wait so did I miss something or do we never find out who the male dead body(the bones) belongs to? so if was just…
probably just another random person unrelated with Sarah's case. i totally forgot if they mention when is his dead, since they mentioned it's a male, i ignore the rest.
The problem with this is that there is no concrete evidence no substantial evidence, everything is peoples' testimonies…
no, director of Nox have confronted her in police station. Director of Nox know her as Sarah Kim. She can be testified that she know her name as Sarah Kim or Kim Mi Jeong.
Boss of the thugs also can be testified.
and her employees in Boudoir whom interacted with her almost everyday can be testified to gave the name, is she known as Sarah Kim or Kim Mi Jeong. Her employees are the weakest among all characters, it'll easier to pressure them to get their testimonies.
if they all said that her name is Sarah Kim, there is still long way to prove Sarah Kim's lie. But it'll prove her lie.
True that police will have a hard time to prove her murder action as Sarah Kim. But it will also hard to prove her as innocent, since she confess killing a Jane Doe that later she claimed as "Sarah Kim".
The murder was happened, they got suspect that confess her murder act. Police need to find more evidences.
When she declared herself as Kim Mi Jeong, there are no concrete evidence that she is Kim Mi Jeong. No legal paper, no id card, unknown nationality, totally unregistered person, no one can confirm that she is Kim Mi Jeong. But later, she as Kim Mi Jeong convicted guilty anyway.
So, it break your theory, that her identity matters. No it's not.
Based on series logic, she can be convicted guilty as Sarah Kim or Kim Mi Jeong. Both name have no legal identity anyway.
The problem with this is that there is no concrete evidence no substantial evidence, everything is peoples' testimonies…
no. in murder case, if she convicted guilty as Kim Mi Jeong, she could be convicted guilty as Sarah Kim.
Whoever she declare her name, she confessed of murdering someone. The name of murderer and the victim doesn't really matter, because with or without name the murder was happened, and the murderer confessed her action.
As Sarah Kim, her action that result the death of another person, can be considered as self defense. As Kim Mi Jeong she confessed that before the confrontation, she have no intention to kill Sarah.
True there is no concrete evidence. Whoever her name is, police have little evidence that she is the murderer. Her confession alone probably considered as weak evidence in court. But in the end they can put her as Kim Mi Jeong in jail.
They could be to do the same to her as Sarah Kim.
As for Sarah Kim, police have some ways to prove her as Sarah Kim. Even without concrete legal identity, they can confront her with people she have interacted with. It'll open many doors to her past identities.
Hold up, murder and scam are different things. If they can't jail her for the murder, why can't they jail her…
yes there are multiple cases happened.
Sarah Kim as Kim Mi Jeong convicted guilty for murder case.
as for the scam, there are no victims, so there are no scam. the victim of scam should be felt as a victim then report it, but since there are no one, nobody make the report.
and as for scam itself, there are two possible scams :
1) investment scam, involving Sarah Kim, and director of Nox. in this case, director of Nox didn't report her case, so on paper there is no scam.
2) Boudoir brand. the brand is not fake, the product is not fake, but the history of the brand is. Thus it can be considered as storytale to elevate the brand, a way to promote it, a way of marketing.
Once they prove that the body isn't Sarah Kim (or that she is Sarah Kim), her confession to murdering Sarah Kim…
that what i think gonna be a plot hole.
1) there are some people whom met with Sarah Kim, they can be testified to prove Eun Jae as Sarah Kim. Some people have interacted with Eun Jae as Sarah Kim, like director of Nox, the paid gangsters, and some Sarah Kim's employees.
2) Sarah Kim as Kim Mi Jeong have confessed of murder, whoever her victim is. If she convicted guilty as Kim Mi Jeong, she could be guilty as Sarah Kim.
She is in prison because of murder case anyway, with only evidence is her confession (although her confession is the murder of Sarah Kim).
