I gotta give it to the writer for having both the chairman and his biological son have similar traits. They are both running and mope around with this victim mentality.... it's quite astonishing.
Yes I totally agree. That's what i-Land did once at least. They got to either choose members first or choose the…
I agree. Also I am not a fan of dare I say random audience members decide who will get benefits after one performance. As you said I would love to have this judging panel or another judging panel actually evaluate the performances. I remember in "Peak Time" during the group challenges they had the on site regular judges give out votes or points or whatever but also a different larger judging panel of industry professionals to vote for the MVP. I don't say they would do a better job than regular people because everyone has likes and dislikes and their opinion who does better or not. However I am always afraid with these survival shows that it comes down to literally face value.
To play my own devil's advocate I am also afraid when there is only the judges who decide that there's a lot of production interference (I am looking at you Kim Sung Min getting S-Rank for no reason whatsoever because it was definitely not your talent which I am still waiting to discover)
I honestly think it is so unfair to give the higher ranking ones benefits to get more benefits. Like they choosetheir teammates and the song and the leftovers just got the leftover song. I would have preferred if the non chosen team was able to call dibs on the song just to even it out a little bit.
I think this show is a case of the sum is greater than it's parts. If you start to dissect the show, you see there are flaws everywhere. But because of its ambition and all the good aspects combined you feel like it's a great show.
I would argue it is a good show in general. But that's it. It's just good, Which might be a problem because that is not reflected in the rating. Do I feel like the rating should be lower? Not necessarily. People rate whatever they want to rate and it should never dictate your enjoyment or lack there of of a show.
I think for most people the issue is with expectations. When a show is close to or crosses the 9.0 mark, most people assume that it has to be a great show.
This is why I prefer the rotten tomatoe model. Their rating is a percentage of how many people give it a good rating. Let's say a show has a 99% on rotten tomatoe. This means that 99% liked it but it also means that 1% didn't like it. It also works the other way around. let's say there is a show with a 1% rating. Everyone thinks this is garbage and you don't need to bother watching. However, you can also say that 1% thinks this is a good show.
At the end of the day ratings mean nothing. You might like a show that nobody likes or you hate a show that everybody enjoys.
I personally think J&J has more good parts than bad ones. But it also suffers from it's own ambition. If they had cut down some storylines and made this a tighter experience it would have been even better.
All in all enjoy what ever you enjoy and if you don't thats fine too. If you think there's room for improvement share it. If someone doesn't agree with you that's fine. You can explain yourself and your point of view. But don't feel the need to convince someone of your opinion. And you know "Opinions are like assholes. Everybody has one"
Is it one of those drama with "FL going to be human doormat for 117 episodes and get happy ending at last minutes…
I wouldn't say for 117 episodes. She does some really idiotic things throughout but once she is done and turns into mamabear it's on and I would say it's for a good portion as far as I remember. However you have to go through a lot of bullshit as always
me looking at some comments that say the show is boring and Kong looks AI generated and Thomas is stiff like a…
So you basically saying they are right in their opinion how some character appears and attributing this to the actor's ability... but they are unaware that this is intentional Regardless of their knowledge of the source material they are just pointing out what they are seeing. Don't you think it's the show's obligation to make this clear whether they are having someone with limited acting ability/experience or that the character is supposed to be that way regardless of the actor? I believe the problem lies with the industry in general. At some point BL were mass produced by small and big companies which attracted rookie actors especially. The audience was exposed to mediocre (and that's being generous) acting a lot. Which is why I believe that most viewers assume the worst when it comes to acting.
I understand your point that the character is supposed to be that way and maybe one should reserve judgment for a couple episodes in.
I believe production (including writers and director) were following the rule of cinema "show don't tell". However in this case, because of the perception of BL acting, it would have been wiser to "show and tell" if it's of significance to the story.
as a Ukrainian myself, who tf even votes for Sviat? and the rank 28 is just mindblowingevery time he gets aired…
I know it sounds really harsh but as far as I can see his participation seems like a novelty to me. If he is going to go further production and editing will do their very best for him to NOT be in the final lineup. There is no way they want to have him in the group.
