The general consensus is that he faked it. He couldn't really remember her but faked it.
in my opinion they both were trying to be the "good guy". hyun min didn't know exactly she was his girlfriend bcz she had committed suicide. I agree with you about the red string thing. it's a kdrama fact that if u commit suicide, your connections are broken with the loved ones and can never be with them. either ur memories are gone or their memories are erased. But the remanets of the feelings remain. They both loved each other and Hyun min literally was trying to grab the ring during the accident. So he may remember her and not at the same time, if you know what i mean. So when she said about the light shop, he could feel it but not remember it. He just went there for her sake. She told him to go bcz she didn't want him to die. but at the same time, she was sad, just like park hye won, to part with her lover. That's why she called out his name outside the light shop. And I think she expected him to remember her after waking up. So that combined with, not remembering her in the afterlife, she's resentful. So, her resentment should be gone for hyun min to be okay again? i guess.
This show is a mess and it's totally unhinged. So is the police detective also suffering from delirium since only…
detective knows exactly what's going on in the afterlife. he asked specific questions, and got exact answers from the light shop owner, not in a round about way. and LSO warned him about that too. like if you finds out the truth about this place it will be harder to live in the other world. so, he remembers the afterlife. and can see ghosts. like the girl and the nurse. we know nurse remember that place too know? cuz he finally make a remark about the LSO to the high school boy. Detective's eyes change, bcz he took over the noodle shop owner's job. He catches ghosts of the dead who are wandering in the living world. others like girl, and nurse, they just see and communicate with the ghosts.
He did not want to live, he wanted to get out of the place he was stuck in. That's not the same. They first need…
i think this is where what the nurse's explanation fits in. "maybe the will is not their own. they need an assist." as you mentioned the boy didn't have an assist. only when the nurse kept the basketball under his bed, he got the help from the driver. bcz, he saw the ball and followed him. remember, he said, "i went up and down the alley so many times but i didn't see you"
Woah I wasn't expecting this to be under the same universe as moving. Don't skip the post credit scenes at the…
alive. noodle shop owner was also alive in the beginning. when the detective suspected him of that old man's murder, he ended up chasing him. when they were met with that truck accident, noodle shop owner saved the detective. He died, and detective went into coma. there he found out about the afterlife so he sees ghosts. And as NSO is dead now, someone has to catch the wandering ghosts of the dead, so detective is catching them now.
but noodle shop owner had leopard eyes. just as the light shop owner. so my guess is they both are celestial beings. one helps the dead and the other helps the ones in coma. remember, that shoe lady obeyed the light shop owner
that part where i don't get it. And then she comeback to where she begin. What is the purpose of those 2 years…
i think, it's bcz at the end she's a demon. she thinks what kind of a judge is she? and she's definitely not good or bad, she's a judge from hell. and in a realistic way, they wanted an open ending to satisfy everyone and they went with this
I agree with you about the red string thing.
it's a kdrama fact that if u commit suicide, your connections are broken with the loved ones and can never be with them. either ur memories are gone or their memories are erased. But the remanets of the feelings remain. They both loved each other and Hyun min literally was trying to grab the ring during the accident. So he may remember her and not at the same time, if you know what i mean.
So when she said about the light shop, he could feel it but not remember it. He just went there for her sake. She told him to go bcz she didn't want him to die. but at the same time, she was sad, just like park hye won, to part with her lover. That's why she called out his name outside the light shop.
And I think she expected him to remember her after waking up. So that combined with, not remembering her in the afterlife, she's resentful. So, her resentment should be gone for hyun min to be okay again? i guess.
Detective's eyes change, bcz he took over the noodle shop owner's job. He catches ghosts of the dead who are wandering in the living world. others like girl, and nurse, they just see and communicate with the ghosts.
"maybe the will is not their own. they need an assist." as you mentioned the boy didn't have an assist. only when the nurse kept the basketball under his bed, he got the help from the driver. bcz, he saw the ball and followed him. remember, he said, "i went up and down the alley so many times but i didn't see you"
when the detective suspected him of that old man's murder, he ended up chasing him. when they were met with that truck accident, noodle shop owner saved the detective. He died, and detective went into coma.
there he found out about the afterlife so he sees ghosts. And as NSO is dead now, someone has to catch the wandering ghosts of the dead, so detective is catching them now.
i haven't read the novel. 😢
and in a realistic way, they wanted an open ending to satisfy everyone and they went with this