So, doesnt matter who is the victim of the murder is, it can be declared as unregistered citizen, or person without legal name. The murder were happened, with or without name.
as for DNA, the police can still obtain DNA sample from loan shark boss. It maybe can't prove her as Sarah Kim, but can be an evidence of Eun Jae and the loan shark connection. Further it can be use to track her another fake identities.
storywise, this show is promising. But the transition from present to past, sometimes make it hard to follow the timeline.
And the biggest disappointment is in technical things, so many plot holes that make me less enjoy this show. Like when both detective and mall owner mutually destroy their recording as a sign of agreement. Their recording using each smartphones, and they destroy it by sink it in the water in a big flower vase.
Like, aren't their smartphones waterproof? The detective's one maybe not, but mall owner's one most likely are.
Not to mention that the brand "Boudoir" built on a myth, and many rich people fall to it.
I feel a little strange why they can't confirm her real identity like why? They could have checked her medically…
At ep 05, one person have confirmed that she is Sarah Kim. At least that person have delivered evidence that the Jane Doe in the sewer is not Sarah Kim.
The beginning of the drama is enchanting nonsense. I know that this drama is based on manga, but can it be better…
it's goofy drama tbh. i kinda surprised how i can enjoy this drama with all nonsensical things in it. Not to mention how the plot are inconsistent at some points.
well this one is the drama when i make exception to turn of my logical thinking. Just enjoy it, and make funs of their nonsensical, and inconsistencies.
i'm just adding my opinion, no intention of arguing or anything.
While I agree with the top two reviews, I still found this drama worth watching at least one time because the…
yeah, both leads actually have good backstory to be explored. But the writer made it too shallow for my taste. it still fun, and entertaining. But i hope i can have alternate universe of this show with deeper story and more serious tone.
If you liked resident playbook, then that means you enjoy slice of life genres, and because you discovered Go…
so far GYJ have picked pretty good scripts. it's maybe not your taste, but i like Death's Game and Sweet Home season 1, both are gore shows. then Lawschool, a crime drama. GYJ have support roles in those shows. It's all good shows.
i pay more attention to GYJ since Alchemy of Souls S2. It's also a good show, although i prefer more of S1, because i don't like it when GYJ took over the main lead from Jung So-Min.
I loved when she appeared as support role in S1 than main role of S2 Alchemy of Souls. if you like her acting, try Alchemy of Souls season 1, she played cool character there. You'll see her right away in opening of episode 1.
and just recently watched old 2019 drama because of another actress, Shin Ye Eun, titled "He is Psychometric", it's also a good show. After some episodes, i just realized GYJ played a role there.
From all those titles, i only suggest you Alchemy of Souls S1 E01
i totally forgot if they mention when is his dead, since they mentioned it's a male, i ignore the rest.
Boss of the thugs also can be testified.
and her employees in Boudoir whom interacted with her almost everyday can be testified to gave the name, is she known as Sarah Kim or Kim Mi Jeong. Her employees are the weakest among all characters, it'll easier to pressure them to get their testimonies.
if they all said that her name is Sarah Kim, there is still long way to prove Sarah Kim's lie. But it'll prove her lie.
True that police will have a hard time to prove her murder action as Sarah Kim. But it will also hard to prove her as innocent, since she confess killing a Jane Doe that later she claimed as "Sarah Kim".
The murder was happened, they got suspect that confess her murder act. Police need to find more evidences.
When she declared herself as Kim Mi Jeong, there are no concrete evidence that she is Kim Mi Jeong. No legal paper, no id card, unknown nationality, totally unregistered person, no one can confirm that she is Kim Mi Jeong. But later, she as Kim Mi Jeong convicted guilty anyway.
So, it break your theory, that her identity matters. No it's not.
Based on series logic, she can be convicted guilty as Sarah Kim or Kim Mi Jeong. Both name have no legal identity anyway.
in murder case, if she convicted guilty as Kim Mi Jeong, she could be convicted guilty as Sarah Kim.
Whoever she declare her name, she confessed of murdering someone. The name of murderer and the victim doesn't really matter, because with or without name the murder was happened, and the murderer confessed her action.
