News Gye is the real Doctor X
I watched the original version of Doctor X first because i read in the chat that it was better. So i thought, rather than waste my time on a remake, why not watch the original? I only watched up to s2, before thinking i aint wasting my time with this sh!t. I couldnt even bother writing a review of it cuz it was so bad. Oh boy I hated it so very much I almost skipped this korean remake altogether.
Then I ran out of titles to watch, the cdrama that I was waiting for became a disappointment and i dropped it, so I had nothing interesting on my plate. Coincidently, my eyes caught sight of the korean remake that I saved into my watchlist and noticed that it was nearing the end of the season, so i thought, yeah let’s give this a try. If i don’t like it i’ll just drop it like I did with the original. So here i am now, beaming like a silly fan.
Being a remake, I just couldnt help making comparisons with the Japanese original:
1. Dr Gye, despite being aloof and indifferent to people around her, looked more like a person than Michiko Daimon. I really hated Michiko’s lame club dance, acting overly cutesy around the people in her home, and pretencious arrogance mask she wears around the hospital. While i saw Michiko’s as an obviously made-up personality, Gye gave off the perfect Dr X vibe that sits perfectly well with me - the nonchalance, the indifference, the arrogance were all blended seamlessly to create a realistic person, very unlike Michiko’s robotlike personality. I dont know how she did it, but when Michiko said”I never fail,” it sounded detestably arrogant, but when Gye said it all i hear is unwavering confidence.
2. I totally love Ms Jang’s personality compared to Michiko’s agent/mentor which I also felt fake like Michiko’s.
3. Korean Dr X has more colour and creative plot compared to the repetitive Michiko-doing-next-to-impossible-shadow-surgeries-to-cover-for-other-doctors in every single episode (or at least up to last episode of S2 where I dropped it). I especially love the Dr Na arc, mannn the payback was really awesomely unexpected. In the Korean remake, they made an effort to create backstory for Gye and the patients - there were actually out of hospital scenes for this compared to the japanese original that merely showed patients going into hospital and Michiko saving their lives. Gye actually bonded with her patients and not just show up for the sake of surgery like Michiko did. My tears flowed like waterfall on Ep 7, that is how creative the korean remake was. And Ep 10 truly is a redemption episode for other doctors who used to stand against Gye.
4. Korean remake has funnier scenes that could actually make me smile or laugh, unlike the japanese original that tried too hard to pull off some lame joke. It’s laughable to read how the chats made the japanese version to be comedic when i saw none of it. They try to be, yes, but comedic is a definite no. 🙄
5. The supporting characters also look more humane instead of pathetic power and money-mongering monsters like those in the original japanese series. Even the hospital director and his goons had their own redemptions here while in the japanese version theyre nothing but power and money-oriented scoundrels at the end of the season.
6. Best part is korean remake has more action than japanese. The Michiko Daimon version was so mundane and boring with repetitive plots in each episode, when she’s not doing surgery she’d either be in the bathhouse or doing that pretentious stretching or club dance, while Mafia in White really showed actual action of Dr Gye doing humanly things other than surgeries, like working out and facing off assailants.
7. The hospital manager in Korean remake acts more like a corporate executive than the manager in the japanese version. In both seasons, the japanese managers are either screaming at Michiko or running after and fawning over the hospital director like some court jester. It’s pathetic overacting. I hated both managers in the 2 seasons that i saw of the Japanese original. I am so glad the Korean version had the manager written as a real person with basic curtesy expected of a decent person.
8. The music and intro here is more likable than the original. I used to fast forward everytime the narration intro of michiko comes on, the voice is so irritating and the narration too repetitive. In this korean remake, they also had that voice narration intro and ending, but theyre not naggy or irratable like the original. I didnt have the tendency to use the ff button throughout the show like i did with the original.
All in all, it was an exciting ride. I hope they would do sequels. This series definitely deserve a few seasons like Taxi Driver or The First Responders.
Then I ran out of titles to watch, the cdrama that I was waiting for became a disappointment and i dropped it, so I had nothing interesting on my plate. Coincidently, my eyes caught sight of the korean remake that I saved into my watchlist and noticed that it was nearing the end of the season, so i thought, yeah let’s give this a try. If i don’t like it i’ll just drop it like I did with the original. So here i am now, beaming like a silly fan.
Being a remake, I just couldnt help making comparisons with the Japanese original:
1. Dr Gye, despite being aloof and indifferent to people around her, looked more like a person than Michiko Daimon. I really hated Michiko’s lame club dance, acting overly cutesy around the people in her home, and pretencious arrogance mask she wears around the hospital. While i saw Michiko’s as an obviously made-up personality, Gye gave off the perfect Dr X vibe that sits perfectly well with me - the nonchalance, the indifference, the arrogance were all blended seamlessly to create a realistic person, very unlike Michiko’s robotlike personality. I dont know how she did it, but when Michiko said”I never fail,” it sounded detestably arrogant, but when Gye said it all i hear is unwavering confidence.
2. I totally love Ms Jang’s personality compared to Michiko’s agent/mentor which I also felt fake like Michiko’s.
3. Korean Dr X has more colour and creative plot compared to the repetitive Michiko-doing-next-to-impossible-shadow-surgeries-to-cover-for-other-doctors in every single episode (or at least up to last episode of S2 where I dropped it). I especially love the Dr Na arc, mannn the payback was really awesomely unexpected. In the Korean remake, they made an effort to create backstory for Gye and the patients - there were actually out of hospital scenes for this compared to the japanese original that merely showed patients going into hospital and Michiko saving their lives. Gye actually bonded with her patients and not just show up for the sake of surgery like Michiko did. My tears flowed like waterfall on Ep 7, that is how creative the korean remake was. And Ep 10 truly is a redemption episode for other doctors who used to stand against Gye.
4. Korean remake has funnier scenes that could actually make me smile or laugh, unlike the japanese original that tried too hard to pull off some lame joke. It’s laughable to read how the chats made the japanese version to be comedic when i saw none of it. They try to be, yes, but comedic is a definite no. 🙄
5. The supporting characters also look more humane instead of pathetic power and money-mongering monsters like those in the original japanese series. Even the hospital director and his goons had their own redemptions here while in the japanese version theyre nothing but power and money-oriented scoundrels at the end of the season.
6. Best part is korean remake has more action than japanese. The Michiko Daimon version was so mundane and boring with repetitive plots in each episode, when she’s not doing surgery she’d either be in the bathhouse or doing that pretentious stretching or club dance, while Mafia in White really showed actual action of Dr Gye doing humanly things other than surgeries, like working out and facing off assailants.
7. The hospital manager in Korean remake acts more like a corporate executive than the manager in the japanese version. In both seasons, the japanese managers are either screaming at Michiko or running after and fawning over the hospital director like some court jester. It’s pathetic overacting. I hated both managers in the 2 seasons that i saw of the Japanese original. I am so glad the Korean version had the manager written as a real person with basic curtesy expected of a decent person.
8. The music and intro here is more likable than the original. I used to fast forward everytime the narration intro of michiko comes on, the voice is so irritating and the narration too repetitive. In this korean remake, they also had that voice narration intro and ending, but theyre not naggy or irratable like the original. I didnt have the tendency to use the ff button throughout the show like i did with the original.
All in all, it was an exciting ride. I hope they would do sequels. This series definitely deserve a few seasons like Taxi Driver or The First Responders.
Was this review helpful to you?

