This is why I’m not a fan of historical fantasy kdramas or just modern fantasy dramas anymore … for some reason…
Yes. The writers don't seem to know how to make the rules in the fantasy world make sense. They spend alot of time on the plot in the beginning then start to lose sense of their own plot lol.
This drama has been repetitive and draggy since early on though. Nothing exciting happens. In fact nothing happens. Or Makes sense. lol. Characters repeating the same things the audience already knew from the first couple of episodes. "Conflicts" making no sense etc. Tons of flashbacks (aka lazy writing).
Lol I loved your review! One of the rare few ones that made sense. The majority of the people stanning for this show don't seem capable of making any sense in their ramblings or capable even any in-depth analysis of a show, except foaming at the mouths over the FL-ML chemistry, which is practically non-existent!.
Gosh this show was a colossal waste of 11 hours of my life I will never get back. I kept watching to see if it'd get better but...it didn't.
1. Nothing makes sense? What was this writer even thinking? There are several different themes/threads running at the same time. Yet nothing was properly explained.
2. There isn't much progression each week with the audience being told the same things repeatedly with nothing being resolved.
3. No character arcs/growth. I actually wonder why any of the main 4 took this drama. Plot is a mess, but the character arcs for each were bad as well. Like Kim Yoo Jung’s HCG only existed to simp after Haram and paint and act like a silly Joseon candy. Gong Myung’s character was straight up annoying. And Kwak Siyang’s villian was just a one-note dude that didn’t appear much anyway. Haram is - what is he even doing?
4. Very little chemistry amongst the cast and between the leads. I wonder if this is also due to the writing. cos I thought AHS and KYJ had some semblance of chemistry in the initial eps, but it disappeared suddenly. BTS – everyone seems awkward with each other, esp AHS who usually has no chemistry with any of his leading ladies anyway.
5. Really basic dialogue between characters. Dialogue is a tool to let the audience learn more about the characters themselves, to reveal thoughts, motivations etc and to give a sense of the dynamics between characters. But you have characters instead repeating things the audience already knows about and saying the most inane things which didn’t move the plot forward
6. Acting. None of the main 4 could elevate their acting above the bad writing. All the characters were one note, though I felt that Haram – if given to a different actor – could have been more complex, more nuanced and layered and more emotional.
6a. And I've never thought AHS to be a good actor, why is he being given lead roles? Just cause he's tall and "handsome"? - I don't find him good looking. SK loves giving roles to tall/"handsome" men who can't act and he's one of a dozen. He has no chemistry with ppl he acts with, always seems aloof, no emotional connection with his cast-mates in scenes and behind the scenes, no emotional connection with the audience - I never feel anything for his characters. He's so bad here! He just had the same usual facial expressions and rarely emoted. PLUS it really bothered me whenever he seemed to know who/what to look at. Isn’t Haram blind as a bat?! Yet he could ride horses, fight with people (whilst looking at them etc). What even. This became blindingly obvious in the later eps. Also, I feel like I’ve not seen KYJ in a good role since MLDWC. Her saguek roles all seem to be the same which is making me start to think she's not a good actress/really bad at picking scripts.
7. Too many flashbacks. This is the epitome of absolutely lazy writing and shows that the writer doesn't know what to do with the plot anymore except to insert a flashback.
Just utterly boring and what a let-down from the aesthetically pleasing teasers. It's no wonder SBS never bothered promoting the cast or this show. They probably saw everything that went down and was like yeah, this sucks LOL.
This drama has been repetitive and draggy since early on though. Nothing exciting happens. In fact nothing happens. Or Makes sense. lol. Characters repeating the same things the audience already knew from the first couple of episodes. "Conflicts" making no sense etc. Tons of flashbacks (aka lazy writing).
Gosh this show was a colossal waste of 11 hours of my life I will never get back. I kept watching to see if it'd get better but...it didn't.
1. Nothing makes sense? What was this writer even thinking? There are several different themes/threads running at the same time. Yet nothing was properly explained.
2. There isn't much progression each week with the audience being told the same things repeatedly with nothing being resolved.
3. No character arcs/growth. I actually wonder why any of the main 4 took this drama. Plot is a mess, but the character arcs for each were bad as well. Like Kim Yoo Jung’s HCG only existed to simp after Haram and paint and act like a silly Joseon candy. Gong Myung’s character was straight up annoying. And Kwak Siyang’s villian was just a one-note dude that didn’t appear much anyway. Haram is - what is he even doing?
4. Very little chemistry amongst the cast and between the leads. I wonder if this is also due to the writing. cos I thought AHS and KYJ had some semblance of chemistry in the initial eps, but it disappeared suddenly. BTS – everyone seems awkward with each other, esp AHS who usually has no chemistry with any of his leading ladies anyway.
5. Really basic dialogue between characters. Dialogue is a tool to let the audience learn more about the characters themselves, to reveal thoughts, motivations etc and to give a sense of the dynamics between characters. But you have characters instead repeating things the audience already knows about and saying the most inane things which didn’t move the plot forward
6. Acting. None of the main 4 could elevate their acting above the bad writing. All the characters were one note, though I felt that Haram – if given to a different actor – could have been more complex, more nuanced and layered and more emotional.
6a. And I've never thought AHS to be a good actor, why is he being given lead roles? Just cause he's tall and "handsome"? - I don't find him good looking. SK loves giving roles to tall/"handsome" men who can't act and he's one of a dozen. He has no chemistry with ppl he acts with, always seems aloof, no emotional connection with his cast-mates in scenes and behind the scenes, no emotional connection with the audience - I never feel anything for his characters. He's so bad here! He just had the same usual facial expressions and rarely emoted. PLUS it really bothered me whenever he seemed to know who/what to look at. Isn’t Haram blind as a bat?! Yet he could ride horses, fight with people (whilst looking at them etc). What even. This became blindingly obvious in the later eps. Also, I feel like I’ve not seen KYJ in a good role since MLDWC. Her saguek roles all seem to be the same which is making me start to think she's not a good actress/really bad at picking scripts.
7. Too many flashbacks. This is the epitome of absolutely lazy writing and shows that the writer doesn't know what to do with the plot anymore except to insert a flashback.
Just utterly boring and what a let-down from the aesthetically pleasing teasers. It's no wonder SBS never bothered promoting the cast or this show. They probably saw everything that went down and was like yeah, this sucks LOL.