As Sarah Kim, her action that result the death of another person, can be considered as self defense.
As Kim Mi Jeong she confessed that before the confrontation, she have no intention to kill Sarah.
True there is no concrete evidence. Whoever her name is, police have little evidence that she is the murderer. Her confession alone probably considered as weak evidence in court. But in the end they can put her as Kim Mi Jeong in jail.
They could be to do the same to her as Sarah Kim.
As for Sarah Kim, police have some ways to prove her as Sarah Kim. Even without concrete legal identity, they can confront her with people she have interacted with. It'll open many doors to her past identities.
Sarah Kim as Kim Mi Jeong convicted guilty for murder case.
as for the scam, there are no victims, so there are no scam.
the victim of scam should be felt as a victim then report it, but since there are no one, nobody make the report.
and as for scam itself, there are two possible scams :
1) investment scam, involving Sarah Kim, and director of Nox.
in this case, director of Nox didn't report her case, so on paper there is no scam.
2) Boudoir brand.
the brand is not fake, the product is not fake, but the history of the brand is. Thus it can be considered as storytale to elevate the brand, a way to promote it, a way of marketing.
if the drama going further, i guess the detective will be influenced by Sarah.
1) there are some people whom met with Sarah Kim, they can be testified to prove Eun Jae as Sarah Kim.
Some people have interacted with Eun Jae as Sarah Kim, like director of Nox, the paid gangsters, and some Sarah Kim's employees.
2) Sarah Kim as Kim Mi Jeong have confessed of murder, whoever her victim is. If she convicted guilty as Kim Mi Jeong, she could be guilty as Sarah Kim.
She is in prison because of murder case anyway, with only evidence is her confession (although her confession is the murder of Sarah Kim).
So, doesnt matter who is the victim of the murder is, it can be declared as unregistered citizen, or person without legal name. The murder were happened, with or without name.
as for DNA, the police can still obtain DNA sample from loan shark boss. It maybe can't prove her as Sarah Kim, but can be an evidence of Eun Jae and the loan shark connection. Further it can be use to track her another fake identities.
what is his disadvantage to prove her as Sarah Kim??
And the biggest disappointment is in technical things, so many plot holes that make me less enjoy this show.
Like when both detective and mall owner mutually destroy their recording as a sign of agreement. Their recording using each smartphones, and they destroy it by sink it in the water in a big flower vase.
Like, aren't their smartphones waterproof?
The detective's one maybe not, but mall owner's one most likely are.
Not to mention that the brand "Boudoir" built on a myth, and many rich people fall to it.
At least that person have delivered evidence that the Jane Doe in the sewer is not Sarah Kim.
i got confuse because she seems have liberty to make some policy, but sometimes she need approval from her superior or HQ
just reach the middle and can't understand why she choose to drop the exam
it's not their character at all
i kinda surprised how i can enjoy this drama with all nonsensical things in it. Not to mention how the plot are inconsistent at some points.
well this one is the drama when i make exception to turn of my logical thinking. Just enjoy it, and make funs of their nonsensical, and inconsistencies.
i'm just adding my opinion, no intention of arguing or anything.
it still fun, and entertaining. But i hope i can have alternate universe of this show with deeper story and more serious tone.
it's maybe not your taste, but i like Death's Game and Sweet Home season 1, both are gore shows.
then Lawschool, a crime drama. GYJ have support roles in those shows. It's all good shows.
i pay more attention to GYJ since Alchemy of Souls S2.
It's also a good show, although i prefer more of S1, because i don't like it when GYJ took over the main lead from Jung So-Min.
I loved when she appeared as support role in S1 than main role of S2 Alchemy of Souls.
if you like her acting, try Alchemy of Souls season 1, she played cool character there. You'll see her right away in opening of episode 1.
and just recently watched old 2019 drama because of another actress, Shin Ye Eun, titled "He is Psychometric", it's also a good show.
After some episodes, i just realized GYJ played a role there.
From all those titles, i only suggest you Alchemy of Souls S1 E01