Noy

I didn't say that it won't or can't be popular. I'm saying it has deter some people from even wanting to try it.

There is a ick Factor to it but this is far from speed and love step sibling trope

I didn't watch go ahead. Therefore I have no opinion of it

The quote unquote sibling aspect is stopping some people from it and there's a lot of complaint from it.

Which is not even the core of this novel / drama. But I can see how the drama is dramatizing everything with more fillers of that and I feel that will drag it out

Regardless of my critique of how they could have done it better by keeping the core characterization.

I can only speak for the five episode I seen. I enjoy the main characters interaction. I wish they kept the friend of the male lead... it gave him more depth and more insight to his background trauma

I don't need them to adopt it 100%. If they're going to change and add stuff. It should improve it

For example. The balloon scene of her hugging. She barely knows him and she would never do that despite her mom. She only verbally threatened her because she needed to do that for a good reason. Also her idea was just to get close to him without invading his personal space.

The core characterization and adding on more drama as fillers is not improving the drama. I still like their engagement and interaction but there is something missing in their debt that they were able to do better in the novel

There is plenty of other novels I read and their adaptation only improved and was better the drama. And I prefer certain drama over adaptation of the novel. It could be handled well

Me stating stating how they did it better in the novel doesn't negate anything. If people enjoy this great but when you read the novel you know it could be better and they could do better.

I still like the interaction between the main leads and I wish there was more interaction with the friend

In the novel there is...in the middle but they both worked it out and I thought it was a good balance. But I feel the drama with dramatize it and stretch it out and prolong everything. To me it doesn't bring anything to the story and it will become annoying and innocence just fillers and drag on

Hidden love. Ml is also a smoker. They even had a scene where she was carrying a cigarette that wasn't hers.

The cigarette is a easy thing they could change and adjust. But yet they choose to change the characterization of the characters

I'm happy about it..i like both leads.....but

I'm for sure criticizing that they added more drama to it

That is why I'll wait until it's done...so i can skip the extra mom/parent drama

Even the step brother is more dramatic

Her going to the partying..
Being more involved with the family...

Ppl are alewady complaining about "incest" and now they added more connect scenes.

Hahaha.... chill ? I'm not mad.

I'm just stating that they had good material to use...they don't even need to change much. If they felt him too harsh.

Lighter and princess....ML was "harsh"

I'm just stating that he is aloof for a good reason....but once he locked in on her
He is very caring and gentle.

Good growth and development until the incidents happened

She is not like this in the novel.....urggggg...i felt it took away from her character dept....i dislike how they changed it

Villian

It has all of what you mentioned

They dramatize this...along with romance focus...the 2 leads has great chemistry

I don't love the changes to the storyline from the novel

Her hugging him. That is out of her characterization. The reaso. He gravitated to her because she was insightful and understanding w/o words. Sbe gave him space...tand wasn't too pushy

So now she is going to his family party.

Now they will have more connection to the family dynamics?!

Ppl are already complaining about "incest"....i won't be able to defend it because they keep added these changes and they are more involved in the family dynamic

Only to say in the novel...it didn’t happen

In the novel...he rarely saw or participated in his family get together

Now I'm more confident they will more annoying stupid scenes to dramatize it even more...

There is plenty of chinese school drama where the boy has lots of fan girl.

They don't need to show anything much.

They change it and now she is going to his family party

Wtf....now her betrayal will be worst...

There isn't much connection with the family in the novel

They changed both of their personalities

He is a good person...but aloof because of his trauma. They could have just bring it down w/o changing the characters personalities.

They added more drama ...her grandma is more dramatic....we see her mom more.

Changes are fine...if they give the good base and core to the story

I felt the novel had a better core and dept of characterizations

Ml isn't a bad person. He had trauma.

Ml in the novel was just aloof ...but he was very caring to her

They can still make him a good person w/o changing his personality

She struggled....had to work. Got into an ok university.

I'm not sure how they will change it in the drama

I'm going to put this on hold until more episode comes. They changed so much of the characterization of the main leads.

I don't like that. But I can say I enjoy the main leads.

I know that they dramatize it. So I know I'm going to be annoyed with how they do things versus in the book. So I'm going to wait until they're almost done and binge watch it so I don't have to wait and be annoyed with how they change the storyline.

On top of that they change a characteristic of the two leads. Which I feel takes away from them. They're Bond and how they are.

I will reset my brain and binge it and watch it as an adaptation and on its own when this drama is pretty much finished. Cuz I know that highly likely that I will be annoyed with the changes that they will put in from what I could already see from the four episodes.

The guy that has been harassing her. He attacked her and he ended up getting stabbed and was in the hospital. He eventually worked hard and went overseas after she disappeared.

I actually like the novel better but they has good chemistry

I'm really enjoying this.

He emoted very well.

Never watched him before
....but there is different display of emotions ...and i feel his acting in various situations is really good...

The awkward moments
- anxieties
-some comedy
-pain/trauma

Ect

I get what you're saying. I read the novel and there's no type of connection at all.

Versus speed and love. Not that has a direct connection with each other.

In this one. They never met or became a family.

The parents and the children lived Separate Lives.

They only met as students in the same school.

While reading the novel I never felt like there's any type of relation in a familial matter.

Even though they changed from the novel adaptation.

I wish they adopted it more closer to the novel. But....

I feel they're not going to have them living together under the same roof as siblings. Because both character hates their parents.

The leads eventually do date.

Because of crazy circumstance and he gets hurt. She lost an important person in her life. She move away and they separate and they never see each other again until 10 years later.

Neither character want nothing to do with their parents.