Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 9 days ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: May 1, 2023
On My Dearest Dec 28, 2024
Title My Dearest
I suffered through 11 episodes of this boring infantile hysterical nonsense and I completely hate it, so I dropped it. Is it the worst series? Of course not, but to me it's superficial Korean "Gone with the wind" which I also hate. Hate is a strong word, let's say I don't vibe with such romcom trying to pretend it's serious and historical nonsense. It's not a great love story, it's your typical fastfood of kdrama that gave me nothing.
Replying to Sophia Dec 28, 2024
Title My Dearest
romantic feelings
Was it ever resolved? For 11 episodes it looks like a mighty queerbate.
Replying to BABY Dec 28, 2024
Title My Dearest
i wish the ending was different ๐Ÿ’”for a person who doesn't belive in marriage and is a misogynist he devoted…
I really don't think they understand the meaning of "misogynist".
Replying to Jakksen Dec 28, 2024
Did you read Taming of the Shrew? Did you understand it?Go watch "10 Things I Hate About You" its another modern…
Exactly - I don't think anyone of them actually read it. It's a medieval sexist patriarchal concept of wive's submission to a husband, and also classisist - she was rich, he was poor, but she had to yield to him because he was an aristocrat. And very simple and straightforward story with no added complicated double meaning. Message is clear - know your place given you by the birthright (or not). None of this should be relatable in the modern world and yet here we are.
Replying to Saeng Dec 28, 2024
You are right! There's almost no connection to The Taming of the Shrew at all. And if Jojo, the scriptwriter and…
Thanks again, this is exactly what I was trying to pinpoint - inspiration is not adaptation.
Replying to Saeng Dec 28, 2024
You are right! There's almost no connection to The Taming of the Shrew at all. And if Jojo, the scriptwriter and…
When you borrow an element or even a character it doesn't make it adaptation. In the modern world it's almost impossible to come up with something so original this never been written before. Like Tolkien didn't come up with elves on his own, he used most of large scale European lore, but he didn't do adaptation of Elder Edda, and Andrzej Sapkowski who used most of Tolkien's and European lore in his Witcher didn't do the adaptation of neither Tolkien nor Elder Edda. Sorry, I went through too much literature studies to put up with this and let it go. All due respect to Heart Killers creators, they can claim all they want, but it will never become Shakespearean adaptation for that ๐Ÿ˜
Replying to Saeng Dec 28, 2024
You are right! There's almost no connection to The Taming of the Shrew at all. And if Jojo, the scriptwriter and…
I think the confusion here is that people don't see the difference between adaptation, inspiration and borrowed elements of the story. Your Dracula example is perfect - shall we say Twilight is adaptation of Bram Stoker or 50 shades of grey? No and no, although it borrowed a lot from both. Are movies like Hellsing, Van Hellsing, Dracula dead and loving it that straight use the characters from Bram Stoker adaptations? Also no. While I would call series Dracula with Jonathan Rhys Meyes a modern adaptation by right.
Tom Soppard, who literally "preyed off off Shakespeare's work" as my British literature professor said (I love Stoppard, my professor hated him lol) is not doing adaptations even.

I don't know who needs to hear this, but Heart Killers have no business being Shakespeare adaptation. If you really want to watch one, my favorite is "The Taming of the Shrew
ShakespeaRe-Told: Episode 1" - that's what modern adaptation of this particular Shakespearean work is.
Replying to aouboom fan Dec 28, 2024
that's what LOOSELY adapted means, my god let's stay in school please
That is not what it means. I studied a lot of literature at the university to be uniquely qualified to tell you this.
Replying to littlecliff Dec 28, 2024
There's two siblings and one wanna date but can't while the other one is not. I'd say that this applies to "loosely…
If you take one minor thing out of another work, that doesn't make it adapted, that makes it that you took that one thing. Adaptation follows the story. Even most fanfics are not adaptations.
On The Heart Killers Dec 27, 2024
"Adapted loosely from the play "The Taming of the Shrew" by William Shakespeare. " Is this a joke?? It has nothing whatsoever in common with Shakespeare in general and Taming of the Shrew in particular. Did you even read Shakespeare??? Omg
Replying to safo43 Dec 18, 2024
Am I the only one who thinks something is missing in this series ? I really dont want to criticize it because…
I was looking if someone feels the same as me and I see that I am not alone. It's really hard to say what is missing exactly. It's like the show is missing emotions. Like every main actor was forced to come on set and they really don't want to be there. They are cold and fake, I don't want to say bad acting, but it kinda looks like it. Khao is too cute for the psycho role he is playing, First has these funny children's transfer tattoos (a bee, seriously?? Why not Winx then?), Joong feels bored and smelling something disgusting 100% of the time, Dunk screams for no reason in most of lines he delivers. The space around characters always looks somehow too big, empty and fake. Every time they show this diner with a terrible logo (like midjourney would do better job for you, seriously), they open the door with a Toilet sign when they go to the kitchen, they dance in bowling, tattoo on Fadel keeps disappearing and reappearing, they go to date into some dark remote abandoned agricultural buildings, etc., etc. It's these inconsistencies in every scene, questionable locations, emotionless acting, it makes these series empty, like a tasteless meal. Like I am served Thai dish without salt or any flavor. Also the pace is so slow, the series have no rhythm. Overall storytelling is inconsistent. Some lines are actually not bad, but so badly emotionlessly delivered, like they just say them, they don't even try to act (except for Dunk who is overdoing absolutely every line).
You know how sometimes you watch some series and you see okay this is bad, this is lacking, would be better to change something here and there, but you can just tell that actors, director and production team poured their soul into it and it swipes you, embraces and takes you on a journey you enjoy so much, it's memorable and it stays with you. I can rip apart pretty much every show I watched and loved, because hey, no one is perfect, but at the end of the day it's entertainment and I was entertained, so it reached its goal 100%. With HeartKillers I feel nothing. Like I am standing in a long queue to the movie theater before anything starts happening.
Replying to Sheherezada Dec 12, 2024
The original was questionable story-wise, but this version is just terrible, hence negative reviews.
I watched 3 episodes, I don't need more to know neither acting or script will improve further))
Replying to Sheherezada Dec 12, 2024
It has no uniqueness since it's almoat word for word remake, and absolutely no charm, it's simply terrible. Sorry,…
I watched it without any prejudice or pre judgement as watching new story - terrible script, terrible acting, terrible styling, zero chemistry, no clear character motivation, really bad directing... I can go on for hours. The problem of these series is not that it's a remake.
Replying to FrankIncese Dec 5, 2024
Not a very satisfying ending. Why bother seperating them? Just to reunite without any consequences or conflicts?…
I absolutely loved the second couple, they had great story with a heavy background, and great chemistry.
Replying to Sun of Love Dec 5, 2024
Hate that the father of Qi Lu went unpunished, i wish he had died.
I completely share the sentiment, but don't you think it's super realistic as it is? Such people never get what they deserve.
Replying to Smiley face Dec 5, 2024
Just watch this drama as ur watching it for 1st time plz don't write negetive about this dramaIt has its own uniqueness…
It has no uniqueness since it's almoat word for word remake, and absolutely no charm, it's simply terrible. Sorry, that's how I feel.
Replying to Smiley face Dec 5, 2024
What the heck..Why all writing negative about thisThis series is good as original and nc scenes great too everyone…
The original was questionable story-wise, but this version is just terrible, hence negative reviews.