lin friend (played by Lu Yangyang) and skateboard lover Fu Zhenchu (played by Li Geyang) ; and "wimpy" brother Yun Ye (Zhao Penghao) with his school crush...
No. that and more ruined all the lingering shreds of goodwill for the female character from me. Such a girlfriend who complained about lack of communication but was herself not attentive I don't know how Lu Yuxiao did not realize how bad this came out, with her often too slow speech pattern from reluctance rather than sincerity. The occasional shy micro expressions became cutesy and forced. Even the occasional sweet finger twining during courtship did not redeem it. Yun Li, did not deserve someone devoted to her; Now both Fu men there turned out more wimp and moron than bright to accept anything from their selfish bitch girlfriends. The digital twin ended up as very underwhelming and the cloying pink fake skies and flowers for thee proposal at VR center was met with fake-feeling surprise. Lack of believable chemistry, tech misused. What a finale, sigh (but we were spared wedding and banquet with the controlling dad, absent Fu elders, and annoying sidekicks)...
Sorry for Lin Yi and Lu Yuxiao to have been participating in the mess. Director and screenwriter are not innocent, but the story was not good in first place (I dropped the book quickly from sheer boredom - Hidden Love novel was not perfect but this one is a syrupy and cloying one) The story was, far from the youth misunderstandings one (2006 The Left Ear) which may have "inspired" the author since she too depicted here (novel version from 2022) a semi handicapped, deaf in left ear character. But what was acceptable then became an additional unwelcome trope in WIMTM.
When I Meet The Moon is so strewn with tropes and references to the first stories that it cannot totally be disentangled from the other two dramas : the story -again- uses as plot devices folded paper (stars, origami moon or half moon, strips of paper with messages) ; strawberries ; "shy" girl suddenly rising to "defend" her man from perceived stalker (although in the original story Sang Zhi was not shy and the stalker was a real weirdo), drunk girl piggyback carrying. There are explicit mentions of the "Overtime" bar and Sang Yan + Sang Zhi in dialogues....
Both Nanwu#1 and Nanwu#3 were shot in Xiamen with local buildings posing as "Nanwu" and "Yihe" in first one, and "Nanwu" and "Xifu" in the present dramatization. Nanwu#1 (Hidden Love - the only drama I really liked in the trilogy)) got credited for starting the drama pilgrimage trend, becoming tied to tourism industry! Production of WIMTM also banked on this : location fans started compiling the spots shown. where audience could discover some views of Xiamen, such as the spectacular one used for EAW exteriors and atrium,in early episodes and finale, or Waldorf Astoria Xiamen (厦门华尔道夫酒店), with its signature doors in final episode .
While some B-Roll Transition Shots were collected from elsewhere for "atmosphere", such as , in ep.27 :
* the Shanghai Film Academy beginning (which has no connection with the shoot), and
* the sweeping glass and steel "skirts" of Shanghai's flagship artificial intelligence and tech hub Shanghai West Bund International AI Tower & Plaza (上海西岸国际人工智能中心), located in Shanghai's Xuhui District along the Huangpu River, on the redeveloped site of the former Shanghai Longhua Airport.
* the Xinhee Design Center (欣贺研发设计中心), designed by by the renowned firm MAD Architects): a striking building which is the headquarters and R&D center for the fashion group Xinhee Co., Ltd. left and center canopies display "追光号3.0" (Light Chaser 3.0)—the flagship VR/tech product developed by Fu Shize's team—while the right canopy shows the "EAW" corporate logo. In the story, this building serves as the headquarters for EAW, the tech company where Yun Li goes for a work trip and product launch in Episode 27. The production crew filmed on location at the Xinhee Design Center in Xiamen and used visual effects (CGI) to project glowing blue holographic graphics onto the building's translucent white canopies.
But I eye-rolled too much in many of the too slow paced and last episodes to give that Nanwu final drama a good rating - this although I am lenient, and always considerate of actors work. The story/script was too expected, not well sewn together. The FL character Yun Li (played by Lu Yiuxiao) with her too often wide eyes stares at ML (even when driving : not focusing on road ahead!!! what was director doing!) became, in my mind, a terribly selfish and cold character. So many inconsistencies : after at last moving in with her boyfriend, she looked outraged that Yu Shize (played by Lin Yi) emerged from the shower in a bathrobe and she demanded he get "properly dressed" (shortly after having been almost crawling over body and face of guy when he was asleep on a couch). The latte-art and sugar-laden rolls as breakfast brought in for a guy who lived on Americanos and whiskey... When Yun Li rushed to fly away back to Nanwu (to watch her brother being operated on), she did not even try to get news from the company,to find out why Fu Shize did not answer her calls and messages, only assumed he was deserting and dumping her! She could not care less if her so-called lover was perhaps -as he was- almost dying alone in hospital (she even demanded a breakup and went to collect her things at their Xifu apartment while he was still in hospital) ! Big inconsistencies....
Also: the very annoying side "love stories" of "fiery" Tang Lin friend (played by Lu Yangyang) and skateboard lover Fu Zhenchu (played by Li Geyang) ; and "wimpy" brother Yun Ye (Zhao Penghao) with his school crush...
No. that and more ruined all the lingering shreds of goodwill for the female character from me. Such a girlfriend who complained about lack of communication but was herself not attentive I don't know how Lu Yuxiao did not realize how bad this came out, with her often too slow speech pattern from reluctance rather than sincerity. The occasional shy micro expressions became cutesy and forced. Even the occasional sweet finger twining during courtship did not redeem it. Yun Li, did not deserve someone devoted to her; Now both Fu men there turned out more wimp and moron than bright to accept anything from their selfish bitch girlfriends. The digital twin ended up as very underwhelming and the cloying pink fake skies and flowers for thee proposal at VR center was met with fake-feeling surprise. Lack of believable chemistry, tech misused. What a finale, sigh (but we were spared wedding and banquet with the controlling dad, absent Fu elders, and annoying sidekicks)...
Sorry for Lin Yi and Lu Yuxiao to have been participating in the mess. Director and screenwriter are not innocent, but the story was not good in first place (I dropped the book quickly from sheer boredom - Hidden Love novel was not perfect but this one is a syrupy and cloying one) The story was, far from the youth misunderstandings one (2006 The Left Ear) which may have "inspired" the author since she too depicted here (novel version from 2022) a semi handicapped, deaf in left ear character. But what was acceptable then became an additional unwelcome trope in WIMTM.
Was this review helpful to you?
2
5
1
3
1