A Well-Directed but making you want to rewrite the script and send it back for reshoots
When the Stars Gossip is an ambitious series that showcases tremendous effort from the production team and a desire for innovation, steering away from clichés to appeal to an international audience. However, despite these efforts, the series ultimately fails on a large scale.
Why did it fail?
The series undeniably has many strong aspects and aimed for a grand scope, but it suffers from a major issue: a lack of clarity in its narrative purpose. It’s difficult to pinpoint exactly what When the Stars Gossip is trying to convey.
The story follows a romance between an astronaut and a gynecologist, but it also attempts to explore multiple other themes—without successfully tying them together. From the beginning, the series places itself in competition with top-tier dramas, raising expectations significantly.
Strong Performances but No Chemistry
The cast delivers impressive performances. Lee Min Ho surprises in a role that breaks away from his usual stereotype of the charming, wealthy romantic lead. He likely took on this risky project to challenge himself. Meanwhile, Gong Hyo Jin delivers a professional, natural performance that fits her character perfectly.
However, the couple lacks chemistry. Their relationship feels more like that of a married couple of 30 years rather than a fresh and passionate love story. This absence of spark makes it difficult for viewers to connect emotionally. he cool astronaut trio, which worked well and could have been truly endearing, faded away after episode 8. The Chaebol father, who played his role so well that I even started to 'like' him, had a satirical side that could have been even more striking and humorous.
An Internationally-Oriented Soundtrack
One of the strongest aspects of the series is its soundtrack. Featuring a strategic selection ranging from Hallyu pop-rock to hip-hop and classical music, the OST is clearly designed to appeal to a global audience.
A Well-Directed but Poorly Written Series
The director does an excellent job, and the production quality is commendable. Unfortunately, the real issue lies in the script.
The writer attempted to create an innovative story blending:
Science fiction, but not executed convincingly.
Themes of procreation and demographic challenges, relevant to aging populations in developed countries. This idea had great potential but ultimately falls apart due to logical inconsistencies.
Satirical comedy, which could have been a bold and effective choice—if fully committed to. However, the series oscillates between realism, comedy of absurdity, and serious drama without successfully uniting these tones.
As a result, the characters suffer from weak development. None are particularly engaging, and their actions often contradict their initial personalities. The love story escalates too quickly to be believable, and while the series raises profound philosophical and ethical questions, it fails to explore them meaningfully.
That said, episodes 7 and 8 stand out as particularly well-executed and engaging, proving that the series had the potential to succeed
A Misdirected and Misunderstood Project
Even the series’ promotional campaign was misleading. The teaser failed to accurately represent its tone, which may have contributed to the audience's confusion.
So...
Despite its flawed script and inconsistent narrative, This serie is still worth watching for its talented actors (10/10), the director’s efforts (9/10) , and the high production values. It raises thought-provoking questions about life, death, and the ethical limits of science. And making you want to rewrite the script and send it back for reshoots :)))
Why did it fail?
The series undeniably has many strong aspects and aimed for a grand scope, but it suffers from a major issue: a lack of clarity in its narrative purpose. It’s difficult to pinpoint exactly what When the Stars Gossip is trying to convey.
The story follows a romance between an astronaut and a gynecologist, but it also attempts to explore multiple other themes—without successfully tying them together. From the beginning, the series places itself in competition with top-tier dramas, raising expectations significantly.
Strong Performances but No Chemistry
The cast delivers impressive performances. Lee Min Ho surprises in a role that breaks away from his usual stereotype of the charming, wealthy romantic lead. He likely took on this risky project to challenge himself. Meanwhile, Gong Hyo Jin delivers a professional, natural performance that fits her character perfectly.
However, the couple lacks chemistry. Their relationship feels more like that of a married couple of 30 years rather than a fresh and passionate love story. This absence of spark makes it difficult for viewers to connect emotionally. he cool astronaut trio, which worked well and could have been truly endearing, faded away after episode 8. The Chaebol father, who played his role so well that I even started to 'like' him, had a satirical side that could have been even more striking and humorous.
An Internationally-Oriented Soundtrack
One of the strongest aspects of the series is its soundtrack. Featuring a strategic selection ranging from Hallyu pop-rock to hip-hop and classical music, the OST is clearly designed to appeal to a global audience.
A Well-Directed but Poorly Written Series
The director does an excellent job, and the production quality is commendable. Unfortunately, the real issue lies in the script.
The writer attempted to create an innovative story blending:
Science fiction, but not executed convincingly.
Themes of procreation and demographic challenges, relevant to aging populations in developed countries. This idea had great potential but ultimately falls apart due to logical inconsistencies.
Satirical comedy, which could have been a bold and effective choice—if fully committed to. However, the series oscillates between realism, comedy of absurdity, and serious drama without successfully uniting these tones.
As a result, the characters suffer from weak development. None are particularly engaging, and their actions often contradict their initial personalities. The love story escalates too quickly to be believable, and while the series raises profound philosophical and ethical questions, it fails to explore them meaningfully.
That said, episodes 7 and 8 stand out as particularly well-executed and engaging, proving that the series had the potential to succeed
A Misdirected and Misunderstood Project
Even the series’ promotional campaign was misleading. The teaser failed to accurately represent its tone, which may have contributed to the audience's confusion.
So...
Despite its flawed script and inconsistent narrative, This serie is still worth watching for its talented actors (10/10), the director’s efforts (9/10) , and the high production values. It raises thought-provoking questions about life, death, and the ethical limits of science. And making you want to rewrite the script and send it back for reshoots :)))
Was this review helpful to you?
