Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 1 day ago
  • Location: Canada
  • Contribution Points: 95 LV2
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: December 19, 2019
  • Awards Received: Flower Award2
Replying to 11878793 • May 16, 2024
Title MIU404
that's not how translating works. it's more than just literally translating word from word. it has to make sense…
Except, see, if he's swearing at him, the translator should have him swear at him. That's pretty basic and it helps the translation stay true to his characterization. Baka is also a very well known word, and to pretend like he's not calling a character stupid is... well, stupid. It's not about the translation needing to be 1:1 literal, it's about it needing to be accurate to what's being expressed - not the same thing. I think my examples actually show quite well that there were often better choices in English for what the characters were expressing within the context of a scene, and they didn't choose them.
4 1
Replying to BL worshipper • Apr 8, 2024
I think some things that were left out in the novel v series:1. In the novel, players entered the game because…
Just as a note, the novel's main 3 organizations are mentioned by name in the book: Obsidian, White Deer, and White Bear are all canon novel names. (well, White Bear barely counts as "main" but it matters insomuch that it's Bai Ming's so it's brought up a few times)
2 0
Cho Na • Apr 8, 2024
I think the drama did decently with what they had to work around + clear budget restrictions, but I'm mourning all the changes and cuts all the same. I went in knowing the BL would be censored (pleasantly surprised by how much they managed to keep there!), and I can understand changing it to a game to please censorship (even tho for some reason they had to cook up a big-bad that doesn't exist in the novel), but changing the door plots wasn't something I always loved. I know they couldn't go all-in with the horror (it was a gore-fest in the novel), but some doors were barely recognizable from the original. It's strange to me lol like the drama is half right? but not right. Even the deaths were different. It's a softer version of the novel in every aspect.
6 0
Replying to LinRuanwoaini • Mar 15, 2024
Title The Spirealm
Even after the censorship they were able to produce such a masterpiece. This series got me so bad, The intense…
he says that a couple of times in the novel too - so happy they kept it!
1 0
Replying to wdh • Jan 20, 2024
Title The Bequeathed Spoiler
"i'm youngho's mom and i'm also your dad's wife" LMAOOO I just started episode 6 and this is hilarious. messy…
the ending was weird in trying to make it feel almost.... sentimental when they were buried together with the incest-family photo... "family... they're family" eugh
8 3
On Masquerade Night • Jan 11, 2024
I feel like this one had more of a mystery we could join in with trying to solve, but the 1st movie had more character moments...
2 0
Replying to Gian • Jan 1, 2024
Gaga already picks it up alongside the previous entries in the franchisehttps://twitter.com/gagaoolala/status/1737050138085122368/photo/1
that's great news! i was hoping gaga or viki would pick it up since they have the first season
1 0
Replying to 10477047 • Dec 29, 2023
just good aesthetics (but tbh wtf with the confetti and sakura petals in the school room so fake lol), they went…
the confetti and sakura petals are callbacks to their S1 high school days
27 0
On A Breeze of Love • Dec 23, 2023
This was so sweet! I do think it's a shame it was only given 15min-ish an episode because with more time we'd be able to expand on the characters, that'd be nice because I found them interesting, but I enjoyed it. They were able to tell a nice love story.
4 0
Replying to logiquement • Dec 23, 2023
Title Night Has Come Spoiler
That's the whole point, at least for the mother. She's not trying to get justice or get them to own up to their…
I know those are her real motivations, but it's still annoying to me. She's mad nobody took responsibility, and says she and her husband wanted to show the class what they did to Se Eun, but they're also repressing their memories every time, keeping them from properly reflecting on their actions. She keeps resetting them, keeping from truly understanding what they did, even though she says she wants them to understand (and feel her pain). Maybe this reasoning would be less frustrating if the show brought their memories of Se Eun back sooner, giving them time to actually live with the understanding that their actions brought them there and be tortured by that.

I'm not talking about the other classmates, I'm talking about the fact that the mother is holding EVERYONE accountable, right down to Yun Seo who didn't know a thing! Not just the bullies and bystanders, but Yun Seo who said herself that she didn't know it was happening until it was too late! But by the mother's logic her ignorance was just as bad as the bullying so she deserves to be tortured too. I know she's not in the best frame of mind, but by her logic she and her husband are just as guilty as Yun Seo then, because they also didn't know what was going on with Se Eun. They also failed to save her. Her justifications frustrated me. At least make Yun Seo a bystander or something then, writers... someone who didn't stick up for her if the show wants to communicate "watching bullying happen and not doing anything is bad too".
5 0