I disagree with you. I appreciate all the comments good, bad or indifferent because it gives me a clear idea of…
I disagree with you. I would not call him an awful actor but he gets typecast, which is why it seems like he is always playing the same one dimensional character. I would describe his acting as serviceable. I would love for him to try a villain role that would be something. Unfortunately he often plays the epitome of the Uke stereotype. Also it's not just him but also the direction he is given. Interesting enough most of his shows have the same director (coincidence? I think not)
...there was this plot point with the plagiarized building design. Was that supposed to be foreshadowing that Homeboy is capable of falsifying document? If that's the case I totally missed it because I thought someone plagiarized him.
I think I am not a big fan of Book's acting (I am not saying he is bad at acting it's just not for me). So far all his leading roles annoyed me ( some more some less) Honestly for me his best part was in "Only Boo" Maybe I prefer this kind of performance only in small doses.
I was like Pat where the hell did your backbone go? I was so annoyed with him this episode!
Exactly! Especially because he said he wanted to meet with her to make things clear. Yet he let himself be womanhandled by her without any fight. I get she is your ex, but that is years ago. How come you can stand up to your boss/boyfriend but turn into a useless wimp when your ex shows up? This was pathetic
I remember in "Peak Time" during the group challenges they had the on site regular judges give out votes or points or whatever but also a different larger judging panel of industry professionals to vote for the MVP. I don't say they would do a better job than regular people because everyone has likes and dislikes and their opinion who does better or not. However I am always afraid with these survival shows that it comes down to literally face value.
To play my own devil's advocate I am also afraid when there is only the judges who decide that there's a lot of production interference (I am looking at you Kim Sung Min getting S-Rank for no reason whatsoever because it was definitely not your talent which I am still waiting to discover)
I would argue it is a good show in general. But that's it. It's just good, Which might be a problem because that is not reflected in the rating. Do I feel like the rating should be lower? Not necessarily. People rate whatever they want to rate and it should never dictate your enjoyment or lack there of of a show.
I think for most people the issue is with expectations. When a show is close to or crosses the 9.0 mark, most people assume that it has to be a great show.
This is why I prefer the rotten tomatoe model. Their rating is a percentage of how many people give it a good rating. Let's say a show has a 99% on rotten tomatoe. This means that 99% liked it but it also means that 1% didn't like it. It also works the other way around. let's say there is a show with a 1% rating. Everyone thinks this is garbage and you don't need to bother watching. However, you can also say that 1% thinks this is a good show.
At the end of the day ratings mean nothing. You might like a show that nobody likes or you hate a show that everybody enjoys.
I personally think J&J has more good parts than bad ones. But it also suffers from it's own ambition. If they had cut down some storylines and made this a tighter experience it would have been even better.
All in all enjoy what ever you enjoy and if you don't thats fine too. If you think there's room for improvement share it. If someone doesn't agree with you that's fine. You can explain yourself and your point of view. But don't feel the need to convince someone of your opinion. And you know "Opinions are like assholes. Everybody has one"
Regardless of their knowledge of the source material they are just pointing out what they are seeing. Don't you think it's the show's obligation to make this clear whether they are having someone with limited acting ability/experience or that the character is supposed to be that way regardless of the actor?
I believe the problem lies with the industry in general. At some point BL were mass produced by small and big companies which attracted rookie actors especially. The audience was exposed to mediocre (and that's being generous) acting a lot. Which is why I believe that most viewers assume the worst when it comes to acting.
I understand your point that the character is supposed to be that way and maybe one should reserve judgment for a couple episodes in.
I believe production (including writers and director) were following the rule of cinema "show don't tell". However in this case, because of the perception of BL acting, it would have been wiser to "show and tell" if it's of significance to the story.
If he is going to go further production and editing will do their very best for him to NOT be in the final lineup. There is no way they want to have him in the group.